What this covers

This is the fourth installment of Real Vision's Crash or Boom series, recorded September 11, 2023. Larry McDonald of The Bear Traps Report talks with Luke Gromen about what the dollar's position means for monetary policy, commodities, and savers. Gromen dates the shift into fiscal dominance to the September 2019 repo spike, when Treasury supply outran private balance sheets. From there the conversation asks what the Fed can still do. Gromen's contested claim is that hikes above 5% act as fiscal stimulus, because they raise the roughly $1.3 trillion in annual interest paid to asset holders. He also leans on Warren Mosler's framework to argue that historical tightening models don't apply.

The middle of the discussion is about how the debt gets resolved. They cite Charles Calamaris's St. Louis Fed paper, which puts the inflation needed without financial repression at about 40%, against roughly 16% with aggressive repression. McDonald brings in Mark Cheval's view of repression as a transfer from savers. Gromen adds that yield curve control may eventually become unavoidable. They also discuss how far repression can go before it threatens reserve-currency status, given the dollar's dependence on open capital flows.

The commodity and geopolitical side runs through peak cheap oil, India and China's energy demand, pressure on shale, and China's direct LNG deals and yuan-denominated oil. Sanctions, in Gromen's telling, have accelerated de-dollarization, and Japan's yen weakness shows how fragile even reserve-currency economies are. McDonald supplies the domestic picture: the roughly $14.3 trillion pandemic-era response, COLA-driven income support, a strained power grid, offshoring's effect on the Rust Belt, defense stocks falling on budget fears, and a cyclical theory of democratic decline. Gromen also offers a labor-hours valuation of oil that implies prices far above today's.

Sharpest takeaway

McDonald and Roman argue that the U.S. faces a structural debt trap requiring either massive commodity inflation, financial repression, or yield curve control, driven by peak cheap oil forcing dollarization and a multi-polar world that will cause a decades-long transition from financial assets to hard commodities.

  • Peak cheap oil and rising energy demand from emerging markets mathematically guarantees dollar FX reserve depletion and forced currency devaluation without de-dollarization of commodities
  • The U.S. net international investment position has inverted from +10% to -70% of GDP, making foreigners' treasury selloffs directly destructive to U.S. banks and deficits rather than to emerging markets
  • Fiscal dominance (not Fed dominance) now controls U.S. economy with 8.5% deficits and requires either 40% inflation, financial repression of domestic savers, or yield curve control to service debt

The claims · ranked32 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.73

The U.S. entered fiscal dominance in September 2019 during the repo rate spike because there was too much Treasury supply and insufficient private sector balance sheet to absorb it, fundamentally shifting the economy from Fed dominance to fiscal dominance where federal government spending drives marginal GDP.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“the U.S went into fiscal dominance in September 2019 in the repo rate Spike because for all the noise about what caused the reposites by yes there was regulatory yes uh the bottom line was there was too much supply of Treasury paper and there was not enough private sector balance sheet that's the very essence of of fiscal dominance”

0.73

Fed rate hikes above 5% function as fiscal stimulus (not tightening) in fiscal dominance regime because they increase interest payments to asset holders (1.3 trillion annually) that flow primarily to wealthy domestic and foreign investors, mimicking the direct cash injections of COVID stimulus, while simultaneously curtailing private sector lending and production.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“Fed rate hikes we were talking about before at five percent if they just stay here we're gonna have a trillion three in interest three and three that's just a stemi it doesn't go to everybody it goes to wealthy asset holders and so it's a little bit more a lot of those a lot of those asset holders are overseas like that money actually leaves the country to some extent because people that own treasuries around the world get get our interest”

0.69

Mark Cheval (formerly Mohnish Pabrai's capital, now runs a family office) has identified financial repression as the core dynamic: keeping interest rates below inflation deliberately reduces the real debt burden but necessitates suppression of bond returns relative to inflation, destroying real wealth of savers.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Larry McDonald

“one of the investors in our book uh I think one of the most brilliant guys that I've met on Wall Street over the years uh Mark Cheval was at more capital for years Zach Coleman Sachs now runs the family uh the family office but Mark's point in my book in in our conversations I can say this with permission is financial repression and let's just describe what that is it's when you when you keep the rate of interest below inflation”

0.69

The fiscal and monetary response to COVID and the Ukraine War was approximately $14.3 trillion (compared to ~$3-3.5 trillion for the 2008 financial crisis response), with hundreds of billions deposited directly into people's bank accounts via stimulus checks and COLA adjustments, creating direct inflation rather than the contained financial crisis response of Lehman.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Larry McDonald

“the response to covid and the War uh in the Ukraine is uh upwards of fiscal and monetary fiscal and monetary so all in fiscal I think it's close to nine the rest is monetary see close to 14.3 trillion of fiscal and monetary”

0.69

If the Fed maintains rates at current levels for 12 months, interest-on-debt will rise from ~$1 trillion to ~$1.3 trillion annually, consuming 150-160% of the defense budget and forcing impossible choices between entitlements, defense, and interest payments, making a fiscal cut without economic collapse mathematically impossible.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Larry McDonald

“if they really keep rates here for 12 months a year from now interest on the debt is not a trillion but really like 1.3 trillion okay and that and then that crowds out your defense spending and your uh you know something maybe you know all of your discretionary”

0.69

Global population has grown 600-700 million since 2014, with 1 billion Indians and 1 billion Chinese lacking air conditioning and automobiles respectively, creating structural energy demand that will push per capita oil consumption in both countries from 1/15 and 1/5 of U.S. levels toward 1/10 to 1/3, driving massive aggregate demand.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“the global population is up about 600 to 700 million human beings okay and so there's a a billion people in India that don't have air conditioning there's a billion people in China that don't have an automobile you set this a recipe for a problem”

0.69

The U.S. power grid is 20-50 years old in parts, is stressed to near-breaking (buckling 3-4 times in recent years), and adding 200,000 new electric vehicles in Texas alone while grid upgrades cost $5-6 trillion, creating massive aluminum and copper demand that feeds into the commodity bull case.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Larry McDonald

“the U.S power grid is like in some parts 30 40 50 years old some parts 20 years old we're going to put all these electric vehicles on it this 200 000 new electric vehicles in Texas and the grid is buckled literally almost broken down three times since uh I'm fighting four times in the last recent years”

0.68

Warren Mosler's MMT framework shows that Fed interest payments are net additions to demand in a fiscal dominance regime, and that no one in modern trading history has operated in a situation where U.S. debt-to-GDP was 120% and deficits were 6-7% at the start of a tightening cycle, making historical rate hike models inapplicable.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“Warren Mosler who's uh uh monetary system expert is known for mmt obviously mmt is really an explanation of of flows it's it's a it's a very politically charged word right people think of hey print money and give it away modern monetary theories it's correct correct but it's really much more of just a description of how how private public sector flows of of money work in a Fiat system and Mosler earlier this year was saying the FED has it backwards”

0.65

Democracies historically last ~250 years and cycle through bondage → spiritual faith → entrepreneurship → abundance → apathy → dependence → despair → bondage; the U.S. is in the apathy/dependence phase where generations vote themselves largesse from treasuries, causing spending to overwhelm receipts, replicating patterns seen in Argentina, Venezuela, and UK.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Larry McDonald

“we go back to the late 1700s and there were these predictions of of the cycle of democracy because no no democracies ever lasted more than 275 250 years and uh you know you really with all democracies there's like a cycle where you you start off an apathy but you think about I'm sorry you start off in bondage is actually the first day bondage”

0.61

The U.S. has taken 5 million jobs out of the country and decimated the Rust Belt through offshoring, trade policy, and cheap labor arbitrage, creating a dependent class of workers displaced by technology and overseas competition; while this improved standards of living in the developing world, it created a new class of energy consumers that now competes with the U.S. for commodities.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Larry McDonald

“we've taken uh five million jobs out of the United States uh We've decimated the Rust Belt uh we now have a massive dependent class of human beings that you know fathers wake up in the midwest that 20 30 years ago their grandfather woke up and really was proud and represented the family”

0.59

The U.S. is transitioning from a unipolar world (1975-2020) to a multi-polar world driven primarily by geological reality: as long as oil and critical commodities are only priced in dollars, peak cheap oil forces emerging markets to run down dollar FX reserves to buy increasingly expensive energy, mathematically guaranteeing currency devaluation crises unless they dollarize commodity purchases.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“a real politique slash geological reality which is as long as oil and critical Commodities are only priced in dollars we are now in a peak cheap oil world where we're not running out of oil but we're the cheap stuff's gone and so oil prices need to rise secularly on average over time uh and as a result that guarantees that dollar FX reserves will run out”

0.59

Defense stocks have been the worst-performing equity sector in the last 4 months (down >20% since April), despite bullish long-term tailwinds from reshoring, due to concern that fiscal crowding-out from interest payments will compress defense budgets, reflecting accurate market pricing of fiscal constraint risks.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Larry McDonald

“the worst performing Equity sector right now is uh in the last four months it's defense talks I mean defense stocks are underperforming the s p but like since this I think since April by over 20”

0.57

Fiscal spending year-over-year is up 15% compared to prior year, with 70 million Americans receiving approximately 9% COLA pay raises, representing direct income supplements that exceed what any tightening can offset in terms of dampening demand.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Larry McDonald

“out of that 14.3 trillion of fiscal monetary we've deposited hundreds of billions of dollars in people's bank accounts whether it be through Cola adjustments to inflation now 70 million Americans 70 million got a nine percent pay raise this year that's one of the reasons why the fiscal side is up I think 15 percent year over year this year we're spending 15 percent more this year than we did last year”

0.57

Charles Calamaris' white paper (St. Louis Fed, June 2023) demonstrates that without financial repression, current deficits would require 40% CPI inflation to maintain debt sustainability, but with aggressive financial repression (raising reserve requirements, cutting reserve rates to zero), inflation could be reduced to 16% while destroying bank profitability.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Roman

“calamaris says it kills the banks kills a profitability uh but it gets inflation needed to get out of this mess down to like 16 16 one six percent so again you yes if you go all in with the financial freshman refresh the tools you get ventilation down to 16.”

0.52

U.S. shale oil production has been under pressure due to SPR releases (price controls) and rate hikes, representing the marginal supply source that is critical to oil market balance, such that restriction of shale production (90% of marginal supply) combined with rising demand from China/India creates severe supply shortage.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“what's happening in U.S Shale you were Shale speaking by virtue of some of these same sanctions where we we implemented price controls in the United States with spr we dumped the spr that was a capping of oil it was price control so they they always work in the short term they always end in tears in the long term”

0.52

For the past 20 years, the U.S. has financially repressed foreign creditors by borrowing 8% per year (debt growth) at 2-3% per year (rates), extracting $100 trillion from foreigners at a favorable 3-4% rate, but as foreigners stop accumulating treasuries, the U.S. must fund its own deficits domestically, making repression of domestic savers equivalent to the U.S. stealing from its own citizens instead of neighbors.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“the last 40 years have basically been about financially repressing foreign us creditors right for the last on average for the last 20 years uh certainly since Lehman the United States debt has grown by eight percent per year cater confident annual growth rate the rate on that debt has rarely been above four and really been about three that's like the greatest deal on the planet”

0.52

The dollar's fundamental underpinning as global reserve currency is open and free capital flows, but financial repression and capital controls necessarily restrict foreign investment, particularly with Boomers as net sellers (incentivized by inheritance taxes to trigger capital flight), forcing limits on the degree of domestic financial repression the U.S. can impose without losing reserve status.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“the dollar AS Global Reserve currency fundamental underpinning is open and free flows of capital and this is a side of it that I don't often hear yes Financial oppression I think some version of it will absolutely happen the problem is is you can only do a little bit particularly with foreigners you can do whatever you want to your own people”

0.52

Over-weaponization of the dollar through sanctions has accelerated de-dollarization of commodities, particularly visible in China's systematic efforts over 10-15 years to establish yuan-denominated oil and commodity markets using gold settlement mechanisms, which the sanctioning of Russia has paradoxically turbocharged rather than prevented.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“China's been working to set up the infrastructure to pay for energy in Yuan uh and people say well who wants to take you on we've seen well the Russians are taking you on Venezuela is taking you on the argentinians are not taking you on uh there's a lot of different commodity uh the Australians are taking you want uh the Brazil so that and the if you want to Turbo charge per capita consumption of oil and other Commodities the single best way to do it is you you start to form a middle class and then you gain the ability to print your own currency for commodity Imports”

0.52

The 2014 Obamacare tax increase (declared constitutional by Supreme Court) on individuals and businesses reduced government health spending by shifting costs to consumers, but within 15 months (2016) the deficit as a percent of GDP rose because higher consumer health care costs reduced spending on automobiles and services, raising the dollar and crowding out global dollar markets.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“we can go back to 2014 with Obamacare which the Supreme Court says was a tax increase it was functionally a tax increase the Supreme Court said it was a tax increase what did it do you go back to the Wall Street Journal December 2014 Obamacare will help reduce the deficit by pushing the government's biggest expenditure a bigger share of that onto U.S consumers”

0.52

Global central banks stopped accumulating treasuries in 2014 and have been storing FX reserves de facto in commodities rather than treasuries, with China particularly cutting out the treasury middleman by signing 27-year direct LNG deals with Qatar, signaling they expect treasuries to collapse relative to commodities.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“you see global central banks stop buying treasuries on net in 2014 and moving into in particular uh you know what zoltan's talked about FX you're storing more of your FX reserves de facto in Commodities right so historically China used to sell out to us we would give them dollars they would take the dollars they'd buy treasuries and then those dollars those treasuries with a piggy bank to buy Commodities in the future all priced in dollars”

0.52

Yield curve control will eventually become necessary when bond markets can no longer absorb Treasury supply at reasonable rates, as the Fed controls short-term rates and can threaten to print money to maintain yields if foreigners and domestic sellers won't, forcing institutional constraints on long-duration rates.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“these sovereigns simply cannot afford to let rates do what they did in response to higher commodity prices mathematically they will have to implement yield curve control because like you said 1.3 trillion a year from now uh pro forma if rates just stay here”

0.52

China has strategically formed a middle class through trade deals, enabling currency printing for commodity imports (yuan oil), replicating the post-WWII U.S. playbook of achieving high per capita oil consumption by being the only nation able to print its own currency for commodity purchases.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“the single best way to do it is you you start to form a middle class and then you gain the ability to print your own currency for commodity Imports that's exactly what the United States did for my middle class after World War II and then in 71 you can print dollars for oil and guess what boom our per Capitol oil consumption is still the biggest in the world”

0.52

The yen weakness forcing Japan into current account deficit and treasury selling, combined with Japan's 60% of GDP net international investment position, demonstrates the fragility of even reserve-currency economies to dollar strength, as they must defend currencies by selling foreign assets including treasuries.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Roman

“when the dollar wrecking ball starts to hit them they just can't say sell treasuries sell treasuries sell Treasures well that's fine in 2000 when southeast Asia was doing it the United States was running a surplus we didn't need anybody to finance our deficit now we're running at eight and a half percent tree League 12 month deficit”

0.49

The 60/40 portfolio (60% equities, 40% bonds) that worked for 40 years is dead because long-duration bonds now offer negative real returns while short-duration bonds offer 5.3%, making bonds unattractive; the next portfolio will shift to 60% equities (rotated toward commodities/industrials) and 40% that is mostly short-duration bonds with minimal long-term bond allocation.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Roman

“I think the 60 40 portfolio of the last 40 years that has just sort of been buy it and forget about it and go to the beach uh I think that's debt uh I think uh the 60 equities I think will still work I think 40 percent bonds you know I think you always want to have some short-term bonds for for income but I don't when I lay out and consider everything we've just talked about Larry I don't know why you own long duration bonds at all in a portfolio”

0.49

Within the equity portion, there will be vicious sector rotation from growth/technology stocks to commodities, industrials, and materials companies, because reshoring of U.S. defense manufacturing, power grid upgrades, and commodity scarcity will drive 10-30% of S&P 500 market cap composition (compared to current 12%) toward energy, metals, and materials, similar to 1980 when industrials/metals/oil/gas comprised 50% of S&P 500.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Roman

“there's a vicious sector rotation within the 60 of equities of of Commodities Industrials uh because we haven't even talked on top of all of what we just talked about hugely bullish secular Dynamic for um for Commodities and Industrials”

0.49

The Boomers control approximately $78 trillion in wealth and are net sellers of financial assets, not buyers, because they have limited time horizons and will not change their consumption time preference regardless of interest rate increases, as evidenced by their YOLO behavior after COVID lockdowns.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Roman

“the Boomers have all the money and their net sellers like like there isn't a rate that you can raise rates to to convince a 70 year old Boomer to change their time preference right like they're saying I got five good years left maybe maybe ten I don't give a if the FED pays me 20. I want my money and I want to go to Italy”

0.49

The value of oil (measured in man-hours of labor content) is approximately $500,000 per barrel at $25,000 man-hours × $20/man-hour, whereas current prices are $75-80/barrel, leaving substantial room for price reappraisal toward $120-200/barrel without reaching theoretical value, driven by reassuring, re-rating of commodity prices, and demographic shifts.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Roman

“everyone knows the price of a barrel of oil right today it's whatever 76 bucks or something not a lot of people understand the value of oil which is 25 000 man hours of work per barrel times twenty dollars per man hour um the value of barrel of an oil is closer to five hundred thousand dollars”

0.49

Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) and financial repression mechanisms (capital controls, reserve requirements, inheritance taxes) are being set up as infrastructure for managing the inevitable debt crisis, forcing savers into treasuries and restricting capital flight.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Larry McDonald

“aren't they going to have to force the entire U.S pension system to own a greater percentage of say treasuries or aren't they going to have to force the banks to regulation to own even more treasuries so what are the what in terms of financial repression”

0.49

Fiscal stimulus spending (COLA, unemployment benefits, direct payments) approved in recent years is being slow-walked and deployed over 18+ months, which is why GDP has remained positive despite what leading economic indicators suggest should be a recession, creating an extended fiscal impulse through 2025-2026.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Larry McDonald

“a lot of this fiscal the Democrats quite brilliantly uh they've they've they've approved a lot of fiscal because they knew the Republicans would potentially take the house and stop them and now they're slow walking a lot of this fiscal in from spending that from what from the debate is a debate but from all the spending that's been approved in recent years especially in the last like 18 months uh there's a certain amount of it uh that hasn't really gotten into the economy yet”

0.47

Commodity price cycles require CFO capital investment decisions, and after 10-15 year bear markets (uranium, natural gas, copper), CFOs are traumatized and conservative, refusing to make bullish capex bets until prices prove sustainable, delaying supply response and extending commodity bull cycles.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Larry McDonald

“if you have a normal commodity cycle there's there's you have CFOs that make bad Investments those CFOs get fired and new CFOs today on the ground in the natural gas space in the oil and gas oil space in the copper space they're looking at their last five or six bosses that all got shot and fired and they're making making you know much more conservative decisions around Capital Investments”

0.45

The 'cleanest dirty shirt' dynamic (U.S. being preferable to other debtor nations despite poor fundamentals) enabled U.S. politicians to be reckless with fiscal policy for decades, but this is changing as other nations (China, emerging markets) improve relative position and investors have choices about which currency/reserve system to use.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Gromen

“the argument for the dollar is you you know where the the cleanest of the old dirty shirts and that's going to and that's essentially what's enabled the politicians to grossly be so irresponsible right because we've always been the cleanest of all the dirty shirts and now we look around the world and there are a lot of dirty shirts out there”

0.13

The book 'When Markets Speak' (Penguin, forthcoming) explores the transition from unipolar to multi-polar world, interviews with figures including James Baker and David Einhorn, and connects the Lehman debacle to COVID-era policy failures and the commodity super-cycle.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Larry McDonald

“our next book is is called when markets speak it'll be out with penguin in the next thing next quarter and uh our first book was a New York Times bestseller about the failure of leaving Brothers it's now published in 12 languages and I'm very proud it's a CFA Institute top 20 all-time a colossal failure of Common Sense the inside story of the collapse of Lehman Brothers our new book connects to Lehman uh debacle with covet in this new world”