diminishing returns
The economic principle that adding more of a variable input while holding another input fixed eventually yields progressively smaller increases in output.
As defined in Joel Mokyr on Growth, Innovation, and Stagnation
Other definitions
The principle that each added unit of input yields smaller gains, here applied to extracting lower-grade ore, oil, and farmland productivity.
An Uncertain Crisis
Where it comes up · 18
- William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better3 claims
- Making Your 80,000 Hours Count (with Benjamin Todd)2 claims
- The future of intelligence | Demis Hassabis (Co-founder and CEO of DeepMind)2 claims
- Mental Models for complexity | Scott Page and Shane Parrish | The Knowledge Project #552 claims
- Tyler Cowen in Discussion With Dwarkesh Patel2 claims
- Putin is Facing Something Even Worse Than Ukraine | Mark Galeotti1 claim
- An Update on Public Markets1 claim
- An Uncertain Crisis1 claim
and 10 more
Most important claims · 10 of 24Search all claims for “diminishing returns” →
- Effective altruism asks five questions to do the most good: (1) what is the impact on wellbeing—how many benefit and by how much; (2) is this the most effective option, since the best programs are far better than merely good ones; (3) is the area neglected, invoking diminishing returns; (4) what would have happened otherwise (counterfactual impact); and (5) what are the chances of success and how good would success be (expected value).William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better
- With fixed recipes, adding more physical capital runs into diminishing returns—the way a distribution center gains huge value from the first forklift but almost none from the fiftieth—which is why economies like the Soviet Union that tried to grow purely through heavy capital investment with essentially no innovation grew briefly then rapidly stalled.Paul Romer on Growth 8/27/2007
- Being a doctor has a smaller impact than people assume because healthcare contributed only a couple of years to life expectancy (most gains came from public health, sanitation, and wealth), those gains are shared across nurses and equipment, there are strong diminishing returns in rich countries, and a fixed number of medical school places means a replacement would have done most of the work; the marginal impact estimates out to roughly saving one life per ten years of work as a UK doctor.Making Your 80,000 Hours Count (with Benjamin Todd)
- Although advertising and virtual goods have an inexhaustible supply, people's time and money are finite, so as their income and attention spread across more products, advertising loses power and each ad becomes less effective—producing diminishing returns in the attention economy, though this limit is still far off.Esther Dyson on the Attention Economy and the Quantification of Everything
- Ricardo understood finishing returns logic and how it applies to growth; he was pessimistic but had the logic right; if Ricardo could see AI today, he would not be surprised—he would see it as extending the frontier but not solving the fundamental problem of diminishing returns.Tyler Cowen in Discussion With Dwarkesh Patel
- The model that AI can make more AI (recursive self-improvement leading to explosive growth) has been understood since classical economics: Ricardo and Malthus discussed diminishing returns to population growth; they recognized that exponential growth in one factor faces constraints from other scarce factors.Tyler Cowen in Discussion With Dwarkesh Patel
- Edmund Phelps is wrong to dismiss conceptual scientific breakthroughs in favor of small trial-and-error innovation; without periodic expansion of fundamental understanding (a change in the 'fixed factor'), incremental innovation will run into diminishing returns, just as classical physics could only take us so far before quantum mechanics enabled electronics.Joel Mokyr on Growth, Innovation, and Stagnation
- At high levels of on-balance-sheet federal debt, each incremental dollar of debt produces diminishing returns and becomes ineffective at stimulating growth, which the speaker considers deflationary, and this has been shown academically.An Update on Public Markets
- Because wellbeing varies roughly with the log of income (any percentage increase in income yields the same wellbeing gain), and a typical American is about 40 times richer than the poorest billion while money goes about 2.5 times further overseas, halving your income could double the income of about 100 very poor people, meaning you can benefit others roughly 100 times as much as you can benefit yourself.William MacAskill on Effective Altruism and Doing Good Better
- The logic by which AIs making more AIs hits limits was already understood by classical economists: Malthus and Ricardo analyzed how rapidly breeding humans faced diminishing returns against other scarce factors, so if they saw today's AI they would expect it to extend the frontier but not solve all problems—an insight Bay Area thinkers, who overvalue intelligence, tend to miss.Tyler Cowen — The #1 bottleneck to AI progress is humans