Esther Dyson on the Attention Economy and the Quantification of Everything
What this covers
Esther Dyson and Russ Roberts explore how attention functions as a distinct economic resource—one that defies the usual rules of modern markets. Dyson argues that attention is scarce and cannot be duplicated or mass-produced, meaning it remains stubbornly non-fungible and resistant to pricing, yet it carries intrinsic value because people derive satisfaction from being noticed. The conversation ranges across what happens when productivity gains and technological abundance free time that flows not into measured economic activity but into online exchanges of content and amusement—a reversion toward direct, face-to-face barter rather than priced transactions.
The discussion moves into the blind spots created by [quantification](concept:Limits of Measurement). Dyson emphasizes that measuring short-term returns can starve long-term investments like education or preventive health, whose payoffs materialize too slowly to register in quarterly metrics. This paradox extends to individual behavior: the quantified self movement shows that tracking behavior changes it, yet metrics themselves—Flickr views, podcast downloads—are engineered to only climb, creating a kind of "attention sugar" that mimics satisfaction without building genuine attention capacity. The conversation also addresses venture capital and entrepreneurship, including distinctions between founding and scaling, the role of luck versus skill in investing outcomes, and Steve Jobs's actual gift for making teams productive rather than technical brilliance. A final strand considers how the internet reshapes cognition toward shorter attention spans and less narrative structure, alongside a glance at how private enterprise is beginning to alter space travel by replacing government risk-aversion with commercial appetite for repeated ventures.
Dyson argues that attention is becoming an economy unto itself—a scarce, non-fungible, non-priced resource that satisfies primal human drives and increasingly draws people away from the measured commercial economy back toward a barter-like exchange of content and amusement.
- Attention is scarce and cannot be duplicated, so it has intrinsic value to people but is not easily traded or priced
- Quantification (of self, community, attention) drives behavior change but cannot capture long-term value
- Productivity gains free up time people spend on economically uncountable activities online
Real entrepreneurial value lies not in starting but in building scalable, sustainable institutions that leverage teams and infrastructure.
- The archetypal entrepreneur is like the conman in the stone soup story (or Tom Sawyer): someone who makes something out of nothing but only with the help of a lot of people—yet the real magic is not the one-pot soup but turning it into a restaurant chain that delivers value regularly at scale.
“Somebody who makes something out of nothing, but with the help of a lot of people. Also like Tom Sawyer. But what we want is not one guy and one soup.”
- Starting a company successfully is easy; the hard part that creates real value is growing it, scaling it, and making it sustainable when the founder leaves—so the current veneration of the hero-entrepreneur is excessive and undervalues the middle management and expanding teams that actually make people productive and let one team's success be emulated by others.
“Being successful and starting a company is easy. Being successful in growing it, scaling it, making it sustainable when you leave--that's hard. And that's what creates real value.”
- The magic of a productive economy comes from institutional infrastructure—business processes, manufacturing facilities, marketing visibility—that makes many leveraged people far more productive than they would be as individuals; though when a company grows too big, hundreds of people chasing one another without product impact makes them less productive.
“the magic of a really productive economy, especially a manufacturing economy, is indeed created when you have lots of people leveraged by institutional infrastructure”
- Private-sector involvement is dramatically changing space travel this decade; with ventures like Golden Spike planning to send two humans to the moon within the decade (by around 2019), the entrepreneurial goal—as with companies generally—is not to do it once but to build a company that does it regularly, making space travel exciting and then routine.
“Golden Spike, which is planning to send two humans to the moon within the decade and then do that, kind of in line with what I said earlier, that entrepreneurs not do it once but build a company that can do it regularly”
Attention is a unique scarce resource that cannot be mass produced, duplicated, or fairly priced across individuals.
- Attention is an extremely scarce resource that, unlike most things in the modern world, cannot be duplicated or mass produced; it is not fungible (one person's attention is not worth the same as another's) and has intrinsic value to people because they inherently find pleasure in being paid attention to.
“attention is one of the few things that can't be duplicated or mass produced, though it can certainly be mass collected”
- Attention can be mass collected even though it cannot be mass produced, which is what movie stars do.
“it can certainly be mass collected, if you like--that's what movie stars do”
- Although advertising and virtual goods have an inexhaustible supply, people's time and money are finite, so as their income and attention spread across more products, advertising loses power and each ad becomes less effective—producing diminishing returns in the attention economy, though this limit is still far off.
“if you show them more ads, they are just less responsive to each individual ad”
Quantifying behavior changes it, but measurement cannot capture long-term value, creating systematic underinvestment in delayed-return activities.
- By quantifying behavior—steps taken, food eaten, sleep—and paying attention to those measurements, people change their behavior; if you don't know what you are doing, it is much harder to change it or even to notice that it needs changing.
“simply by paying attention, and perhaps with some game dynamics, by quantifying your behavior, you change it. If you don't know what you are doing, it's much harder to change it”
- The central challenge of quantification is that you cannot measure everything—particularly long-term things—so if you quantify the return on education (which is very low in the short term) or preventive health, you may underinvest in them because their payoffs take a long time to materialize.
“you might quantify the return on education--which is very low in the short term--and not spend enough on education. Or on preventive health.”
The United States startup advantage is eroding due to education, infrastructure, and health decline despite structural benefits elsewhere.
- The United States is uniquely suited to startups because of a failure-tolerant culture, a huge market open to new things, and supporting infrastructure—you can walk down the street and find a CFO or a landlord who will take equity—things hard to find elsewhere; but this advantage is eroding due to a crummy educational system, underinvestment in infrastructure including broadband, and self-inflicted poor health.
“it's a combination of a very failure-tolerant culture, a huge market that is open to new things... and an infrastructure that supports this.”
- One reason health care costs so much in the United States is that Americans are so unhealthy, and much of that ill health is self-inflicted—though Russ counters that Americans are unhealthy partly because they are wealthy enough to afford both an extravagant health care system and an extravagant lifestyle while still living longer each year.
“one reason health care costs so much in the United States is that we're so unhealthy. Much of it is self-inflicted.”
Intellectual labor's global fungibility forces American workers to compete with lower-wage workers abroad, requiring wage adjustment.
- The tech sector is in a bursting entrepreneur bubble, and the lesson—increasingly recognized—is to build scalable companies rather than apps; the bigger problem is that Americans are earning too much relative to the rest of the world, since intellectual labor is fungible in a way that building bridges is not, so US workers must adjust to competing with lower-paid workers in India and China.
“we've had a bubble around here for the entrepreneur that's beginning to burst... Let's build a scalable companies rather than apps.”
- Cosmonaut training, based on six months at Star City outside Moscow as a backup to Charles Simonyi, is much less about piloting and much more about 'space plumbing'—learning to fix the space station and run the machines that keep humans alive.
“It's much less about piloting and much more about space plumbing than you might imagine.”
- Attention metrics like Flickr views or podcast downloads are so gratifying precisely because they generally never go down—they grow slowly or stall but are not subtracted on a slow week—making them like 'the odd little chocolate.'
“The great thing about most of these stats is that they never go down. They may grow slowly or not at all, but they don't get subtracted on a slow week. Which is why they are so gratifying.”
- Compared with venture capitalists—where roughly 3-4 of 10 bets fail, 3-4 are so-so, and 2-3 carry the portfolio—angel investors experience more failures but even bigger returns because they invest at an incredibly early stage.
“For angels there are more failures but the returns are even bigger because you came in... At an incredibly early stage”
The internet and attention economy degrade human cognition toward shorter attention spans and less coherent thinking.
- The internet is making us think more short term and with less narrative, structure, and coherence—evidenced by the fact that no one would sit still for the multi-hour speeches Lincoln gave, people prefer videos to books, and an incredible share of time is spent on short, useless videos.
“I think it's making us think more short term. I think it's less narrative, less structure”
- Just as sugar is a kind of food that satisfies some nutritional needs while creating metabolic disorder, there may be a 'sugar equivalent' of attention—bad attention (e.g., from a movie star who doesn't return it, or Likes from strangers) that gives some of the same satisfaction as real attention but actually destroys one's attention metabolism and can become pathological.
“Is there a sugar equivalent--is there bad attention? I pay attention to the movie star who doesn't pay attention to me; it gives me some of the same satisfaction but it actually destroys my attention metabolism.”
Productivity increasingly flows through direct peer-to-peer exchange and intellectual work outside priced markets, reversing toward pre-market economies.
- As we become more productive, people will increasingly do intellectual work for free or for barter—producing content and amusement for one another in a distributed, many-to-many attention market that is not fungible or priced—harking back to a pre-market society where exchange was direct, face-to-face, and uncounted by the measured economy.
“we will be producing content and amusement for one another, without engaging in explicit (taxable) financial exchange”
Private sector risk tolerance and competition accelerate innovation and routine deployment better than government risk aversion.
- Government-run programs like NASA are extremely risk-averse because any disaster invites criticism, which holds back human space travel; if the government ran Mt. Everest, nobody would ever be allowed up—whereas the private sector entering space unleashes commercial energy and greater risk tolerance.
“people die on Mt. Everest all the time. If the government were running Mt. Everest nobody would ever go up.”
Investment success depends primarily on luck rather than skill, yet investors systematically misattribute outcomes to effort.
- Investing success is largely statistics and luck rather than effort: you get lucky sometimes and unlucky others, and the founders in a company work hard regardless of outcome, so investors must be comfortable with luck—yet people tend to attribute successes to their intelligence and hard work and failures to bad luck.
“you have to be comfortable with getting lucky, because people tend to attribute their successes to their intelligence and hard work and their failures to bad luck. But it's often not that way.”
Economic thinking provides essential reality checks on value, alternatives, and opportunity costs distinct from business knowledge.
- Economics is, in essence, quantitative thinking—valuing things, exploring alternatives, understanding opportunity costs, and reasoning rationally about the world—and provides a reality check on how the world actually works, which is distinct from business knowledge.
“It is, in essence, quantitative thinking: valuing things, exploring alternatives, understanding opportunity costs. Just a way of thinking rationally about the world”