
Great Authors - Literature of Ancient Greece and Jerusalem - Thucydides and the Dawn of History
What this covers
This is a single-lecturer survey by Michael Sugrue of Thucydides and his account of the Peloponnesian Wars. It starts with the man: a wealthy Athenian general, writing as a participant, who was exiled for twenty years after losing a battle to Brasidas. The lecture treats that exile as the period when he gathered interviews and evidence and became aware of his own biases. Much of the first half places him among his predecessors. He departs from Homer as the teacher of Greece and writes in deliberately dry prose. He gives up the looser methods of Herodotus. He draws on the pre-Socratic physicists, the sophists, and Hippocratic medicine, so that he is in effect a doctor of the collective political body.
The middle of the lecture is about method and form. It stresses his separation of the apparent causes of the war (Corcyra, Potidaea) from the real one, Spartan fear of Athenian power. It also covers his admission when evidence is lacking, and his claim to write a possession for all time on the premise that constant human nature yields similar outcomes. The lecturer reads the History as epic in subject and tragedy in form, but without divine justice. Athens appears almost as a tragic hero, with openness and innovation undone by instability and the influence of demagogues.
The sharpest episodes get the most attention. Pericles and his Funeral Oration give the idealized picture of Athenian civic life. After his death, Cleon leads the demos toward hubristic policy. The Corcyra civil war is read as a "terror of history," a point the notes mark as contested: once mythological supports are gone, reason proves unstable under stress. The Melian Dialogue is treated as a script-like debate in which Athens rejects talk of justice and the Melians' virtuous resistance ends in slaughter and enslavement. The lecture closes on reception, noting that Machiavelli and Hobbes admired the realism, that Hobbes translated the work, and that the American Founders drew on its account of Athenian democracy when they chose a republic.
Thucydides pioneered social science by applying rigorous, empirical, secular methodology to political and military history, replacing mythological explanation with causal analysis of human nature under stress, establishing a realist tradition that influenced Machiavelli, Hobbes, and modern political thought.
- Thucydides synthesized pre-Socratic secular naturalism, sophistic rhetoric, and Hippocratic inductive medicine to create the first non-mythological account of politics and war
- His method of reconstructed speeches and antithetical argumentation, while not verbatim, captured political reality through rhetoric and psychological insight rather than divine intervention
- His unflinching analysis of events like the Mytilene massacre and Melian dialogue reveals that politics operates on power and expediency, not justice or morality, a lesson that shaped subsequent political theory
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Hippocratic medical writers create a body of knowledge about disease through careful observation, case studies, and inductive inference from evidence; Thucydides adopts this inductive, evidence-based methodology for analyzing political behavior, treating himself as a doctor of collective political bodies.
“the writings of hippocrates attempt to analyze the diseases of the body in this secular non-mythological this worldly way they are essentially inductive in their procedure the hippocratic doctor dispassionately observes the various maladies that accompany certain kinds of behavior or certain kinds of diet or certain kinds of climate and tries to draw connections between particular facts of the human condition and particular consequences of those facts”
Thucydides distinguishes between the apparent reasons for the Peloponnesian War (disputes over subsidiary cities like Corcyra and Potidaea) and the real reason (Spartan fear of growing Athenian power and dominance), establishing the methodological principle that surface causes often mask deeper structural causes.
“he says look there was a treaty between athens and sparta and they had fought against the persians and been successful and all kinds of stuff like that and they had had a minor dispute over two subsidiary cities of course i think it's corsair and potadia and ostensibly that's what the peloponnesian war is about but in fact that's not really what it's about what it's really about is the fact that athens had become progressively more powerful since the persian wars it had established a navy it had established a naval empire it had engaged in commerce and become very wealthy and very influential and the spartans used to be number one back at the time of the persian wars and they were gradually losing their relative position of eminence to the new upstart athenian empire and in the long run he implies at least that this war is inevitable because the real origin of this war lies in spartan fear of growing athenian power”
Thucydides sees Homer as an outmoded educator and intends to supersede Homer as the teacher of Greece through his History, just as Socrates/Plato aim to replace Homeric mythology with philosophical inquiry.
“he intends to supersede homer's poetry with an unapologetic prose in other words poetry and meter and rhyme is a very appropriate way of exp of describing the world if you're describing it from a mythological standpoint from an imaginative a fanciful standpoint but for someone that wants to be severe and rigorous and serious and empirical kind of brass tacks well then the best way to handle that would be in the way that thucydides does with a severe rather forbidding rather dry style that is prose rather than poetry in that respect he's re his project is rather similar to that of socrates remember that socrates also intends one assumes or if not socrates certainly plato intends to be the new teacher of the greeks to supersede the bad teaching of homer”
The failure of the logos to ground political order at Corcyra reveals a 'terror of history'—when civilization abandons mythological supports for rational-secular ones but reason proves unstable under stress, it leaves humans facing only brute force and power.
“corsira is undermined by the greeks by greek cultures rationalistic hubris and this hubris comes back and destroys them and this hubris in an enlarged sense can be extrapolated to the entirety of the peloponnesian wars the fact that athens is accessible and open to new ideas and it is part and is open to the possibility of bringing in new critiques of ancient myths turns out to be unstable and dangerous words change their meanings and if we can't depend on the logos we can't depend on anything the logos got rid of the gods but we don't have anything to take its place nothing helps us out of that well corsira is a frightening and horrifying realization that our project of liberating ourselves from mythology liberated us but didn't give us anything to fill the gap and as a consequence we're faced with what might be called the terror of history we're faced with simple brute force”
Pericles' Funeral Oration in Book Two of the History presents an idealized conception of Athenian civic life emphasizing that political participation is not merely possible but an expected attribute of all useful and desirable citizens.
“he gives one of the most influential and famous speeches in greek history it's called pericles funeral oration it's in book two of of the peloponnesian wars and what this presents us with is an idealized conception of athenian civic life and the importance that individual citizens have in making democracy possible in the fact that political participation is not a possibility but it's an expected attribute of all useful and desirable citizens”
Thucydides consciously wished to write a possession for all time that transcends national and personal bias by revealing truths about human nature that apply across situations, operating on the assumption that human nature being constant, roughly the same circumstances will produce roughly the same consequences.
“as he says in the beginning of his history i wish this to be a possession for all of time he wishes to write something that will be true about human nature as such which will give us a glimpse into the nature of people under the greatest possible political duress under the greatest challenges that society can offer which is war”
Thucydides was influenced by pre-Socratic physicists (Thales, Anaximander, Anaxamenes) who rejected mythological accounts of nature in favor of secular, naturalistic explanations, and he applied this same method to politics and history.
“the pre-socratic physicists like thales anaximander aneximines were men who attempted to get beyond the earlier mythological accounts of nature in greek mythology we often describe the sun as the chariot of apollo the sun god and that's what the sun really is at an early phase in greek culture when it was relatively primitive that was a fairly satisfactory account of what the rising and setting of the sun amounted to but as greek culture became more self-conscious and more sophisticated pre-socratic physicists attempted to account for the sun accounted account for the moon account for the earth account for everything in nature in a purely secular non-mythological way one of the greatest breakthroughs in the entire history of the world and certainly one of the great achievements of greek culture is the creation of this first secular knowledge these non-mythological accounts of nature well what thucydides is going to do is trying to take this approach this non-mythological secular this worldly approach to accounting for nature and bring it to his account of human realities of politics of war and of statecraft so in that respect he's the kind of god child or nephew if not the son of the pre-socratic physicists”
Thucydides constructs his History as a fusion of epic and tragedy: epic in its subject matter (great armies, heroic stakes) and tragedy in its form (hubris, overreach, catastrophe), but without the moral order or divine justice that characterizes Greek tragedy.
“at least in outline is a discernible tragic form those of you who have studied greek tragedy know that the form of the tragedy is hubris atte moira in other words a hero with many good qualities but one fatal flaw goes beyond the limits of what he ought he transgresses somehow he is forced by the nature of his transgression to some catastrophe there's the catharsis of pity and fear and all that aristotelian stuff and at the end moral order is restored if you think about the tragedies of sophocles for example where moral order we transgress and then it's restored as in the case of the most important esophagus tragedies you'll see that that tradition now thucydides has some elements of that form but the difference is that there's no moral order there to transgress people will overreach but it's not an intrinsic moral order it's more the limitations of human society or the limitations of the human being itself or the limitations of warfare or society or sometimes just dumb luck blind chance the things we can't predict”
Thucydides intentionally wrote in severe, forbidding, dry prose rather than poetry to express rigorous, empirical seriousness, in contrast to Homer's mythological poetry, establishing prose as the appropriate medium for scientific and political inquiry.
“poetry and meter and rhyme is a very appropriate way of exp of describing the world if you're describing it from a mythological standpoint from an imaginative a fanciful standpoint but for someone that wants to be severe and rigorous and serious and empirical kind of brass tacks well then the best way to handle that would be in the way that thucydides does with a severe rather forbidding rather dry style that is prose rather than poetry”
The Melian Dialogue presents Athens and Milos in direct opposition: Athens explicitly rejects all discourse about justice, hope, and righteousness, insisting only on power imbalance and the certain destruction of Milos if it resists.
“what happens in the million dialogue is the athenians come in and say hey look you're part of the empire and if you don't like it that's tough because we're going to kill all of you check it out so that's the brass tacks of it so now we'll give you two choices you can do exactly what you're told you can surrender to us at our discretion you can come back to the empire and you can knuckle under or you can be dead and they said before we get any further we don't want to hear any jazz about hope or any nonsense about righteousness or any of that stuff because it's hogwash that's not the way politics really works so rather than give you some song and dance about the fact that the gods like athens and that they're supporting our cause and all the rest of that hogwash let's get down to breast tax we have a big army and you have a little army and there's nothing more to talk about”
Thucydides' History of the Peloponnesian War is one of the greatest achievements of Greek culture because it attempts to create a science of human things by finding the nature of human society and the human psyche under the greatest stress, particularly war.
“thucydides history of the peloponnesian wars is one of the greatest achievements of greek culture it's an attempt to create a science of human things it's an attempt to find the nature of human society and of the human psyche in the greatest possible under the greatest possible stress particularly the stress of war”
Machiavelli and Hobbes were great admirers of Thucydides because his work shows politics as it really is—power and realpolitik without illusions about virtue or righteousness; Hobbes translated the entire Peloponnesian Wars into English for statesmen.
“it's not an accident that later writers like machiavelli and hobbes were really great fans of the city as a matter of fact hobbes translated the whole of the city's peloponnesian wars into english because he thought it was a great book for the statesman because it shows politics the way it really is none of this jazz about virtue and righteousness and all that politics is a matter of power it's real politic bigger big fish eat little fish that's the way the physical world is stop kidding yourself”
When Thucydides does not have evidence, he explicitly fesses up and says the evidence is unclear rather than inventing or speculating; this contrast with Homer's claimed omniscient knowledge is a quantum leap toward honesty about the limits of knowledge.
“and with acidities doesn't have evidence he just fesses up and says look the evidence is unclear here it's not so certain so i'll do my best with it in addition to that it's worth considering that the cities in some respects different from contemporary historians”
The Melians choose to resist and be virtuous and patriotic rather than surrender, resulting in the extermination of all male Melians and the enslavement of women and children—a stark empirical validation of Thucydides' claim that virtue without power is futile.
“well the way it finishes is that they have this back and forth and eventually they go back and decide to be virtuous and patriotic and fight for this city and they all get killed every man in milos is exterminated in that battle they kill them either in battle or the ones that captures prisoners they kill them their women and children are all sold into slavery there are no millions that is what makes thucydides in history thucydidean the rigorous insistence that the world is as it actually is he's not going to sugarcoat the lessons of politics”
The Melian Dialogue is structured as a script-like antithetical debate between Athenian ambassadors and Melian leaders, resembling Euripidean tragic dialogue, showing Thucydides' sophisticated integration of dramatic form and political analysis.
“it's constructed as a set of antithesis it reminds me very much of the dialogue we see in the contemporary tragedian euripides because in euripides it's a kind of cynical but very realistic view of human condition people are often rather brutal rather than heroic and also there's a kind of cynicism and irony here what we get and what's interesting also is we get direct discourse at the beginning of each speech there's ath for athenians and familians i mean it really looks like the script to a play and in some respects it is if you stop and think about what the city's method is like”
Pericles, as the greatest Athenian leader, maintained the forms of democracy while actually governing as the first citizen and most important figure, and he counseled against hubris by urging defensive rather than expansionist war strategy.
“pericles is the great figure in athenian democracy and what's great about pericles is that he is that although he keeps the forms of the appearance of democracy in fact when pericles is still alive the government of athens is in fact the government of the first citizen the most important figure and that's pericles he's a wise prudent intelligent ruler”
The American Founding Fathers rejected direct democracy and created a republic specifically because they studied Thucydides' account of how democratic Athens made catastrophic decisions, teaching them to balance democracy with institutional restraints.
“what thucydides offers us and it was not offered to just us think about the american founding fathers why don't we have a direct democracy they read their thucydides right i said this it's a dangerous thing we've got to find that balance”
Cleon is an evil, roguish, demagogic leader; when Pericles dies, Cleon takes power and suggests oppressive, tyrannical, hubristic policies that the Athenian demos supports, leading to the society's collapse.
“when pericles dies and cleon evil navish roguish demagogic cleon comes in he suggests that they do all kinds of oppressive tyrannical hubristic stuff and of course the entire society collapses because they all say yeah that's a great idea cleon”
Athens, like a tragic hero in Thucydidean terms, possesses great qualities (innovation, openness, freedom) but has a fatal flaw (instability, susceptibility to demagogues, foolish collective judgment) that ultimately leads to its defeat and collapse.
“you could say that athens is a sort of collective hero which has many good qualities compared to sparta sparta is traditional athens is innovative sparta is disciplined athens is free these these differences these very good qualities in athens come out in pericles funeral oration but it turns out that these very good qualities also bring with them a sort of fatal flaw right can you see athens is a sort of a tragic hero and this fatal flaws are instability their foolishness the fact that they don't have good basis for their political judgments the consequence of this is that ultimately athens collapses athens loses this war the hope the aspiration of greek culture is undermined by its own internal flaws and the the tragic form comes out”
Thucydides borrows from the sophists the idea that human society is fundamentally secular and this-worldly, finding little moral order in the world; the world of politics is one of raw power, with ethical limitations becoming apparent particularly under the extreme stress of war.
“thucydides himself borrowed much from the sophists he borrowed the idea that human society was essentially secular in this worldly he had no taste for mythological or kind of divine accounts of the origin of society in addition he himself seems to find very little in the way of moral order in the world the world of thucydides and habits is a world of raw political power”
The sophists reject mythological accounts of virtue and divine intervention in battles in favor of a caustic skepticism about moral order; while this can be debilitating through leading to moral nihilism and realpolitik, it is also liberating and tough-minded.
“the sophists reject the earlier mythological accounts of the world the mythological accounts of virtue the descriptions of battles as being influenced by divine intervention and things like that they have a caustic kind of withering skepticism which on the one hand can be kind of debilitating on account of the fact that it is that it moves us in the direction of moral nihilism a kind of sheer real politic a kind of power worship but on the other hand it's also liberating and tough-minded because it gives us a more this worldly a more immediately plausible account of the human condition and of political life”
Herodotus, the real father of history who lived about a generation before Thucydides, was insufficiently rigorous with evidence; Thucydides specifically gives up Herodotus' project in favor of careful interrogation of documents and evidence.
“he specifically gives up on the project of herodotus the real father of history who lived about a generation before thucydides who he thought was a little bit too loose with evidence thucydides carefully interrogates his documents and instead of having amused the way homer does that comes down and gives him omniscient knowledge about everything that's going on thucydides has instead evidence which is a quantum leap if you stop and think about it the idea of moving from inspiration to hard facts to good solid evidence”
Thucydides was exiled for 20 years after losing a battle to the Spartan general Brasidas, which gave him time to conduct interviews, gather evidence, and become conscious of his biases while maintaining rigorous intellectual honesty.
“he lost a battle you know he was he's he was a one-trick pony they made him a general they sent him on in and of course he just got there a little bit late and lost the battle to a great spartan general named bracidus as a result he was exiled for 20 years because the athenian people were very very vindictive you mean they want results and they didn't ask for you know they didn't send you there to mess up now that 20-year exile gives him plenty of time to gather evidence and talk to the relevant figures about this war which makes him if not a perfectly objective observer an observer who is at least conscious of his biases and trying to compensate for them trying to be as fair-minded as he can”
Thucydides was a wealthy Athenian general who lived between roughly 460 and 400 BC, participated in the Peloponnesian War as a military commander, and writes from the position of a first-person participant with intimate knowledge of politicians, crowds, and soldiers involved in the conflict.
“thucydides himself was a wealthy athenian he lived between roughly speaking 460 and 400 bc and his lifetime encompassed the entirety of the peloponnesian wars the war between athens and sparta for supremacy within the mainland of greece and this war itself was quite quite lengthy it lasted from 431 to 404 bc and thucydides was actively involved in this war he was one of the athenian generals”
The Athenian decision to execute all men in Mytilene and enslave all women and children, followed by revocation of the decree the next day to execute only the guilty, demonstrates that democracies make unstable, depraved decisions driven by whim rather than rational judgment.
“what they decide that they're going to kill every man in my tillany and they're going to sell all the women and children into slavery can you see why democracy gets a bad name it's genocidal and it's unabashedly genocidal and for no good reason because the people who are condemning who are condemning all the mycolonians know for a fact that not everybody was involved in this evolved but they don't care to separate the guilty from the innocent they're just going to kill everybody and let god sort them out or since there are no gods in this nobody sort of they just die well the next day they go home they feel bad about the next day they change their mind”
The sophists taught rhetoric as the art of constructing persuasive speeches for either side of a political position regardless of truth, and Thucydides absorbed this sophistic training, which enabled him to reconstruct speeches in his history with psychological insight and argumentative power.
“sophists teach the art of speech they teach the art of making arguments for one side of of a political issue or the other a sophist doesn't teach you it doesn't claim to teach you the one imperishable truth about politics or ethics he tells you that look it's a question of perspective it's a question of judgment different people have different interests or desires the sophist teaches you how to satisfy your desires by constructing speeches which will persuade either law courts or the people as a whole in the case of a democratic society like athens they teach you how to speak effectively how to manipulate the crowd or how to manipulate the jury to get the ends that you've decided you want to achieve”
In the civil strife at Corcyra, the loss of moderate voices and fracturing into oligarchic and democratic factions led to increasing brutality and the collapse of meaningful debate, ultimately destroying the possibility of reasonable political agreement.
“the city breaks up into factions and they lose a reasonable moderate group of people that want to reconcile the uh the populist faction and the oligarchic faction and as society breaks into faction and as the possibility of reasonable er of reasonable agreement about moderate uh policies becomes impossible civil strife becomes worse and worse they end up with a civil war in corsira and eventually of course it destroys the society entirely this combat which becomes more and more ruthless and more and more bloody between the oligarchs and the democrats neither of them are any good all of them are dangerous because they lose a sense of the platonic virtue of moderation”
The Athenian plague described by Thucydides, which he personally experienced, undermines any notion of divine order because both righteous and unrighteous people contracted it equally, whether or not they made sacrifices to the gods.
“he also gives us that idea about the plague he says look a lot of people were talking about the gods sending the plague well look check this out good people got the plague and bad people got the plague and people at sacrifice to the gods got the plague people they didn't sacrifice the gods got the plague so i can't make any sense of it so i'm going to leave all the gods out of this i mean the belief in the gods is important because it influences social behavior but i don't want to talk about the gods now”
Thucydides had a dispassionate, cold writing style that distances him from sentiment, exemplified by his matter-of-fact treatment of a massacre of schoolchildren in one paragraph before moving on without moral commentary.
“later on in book seven there's a massacre at a place called michaelas's which is not very important but um some thievin soldiers come in and they come to a city and they kill the people but they also come to a school where little boys are being taught and they step in and they butcher all the little boys and vicinities knocks it off in about a paragraph and then goes right on no weeping no worrying about the human condition no worrying oh why does god allow this none of that jesus look they killed him they butchered him and now let's move on cold authoritative severe right dispassionate in many respects almost in an unnatural way”
The mythological Greek belief in a golden age from which civilization has degenerated is rejected by Thucydides as hogwash; he argues instead that ancient times were barbaric and uninteresting.
“there had been a tradition in greece that there was an er you know in greek mythology that in the earliest phases of human existence there had been a golden time and we have been degenerating ever since that earlier mythological golden period and the city says that's hogwash don't give me any of that i'm a hard-headed guy actually olden times are really barbaric and not very interesting at all”
The speeches on the Mytilene question pit Cleon's argument for genocide against Diodotus' argument for expedience-based clemency, establishing Thucydides' theme that practical politics is driven by expediency rather than justice or morality.
“there's another guy i think his name is diodotus who says well look this may not be a question of justice it may be a question of expediency and here's another important thucydidean theme the conflict between what is expedient and what is right and as thucydides says look in practical politics expediency is what's happening don't tell me anymore about the right or the ultimate good or any of the platonic stuff what's expedient is what works again you see the the legacy of sophistry here well diode says look it may not be expedient to kill all these people and he actually convinces the athenian demos by a very small margin to revoke their decree”
Unlike contemporary historians who interrogate documents, Thucydides interrogates people who were present at events, making allowances for personal bias, nationality, wishful thinking, and memory lapses; he rigorously tests evidence by talking to witnesses.
“thucydides takes as evidence not so much documents because you've got to remember that there aren't there isn't a stenographer in every courtroom writing down transcripts of trials and you can't find out what people were saying on the other side of greece what you can do on the other hand is talk to people that were there whereas a modern historian usually interrogates documents and tries to critically evaluate pieces of paper the acidities interrogates people and says okay were you there what did you see and then he starts to make allowances for personal biases for nationality for wishful thinking and for simple lapses in memory”
Thucydides is a great prose poet whereas most contemporary historians lack artistry; modern historians are more scientific but lack the literary quality that makes Thucydides' history compelling.
“it's worth considering that the cities in some respects different from contemporary historians well the first way is different because the cities is a great prose poet whereas i suspect that most of our contemporary historians are lacking in that respect there's not quite the same degree of artistry even though perhaps is a good bit more science”
Thucydides' eighth book is the only one in his History that consists entirely of narrative without speeches, suggesting the work remained incomplete at his death.
“the cities history is composed of eight books and although in the ancient world nothing like the city's history was written on scrolls of papyrus they didn't have books in the physical sense that we do and we just carve it up into books because it's a kind of editorial convenience the last of these eight books is clearly incomplete and what's notable about it it's the only book that's straight narrative without any speeches”