first-past-the-post
An electoral system in which each district elects one winner—the candidate with the most votes—which can waste a large share of votes and produce disproportional results.
As defined in 344 | Adam Gurri on Liberal Democracy and How to Fight For It
Where it comes up · 8
- 287 | Jean-Paul Faguet on Institutions and the Legacy of History2 claims
- July Liberal Values Lab: America's Political Transition with Peter Zeihan1 claim
- Peter Zeihan: Mapping the Collapse of Globalization1 claim
- Roy Foster1 claim
- Tom Tugendhat1 claim
- Lilliana Mason on Uncivil Agreement1 claim
- 344 | Adam Gurri on Liberal Democracy and How to Fight For It1 claim
- David Brady on the Electorate and the Elections of 2010 and 2012 08/15/20111 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “first-past-the-post” →
- A viable centrist third party is extremely unlikely because the US first-past-the-post system makes 20% in a district worthless, building a grassroots party from the House level up requires generating and funding candidates against two entrenched parties, and it is far easier to take over an existing party (as the Tea Party did with Republicans) than to start a new one—even though popular third-party presidential candidates (Perot, Wallace, Anderson, Teddy Roosevelt) are relatively easy to run.David Brady on the Electorate and the Elections of 2010 and 2012 08/15/2011
- Single-member first-past-the-post elections can produce less democratic results than even the US system when more than two parties compete, because a large share of votes (40-45% or more) become 'dead votes' that elect no one, letting a party win a parliamentary majority with well under 50% of the vote (as in Canada), whereas proportional party-list systems route nearly all votes to seats and reliably produce competitive multi-party systems.344 | Adam Gurri on Liberal Democracy and How to Fight For It
- Per Duverger's Law, a first-past-the-post, majority-wins electoral system always produces two parties, so the only way to make a viable third party possible is to move to a proportional-representation system where a party winning 15% of the vote gets 15% of seats, which would create coalitions and reduce the zero-sum aspect of current politics.Lilliana Mason on Uncivil Agreement
- UK election outcomes have become uneven because of the voting system: a small number of votes in a number of seats can swing many seats, so Labour won a 179-seat majority in 2024 on only ~34% of the vote by stacking many narrow wins, meaning a switch of about 175,000 votes out of a 40-million electorate could turn a two-thirds Commons victory into a 50-50.Tom Tugendhat
- American factions have shifted significantly over the past 30 years due to globalization's rise and fall, China's rise and fall, the Ukraine war, and the information revolution, making it logical that political factions move around based on these changes, and the US electoral system (first-past-the-post, voting for persons rather than parties) creates weak big-tent parties with many factions.Peter Zeihan: Mapping the Collapse of Globalization
- The American political system is fundamentally structured as a first-past-the-post, single-member district network, which forces the formation of large coalitions because winning requires only one more vote than the second-place competitor; this mathematical reality means that with nine parties, you could win with just 15% of the vote, but coalitions force that threshold much higher, making it nearly impossible for a third party to become serious.July Liberal Values Lab: America's Political Transition with Peter Zeihan
- First-past-the-post voting turns relatively small electoral majorities into large legislative majorities, producing strong but brittle governments that can enact sweeping change (a 35% vote can yield a vast parliamentary majority—an 'electoral dictatorship'), whereas proportional representation gives parties seats proportional to votes, better representing sincere preferences and enabling coalitions but producing only minor reshuffles; PR is better when things go well, but first-past-the-post's capacity for a clean sweep is valuable when things go badly.287 | Jean-Paul Faguet on Institutions and the Legacy of History
- Through most of the 20th century, US parties overlapped ideologically—many Southern Democrats were right-wing and many Northeastern Republicans were left-wing, belonging to a party for tribal or historical rather than ideological reasons—but over time, as visualized through roll-call votes, they separated completely so there is now no overlap, producing en-masse party-line voting and removing the cross-party common ground that once enabled cooperation.287 | Jean-Paul Faguet on Institutions and the Legacy of History
- Ireland's adoption of single transferable vote PR encouraged coalition governments between unlikely allies and produced a remarkably stable democracy in a post-revolutionary country—superior to Britain's archaic first-past-the-post system that grants sweeping power to parties lacking national majorities—though at the cost of clientelist, pork-barrel politics especially in rural constituencies.Roy Foster