crowding out
The idea that government borrowing can displace private investment by raising the cost or reducing the availability of financing for businesses and homeowners; operates through a credit-market mechanism, not automatically.
As defined in cwt_benjamin-friedman
Other definitions
The reduction in private consumption or investment that occurs when government spending or borrowing draws on the economy's finite resources.
Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/2007Economic phenomenon where government or state-backed credit allocation displaces private sector investment by channeling capital to state enterprises instead, reducing the available capital and competitive space for private firms
Keyju Jin: China from within: Myths and realities in a new era
Where it comes up · 35
- Valerie Ramey on Stimulus and Multipliers 10/24/20115 claims
- CBO Director: What Happens When Debt Hits 122% Of GDP | Phillip Swagel3 claims
- Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee2 claims
- Neil Monnery on Hong Kong and the Architect of Prosperity2 claims
- FED PANICS TO BAIL OUT SOARING GOVERNMENT DEBT2 claims
- Hedgeye Investing Summit Fall 2024 | Daniel Lacalle, Chief Economist at Tressis2 claims
- Crash or Boom? The Dollar in an Increasingly Multipolar World2 claims
- Peak Cheap Energy - Luke Gromen2 claims
and 27 more
Most important claims · 10 of 48Search all claims for “crowding out” →
- Rising net interest outlays consume resources not available for other government purposes such as defense, non-defense spending, social programs, or tax relief, creating a crowding-out effect at the federal level.CBO Director: What Happens When Debt Hits 122% Of GDP | Phillip Swagel
- The most regrettable form of philanthropy is foundation money going to ordinary social services the public has already assumed responsibility for—especially private money flowing to already-wealthy public school systems—because it exacerbates existing inequalities, lets parents take a tax deduction for worsening an inequality the state should remedy, and adds a psychological perversion of feeling noble while doing so.Rob Reich on Foundations and Philanthropy
- Government spending in wartime is a resource constraint: more tanks mean less butter, so a classical argument explains consumption falling after military spending, without needing a neoclassical or Keynesian multiplier story.Valerie Ramey on Stimulus and Multipliers 10/24/2011
- Capital inflows to the United States (international investors providing resources to U.S. government and businesses) help keep U.S. interest rates low despite large deficits, dampening the crowding-out effect, but if global investors become hesitant to provide capital or start worrying about U.S. creditworthiness, this cushion will disappear.CBO Director: What Happens When Debt Hits 122% Of GDP | Phillip Swagel
- There is a relationship between deficits/surpluses and economic growth, but it works through a time-lagged mechanism: deficits lead to debt, which affects interest rates, which crowds out private investment and consumer spending, affecting economic growth.CBO Director: What Happens When Debt Hits 122% Of GDP | Phillip Swagel
- Government welfare expansion (dating to roughly 1933-1935) crowded out private charity to poor people; American private charity, while still healthy, now flows largely to education, hospitals, and art museums rather than the poor, because there is no reason to privately fund what the government already funds through taxes.Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee
- Operating above the historical spending range is dangerous not because borrowing a trillion a year is currently hard—the capital market easily absorbs it—but because markets run on expectations; if persistent borrowing with no spending restraint is expected, markets will eventually see through it, interest rates will rise, and private activity will be squeezed out, making the transition (like going over Niagara Falls) the dangerous part.Steve Hanke on Hyperinflation, Monetary Policy, and Debt
- The free rider problem reduces but does not eliminate private giving; evidence is that millions of dollars are donated for scholarships to private schools for poor children even though free public schools exist and the free rider problem should have crowded that out—people give because they care passionately—so a private charitable solution is viable, with the open question being its magnitude.Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee
- The Trump administration faces a fundamental unresolved contradiction: it wants to eliminate trade deficits while simultaneously attracting massive foreign capital inflows and running larger federal deficits, but trade flows and capital flows are two sides of the same coin—restricting trade necessarily restricts capital inflows, which means the deficit expansion will lead to crowding out and real interest rate increases that will starve domestic capital investment.Neil Howe: The Fourth Turning Is Now Raging...And It's Gone Global
- After a military spending increase, consumption falls in the short run and then recovers as government spending declines; this pattern is consistent with the classical model and inconsistent with the traditional Keynesian model.Valerie Ramey on Stimulus and Multipliers 10/24/2011