Tom Tugendhat
What this covers
Tom Tugendhat, a British politician and former soldier, sits with Tyler Cowen to diagnose what has gone wrong with Britain and why its institutions, however odd they seem, are worth defending. Tugendhat argues that the country's core failures — economic stagnation, housing unaffordability, architectural mediocrity, and regional inequality — trace to four decades of underinvestment in infrastructure and a state so centralized that it severs the link between those who make decisions and those who pay for them. The conversation ranges from infrastructure policy and housing supply to the unusual architecture of British government, with Tugendhat making the case that institutions many assume are anachronistic — the House of Lords, parliamentary sovereignty, the monarchy — actually work because they force the kind of long-term and cooperative thinking that modern democracies otherwise lack.
On economics, Tugendhat traces Britain's 18–25 percent output loss since 2007 to infrastructure neglect, which concentrates population and economic activity while starving regions of opportunity. He connects this to housing, arguing that restricting land supply inflates land costs, forcing builders to cut corners on quality and design rather than expand the building footprint. He contrasts this with countries like Taiwan and South Korea, which grew rich partly through Property Rights and the Rule of Law — a stability that China's arbitrary wealth confiscation and opaque legal systems for Party members undermine. On governance, Tugendhat attacks imbalanced devolution that violates the principle of Aligning Accountability, Responsibility, and Authority, and defends Parliament's bicameral structure: the House of Lords, he argues, injects Lottery / Sortition-like randomness into policymaking, forcing Repeated Games / Long-Term Interest thinking that counteracts democracy's short-term bias. He also addresses geopolitical matters — Afghanistan's exposure to neighboring states, Iranian millenarianism, Houthi rationality — and argues that Cock-up Over Conspiracy better explains history than coordinated plots.
Tugendhat argues that Britain's core failures — economic imbalance, unaffordable housing, ugly building, regional inequity — stem from decades of infrastructure underinvestment and a centralized state that misaligns accountability with authority, while its idiosyncratic institutions (parliamentary sovereignty, the House of Lords, the monarchy) work precisely because they force long-term and cooperative thinking that democracies otherwise lack.
- Lack of infrastructure investment over 30-40 years drives concentration, housing shortages, and regional poverty
- Restricting land supply distorts costs onto land rather than buildings, degrading architectural quality
- British institutions endure because they force partnership and long-term thinking against short-term incentives
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Taiwan and South Korea democratized and grew rich while China did not because they had the freedom to hold property, keep accumulated wealth, and have disputes reasonably adjudicated; China's dual court system (one for Party members, one for others), arbitrary wealth removal, and unpredictable asset ownership — exemplified by the arrest of Jack Ma — make long-term investment difficult.
“The freedom you need is the freedom to be able to hold your own property, to know the wealth that you accumulate you’ll be able to keep, and that deals you make will be, in some way, reasonably adjudicated when there’s a dispute.”
Afghanistan has not been a civil-war zone or 'graveyard of empires' so much as the playground of others — its regions dominated by neighboring states' political interests, which generates internal friction and friction between neighbors — so there is no credible medium-term optimistic case, only a long-term one contingent on fundamental changes in neighboring states.
“Afghanistan hasn’t been either in civil war or been the death of empires, as people claim. It’s been the playground of others.”
When developers set out beautiful design codes and buildings that add to the environment — as in Nicholas Boys Smith's Create Streets work — people object far less, because attractive additions (e.g. Georgian villas) are perceived to increase neighbours' property values rather than diminish them, unlike modernist monstrosities.
“When you set out beautiful design codes, when you set out buildings that really add to the environment, people don’t object so much.”
Restricting access to land loads costs onto the land rather than the building, which inflates land prices and forces builders — who legitimately need profit — to spend less on architecture and quality, producing worse-quality design and housing.
“Once you restrict the ability of people to access land, and so you put all of the costs on the land rather than on the building, you end up massively distorting the amount that people are willing to spend on the architecture and on the quality”
Kent, colonized by the Jutes, used Frankish partible inheritance (land shared among male heirs) rather than primogeniture, producing small landholdings; because owners couldn't simply live off peasants' rents, this spurred early industry such as the Kentish ironworks that made the arrows for the Battle of Crécy.
“you can’t effectively just farm the rents of your peasants by owning a lot of land, then you actually have to do something about it. You see, for example, the rise of industry in Kent earlier than in other places.”
Divorcing the splendid from the sordid — keeping ceremonial monarchy taken seriously but irrelevant day-to-day, while not wanting the prime minister bathed in gold — is a healthy way of organizing government, in contrast to the US presidential system that fuses dignity and power.
“I think divorcing the splendid from the sordid, if you like, is rather a healthy way of having a government.”
Access to classified information taught that conspiracies are unbelievably difficult and effectively don't happen; instead there are huge numbers of mistakes and constant misjudgments — cock-up — which produce very unpredictable outcomes.
“Conspiracies are unbelievably difficult, and I just don’t believe in them anymore. I believe in cock-up.”
UK election outcomes have become uneven because of the voting system: a small number of votes in a number of seats can swing many seats, so Labour won a 179-seat majority in 2024 on only ~34% of the vote by stacking many narrow wins, meaning a switch of about 175,000 votes out of a 40-million electorate could turn a two-thirds Commons victory into a 50-50.
“the Labour Party won with a majority of 179 off 33 percent and a bit, 34 percent of the vote... they’ve managed to get a lot of very narrow wins.”
Crossrail looks set to reach break-even within five or six years — a remarkable speed of return — precisely because so little other infrastructure has been built, giving it near-monopoly dominance in serving demand.
“The reason for the speed of the return is, frankly, that so little other infrastructure has been built. So it’s not quite a monopoly provider status, but you know what I mean.”
The Houthis are rational within their own metrics: their goal is to win a Yemeni civil war and gain legitimacy, and attacking Israel both confers legitimacy in an internal Islamic civil war and secures weapons from Iran — so although closing the Red Sea doesn't directly help them win, it signals competence as a military power.
“if you want to fight civil war and you want to have legitimacy in weapons, attacking Israel helps you.”
The James Bond franchise has a future because the brand functions as an economic assurance: it guarantees enough money will be spent — on special effects, original music, famous screenwriters, popular actors — so the brand's strength, not any particular actor or storyline, keeps it viable, and Bond can be recast from any background much as Doctor Who regenerates.
“The brand is your assurance that enough money will be spent on it, that they don’t want to devalue it, that the special effects will be good enough”
Britain grew at a healthy 2-3% until 2007-08, but the lack of infrastructure investment over the following decades caused a fall-off that has left the country effectively 18-25% poorer, so the UK needs a massive injection of infrastructure investment in London, Manchester, Birmingham and beyond.
“The fall-off since then has left us effectively, depending on who you ask, anywhere between 18 percent and 25 percent poorer.”
The UK is a very centralized state in which even the Mayor of London has very limited powers — controlling transport and sharing police and planning authority — making the office far weaker than the Mayor of New York or a US state governor; this centralization should be changed.
“The reality is the UK is a very, very centralized state. Although there is a mayor of London... the reality is the mayor has very, very limited powers.”
A mid-level civil service career offers far more responsibility much earlier than expected, the chance to shape government policy and work with interesting people, and the unusual ability to change jobs roughly every two years across the whole range of government — a breadth of experience that is much harder to achieve across business.
“you can change your job every two years, and you can go and do things across the range of government in ways that is very difficult to do across the range of business.”
UK devolution is not too far but imbalanced because it violates the principle of aligning accountability, responsibility, and authority: devolved representatives have strong incentives to promise lavish spending and blame Westminster, since they raise little of the money they spend, unlike the layered US city-county-state-federal taxation, producing infrastructure and housing inequities.
“you’d have to be nuts, as a devolved representative seeking office, not to promise to pave the steep streets of your community with gold, and then to blame Westminster for not paying for it because you have very little responsibility for raising any of the money”
The Brexit deadlock reflected a real defect introduced by the Fixed-term Parliaments Act: it left a prime minister who could not command a Commons majority unable to dissolve Parliament, producing total inertia until the Liberal Democrats blundered into forcing an election; the system normally works because a PM must either command a majority or trigger Parliament's collapse, which forces honesty into votes.
“we got to a position, because of the Fixed-term Parliaments Act... where there was somebody in the Commons who was sitting in the seats of the prime minister but could not command a majority. That led to complete inertia”
Rent control is one of the single greatest threats to housing people, because once you start talking about it nobody wants to rent out or build a house; it is a disastrous policy that has been tried 100 times and failed 100 times.
“it’s one of the single greatest threats to the ability to house people, is to introduce rent controls. It’s a complete disaster of a policy that’s been tried 100 times and failed 100 times”
The immunity provisions of the 2023 Legacy Act for Northern Ireland are necessary and painful: after 40 years of repeated inquiries, the surviving subjects are men in their late 70s and 80s with sketchy or absent recollections, so the correct way to inquire into the past is now historical inquiry based on the written record rather than judicial processes.
“We’ve got to a point where the correct way of having inquiry into the past is to do historical inquiry based on written record, and I think that’s what this offers.”
The House of Lords should not be abolished because, despite being indefensible by design and demographically narrow, it works: the hereditary principle injects a lottery-like randomness and forces generational (50-100 year) thinking that counteracts democracy's chronic short-termism, while lacking power to block the elected chamber.
“The extraordinary thing about the House of Lords is it’s not something that anybody would invent — but it works.”
It cannot be right that the only way for disadvantaged kids or young people from certain areas to escape disadvantage is to join the armed forces; Tugendhat entered politics because, although the military gave many of his soldiers' relatives a way out, society must find better ways of solving these problems rather than relying on a general to fix everything.
“it simply cannot be right that the only way to help disadvantaged kids is for them to join the armed forces, or the only way for young people to have an opportunity from a certain area is to join the armed forces.”
The British parliamentary system endures and protects classical liberal foundations because it forces partnership: with only a few hundred MPs who must work together for years, even leadership rivals competing in a quasi-primary must cooperate, which forces remembering the long-term interest rather than the immediate one.
“our system forces you, into partnership. There are 650 people who you have to work with in some way in Parliament over the next four or five years.”
Where government is the only possible provider of a service — such as intelligence or defense — the best people work for the state despite lower salaries, because only in government can one truly use all the available powers and resources; where the work can be done in either sector (logistics, processing), the competition for talent is much harder.
“whenever the government is the only provider of that service — so intelligence or defense — and you can only really do it properly in government, then despite the salary differential, you still get the best people.”
Iran is a great civilization burdened by a cancerous, psychotic regime that effectively operates as a millenarian death cult — it openly states it is preparing for the coming of the Mahdi and must destroy Israel and conquer Jerusalem to achieve it — and when people tell you what they believe it is wise to believe they are telling the truth.
“when people tell you what they believe, it’s often wise to believe that they’re telling you the truth.”
Britain has never been better ruled than under its reigning queens — Elizabeth I, Victoria, and Elizabeth II — whose genius was to be a guiding presence without becoming strident or divisive, which is central to why the British monarchy has uniquely persisted as a global fascination.
“I think we’ve never been better governed and better ruled than when our reigning monarch is a woman.”
Thin electoral mandates make Tugendhat more optimistic about liberalism because winning requires appealing broadly and persuading opponents to support you or stay home; low turnout and low margins (as in 2024, with no enthusiasm or fear toward Keir Starmer) mean large seat majorities rest on weak foundations, so good ideas can produce rapid swings within a single term.
“the only way you get these mandates is by appealing to a wide enough section of your own voting bloc, and by convincing those who are against you either to support you or to stay away.”
Russia consistently goes wrong politically in ways hard to explain, but a constant fear of losing everything pervades Russian life — and that fear is rational given that, over the last 100 years, the probability of losing everything every 30-40 years has been quite high, as illustrated by Estonia outsourcing its public records abroad in anticipation that 'when the Russians come' they will be destroyed.
“if you look at Russian history even over the last 100 years, the probability of losing everything every 30 or 40 years is quite high.”
The most recent figure who would have become prime minister had he stayed in Parliament is George Osborne — when Theresa May returned from the 2017 election with a minority administration, Osborne would have become PM within weeks, a sliding-doors moment in British history.
“I think George Osborne would’ve been prime minister within weeks had he stayed in Parliament. But he stood down”
London is not a single city but many different villages cobbled together, and outsiders who only use the Tube or bus miss the real intimacy and small communities that become visible when walking along the river.
“the truth is, London isn’t a single city. It’s many, many different villages, all cobbled together in various different ways.”
British private schools like Tonbridge have reformed and are now far more integrated into their towns — offering bursaries (some students pay nothing), sharing sports facilities and theaters with the community, and running programs like the Combined Cadet Force — so although fees are now higher, the community benefit is substantial.
“Forty, fifty years ago, it would’ve been a very standalone institution, but the fees would’ve been relatively lower. Now the institution is much more integrated in many ways into the town.”
There is nothing wrong with repeating a good, well-liked architectural design — what some architects dismiss as pastiche — simply because the plumbing or wiring behind the facade has changed; you don't have to reinvent the wheel every time.
“I’m a fan of what some architects call pastiche. You don’t have to reinvent the wheel every single time.”
The Iranian regime has realized it can conduct large amounts of violence through proxies, with the Houthis, Hamas, and Lebanese Hezbollah functioning in many ways as proxies for the Iranian state.
“it’s also true that Hamas and Lebanese Hezbollah are mere proxies, in many ways, for the Iranian state.”
Asking for an underrated song is self-defeating, because you immediately reach for your favorite, which is almost by definition not underrated since you rate it so highly.
“when you say underrated, you immediately go to your favorite one, and your favorite one is almost by definition not underrated, because you know — very well.”
Kent's historic pattern of small landholdings persists today, giving the county a stronger feeling of equality than many other parts of the UK and making it a continuing source of political innovation and challenge.
“You still have much more of a feeling of equality in Kent than you do in many other parts of the United Kingdom.”