Elizabeth Anderson on Worker Rights and Private Government
What this covers
Elizabeth Anderson and Russ Roberts examine the structural power dynamics between employers and workers in this conversation from EconTalk. Anderson argues that employers exercise a form of private government—unaccountable hierarchical control comparable to state authority—that workers accept in ways they would never tolerate from the public sector. The discussion traces how this arrangement arose and why standard defenses of it fail, particularly for low-wage workers. Roberts pushes back at points, raising concerns about the unintended consequences of reform and offering competing explanations for wage trends. The conversation oscillates between historical claim, economic mechanism, and normative principle.
Anderson draws on intellectual history to show that Adam Smith and 17th-century free-market radicals like the Levellers envisioned markets as a tool for worker independence, not for concentrating employer power. She argues that the exit option—workers' theoretical freedom to quit—provides little protection, especially under monopsony conditions where few employers compete for labor, during recessions, or for high-turnover roles like warehouse work where turnover costs are trivial to firms. She proposes a framework separating inviolable constitutional rights for workers—such as protection from discrimination and basic bodily autonomy—from governance questions better resolved through co-determination, the German model where workers elect representatives to management boards. Roberts counters that legal protections raise hiring costs and that competition does discipline employer behavior for workers in whom firms invest. The pair also contest wage stagnation claims, housing affordability, and whether automation poses a crisis beyond economic subsistence.
Anderson argues that employers exercise unaccountable, government-like power over workers' lives—a 'private government'—that we would never tolerate from the state, and that the exit option and market competition are insufficient to protect workers, especially the low-skilled.
- Any large organization needs hierarchy, but the default American workplace is an unaccountable dictatorship that leaves workers open to abuse
- The exit option fails for low-skilled workers facing monopsony, recessions, and precarious temp employment
- The same anti-paternalism libertarians apply to public government should apply to private government in the workplace
Competition between employers mitigates abuse of power and protects workers without legal mandates.
- The existence of multiple employers usually mitigates the level at which a boss takes advantage of their power because they lack a monopoly, and firms that abuse workers struggle to attract them—as illustrated by the summer-camp-like conditions at Facebook and Google—though competition may reduce but not fully eliminate abuse.
“the fact that there are different choices usually mitigates the level at which a dictator will take advantage of the power they have available to them, because they don't have a monopoly.”
- A self-employed house-cleaning crew earning around $25 an hour—well above the minimum wage—demonstrates that competition can protect low-education workers on the monetary dimension, because the employer must pay that much or the workers will go clean someone else's house.
“the question is why do I pay them so much money? And the answer of course is, if I don't, they won't come. They'll go to somebody else's house... at least in that case, competition does protect at least on the monetary dimension.”
Consistent classical liberalism rejects paternalistic control regardless of whether it is private or public.
- If a classical liberal rejects the nanny state's infantilizing control even when it might save lives, consistency demands rejecting the same paternalistic, freedom-restricting control when exercised by private government in the workplace rather than applying cost-benefit analysis there.
“If I accept that point in the case of public government--what we would call, normally, public government, why do I accept it in the case of private government? Why do we do a cost benefit analysis there, when it comes down to freedom?”
- Even white-collar employees exhibit a level of quasi-slavery in their devotion to keeping their jobs—giving up weekends and working overtime at the boss's wish—and whether it is worth it is not the right criterion for deciding whether such practices should be legal or conventional.
“Nassim Taleb in a recent episode... did talk about how employees are more like slaves than, say, contracted workers... to keep your job is really a thing that workers long for. And they will do some things that are not so pleasant.”
Legal protections on hiring increase costs and reduce worker access to jobs overall.
- Converting protections such as not being fired for drug use, political expression, or suspicion of sexual harassment into legal rights would make hiring more expensive because of the subjectivity and legal nuance involved, potentially leaving workers worse off by reducing their access to jobs.
“once we put those issues as rights... it would make it a lot more expensive for people to be hired. And my worry is if we move to what you would call maybe a freer system, it could be a world where workers have a hard time getting access to it”
Measured wage stagnation and living standard decline are statistical artifacts of poor measurement methods.
- Most of the affordability problems in housing, health, and education arise because government subsidizes access to those systems, driving up prices as more people gain access—analogous to a place being so crowded nobody goes there anymore—with subsidized student loans being an especially harmful mechanism for those who don't finish college.
“most of the problems with affordability come from government subsidizing access to the system. So, it's a little bit like the Yogi Berra line: It's so expensive, 'It's so crowded nobody goes there any more.'”
- Conventional measures of the standard of living are grossly inaccurate because we measure productivity poorly in the computer era and fail to capture rapid quality improvement when measuring prices, so the claimed wage stagnation is overstated—evidenced by the fact that the average American would not choose to live in 1973.
“we don't measure productivity particularly well in the era of computers. We don't measure prices very accurately when there's enormous, rapid quality improvement. So I would argue that our measures of the standard of living are grossly inaccurate”