demagogue
A leader who gains power by appealing to the emotions and prejudices of disengaged or aggrieved masses rather than through reasoned debate.
As defined in 344 | Adam Gurri on Liberal Democracy and How to Fight For It
Other definitions
A political leader or public figure who appeals to emotion and prejudice rather than reason and evidence, using charisma and populist rhetoric to gain power without regard for truth or substantive policy
Sam Harris on How Populism and Inequality Threaten Open Societies (Making Sense #423)
Where it comes up · 9
- Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)4 claims
- Scholar explains why he thinks the GOP has turned away from Democracy1 claim
- Your Mind Has Been Lying to You - Sam Harris (4K)1 claim
- Claudia Hauer on War, Education, and Strategic Humanism1 claim
- 471 - The End Of History Revisited1 claim
- 423 - More From Sam Democracy Populism Wealth Inequality News-induced Anxiety Rapid Fire Qu1 claim
- Bernie Sanders1 claim
- 344 | Adam Gurri on Liberal Democracy and How to Fight For It1 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “demagogue” →
- When citizens see government breaking down and failing to enforce the law during mob rule, the lawless in spirit become lawless in practice (looting for self-interest), and good citizens become alienated not just from a particular administration but from the very form of popular government, leading them to turn to a strongman or demagogue who promises to restore order—which is how democracies are abandoned.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
- Lincoln saw it as a permanent danger that individuals who believe they belong to 'the family of the lion and the tribe of the eagle'—natural rulers of the founding type—will come along after the founding, find the Presidency insufficiently glorious because the glory is already harvested, and seek to destroy the separation of powers as aspiring demagogues and tyrants.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
- The danger to democracy is not solely from the few; aspiring tyrants succeed by capitalizing on the passions of the many, so ordinary citizens themselves must be aware of their own temptations to tyranny—of which mob rule is one instance—and must be educated enough in self-government to recognize and refuse to elect demagogues.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
- A large disengaged, non-voting segment of society is dangerous because such people become ignorant of basic politics and remain mobilizable by a demagogue—as Trump mobilized many non-voters—so mandatory voting (in practice a nominal payment for showing up or small fine for not, plus a day off) is worthwhile because getting people in the habit of participating prevents this latent instability.344 | Adam Gurri on Liberal Democracy and How to Fight For It
- A single leader, even a very popular demagogue like Donald Trump, cannot destroy a democracy by himself; it requires the enabling, toleration, support, and protection of a major political party.Scholar explains why he thinks the GOP has turned away from Democracy
- Demagogues like Tucker Carlson and Trump can keep tacking left and right because they feel no burden of coherence, no burden of paying attention to what really happened in the world, and no burden of avoiding hypocrisy—since hypocrisy is not even an acknowledged fate when you have no principles—turning political and media life into entertainment that carries us toward the precipice.423 - More From Sam Democracy Populism Wealth Inequality News-induced Anxiety Rapid Fire Qu
- Athens, like a tragic hero in Thucydidean terms, possesses great qualities (innovation, openness, freedom) but has a fatal flaw (instability, susceptibility to demagogues, foolish collective judgment) that ultimately leads to its defeat and collapse.Great Authors - Literature of Ancient Greece and Jerusalem - Thucydides and the Dawn of History
- Working-class anger is justified, but demagogues like Trump succeed by directing that anger against people who are even worse off rather than at the structures responsible, which is what demagogues always do.Bernie Sanders
- Demagogues like Tucker Carlson are facile and lack an ethical core, but are extremely effective at channeling appetite for calling out powers and institutions, whether rightly or wrongly, which opens the door to conspiracy thinking of every flavor by creating a permission structure for contrarianism without coherent standards.Your Mind Has Been Lying to You - Sam Harris (4K)
- Although reasoning political beings necessarily operate through speech, rhetoric and rhetoricians are dangerous because rhetoric can be used for malign purposes—to lie and talk people into bad things—and demagogues specialize in it, so oratory is not the only or a uniformly good form of democratic speech.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)