What this covers

This is a single-guest conversation with Peter Zeihan for the Institute for Liberal Values, built around how American party coalitions form, break and re-form. He starts from the mechanics: a first-past-the-post system with single-member districts pushes everyone into large coalitions, which is why third parties rarely become serious. He then walks through how factions inside the two parties rise, fall or switch sides every generation or two, and why the present moment resembles late Reconstruction and the Great Depression.

The middle of the discussion is a close reading of the current coalitions. Zeihan describes the 2016 election as the point where nearly every bloc fractured, with Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump each alienating constituencies. He argues Trump's main effect was activating a populist bloc that had sat out six elections, while picking fights with four establishment factions, including business and the national security community, who are now swing voters. He explains why unions, economically liberal but socially conservative, could move toward Trump, and he notes Trump's gains among Black and Hispanic voters. He also covers three routes by which a third party might arise, citing Theodore Roosevelt and Ross Perot, and he argues that a durable multiparty system would require a constitutional convention, which he treats as close to a free-for-all.

The final stretch turns outward. Zeihan contends that Joe Biden and Trump converge on isolationist trade, with Biden keeping and institutionalizing the tariff regime. He is pointed about Trump's stated intent to leave NATO and argues that the timing relative to Russia's decline matters. He disputes the right's argument that China, not Russia, is the real problem, and he discusses industrial policy as the US prepares for demographic dissolution in China. He also makes a case for why personalities matter more during transitions, citing Harry Truman. The more contested claims are the historical parallels and the characterization of populists as unable to consolidate.

Sharpest takeaway

The United States is in the sixth major political realignment in its history; current parties are irreversibly fractured and will consolidate into a seventh party structure within 1-2 election cycles, but this transition period leaves the US unable to project power internationally at a moment when major geopolitical crises (China's demographic collapse, Russia's war, EU dissolution) demand coordinated American leadership.

  • First-past-the-post electoral system forces coalition-building; when demographics and economics shift, factions realign—this has happened 5 times before and is happening now
  • Key power brokers (business community, national security establishment, unions) are currently homeless across both parties, leaving no coherent governing coalition or foreign policy consensus
  • During past transition periods (Reconstruction, Great Depression), the US abdicated international leadership, allowing totalitarianism and major-power wars to unfold unchecked; the next decade risks similar abdication during China's dissolution and Russia's war

The claims · ranked57 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

With regards to globalization, both Trump and Biden are going to be more isolationist in their trade policies; Trump ended the World Trade Organization and stopped all trade negotiations, and Biden has not only continued every single tariff Trump put on but has institutionalized them into US policy—they are converging on isolationism despite rhetorical differences.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“when it comes to economic issues absolutely I mean a lot of the business Community really really hated Trump for like basically shutting down the World Trade Organization and stopping all trade negotiations Biden hasn't picked up any of that stuff in fact every single tariff that Donald Trump put on Biden hasn't only continued with he's institutionalized into US policy”

0.74

To have an institutional third, fourth, or fifth party, you would need a constitutional amendment changing the electoral system; this is so fundamental that it would require a constitutional convention, something this country has never had, and there is no guidance in the Constitution as to how you run it or how many states get what votes; if we went to that stage, we'd be talking about everything being a free-for-all and a Bolivian-style cluster.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“if you want to have an Institutional third fourth or fifth party you have to have a constitutional change the electoral system is core in the Constitution we're not talking about a an amendment here we're talking about a constitutional convention which is something this country has never had and there's actually no guidance in the Constitution as to how you run it or how many states get what votes so if we were to go to that stage you're talking about everything being a free for-all and we have a Bolivian style cluster”

0.69

During the 2016 election, the coalitions broke down in an unprecedented way: Black Americans saw Hillary Clinton as undeserving (a former resident who didn't need to return to the White House); Socialists opposed her as a Wall Street representative; under-30s saw her as too old; Greens and unions fought over economic policy; unmarried women divided; on the Republican side, the business community saw Trump as a marketer, not a businessman; national security experts favored Clinton; Evangelicals split between younger ethical voters and older power-focused voters; pro-lifers were confused by Trump's shifting positions; fiscal conservatives saw Clinton as more conservative; and Catholics were alienated across the board.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“black Americans saw Hillary Clinton as a white chick who had already lived in in the White House and she didn't need to be there again the Socialists had a real problem with her because she was seen as a representative Wall Street same with the under 30s who saw her has too old uh the greens and unions got into a fight over what a good Economic Policy would be unmarried women liked her aside from the fact that she was married uh on the business on the Republican side the business Community looked at Trump and they saw not a business person but a marketer and not a very good one at that”

0.69

By activating this populist bloc, Trump ended up picking fights with four factions previously considered the adults in the room of American politics: he campaigned against their congressional candidates, purged them from his administration, and as of March 2024 purged all their representatives from the Republican National Committee; these four factions are now swing voters.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“in drawing this group into the system he ended up picking fights with four factions that had until now kind of been considered the adults in the room of American politics and he ended up campaigning against their candidates for congress he purged them from his administration and as of March of this year he purged all of their representatives from the Republican National Committee”

0.69

Despite the severity of coming crises, the United States is in a relatively good position because it is the world's largest food producer and exporter, the world's largest energy producer and processor and now exporter of finished refined product, and is massively expanding its industrial plant to insulate itself from China; these advantages mean if the world breaks, the US is in a pretty good spot, but if the world breaks, the US will still feel a lot of it.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“I focus on the really really big pictures and while all of things these things are crazy and substantial the impact directly on the United States is somewhat limited we the world's largest food producer and exporter we the world's largest food uh energy producer and processor and now exporter of finished goods or finished refined product and and we're in the process of massively expanding our industrial plant to insulate ourselves from the Chinese you know these are all good things and they mean if the world breaks we're in a pretty good spot but if the world breaks we will still feel a lot of it”

0.69

Unions are economically liberal (believing in government intervention to manage the economy) but socially conservative, so ideologically it is not a big step for them to shift from Democrats to Trump; Trump fights the culture war competently, which appeals to union voters' social conservatism.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the second issue unions may be economically liberal on the liberal versus conservative front but they're socially conservative so it wasn't really a big hop for them to make the shift especially when Donald Trump does fight the culture War very very competently”

0.69

There are three ways for a third party to break through: (1) a very powerful personality with massive personal following who can draw votes from both major parties (like Teddy Roosevelt or Ross Perot, though Perot failed and Trump would have gone this route if he hadn't captured the Republican party); (2) a fight within an existing party that splits it down the middle (which is where Democrats came from, and it could happen today in the Democratic party since Republicans are already consolidated); or (3) an organic, usually regional group rising up (like an urban party).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“well there's three ways we've done this in the past number one is you have a very very powerful personality who has enough of a personal following that they're able to draw votes from the other two uh that has happened in the past with us that's you know for example the Teddy Roosevelt play um Ross perau failed Donald Trump probably would have gone that path if he hadn't been able to capture the Republican party”

0.68

Donald Trump's single biggest political impact is that he activated a large populist voting bloc that had sat out the previous six presidential elections; this group was on the sidelines and had not been part of the political process, and under Trump's first term they got a taste of power for the first time and liked it, making them now not going away and forming today the single most numerous voting block in the system.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“enter Trump the single biggest impact that he has had is he's elevated one faction above all the others and they came in from left field right field I guess it would be uh the American populace have really sat out the last six presidential elections until Donald Trump came up out and so he was basically able to activate a group that was on the sidelines had not been part of the process and in doing so he made this very powerful very cohesive very loyal voting block that I would argue today is the single most numerous voting Block in the system”

0.68

In times when the American political system is unsettled (like during previous transitions in late Reconstruction and the Great Depression), it is hard to build consensus domestically and the US tends to ignore everything internationally; during the late Reconstruction period, Europe underwent mass urbanization and industrialization, European monarchies were collapsing and forming alliances that would lead to world wars, Japan rose as a major power, and American business people made foreign policy for themselves—a legacy that still poisons US-Latin American relations; during the Great Depression, totalitarianism rose across Europe and Northeast Asia (Hitler, Stalin consolidation, Spanish and Chinese Civil Wars, Japan's Pacific expansion), and the US was unable to play any role in these changes.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“in times when the American political system is unsettled like it is today it's hard to build in consensus on anything domestically and we tend to ignore everything internationally and if you look at the third to the fourth transition and the fourth to the fifth transition the first one is late reconstruction the fourth to the fifth is in the Great Depression the Americans basically didn't play a role in much of anything from a government point of view”

0.68

Every generation or two, as the world changes—demographics shift, economic patterns evolve, employment patterns transform—the factions within the two major parties rise and fall in power, sometimes jumping to the swing category or switching sides completely; the last major reshuffling was in the Great Depression when Democrats and Republicans fundamentally swapped their core constituencies (big business left the Republican party, African-Americans shifted from Republican to Democrat).

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“every generation or two when you have two big tents things have changed the world has changed we've changed demographics have changed economic patterns have changed employment patterns have changed and every time that happens the factions that make up the parties move around they rise and fall in power within their own big tents and sometimes factions jump into the swing category or maybe even switch sides completely”

0.68

The American political system is fundamentally structured as a first-past-the-post, single-member district network, which forces the formation of large coalitions because winning requires only one more vote than the second-place competitor; this mathematical reality means that with nine parties, you could win with just 15% of the vote, but coalitions force that threshold much higher, making it nearly impossible for a third party to become serious.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“the key thing to remember about the American political system is that it's a first past the post single member district Network which is a funny political science legally way of saying that you vote for a specific person who would then represent a specific group of people in a specific geography you don't vote for a party you vote for a guy or a gal and because of this system uh we tend to get two very very large coalitions”

0.68

Union opposition to bipartisan free trade and alliance consensus for 75 years stems from how US globalization policy functioned: by allowing unstable countries to stabilize through US military protection and granting them access to American markets, the US provided an unfair advantage to less-stable countries, which indirectly hurt unions by raising competition for American workers; Trump directly confronted this consensus while Democrats perpetuated it.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“international affairs from an American point of view has been based on an alliance system for decades also on International engagement and open trade of various forms and you know there's definitely differences Administration to Administration party to party but there's been a bilateral excuse me a bipartisan consensus on that for decades um that consensus is arguably the single biggest detriment to the unions of the last 75 years because if you allow countries to compete on a Level Playing Field American workers will do very very well but if you provide a globalized structure where countries that normally couldn't be stable themselves are allowed to be stable because the United States destroys all of the threats and allows everyone to access everyone else's Market you're providing from the Union's point of view an unfair advantage to the countries that are less stable by elevating them and that has indirectly hurt the unions”

0.68

JD Vance and others are arguing that Russia is not the problem but China is; however, there is no China without Russia—if you want to destroy China, the easiest way is to kneecap Russia, because that's where the energy and raw materials for China come from; this creates a disconnect in national security thinking on the right because they've ejected all the people who actually can find Canada on a map.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“there seems to be this movement that uh especially JD Vance is is um headlining for the idea that Russia's not the problem that China's the problem but there is no China without Russia I mean if you want to destroy China the easiest way to do that is to neak I'm sorry if you want to yeah if you want to destroy China the easiest way to do that is to kneecap Russia that's where the energy and the raw materials come from so there's this disconnect in National Security issues on the right because they've ejected all the people who actually can find Canada on a map”

0.68

In moments of political transition like today, personalities matter a lot because institutions matter less; the US has had a remarkable absence of debate about central power versus states since the Civil War and respect for elections, so changes at the top have been the only real foreign policy changes; the last time through a major realignment was post-WWII with Truman, and if we had emerged with a different president, we might not have had the Japanese Alliance or the Cold War structure—these presidential personalities shaped decades of policy.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“in moments of transition like this when the new consens or the new foreign policy diet hasn't been imagined yet it really comes down to the decision-making of the people in question the last time we went through one of these reshufflings for real the really big one was in the Great Depression the last time we went through one of these reshufflings for real the really big one was in the Great Depression”

0.68

Populists have their moment during political transitions but never consolidate into a stable new political force because they are cultish, not good at math, don't respect rule of law, and once you try to make a political movement out of that, it only takes one person dying and the whole thing falls apart; whichever party is more responsible tends to pick up the pieces, and this happened in favor of Republicans last time (with Reconstruction populists) and Democrats the time before.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“historically speaking the populists have their moment during the transition but they're never able to consolidate into a new political force because ultimately they're cultish they're not good at math they don't respect the rule of law and if you try to make a political movement out of that all it takes is one person dying and then the whole thing falls apart and whichever party is more responsible if that's the right term tends to pick up the pieces and run with it”

0.68

Third parties can emerge during transitions when an existing party splits or falls apart, and they might exist for one or two election cycles, but they either need to merge or drive a bigger party apart to achieve national power, and once it becomes clear they can never get power, they collapse quickly; a third party between national security conservatives, business community, and labor could be interesting but would not be stable beyond one or two cycles.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“we do get third parties in times of transition like we have right now basically you have a party that splits in half or falls apart or a new group that rises up and in the time you have like a one political cycle maybe two where the three of them do get out but it becomes very very clear that the two smaller ones either need to merge or find a way to drive the bigger one into pieces in order to have a chance at National Power because it's all great to say you have a third party but if the third party can never get into power it falls apart pretty quickly”

0.68

One of the beautiful things about globalization was that the US held the lid on everything and made everything stable in places that normally wouldn't be; now that the United States is stepping back from that role, the lid is coming off and what happens in everyone's individual backyard all of a sudden matters a lot more—this is why chaos is global.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“it's there are a lot of Els this year and a lot of them really matter and a lot of them have gone batshit that's a very optimistic tune well it's like one of the beautiful things about globalization is the US kind of held the lid on everything and made everything stable in places that normally wouldn't be now that the United States is stepping back from that role the LD is coming off and what happens in everyone's individual backyard all of a sudden matters a lot more”

0.64

Trump has garnered a greater percentage of African-American and Hispanic voters than any Republican president of the last 60 years (not a majority, but enough to spook Democrats); this suggests that Trump's coalition is acquiring some breadth despite being dominated by white working-class voters.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“Donald Trump for all of his faults and yes there's a list garnered a greater percentage of africanamerican and Hispanic voters than any Republican president of the last 60 years that is not around in error despite all of his flaws in bits and pieces some of that big tent feeling is starting to happen a little bit he's not to the majority of either of those communities but it is enough to Spook the Democrats”

0.64

Trump has been able to consolidate the Republican party by remaking it as the 'Donald Trump party'; he has absorbed Never Trumpers like JD Vance, Nikki Haley, and Ron DeSantis into leadership positions, though the absorption is incomplete and sometimes awkward (Nikki Haley's endorsement appeared forced).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“he has been able because he's remade the party as the Donald Trump party as I if I heard you correctly uh he's been able though to pull in these people who were never trumpers the JD vces the Nikki Haley's the you the disantis”

0.63

Donald Trump made it very clear near the end of his first term that if reelected, the first thing he would do on day one of his second term was leave NATO, which would have significant implications for National Security.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“Donald Trump made it very clear near the end of his first term that if he was reelected the first thing he would do on his second term the first day was leave NATO obviously that would have some implications for National Security issues”

0.62

Trump brought in national security experts who could speak truth to power in his first term, but they were never the last person to flatter him, so he fired them and went with Russians and Chinese instead—this is problematic from a security perspective and suggests a second Trump term would have similar personnel problems.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the problem with predicting Trump it's whoever flattered him most recently who gets their way and the problem we saw in his first term is he brought in a lot of people in the National Security Community who really knew what they were doing but they were willing to speak truth to power so they were never the last person to Flat flatter Donald Trump he fired them he went with the Russians and the Chinese”

0.61

The optimal manufacturing configuration is: the United States is really good at high-end design and research; Mexico is really good at mid-quality assembly and medium-tier production; combining those two produces the most powerful economy in the world by a factor of three; breaking them apart means neither works well.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the United States is really good at the highend we're really good at the design Mexico is really good at the mid quality they're really good at the assembly and you combine those two you get the most powerful econom in the world by like a factor of three you break them apart and neither of them work well”

0.60

Leaving NATO while a hot war with a nuclear power (Russia) is ongoing is a really big deal; if the US withdraws from Europe while Russia is intact and on the war path, it's one strategic outcome; if the US withdraws when Russia is broken after the demographic bomb, it's a very different outcome—the timing matters enormously.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“we have a hot war with the nuclear power going on right now and if this is the moment the US steps back we are picking a really big fight for us on the long term if we can hold on for another four years and I'm not saying that because that's the presidential term that's how long the Russians can maintain their current Tempo it's a different conversation if the US withdraws from Europe while Russia is intact and on the war path that's one thing if the US withdraws from Europe when Russia is broken and on the other side of the demographic bomb that's another”

0.60

The biggest issue the United States faces in the next decade is that as the Chinese system breaks up due to demographic dissolution, if the US still wants manufactured goods, it has to build them itself, requiring a massive industrial policy that allows very rapid expansion of the industrial plant and electrical grid; this is a states-level issue that should be solved decentralized, though this is slower and the US has limited time.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the biggest issue that the United States has to wrestle two issues that the US has to wrestle with in the next decade regardless of who is the president number one as the Chinese system breaks up due to demographic dissolution if we still want stuff we have to build it ourselves so we need to have an industrial policy that allows us to very very rapidly build out the industrial plant and our electrical grid”

0.60

Trump's Republican coalition today is powerful, large, and loyal but is not enough to win an election, because big tents are how you win elections; the coalition has a very real problem reaching out and forming alliances with other factions.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“this today is the Trump Republican Coalition it is powerful it is large it is loyal and it is not enough to win an election remember big tents are how you win an election and this group has a very real problem reaching out and forming alliances with other people”

0.57

Trump was atypical in his Mexican relationship compared to other US presidents: he had a one-on-one relationship with Amlo that was reasonably productive; Trump basically told Amlo 'if you become the real wall in blocking Central American migrants to the US, I will let you have your way on everything else (water rights, security, drug war)'—with that sort of simple, transactional deal, the trade relationship was fine.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“Donald Trump was an atypical president for the Mexican relationship and that he had a one-on-one relationship with amlo that was actually reasonably productive he basically told Amo if you become the real wall in blocking Central American migrants to the United States I will let your way H you have your way on everything else else water rights security issues the drug war I don't care what anything else is you just deal with that one issue and with that sort of backdrop the trade relationship was fine”

0.56

If Chinese demographic collapse is as severe as new data suggests (8 million children under age five lost in recent data), then the US will need to double the size of its industrial plant to supply goods the world still demands; virtually all of these new manufacturing jobs will be blue-collar, positioning the US at the beginning of a golden age of organized labor.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“if I am right about the Chinese and their depopulation is really as bad as it looks and the new data from just this week suggests that they lost another 8 million children under age five well [ __ ] if we still want stuff we need to double the size of the industrial plant how many of those jobs do you think are going to be bluecollar all of them so we're at the beginning of the golden age of organized labor in the United States”

0.56

In the next 10 years, the United States will face multiple simultaneous geopolitical crises: demographic dissolution of the Chinese system, probable end of the European Union, significant expansion of Russia's war in Ukraine to involve nuclear powers, a war in the Middle East that hits the energy sector, continental-scale famines in the Eastern Hemisphere, global energy shortages, and when China breaks, all hell will break loose in the Middle East; the United States cannot address any of this while preoccupied with domestic political realignment.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“in the next 10 years we're going to see the demographic dissolution of the Chinese system we're probably going to see the end of the European Union we're going to see a significant expansion of Russia's war in Ukraine to involve a number of nuclear Powers we're probably going to see a war in the Middle East that hits the energy sector and of course when China breaks all hell is going to break loose in the Middle East we are going to have F famines on a continental scale in various parts of the Eastern Hemisphere and we're also going to have Global energy shortages”

0.52

The Teamsters union boss appeared at the Republican National Convention, which would have resulted in arrest eight years ago; this shift reflects that the business community being part of the coalition is necessary for union busting—without the business community in the Republican coalition, union busting is not possible, so the unions no longer have that enemy to fear from Republicans.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“you'd mentioned the unions and how they shifted and the union boss came and spoke at the RNC and that had A's boss of all of them like basically if you want to put concrete shoes on someone the teamsters are the people you turn to so you know to have them show up at the RNC I mean this had happened eight years ago the guy would have probably been arrested”

0.52

As long as the US is preoccupied with figuring out what the next political evolution will be, it won't have the bandwidth to focus on international affairs in a seriously meaningful way, no matter who wins the presidency, because the problem is structural—not a function of individual leadership.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“as long as we're [ __ ] around with figuring out what the next political evolution is going to be we won't have the bandwidth to focus on International Affairs in a seriously meaningful way no matter who wins the presidency”

0.52

The unions and the business community are, for the first time in American history, not in one coalition or another; they have traditionally been the backbone of the two parties typically on opposite sides, and their conversations, debates, and compromises are responsible for economic policy; without them in the room, there isn't coherent economic policy, which will be a problem until these factions rejoin one or the other coalition.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“there's any number of ways that we can go with this but let me focus on two first of all the unions in the business Community for the first time in American history are not in one Coalition or another they have traditionally been the backbone of the two parties typically on opposite sides and their conversations their debates their compromises is what is responsible for economic policy in this country”

0.52

The national security folks are not even in the room during this realignment, and business and national security have been the core of American foreign policy going back over a century; their absence will have severe geopolitical consequences.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the other issue from my point of view which is just as important if not more is that the National Security fots are not even in the room and if you look at these two factions business and National Security that has been the core of American foreign policy going back over a century and again they are no longer in the room”

0.52

Republicans have historically needed to capture at least two-thirds of independents to win the presidency, because there are fewer Republicans than Democrats; Trump has told independents that their vote doesn't matter and should be decided at the primary level, which was not a smart political move and undermines his general election prospects.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“Republicans have never ever captured the presidency without capturing at least two-thirds of The Independents remember there's fewer Republicans and Democrats they need those independent votes and Donald Trump Has Told The Independents that their vote doesn't matter that it should all be decided at the primary level well that that wasn't very smart”

0.52

The second big challenge is relations with Mexico, because nothing in the American manufacturing system works today without Mexican involvement; if the US loses the low-end productive capacity and quality of China and has to do it on its own without Mexico, the result would be a catastrophic loss in economic vitality and standard of living, with massive political consequences.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the second Big Challenge is relations with Mexico because there is nothing in the American manufacturing system that works today without some Mexican involvement and if we're going to lose the low-end productive capacity low-end quality productive capacity of China then Mexico is our best friend in replacing that in North America and if relations between the United States and Mexico fall apart and we have to do this on our own we're looking at a catastrophic loss in economic vitality and in the standard of living of the of the average American”

0.49

The United States is currently in the midst of its sixth major political realignment and will enter what will be called the seventh party structure; these transition periods take anywhere from four to 12 years, and based on the current timeline (year six to seven of this transition), there is probably one more political cycle to go through before the new coalitions settle.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“we're in the midst of this process right now this is not the second time we've done it this is not the third time we've done it this is the sixth time we've done it and when we emerge from this on the other side we will be entering what will be called the seventh party structure but we're not there yet”

0.49

Trump has done a better job catering to union insecurities and hopes than Democrats have; with Democrats, it has mostly been about making unions into a voting machine, which worked until six years ago.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“to be perfectly blunt Trump's version of the Republican party has done a better job of catering to these people's insecurities and hopes than the Democrats have with the Democrats I'm a little oversimplifying here but it's been mostly about making them into a voting machine and that worked until six years ago”

0.49

One could imagine an urban coalition that involves the business side of the current Republican coalition and the intellectual side of the current Democratic coalition, which would be diametrically opposed to what Trump is trying to form and would be potentially a stable mix; alternatively, one could imagine a more corporatist European coalition where unions and the business community are in the same group, which would also be potent.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“you can imagine I'm not saying it's going to go this way but you can imagine an urban Coalition that involves the business side of the current Republican Coalition and the intellectual side of the current Democratic Coalition which would be diametrically opposed to what Trump is trying to form that is potentially a stable mix you can also Imagine a more Co European Coalition where the unions and the business Community are in the same group that would be potent”

0.48

The Republican coalition historically built around rule of law, national security, strong economic growth, the business community, and social conservative values is gone; the Democratic coalition built around racial inequality and intellectualism is gone; the new coalitions and their factions will realign, and it's unknown how the factions that respect rule of law and national security will reconstitute.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the Coalition that on the Republican side has built been built around rule of law National Security strong economic growth the business community and then to as the side car um social conservative values the Democratic Coalition that's been built around racial inequality and intellectualism those two coalitions are gone and we don't know how the factions that respect the things that you're identifying with are going to come together or not”

0.48

The Democratic party came from a mechanism-(2) split; if a similar split happened today in Democrats, it would involve Governors as candidates because campaign finance has made it very difficult for people with political track records to run (anyone can find something to attack), so we get ideologues; Governors make better presidents because they actually have to deal with people they don't like and still make trains run on time.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“this is exactly where the Democrats came from uh and if it were to happen today I think it would probably happen in the Democratic party because the Republican party is already broken um it's already been Consolidated into this new form that's very prot Trump and all the old school the reaganite Republicans have been forced into the political Wilderness”

0.46

Democrats don't need coherence to win; Republicans need coherence because they have fewer voters; with the probable loss of the unions as a voting bloc, Democrats really need to figure out another plan or they will flip with Republicans in having fewer voters.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“on the left they don't need coherence that has been something that it's been the Republicans that need now that's for this electoral cycle the Democrats are as disorganized as ever and with the possible probable loss of the unions they really need to figure out another plan or they're going to have a flip with the Republicans in that they will have fewer voters”

0.45

Mexico is only really being a real democracy for about four election cycles now, so Mexico is also making up its political system as it goes along, just like the United States is with its realignment.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“keep in mind that Mexico is really only being a real democracy for like four election Cycles here so they're making this up as they go along just like we are with our political system”

0.45

Trump is not a builder, he is a breaker; it is very easy for a president to take a treaty, an association, or a relationship and end it because there is a lot of executive authority in that, which Trump proved; it is much more difficult for a president to come in and build something new because that requires a degree of attention that Donald Trump has never demonstrated.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“he's not a builder he's a breaker and so it's very very easy for the president to take a treaty to take an association to take a relationship and end it there's a lot of executive Authority in that and Trump proved that it's much more difficult for a president to come in and build something and that requires a degree of attention that Donald Trump has never demonstrated”

0.45

Trump's assassination attempt survivor status is unprecedented in American politics; we have no modern example of a presidential nominee who was an assassination attempt target and survived; the only past example is Teddy Roosevelt, who finished his speech after being shot and then led his party to one of the five greatest electoral defeats in American history, so caution should be used in predicting how this will affect Trump's political future.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“I have to go with a firm I don't know because this has never happened in American politics before we've never had somebody who was obviously going to get the nomination who was the target of an assassination attempt and survived obviously if Trump had died would be really easy to forecast his political future um that's a copout of course uh but the last guy who got the nomination was shot was Teddy Roosevelt who finished his speech after getting shot and went on to lead his party to one of the five greatest electoral defeats in American history”

0.45

There is a lot of knee-jerk reaction on the Republican side that is completely disconnected from reality; Biden, despite his faults, was around when the Han ethnicity emerged (sometime in the 3rd century AD), so he remembers their rise and has had a conservative, classically conservative approach to foreign policy; this gives him a degree of grounding that we're not seeing in Republicans.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“there's a lot of knee-jerk reactions that are completely disconnected from reality uh say what you will about Jo Biden he was around when the Han ethnicity emerged sometime in the 3 Century ad he remembers their rise probably uh although that's a little bit in doubt now and so he's actually had a very conservative approach classically conservative approach to most of the foreign policy questions does that make him an aess president no but it does at least give him a degree of grounding that we're not seeing in the Republicans these days”

0.45

The 'Law and Order' group currently has a terrible menu of choices; this includes border and immigration officials who like Trump, financial sector/regulation folks (a much larger group) who are completely in the mix, and law enforcement who have discovered that security threats have shifted from left-wing groups (Black Lives Matter, Antifa) to white people with weapons, creating fear and confusion.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“it's like at the moment the menu for that group is awful so you know you're going to have folks like I don't know border and ins who obviously like Trump for a number of reasons but you're going to have all people in the financial sector doing regulations uh which are a much larger group physically who are completely in the mix folks in law enforcement have discovered in the last few years that they've gone from very much on the right being concerned about groups like black lives matter and antifa to all of a sudden finding themselves having to deal with weapons and white people and it's like just the security environment in this country has changed dramatically in the last 10 years”

0.44

Neither Biden nor Trump is comparable to Truman or Roosevelt; both are obsessed with domestic political issues (culture war, economic repositioning), and for them foreign affairs are an edge issue at most; while Trump is more vocal about isolationism, on economic issues (international trade, globalization breakdown) Biden and Trump are the two most similar presidents in US history.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“we are now at one of those moments in history and I don't care how much you love Biden or how much you love Trump but neither of them is a Truman or a Roosevelt these are people who are obsessed with domestic political issues it's the culture War it's the repositioning of the American economy for them Foreign Affairs are an edge issue at most”

0.43

If Donald Trump were to die today, the Republican Party would basically become a third party and the Democrats would probably split in half; this represents the fissure points of the current political system.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Peter Zeihan

“don't get mad at me if Donald Trump were to die today the Republican Party would basically become a third party and the Democrats would probably split in half that's just kind of where the fisser points are right now”

0.43

The Mexican border communities have evolved over 30 years and now have higher value-added per cost unit than Canadian manufacturers; they are highly efficient; comparing raw material cost versus final product quality, the US-Mexico border may represent the highest value-added economy in the world, making Mexico an irreplaceable partner.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“most of the Border communities in on the Mexican US border now actually have a higher value ad per per cost unit than Canadian manufacturers they've really come a long way in the last 30 years and from if you compare the the cost of the material or the raw the low-end components that go into Mexico versus the stuff that comes out it's arguably the highest value at economy in the world right now”

0.42

An open Democratic convention late in the process (if Biden withdraws) would be good because it prevents wackadoos who want crazy candidates from controlling the process, and any Democratic governor would make a solid candidate for moderate voters.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“I would argue that any Democratic governor would make a solid candidate for moderate voters that's the whole point of having an open convention this late in the process is all the wackadoos who want crazy candidates don't control the process that would be a step forward no matter which party it was”

0.42

The way to overcome Democratic disorganization is by building new factional coalitions or having a very strong personality at the top; Democrats are far behind Republicans in this regard currently.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“the way you get around this is by building new factional Coalition or having a very strong personality at the top and in that the Democrats are far behind the Republicans”

0.41

Biden is a more traditional president in Mexico relations, addressing all bilateral issues (water rights, security, drug war) rather than focusing on one; Amlo took this as a personal front because he was defensive about these issues; since Amlo is no longer president, it is really new and uncertain how the relationship will evolve.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Peter Zeihan

“Joe Biden is a much more traditional president and that there's all these issues in the bilateral relationship as a neighbor that we have to talk about and Amo being the ass hat that he was took that as a personal front so if Amo was still the president I could tell you how it would probably go down but Amo isn't the president so it really is new”

0.36

A new Mexican president is taking office, which is good because the previous president (Amlo) combined the worst attributes of Donald Trump, Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, and JD Vance—he was an incompetent ideologue driven by ideology regardless of what was happening in the world; the incoming president (Sheinbaum) is Amlo's protégé, so her independence from him remains to be seen.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Peter Zeihan

“we're about to get a new president in Mexico which is great because the last one was a [ __ ] uh whether not the new one is going to be sufficiently independent from the old guy remains to be seen I'm sorry let me use names Am low is the old guy he basically combined the worst attributes of Donald Trump Bernie Sanders Elizabeth Warren and JD Vance and T and Ted Cruz that's Quite a feat an incompetent [ __ ] um driven by ideology regardless of what actually was happening in the world um unfortunately Shin bomb the incoming president is his prot so we don't know how independent she will be”

0.34

The two major parties only cooperate to keep third parties from becoming too powerful; there is no incentive on either major party to let a new competitor emerge and consolidate power.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“they they can it seems like the only at least my view of it the only two the only time that the two traditional parties seem to get along is when they try to keep the third party from becoming too powerful so have it how does that third party get around all this I mean that's because it I mean I think it would be introduce a new Dynamic to I think it would be interesting but there's no incentive on either the two major parties to let let the let the new guy on the Block come in”

0.32

Chaos is not limited to the United States; many elections are happening this year and many of them have gone 'batshit'—this is a global phenomenon, not just American.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“no it's there are a lot of Els this year and a lot of them really matter and a lot of them have gone batshit”

0.29

When it comes to politics, the speeches and narratives change quickly based on current events, so the assassination attempt will be discussed differently by each camp: Republicans (at RNC) claim it helps Trump, while later Biden will talk about going toe-to-toe with COVID; this is normal political messaging and doesn't reveal real impact.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“we are having the Republican poll loser right now so of course they're going to say anything that talks up their candidate and by the time we get to august 19 assuming that Biden is still gonna be the candidate he's gonna be talking about how he went toe-to-toe with covid and won and everyone's gonna be like Yay beat Co you know it's like this is just the part for the course when it comes to politics”

0.19

Both Biden and Trump are nearly 80 years old; neither Biden nor Trump will be the oldest president on their respective first terms (Biden would be the oldest president ever; Trump would be the oldest on first taking office); this age differential is significant.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Peter Zeihan

“I've got a question about the Republican party but you know it's 180 billion years old you might not aren't they both about that same age pretty close they're they're less than two years apart so if Trump I mean obviously if Biden wins he'll be the oldest president ever but if Donald Trump wins he will be the oldest president on the first a hipst term as well”

0.13

Oprah is the only person besides Trump who could potentially throw her hat in the ring and change the third-party pattern, but she has made it very clear she is not interested.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Peter Zeihan

“I wouldn't rule it out but I wouldn't say that there's anyone out there except for maybe like Oprah uh who could throw their hat in the ring and actually change the the the pattern and she has made it very clear she is not interested”