normative

Intentions judge agents, consequences judge acts

Intentions are critical for judging the moral character of agents but not for judging whether an act was right; the rightness of an act depends on its consequences, so a person with good intentions whose act produces terrible outcomes is judged on character (modulated by negligence), while the act itself is evaluated solely on its consequences.

normativepending

Speaker

Peter Singer

Evidence Quote

“what do we think of the act um did what he did the release of the information was that the right thing to do um that doesn't depend on his intentions that depends uh in my view on the consequences”

Source

48 - What Is Moral Progress— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:52:04 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...