consequentialism
The family of ethical theories holding that the rightness of acts depends solely on their consequences.
As defined in cwt_peter-singer
Other definitions
The ethical view that the right action is the one producing the best overall consequences, in contrast to deontology's fixed principles.
Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
Where it comes up · 42
- 305 - Moral Knowledge10 claims
- Robert Frank on Coase8 claims
- 448 - The Philosophy Of Good And Evil7 claims
- 48 - What Is Moral Progress6 claims
- 92 - The Limits Of Persuasion3 claims
- 364 - Facts Values3 claims
- 446 - How To Do The Most Good3 claims
- 126 - In Defense Of Honor3 claims
and 34 more
Most important claims · 10 of 92Search all claims for “consequentialism” →
- Contra the view that intentions are irrelevant in foreign policy, intentions matter ethically because they are the best guide to what an actor will do next; the difference between Japan's intended Rape of Nanjing and America's post-war rebuilding of Japan and Germany shows that consequentialism cannot stop at body count, and knowing whether your neighbor is a benevolent partner or a cannibal awaiting his chance is decision-relevant.32 - The Best Podcast Ever
- If what you are concerned about morally does not ultimately bear on the actual or potential wellbeing of conscious creatures somewhere at some time, then it is a pseudo-moral concern—a category error; even religious concerns about heaven and hell, when drilled down, reduce to the wellbeing of conscious (often fictional) creatures.92 - The Limits Of Persuasion
- Harris argues that when Wilson's theology is drilled down, what he ultimately cares about—the difference between eternal agony and eternal union with God—is experiential, so Wilson is effectively a consequentialist whose utilitarian-style concerns about suffering and glory are framed by Christianity and his expectations about the afterlife.443 - What Is Christian Nationalism
- Consequentialism is a theory of moral truth—a claim about what makes something really good or bad and what it is legitimate to care about—but it is not a decision procedure; one must distinguish answers in principle (which exist) from answers in practice (which may be unobtainable).305 - Moral Knowledge
- Any claim that consequentialism is bad or has repugnant implications is itself ultimately (and usually unacknowledged) a claim about unwanted consequences; critics who recoil from consequentialism are pointing to life-negative effects, which means they are reasoning as consequentialists without admitting it.305 - Moral Knowledge
- Utilitarianism (maximize aggregate utility) and deontology/Kantianism (follow hard-and-fast rules regardless of consequences) both claim to possess a formula that makes moral intuition unnecessary, yet each refutes the other only by appealing to moral intuition—the utilitarian invokes our gut sense that betraying Anne Frank is wrong, and the deontologist invokes our gut sense that harvesting one healthy visitor's organs to save five patients is wrong—proving moral intuition is inescapable.Moshe Koppel on Norms, Tradition, and Resilient Societies
- All consequences that ultimately matter morally must matter to some conscious mind somewhere (at least potentially); anything else we claim to care about collapses down to the actual or potential conscious states of conscious creatures, which is the foundation of Harris's moral landscape view.305 - Moral Knowledge
- Deontological principles and virtues are only ever nominated as good because we believe they have good consequences on balance; no one would endorse a categorical imperative known to uniformly produce terrible consequences, and a virtue like courage in service of an awful end (e.g., a more courageous Hitler) ceases to be praiseworthy—so non-consequentialist theories covertly smuggle consequentialist assumptions everywhere.305 - Moral Knowledge
- Intentions are critical for judging the moral character of agents but not for judging whether an act was right; the rightness of an act depends on its consequences, so a person with good intentions whose act produces terrible outcomes is judged on character (modulated by negligence), while the act itself is evaluated solely on its consequences.48 - What Is Moral Progress
- Traditional moral philosophy arbitrarily limits what counts as a consequence by ignoring mental states; if someone kicks a puppy out of the car's path while wanting to cause it pain versus to save it, the difference lies in the consequences of having such a mind—intentions matter because they color the mind in every moment, determine behavior, and shape how others respond, so both inner and outer consequences account for everything of value.364 - Facts Values