Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
What this covers
Russ Roberts interviews Diana Schaub, a political scientist at Loyola University, Maryland, about three of Abraham Lincoln's most celebrated speeches and what they reveal about the permanent vulnerabilities of self-government. The conversation treats these speeches not as historical artifacts but as diagnoses of recurring democratic crises. Schaub argues that Lincoln identified a fundamental threat: the passions that enabled the Founding—elite ambition and popular resentment of external enemies—become destructive in post-founding generations. Without deliberate intervention, ambitious politicians exploit public anger, demagogues capitalize on mob rule, and citizens lose faith in democratic institutions and turn toward strongmen. Lincoln's remedy, Schaub contends, is civic education grounded in Reverence for Law, Reason over Passion, and fidelity to the principle of equality.
The discussion ranges across Lincoln's Lyceum Address, the Gettysburg Address, and the Second Inaugural, tracing how each speech works to stabilize democracy by redirecting citizens away from destructive passion and toward durable principle. A significant portion examines Lincoln's disagreement with Martin Luther King, Jr. over civil disobedience—Lincoln insisted that An Unjust Law Is Not a Law could not justify lawbreaking in a fundamentally sound democratic order, whereas King defended bounded, openly accepted civil disobedience as moral witness. Schaub also addresses Lincoln's handling of war powers, emancipation, and secession, his theology of national atonement, and his intuitive grasp of how small speeches distributed through newspapers could reach and shape public sentiment. Throughout, the conversation connects these nineteenth-century problems to contemporary concerns about democratic fragility, the loss of shared cultural resources for serious rhetoric, and the hazards of moralism across the political spectrum.
Schaub argues that Lincoln's three greatest speeches diagnose a permanent fragility in self-government—that after a founding, the passions of ambitious elites and the resentful many threaten democracy—and that the cure is a deliberate civic education grounding citizens in reverence for law, reason over passion, and fidelity to the principle of equality.
- The Lyceum Address warns that post-founding generations lose the salutary passions that built the republic and must replace them with reason and law-reverence.
- Lincoln's commitment to constitutional majority rule and law-abidingness sets him against civil disobedience (King) and secession alike.
- The Gettysburg Address and Second Inaugural both link reverence for the past (the Declaration) to a forward-looking, aspirational national project requiring present resolve and charity.
The quality of national political leadership has declined across American history from the founding era through Lincoln to today.
- It is hard not to see the arc of any nation's history as an arc downward in leadership greatness—the founding generation produced an abundance of great men, Lincoln stood out dramatically, and the present moment offers leaders neither of whom seems great or worthy of leading a great nation—as if national leadership increasingly turns elsewhere for its expression.
“it's hard not to look at the arc of any nation's history as a arc downward... The founding generation, they're grown on trees, the greatness”
Modern commercial and technological innovation now offers creative individuals scope for world-affecting ambition unavailable in earlier eras.
- Commercial life in Lincoln's time was modest, but modern commercial and technological life—driverless cars, artificial knees, pharmaceuticals, the iPhone—offers the creative few enormous scope to affect a world of billions, providing an outlet for ambition that did not exist in the 1830s.
“no one at that time could imagine the driverless car or an artificial knee or a pharmaceutical that cured an illness... that give the few--the creative among us--the scope to do something that... affects... a world of billions of people”