causal

Calculation Argument Concedes Incentives Yet Defeats Socialism

Mises's calculation argument is distinct from and stronger than the incentive critique of socialism: granting for the sake of argument that a 'Socialist Man' is transformed to work selflessly for the common good, socialism still fails because without private property in the means of production there are no markets and no prices for those means, leaving the planner unable to calculate how to allocate scarce resources among competing ends—so socialism cannot achieve its own ends.

causalpending

Speaker

Peter Boettke

Evidence Quote

“This is Mises's calculation argument... that is a lynchpin argument against socialism claiming that socialism will have to do without economic calculation”

Source

Peter Boettke on Mises— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:03 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...