cognitive dissonance
The mental discomfort from holding conflicting cognitions, often resolved by changing attitudes—e.g., valuing a chosen option more after choosing it.
As defined in Paul Bloom
Other definitions
Psychological discomfort experienced when holding contradictory beliefs or when reality contradicts expectations; in this context, investors' confusion about distinguishing between money (gold) and credit (fiat currency)
Jaime Carrasco: Gold at the Heart of the New President's Agenda?
Where it comes up · 22
- 1 | Carol Tavris on Mistakes, Justification, and Cognitive Dissonance10 claims
- 87 - Triggered4 claims
- David McRaney on How Minds Change3 claims
- What Modern Medicine Gets Wrong (with Marty Makary)2 claims
- Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politics | Big Think1 claim
- Paul Bloom1 claim
- Ron Brownstein on the 2024 Presidential Election: What Just Happened?1 claim
- Charles Marohn on Strong Towns, Urban Development, and the Future of American Cities1 claim
and 14 more
Most important claims · 10 of 37Search all claims for “cognitive dissonance” →
- It is easier to act your way into a new way of thinking than to think your way into a new way of acting; forcing oneself to perform ethical behaviors (like visiting friends in the hospital) eventually shifts one's self-concept and makes one genuinely better, operating like cognitive behavioral therapy and cognitive dissonance.110 - The Change Artist
- Cognitive dissonance—holding a belief despite overwhelming contrary evidence—is not merely a psychological mechanism but can arise from neurological malfunction, as shown by misidentification syndromes (e.g. Capgras-like delusions after parietal lobe injury) where a patient acknowledges all physical evidence that his antique table is genuine yet insists it is an imitation because it no longer 'felt' the same.Robert Burton on Being Certain
- Rigid ideologies like orthodox Marxism, religious fundamentalism, and wokeness function the same way: they offer a single unfalsifiable creed that lets adherents prejudge the world, enter any conversation feeling intellectually superior and morally righteous at the vanguard of history, and avoid ambiguity—an attraction one level above mere confirmation bias, satisfying a craving for cognitive closure and belonging.160 - The Revenge Of History
- Social media polarizes not by creating pure echo chambers but by making most of a user's feed agreeable so they feel their view is the popular, right-side-of-history consensus, then occasionally inserting an opposing-side post (mocked by an ally or posted by a 'crazy uncle') that triggers cognitive dissonance and the backfire effect—convincing users that the whole world agrees with them while the other side is radically dangerous.Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity
- Every closed-minded person perceives that they are impeccably open-minded, and this self-deception is part of the human condition rather than a sign of bad character; recognizing it is necessary because, per Festinger's cognitive dissonance, the brain subconsciously reframes new information to fit existing beliefs because it wants peace rather than conflict.What Modern Medicine Gets Wrong (with Marty Makary)
- When a strong positive attitude (toward a political candidate) collides with a strongly negative event, people resolve the dissonance in ways that feel like NOT changing their mind—reinterpreting the bad act as actually positive, denying it happened, or claiming the actors weren't really their side—yet they have in fact updated their priors and beliefs about the situation.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- A patient with lesions to the anterior cingulate cortex could not experience cognitive dissonance, so when faced with two contradictory perceptions (eyes closed yet seeing fingers in a mirror), she felt no urge to resolve the conflict and simply allowed both to be true, undergoing a 'cognitive filibuster' and resetting rather than updating her beliefs—revealing that dissonance is a brain-based mechanism that normally drives belief resolution.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- The 2016 election created a 'cognitive dissonance cluster bomb' that split the country into two groups watching entirely different movies on the same screen: one half saw the election of a Hitler-like figure, the other saw a competent businessman, with the difference explained by confirmation bias and cognitive dissonance rather than disagreement over facts.87 - Triggered
- The binary distinction between sincere-but-deluded faith healers and deliberate tricksters is not real; given our capacity for cognitive dissonance and self-justification, a person can run both tracks simultaneously, with sincere belief leveraging deliberate trickery considerably—as illustrated by the guru Sai Baba who was an awkward stage magician palming sacred ash and jewelry.143 - The Keys To The Mind
- The single-axis framework explains intersectionality: if you know someone's view on one issue you can predict their view on every issue, because they apply the same lens to everything rather than reasoning case by case; humans find this comfortable because it makes maintaining tribal alignment easier and avoids the cognitive dissonance of a tribe agreeing on some issues but not others.Misinformation and the Three Languages of Politics (with Arnold Kling)