eminent domain
The government's power to take private property (with compensation) for public use, historically used to overcome holdouts in land assembly.
As defined in Jenny Schuetz on Land Regulation and the Housing Market
Other definitions
The government's power to compulsorily acquire private property (with compensation) for public use, used to overcome holdout/gridlock when assembling land.
Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009
Where it comes up · 18
- John Allison on Strategy, Profits, and Self-Interest 5/7/20075 claims
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - What Robert Caro learned about power after studying it for 50 years3 claims
- Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/20073 claims
- Anthony Gill on Religion2 claims
- Jenny Schuetz on Land Regulation and the Housing Market2 claims
- Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/20062 claims
- Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/20091 claim
- Ryan Avent on Cities, Urban Regulations, and Growth 10/31/20111 claim
and 10 more
Most important claims · 10 of 29Search all claims for “eminent domain” →
- Unlike oil and gas mineral holders, who have quasi-eminent domain to extract, water disposal has no eminent domain protection, so a rancher can refuse access or demand high payments, which makes disposal routes across many landholders hard to build.WaterBridge: Oil and Water
- Schemes requiring a vote or agreement of neighborhood landowners face holdout problems: if a developer needs 50% approval and has 49%, the marginal holdout can demand an outrageous payout, which is historically why eminent domain has been used to overcome holdouts—so any compensation scheme must be structured to prevent a handful of holdouts from blocking it.Jenny Schuetz on Land Regulation and the Housing Market
- Even in the United States, with a transparent legal system and good respect for private property, exchanging property is expensive because of large transaction costs—thousands of dollars to prove a house is yours, that the boundaries are as claimed, and that you are not a squatter—often requiring title insurance, so economists' casual talk of straightforward property rights understates the real cost of ambiguity and lack of trust.Jim Epstein on Bitcoin, the Blockchain, and Freedom in Latin America
- Kelo v. New London is immensely important because it held that tax revenue could count as a public good justifying eminent domain seizures—whereas eminent domain previously required a physical public use like a sewage plant or freeway—thereby opening a Pandora's box that gives local governments enormous power and temptation to seize property for higher-revenue uses.Anthony Gill on Religion
- Today's restrictive community-engagement process originated in legitimate 1960s-70s reactions to urban renewal (federal bulldozing of poor and minority neighborhoods for highways) and the environmental movement, which together established mandatory community consultation; but this process was later co-opted by wealthy white homeowners who define 'the community' as themselves and use it to block all change.Jenny Schuetz on Land Regulation and the Housing Market
- Detroit should 'shrink to greatness' by restricting where city services are available, charging the incremental cost of services to those outside compact core areas (or not providing some services there), pressuring people to relocate to denser areas, and selling off remaining space to private developers—combined with near-complete charterization of schools and borrowing successful policing tactics from cities like New York.Edward Glaeser on Cities
- Despite the public perception that the oyster company was treated unfairly, Brennan's research found no evidence of any promise or suggestion of lease renewal; Kevin Lunny bought the farm in 2004 knowing the lease was terminable and would expire in 2012, so the eviction involved no deception—he simply did not get the outcome he wanted.Summer Brennan on Wilderness, Politics and the Oyster War
- Property rights are a key dimension of religious liberty because congregants need physical meeting places (churches, synagogues, mosques), so any restriction raising the cost of acquiring or using such property restricts religious freedom; local governments increasingly bias zoning and land-use decisions against churches because tax-exempt church land generates far less revenue than commercial uses.Anthony Gill on Religion
- Societies settle on a stable equilibrium of both common property (open access governed by rules, like roads and beaches) and private property (exclusive ownership), because geometry and access problems mean neither alone works: long linear assets like roads need assembly and eminent domain, while factories and farms need exclusive, intensive use.Richard Epstein on Property Rights and Drug Patents 2/19/2007
- Eminent domain solves the holdup problem by eliminating individual ownership when assembling a large bundle of property rights, but it is a last-best 'nuclear option'—abused (raising Public Choice problems, as in Kelo), broadly hated, and not the right approach for intellectual property, where the analogous government 'march-in' right on patents would crush pharmaceutical companies' incentive to invest the ~billion dollars it takes to develop a drug.Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009