comparative statics
An economic analysis technique comparing equilibrium states before and after a change, holding all else constant, without specifying how or when the new equilibrium is reached.
As defined in Michael Clemens on Aid, Migration, and Poverty
Other definitions
An analytical technique in economics that assumes equilibrium, changes one variable, and examines the new equilibrium to gain insight
Daniel Botkin on Nature, the Environment and Global Warming 11/26/2007
Where it comes up · 8
- Barry Weingast on the Violence Trap2 claims
- Daniel Botkin on Nature, the Environment and Global Warming 11/26/20072 claims
- Peter Henry on Growth, Development, and Policy 07/27/20091 claim
- Michael Clemens on Aid, Migration, and Poverty1 claim
- Edward Lazear on Becker1 claim
- Daron Acemoglu on Inequality, Institutions, and Piketty1 claim
- Mike Munger on Shortages, Prices, and Competition 10/19/20091 claim
- Edmund Phelps on Unemployment and the State of Macroeconomics 02/15/20101 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “comparative statics” →
- Because outside observers lack perfect knowledge of why demand fell, comparative-statics thought experiments are deeply problematic: there is always 'one more step in the argument we leave out,' since something must have changed and that underlying cause—rarely truly random—shapes the result and limits our ability to predict.Edmund Phelps on Unemployment and the State of Macroeconomics 02/15/2010
- The real debate over institutions is not whether property rights help growth (they obviously do) but one of magnitude—how much of the variation in growth rates institutional factors actually explain—and pinning down such point estimates over 300 years is essentially impossible because you cannot control for everything else.Peter Henry on Growth, Development, and Policy 07/27/2009
- Economic theory provides little guidance about when aid effects on growth should arrive, because much theory relies on comparative statics that predict a new equilibrium 'at some rate within some time period' but not precisely when—so detecting growth effects requires guessing the lag between disbursement and impact.Michael Clemens on Aid, Migration, and Poverty
- Ecology lags behind economics in handling static models: whereas economists use comparative statics knowing equilibrium is a useful fiction (changing one thing to gain insight), ecologists tend to believe their static models actually are reality.Daniel Botkin on Nature, the Environment and Global Warming 11/26/2007
- Ecology lags behind economics because economists treat equilibrium as an analytical convenience they know is unreal (comparative statics), whereas ecologists tend to believe their static models actually are reality.Daniel Botkin on Nature, the Environment and Global Warming 11/26/2007
- Becker showed that even with equal distaste toward two minority groups, members of the larger group suffer a bigger wage differential because they must sell their services further down the distribution of buyers who have tastes against them, whereas a smaller group can find buyers less averse to them.Edward Lazear on Becker
- The essence of economics is asking 'and then what?', a phrase Roberts attributes to Thomas Sowell. You can't hold everything else constant; the good economist figures out how people respond to new incentives. Yet academic economics, focused on comparative statics, nearly disqualifies those who ask it.Mike Munger on Shortages, Prices, and Competition 10/19/2009
- The geographic distribution of towns explains divergent European development: France was mostly interior so coastal towns had little reach and stayed weak (though France was powerful as a nation); the Dutch Republic was almost entirely towns, which easily dominated the small agricultural population, became nearly 100% market with rule of law, and used deep capital and debt financing to defeat the much more powerful Spanish Hapsburgs; and England, split roughly half coastal-commercial and half interior-subsistence, saw those two groups fight the 1640s civil war, with the growing commercial economy ultimately dominating after the Glorious Revolution of 1689.Barry Weingast on the Violence Trap
- Piketty's book is genuinely important and tapped a deep public angst while building on decades of inequality research, but it suffers from a tension because he tried to do in one volume both the academic work of advancing empirical comparative-statics claims and the popular work of appealing to readers' sense that something is deeply unfair—so it becomes hard to parse which statements are scientific claims about the effect of x on y and which are persuasive appeals made even when the data is not there.Daron Acemoglu on Inequality, Institutions, and Piketty
- An external existential threat can serve as a commitment device that ends internal factional fighting: when an outside enemy can take more from both factions than they would take from each other, the cost of internal fighting rises and former enemies become fast friends—as in post-1870 France, where defeat in the Franco-Prussian War and German unification forced the republican and monarchist factions to stop fighting and produced France's longest-lived constitution, the Third Republic (1871-1940).Barry Weingast on the Violence Trap