
Mike Munger on Shortages, Prices, and Competition 10/19/2009
What this covers
This EconTalk conversation pairs host Russ Roberts with Mike Munger of Duke. It begins with vaccine shortages during the H1N1 season and widens to organ transplants, triage, and what role price should play in allocating scarce goods. Munger separates two problems: how to divide the supply that exists, and how to choose a system that produces more supply. He argues that people tend to ignore how responsive supply is to the mechanism chosen. The discussion also covers non-price alternatives: queues, lotteries, expert authority, favoritism, and contests in which effort is burned for a chance at the prize.
The examples are varied. Alchian and Allen are used to explain why Rose Bowl tickets are underpriced, and Munger recounts Chinese officials describing rice coupons and local discretion. He also covers the Federal Communications Commission's spectrum giveaways as a rent-seeking contest, and airline meals under fare regulation, including Eastern's sirloin "sandwich." These illustrate what Munger calls hydraulic competition: block one margin of competition) and the rivalry moves to another. Munger forecasts a US black market in vaccine if H1N1 turns more virulent, and compares flu-shot lines to Soviet meat lines.
The more contested turns come later. Roberts argues that "we can't afford" universal care is an evasion, that the optimal infant mortality rate is positive, and that markets matter more for livers than for Ferraris. He proposes a voluntary insurance-style contract for organ compensation and says the moral hazard objection to organ markets cuts the other way. The final stretch applies the same logic to the minimum wage: queues of applicants give employers discretion, and non-wage conditions worsen. Munger also floats job gentrification in Santa Fe's higher living wage. The thread running through is the seen and the unseen, with a brief detour into Elinor Ostrom's Nobel.
Roberts and Munger argue that price controls and non-price rationing (of vaccines, organs, rice, tickets, or labor via the minimum wage) do not remove competition. They push it onto hidden margins: favoritism, discretion, shortages, black markets, and worse non-wage conditions. Good economics requires the imagination to ask 'and then what?' rather than just reading supply and demand curves.
- Supply responds to the allocation mechanism, so suppressing prices and profits (vaccines, livers, rice) creates artificial shortages.
- Price ceilings and floors hand discretionary power to whoever allocates the scarce good (Rose Bowl tickets, FCC spectrum, Chinese rice coupons, minimum-wage employers).
- When one margin of competition is legally blocked, competition shifts 'hydraulically' to non-price margins (airline meals, worker treatment, training, job gentrification).
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Many schemes adopted to replace price, such as a minimum wage or official rationing during a shortage, unintentionally increase opportunities for personal favoritism by hiring managers or local officials.
“a lot of the schemes that we choose end up unintentionally increasing the amount of favoritism”
When airline fares were regulated so that carriers could not lower prices, they competed on non-price margins: meals escalated from sandwiches to steaks. Eastern Airlines served a large sirloin between two tiny pieces of bread and called it a 'sandwich' to evade limits. They also added more flights with lower load factors, more room, and more attractive stewardesses and upholstery. This price-quality mix was not what consumers would have chosen.
“Eastern airline which is now bankrupt famously had a lunch which was a large sirloin steak between two tiny pieces of bread and they called that a sandwich”
Chinese officials at a Liberty Fund conference in Scottsdale described the consequences of rice price ceilings. Farmers produce less rice, and coupon rationing gives local officials discretion to favor relatives, punish enemies, discriminate, or sell out the back door. The artificial rent is dissipated in a thousand ways, and the public blames 'lazy farmers' rather than the officials who benefit.
“we heard from a lot of Chinese officials about the terrible problems that they have with price ceilings”
Alchian and Allen explain underpriced Rose Bowl tickets (about 100,000 seats, more demand than that) as a choice by the people selling them. They don't capture the extra revenue, which would go to the organization anyway. By keeping prices low and creating excess demand, they gain discretion to allocate valuable tickets as favors, like kings handing out treasure.
“why would the people who run the Rose Bowl not try to make as much money as possible”
Saying 'we can't afford' universal liver transplants is a linguistic evasion. We could afford it; we choose not to, given what we'd have to give up. Just as a parent 'could' buy a Ferrari by mortgaging the house, 'can't afford' really means 'I choose not to afford'.
“I want to just challenge a linguistics that you say we can't afford it”
Because of opportunity costs, an economist must accept that the optimal infant mortality rate is positive. Keeping every infant alive would require giving up education and nutrition for other children. Health care is therefore always rationed, and the idea that it should be free is 'insane'.
“an economist is someone who believes as a matter of moral good that the infant mortality rate should be positive”
A minimum wage is a price floor that blocks voluntary transactions. It creates Marx's 'reserve army of the unemployed', which would not exist where markets function. Employers facing a queue of applicants gain the same discretion as rice officials and can reject people because 'I don't like your face'.
“what the minimum wage does is create Marx's reserve army of the unemployed”
Building on Yoram Barzel's work on how competition takes place, Roberts argues that a minimum wage set above market creates excess labor supply. Since wages legally cannot fall, competition pushes down non-monetary compensation instead: harder work, fewer breaks, split shifts, paying for your own uniform, less on-the-job training and mentoring, and tolerance of an abusive boss. Workers 'exploit themselves' because losing the job means facing more competitors for fewer jobs.
“the person is the so-called beneficiary who's now making 725 an hour is really in a position to be exploited by his employer and will often act and exploit himself”
Allocating a scarce good involves two distinct problems: how to allocate the stuff we have, and how to choose a system that produces more stuff to allocate. People ignore how responsive the quantity available is to the allocation mechanism chosen.
“we're worried about how to allocate stuff and how to choose a system where there's more stuff to allocate”
People dislike price allocation partly because price does two things: it allocates, and it redistributes between buyer and seller within a transaction. The redistribution makes trade look zero-sum. That is true only if the transaction occurs; a high-enough controlled price can turn the buyer into a non-buyer who is even worse off.
“price does two things it allocates... it also redistributes between buyer and seller”
Alternatives to price for allocating scarce goods include queuing, lotteries, authority (experts deciding need), personal favoritism, and rent-seeking contests where your chance of winning depends on how much effort or money you burn. An example of the last is a 'ditch-digging contest' where you dig a ditch and fill it back in.
“we could use a lottery... we could use Authority... we could use personal preference or favoritism... we could set up a rent seeking contest”
Elinor Ostrom's 2009 Nobel (shared with Oliver Williamson) rewarded case-study work showing that groups often solve commons problems through cultural norms and voluntary agreements. This challenges Garrett Hardin's conclusion that only government regulation, taxes, or subsidies can prevent ruin. Like Coase and Stigler, she asked 'is it actually true?' Most economists disdain her case-study method.
“Elinor Ostrom Oliver Williamson were awarded the Nobel Prize in Economics”
The beauty of the marketplace, when allowed to work, is that it encourages people to be decent. It takes an artificial wage to allow people to afford to be cruel.
“the beauty of the marketplace when it's allowed to work is that it encourages people to be decent human beings”
Organ compensation could be structured as voluntary insurance. You sign a contract saying that if you die while a viable donor (roughly ages 25–55), your liver may be harvested and compensation goes to your heirs. It costs the signer nothing, which separates compensating the donor from the question of who receives the organ.
“allowing them to sign a contract saying in the unlikely event of my death my liver can be harvested and the compensation will go to my heirs it's actually a kind of insurance”
The pill example can illustrate two different questions. First: given fixed supply, do we ration by price, need, or something else? Second: if supply responds sharply to the allocation mechanism, do we let price or command (top-down government) drive the increase? For vaccines, supply is responsive, yet people prefer command because they trust it more than the profit motive.
“there are two different things that his example might illustrate and you and I took it different ways”
Blocking price competition is like hydraulics: the surplus gets pushed to some other margin almost automatically.
“it's kind of like hydraulics if there's this surplus it's going to be pushed to some other margin almost automatically”
Quantity responses to sufficiently large price distortions are obvious (for example, a $50 minimum wage). The more interesting effects are non-quantity responses. Under rent control, landlords rarely paint, are slow to repair, and choose tenants in discriminatory ways despite laws against it.
“what I think is interesting are these non quantity responses”
Economics and imagination work in both directions. Imagination helps you understand economics because seeing how competition works reveals hidden, unseen effects. This is what Bastiat meant by 'the seen and the unseen': it is a requirement of imagination.
“improving your in your imagination may help you to understand economics”
US flu vaccine shortages resemble Soviet-era meat lines. In the Soviet case, butchers sold at low state prices to the first few in line and diverted meat out the back at higher black-market value. A more virulent H1N1 would likely produce a US black market in vaccine.
“it reminds me of people use the lease to want to buy meat or sausage in Poland or the former Soviet Union”
The usual intuition that markets are fine for Ferraris but not for liver transplants should be reversed. Precisely because transplants are more important, we should want the market's economies of scale, innovation, and profit incentives unleashed on them.
“people say well the markets fine for Ferraris but not for liver transplants and for me it goes the other way around”
Hazlett argued that when the FCC chose to give away electromagnetic spectrum through applications rather than auction it, the process became a rent-seeking contest. Rent-seeking dissipates the asset's value through unrecoverable application effort, or else hands the controller discretionary power.
“the Federal Communications Commission decided not to auction off electromagnetic spectrum they were going to give it away”
The moral hazard objection to organ markets cuts the other way. Livers are more precious now because they are artificially scarce, so the pressure to pull the plug on listed donors is arguably greater under the current non-price system than it would be under a market that made livers less scarce. The current system also already has black markets and gives doctors discretionary allocation authority.
“I think that happens more now than it would under a price system because livers are so precious”
Santa Fe dramatically raised its living wage (from about $7 to roughly $11–14). This likely caused 'job gentrification': higher wages attract better-qualified applicants, such as college graduates, who crowd out the low-wage neighborhood residents the policy meant to help, just as rising housing prices gentrify poor neighborhoods. A New York Times Magazine article interviewing beneficiaries never asked whether they feared losing their jobs.
“the city of Santa Fe raised their living wage to something dramatic”
The US vaccine shortage is not merely a physical production-time problem. In the prior two years, three large manufacturers left the vaccine business because they couldn't make profits. If the private sector finds vaccines unprofitable despite their obvious value, the compensation and price signals are failing to transmit that value.
“in the last two years three large manufacturers have left the business”
Roberts is skeptical that Card and Krueger's finding (that minimum wage increases raised employment) will stand the test of time. He is equally skeptical of studies supporting his own view, because it is very hard to tease out effects of small national minimum wage increases on low-skilled labor. The recent jump in teenage unemployment is suggestive but could be coincidence.
“card and Krueger claimed it actually increases it I don't know if their work will stand the test of time”
Liver transplants are expensive partly because people are not allowed to pay for livers. Many good livers are buried that donors would have given if offered something like funeral expenses plus $50,000 for their heirs. The ban on payment creates an artificial organ shortage.
“part of the reason is we don't let people pay for livers”
The standard economic analysis of the minimum wage is 'remarkably unimaginative'. It treats the issue as a utilitarian sum: gains to workers raised from $5 to $7.25 versus losses to those who lose jobs. That makes it purely an empirical question of the elasticity of low-skilled labor demand, so with low elasticity it looks like a clear win. This framing ignores non-wage margins of competition.
“I think the way economists look at this is remarkably unimaginative”
Altruism ('love and affection and decency') can operate at the margin for professionals like doctors once their average costs (training, practice expenses) are covered. Shortages occur at the margin, though, and impersonal physical goods like vaccines cannot rely on altruism to be produced at scale.
“she needs to cover something like what economists call the average cost ... but at the margin she's happy to help people problem is the shortages occur at the margin and vaccines are physical things”
The Mankiw pill and lifeboat-style examples pose a false moral dilemma. They assume fixed supply with no way or incentive to produce more, which corresponds to almost nothing in a market economy. An innovator would want to sell to many people at lower prices, just as cars went from a rich-only good in the early 1900s to near-universal ownership within about 60 years.
“I think it's a false way of posing it”
Altruism can work at the margin for individual professionals: a doctor covers her average costs and then may help people for free. But shortages occur at the margin, and vaccines are impersonal physical goods with large information asymmetry about quality. So love and decency cannot be relied on to supply them.
“she needs to cover something like what economists call the average cost... but at the margin she's happy to help people problem is the shortages occur at the margin”
Ironically, the employer who responds rationally to a minimum wage becomes an 'exploiter'. He barks at workers, offers nothing beyond wages, and fires impulsively, while no one quits. People then blame greedy employers, but the interference in the price mechanism created that environment. Functioning markets encourage decency, whereas artificial wages let people afford to be cruel.
“the employer who responds to the incentives right is an exploiter”
At the heart of resistance to markets in health care is a moral intuition that no one should ever profit from serving desperate needs. This was captured by a pediatrician who said she wouldn't trust a vaccine made by someone seeking profit. Yet she herself charges for her services, and would be horrified at the suggestion that she can't be trusted when a child is very sick.
“we have a sense that it's wrong to use the profit motive at all as a way of organizing production that's involved in serving really desperate needs”
Non-quantitative effects of wage and price controls, such as changes in the nature of the workplace, are understudied because you can't run a regression on them. A fruitful research agenda would study how competition actually works instead of stopping at whether supply and demand curves cross.
“you can't run a regression so it doesn't get very often”
The essence of economics is asking 'and then what?', a phrase Roberts attributes to Thomas Sowell. You can't hold everything else constant; the good economist figures out how people respond to new incentives. Yet academic economics, focused on comparative statics, nearly disqualifies those who ask it.
“it once again illustrates the essence of economics which is and then what”
Getting a $5 flu shot at a drugstore instead of a $100 doctor's appointment shows market entry displacing doctors' monopoly and entry barriers, as physician assistants and pharmacists take on more tasks. Many people, however, distrust such impersonal market services.
“instead of having to go and make an appointment with a doctor and pay $100 I paid $5 at a drugstore and this is displacing some of the monopoly”
A rich 90-year-old buying a liver abroad that could have gone to a productive 30-year-old father seems repulsive. But this is a result of an artificial shortage. Non-top-down responses are also available, such as charities and foundations voluntarily subsidizing organ acquisition for younger or poorer patients.
“it's pretty repulsive isn't it it's an artificial shortage”
Paid organ contracts raise a moral hazard. Heirs and sometimes doctors might be overeager to harvest organs and hasten death; in poor societies with weak property rights and justice systems, people have been murdered for body parts.
“you have what economists call a moral hazard problem that both the heirs and sometimes the doctors might be overeager to harvest that liver”
Immigrants from the former Soviet Union carried thousands of dollars in cash on arrival in the US. Under Soviet supply uncertainty you had to be ready to buy a TV the moment one appeared at the state price. This shows how chronic shortages reshape everyday behavior.
“people from the former Savini when they came to the United States would often carry large sums of cash”
Munger worked minimum wage jobs for two summers. He says he likely couldn't have found work, or worked his way through college, at a higher 'living wage' such as $11 an hour. Low-wage jobs give economically marginal people a foothold to build work skills and move up, and a jump from $5 to $7.25 is a large increase.
“I myself worked for a minimum wage job for two summers I wouldn't have been able probably to find a job if the minimum wage had been higher”
Like airline consumers, minimum wage workers would prefer a different mix: the market wage plus better treatment, more breaks, more on-the-job training, and better promotion chances.
“the guy employed at a minimum wage would prefer a different mix”
Greg Mankiw posed a 'Dorian Gray pill' thought experiment in a New York Times column. In it, a pill costing $150,000 per year stops aging and death, but supply is fixed even if all of society's resources were devoted to it. The question is whether markets should allocate it so a handful of rich people live forever.
“he calls it the Dorian Gray pill after the Oscar Wilde character”
Beyond the job-quality effects, a minimum wage also eliminates some jobs entirely. Businesses near failure see profitability cut and close, which is separate from the elasticity of labor demand within surviving firms.
“some of these businesses are gonna fail it says nothing to do with just the elasticity of labour within a business”
Society seems to have decided vaccines are too important for markets and so puts the equivalent of the Department of Motor Vehicles in charge, despite no good reason to think government is better at producing them.
“we're going to put the Department of Motor Vehicles in charge of it with all of their efficiency and politeness”
Inequality in luxury versions of goods matters less than it seems: the rich get Ferraris and the poor get Hondas, which get you from A to B just as successfully.
“rich people do get the Ferrari support people don't but poor people get Honda's and they're really nice”
Orson Scott Card argued the minimum wage is good even if it reduces low-skilled jobs, because it destroys 'crummy jobs' people cannot live on.
“it's good to have the minimum wage because what it does is it just economists are right ... that's good because it's destroying crummy jobs”
As a devil's-advocate check, Roberts asks whether the claim that non-price competition 'has to be true' is just economists' faith-based worldview. Such arguments rest on margins, and the magnitudes are unknown and must be studied.
“isn't that just are you just acting like some kind of faith-based economist”
Roberts plays devil's advocate against himself: perhaps the claim that non-price competition must occur is a naive, faith-based economists' religion, and $5-an-hour workers would not actually get benefits and friendly bosses without a minimum wage.
“isn't that just are you just acting like some kind of faith-based economist”
Few listeners have ever considered that competition for jobs can express itself along margins other than wages. This should at least be factored into decisions about minimum wages, rice price controls or rent control, even if its magnitude is uncertain.
“I'm willing to bet almost none of the listeners have ever thought about that kind of competition for jobs expressing itself as competition along other merchants other than wage”
If healthcare is not allocated by markets, it is reasonable for healthcare workers to get the vaccine first, since they contact the disease and vulnerable people.
“probably healthcare people should get at first because they're gonna come into contact with it a lot”
Liver transplants are also expensive because of the sheer complexity of the operation, not only because of the organ ban.
“liberty transplants are also expensive though because of the very complexity of the operation”
If a life-extending pill had to be allocated by price, it would create a two-tiered society that people would object to, so voters might simply outlaw it. Munger says the US is about to do the equivalent in healthcare.
“I would wonder if we might not take a vote and outlaw the pill”
Playing devil's advocate against himself: is the claim that non-price competition 'has to' occur just economists' faith-based worldview, two economists in a fantasy world assuming competition solves everything?
“isn't that just are you just acting like some kind of faith-based economist”
In fall 2009, Walgreens had already given twice as many regular flu vaccines as in all of the previous year, before flu season started in December. Anxiety over H1N1 was driving this, even though swine flu had caused about 600 US deaths versus roughly 36,000 annual deaths from ordinary flu.
“Walgreens for example which gives the regular flu vaccine has already given twice as many as it did all of last year”
A liver transplant costs about $1–1.2 million all-in. Society cannot pay that for everyone, so wealthy people and those with gilt-edged plans get them. Under single-payer systems such as Germany or England, it is reportedly impossible to get one legally in some cases, which is effectively a decision to ration.
“liver transplant cost about 1 million 1.2 million by the time you go through all of it”
At the time there were about 600 US deaths from swine flu versus about 36,000 deaths from ordinary flu each year. Swine flu was not yet particularly different from regular flu; the concern came from the possibility that it could become worse.
“they've got a total of 600 deaths in the u.s. from swine flu we have 36,000 deaths from flu every year”
Many economists may 'live in their own world', assuming people behave in certain ways and treating that as reality.
“it's fair enough to say that many economists live in their own world”
Matt Holliday should not get a Dorian Gray pill because he missed a fly ball in the outfield (a Cardinals fan's joke).
“it is not Matt Holliday for from my own sake since he missed that flyball in the outfield”