What this covers

This is a single-speaker talk by Jordan Peterson, about ten minutes long, framed as a "technical problem" in depolarization. He starts from the Right, where the boundary of acceptable opinion is already drawn around racial superiority. He cites William Buckley turning away David Duke-type figures in the 1960s and Ben Shapiro doing the same after Charlottesville. He then asks where the equivalent line sits on the Left, and proposes that it should separate equality of opportunity, which he calls laudable, from equality of outcome. He frames the Left's concern with inequality as understandable in origin and says it goes wrong when pursued without limit.

The middle of the talk is a practical critique of outcome equality. Gender pay gap legislation serves as the simplest case, and he argues that even it needs a bureaucratic inquisition to enforce, which raises the question of who measures and by what standard. He then turns to intersectionality. Crossing racial, gender, class and other categories multiplies the groups without limit, and he calls this a fatal flaw the radical Left has found but not understood. He also asks which dimensions of inequality would be equalized at all.

The last stretch is intellectual history, and it is the most contested part. Peterson says Derrida and other French thinkers who had been Marxists reworked Marxism into post-modernism and identity politics once evidence from the Soviet Union and Maoist China made defending it untenable. He argues that post-modernism's rejection of any overarching narrative leaves it incoherent, so it falls back on a loose egalitarian Marxism. He also contrasts the Western emphasis on the individual with group identity. A brief aside covers his collection of Soviet socialist realist paintings and why he owns nothing comparable from the Nazi era. He ends by predicting that the result will be tribalism, and by calling the Left's failure to police its own extremes an ethical failure.

Sharpest takeaway

The speaker argues that depolarization requires the political Left to identify and explicitly reject markers of pathological extremism (particularly equity doctrine and identity politics) with the same clarity the Right has applied to racial superiority, because failure to do so represents an ethical failure that threatens liberal democracy.

  • The Right has successfully identified racial superiority as the boundary marker for unacceptable ideology; the Left has no equivalent boundary
  • Equity (equality of outcome) implemented through identity politics creates unsolvable measurement, bureaucratic, and intersectional problems that make it fundamentally unworkable
  • Post-modern identity politics on the Left is a disguised continuation of discredited Marxism, lacking internal coherence

The claims · ranked21 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.78

The West privileges the individual because Western civilization figured out 2,000 to 3,000 years ago that you can fractionate group identity appropriately all the way down to the level of the individual, which is a foundational principle distinct from group-based identity politics.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“The reason that the West privileges the individual is because we figured out 2,000 years ago, 3,000 years ago, that you can fractionate group identity appropriately right down to the level of the individual.”

0.71

Derrida and Foucault were barely repentant Marxists who were part of the student revolutions in France in the 1960s, but by the end of the 1960s the evidence from the Soviet Union and Maoist China of the devastating consequences of Marxism made it impossible to be apologetic for it, so French intellectuals transformed Marxism into post-modern identity politics.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“Derrida himself regarded—and Foucault as well—they were barely repentant Marxists. They were part of the student revolutions in France in the 1960s, and what happened to them, essentially—and what happened to Jean-Paul Sartre for that matter—was that by the end of the 1960s you couldn't be conscious and thinking and pro-Marxist. There's so much evidence that had come pouring in from the former Soviet Union, from the Soviet Union at that point, and from Maoist China, of the absolutely devastating consequences of the doctrine that it was impossible to be apologetic for it by that point in time. So the French intellectuals in particular just pulled off a sleight of hand and transformed Marxism into post-modern identity politics.”

0.62

Concern about inequality on the Left is driven fundamentally by a horror of inequality and the catastrophes that inequality produces, which is reasonable, but that concern can go too far when it pursues equality of outcome rather than equality of opportunity.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“The Lefties have their point. They're driven fundamentally by a horror of inequality and the catastrophes that inequality produces—and fair enough, because inequality is a massive social force and it does produce, it can produce, catastrophic consequences. So to be concerned about that politically is reasonable. But we do know that that concern can go too far.”

0.62

Equality of outcome, while distinct from and less unacceptable than equality of outcome, should not be pursued without limit—thoughtful people on the Left should draw the line at rejecting equality of outcome while accepting equality of opportunity.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“And it seems to me that that's where people who are thoughtful on the Left should draw the line, and say, "No. Equality of opportunity? Not only fair enough, but laudable. But equality of outcome…?" it's like, "No, you've crossed the line. We're not going there with you."”

0.62

You cannot win if you play identity politics.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“You cannot win if you play identity politics.”

0.57

Attempts being made to implement legislative requirements to eliminate the gender pay gap are an example of equality of outcome doctrine, and while it may not seem pathological on the surface, it requires setting up a bureaucratic inquisition to ensure compliance, which is not good.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“An example of equality of outcome are attempts being made now to implement the legislative necessity to eliminate the gender pay gap. That's a good example. I mean you think, "Well no, that's not—like there's nothing pathological about that." It's like, "Oh yes there is!" You have to set up a bureaucratic inquisition to ensure that that's the case. It's like—it's not good.”

0.55

On the Right, the identified marker for people who have gone too far in their ideological presuppositions is racial superiority, a boundary that has been maintained at least since the end of World War II and exemplified by William Buckley rejecting David Duke types in the 1960s and more recently by Ben Shapiro after Charlottesville.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“On the Right, I think we've identified markers for people who have gone too far in their ideological presuppositions. And it looks to me like the marker we've identified is racial superiority. I think we've known that probably since the end of World War II, but we saw a pretty good example of it in the 1960s with William Buckley, because Buckley, when he put out his conservative magazine, the David Duke types kind of attached themselves to it, and he said, "No, here's the boundary. You guys are on the wrong side of the boundary. I'm not with you." And Ben Shapiro recently did this, for example, as well in the aftermath of the Charlottesville incident.”

0.55

The measurement problem in equality of outcome implementation is paramount—if you don't solve the measurement problem (who measures equality of outcome and by what standard), you don't solve the problem at all, and this is not a minor issue to be figured out later.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“Here's one: "Let's push for equality of outcome." All right, who measures it? That's a big problem. It's not a little problem. It's not like, "We'll figure that out later." Oh no, no, no. The measurement problem is paramount. So you don't solve that, you don't solve the problem at all. Who measures it?”

0.53

There is a triumvirate of concepts—Diversity, Inclusivity, and Equity—that have the same potentially catastrophic outcomes when implemented as racial superiority doctrines, with Equity being the most unacceptable because it is the doctrine of equality of outcome.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“So I've suggested that there's a triumvirate of concepts that have the same potentially catastrophic outcomes when implemented as the racial superiority doctrines. Diversity, inclusivity, and equity as a triumvirate—even though you could have an intelligent conversation about two of those anyways. But I would say that of the three, equity is the most unacceptable. The doctrine of equality of outcome.”

0.52

The speaker owns a large collection of socialist realist paintings from the former Soviet Union despite the murderousness of those regimes, but does not own paintings from the Nazi era because he regards the communist totalitarian regimes as equally murderous, yet the evil associated with the Nazi regime seems more palpable.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“In my house, I have a very large collection of socialist, realist paintings from the former Soviet Union—propaganda pieces, but also kind of harsh impressionist pieces of working-class people and so forth—and I collected them for a variety of reasons. Now you could debate about the propriety of that given the murderousness of those regimes. And fair enough, I have my reasons. But I don't have paintings from the Nazi era in my house, and I wouldn't. And that's been a puzzlement to me because I regard the communists, the totalitarian communist regimes, as just as murderous as the Nazi regimes. But there's an evil associated with the Nazi regime that seems more palpable in some sense.”

0.52

Gender pay gap legislation is relatively simple and definable compared to other equality of outcome initiatives, yet once implementation starts to get murky, it becomes complex beyond rectification.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“And that's actually a relatively—like, of all the things that you could push for with regards to equality of outcome, that's rather simple and definable. It's not even murky. Once it starts to get murky it's just complex beyond any rectification.”

0.52

Post-modernists respond to the coherence problem by defaulting to a loose, egalitarian Marxism without any real attempt to grapple with the cognitive dissonance, using post-modernism as an intellectual gloss to hide the fact that a discredited economic theory is being used to fuel an educational movement and produce activists.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“So what happens is they default—without any real attempt to grapple with the cognitive dissonance—they default to this kind of loose, egalitarian Marxism. And if they were concerned with coherence that would be a problem, but since they're not concerned with coherence it doesn't seem to be a problem. But the force that's driving the activism is mostly the Marxism rather than the post-modernism. It's more like an intellectual gloss to hide the fact that a discredited economic theory is being used to fuel an educational movement and to produce activists. But there's no coherence to it.”

0.48

The entire project of implementing equality of outcome through identity politics is a complete and absolute mess—a catastrophe that cannot be rectified because it has no logical solution.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“It's a complete bloody catastrophe. It's an absolute mess.”

0.47

The number of gender categories is hypothetically infinite, and decisions about which racial groupings, ethnic categories, classes, socioeconomic variables, and other dimensions to include in equality measurements are not pre-determined, making the problem of intersectionality essentially unsolvable.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“How many genders? Hypothetically there's an infinite number. What about racial groupings? Are you going to include ethnicity? Do you want to add class to that? Do you want to add socioeconomic class? How about attractiveness? And every time you add another category to the singular entities, you increase the multiplicative entities in a multiplicative fashion.”

0.47

Post-modernism's fundamental claim is that there are an infinite number of interpretations and no canonical overarching narrative, but this creates a coherence problem: if there is no narrative or value structure, how does one orient oneself in the world?

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“the fundamental claim of post-modernism is something like an infinite number of interpretations and no canonical overarching narrative. Okay, but the problem with that is: okay, now what? No narrative, no value structure that is canonically overarching, so what the hell are you going to do with yourself? How are you going to orient yourself in the world?”

0.47

While it is known that things can go too far on both Right and Left, the markers for going too far on the Left are not clearly identified, and it is ethically incumbent on those who are liberal or Left-leaning to identify the markers of pathological extremism on the Left and distinguish themselves from those who hold those views—and this is not being done, which represents a colossal ethical failure that may doom the liberal-Left project.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“We know that things can go too far on the Right and we know that things can go too far on the Left. But we don't know what the markers are for going too far on the Left. And I would say that it's ethically incumbent on those who are liberal or Left-leaning to identify the markers of pathological extremism on the Left and to distinguish themselves from the people who hold those pathological viewpoints. And I don't see that that's being done. And I think that's a colossal ethical failure, and it may doom the liberal-Left project.”

0.47

The intersectionality problem arises when pursuing equality of outcome across multiple identity categories: starting with three racial categories and two gender categories yields six intersectional categories, and adding more categories increases intersectional entities in a multiplicative fashion, creating a problem the radical Left has discovered but not adequately understood.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“Which identities? That's the intersectional problem. The radical Leftists have already hit the problem of intersectionality. It's like, "Well, we've got race and gender, let's say." Well, okay, what about the intersection between race and gender? That's a multiplicative intersection, right? So you might start with three racial categories and two gender categories. But you end up with six intersectional categories. And then you're just getting started.”

0.47

Even if intersectional categories could be managed, there is a fundamental problem of deciding what dimensions of equality to equalize across—whether it is socioeconomic, salary-based, or some broader measure of inequality—and whether to stop with economic inequality or address all other ways people are unequal.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“What are you going to do? Are you going to equate across all those categories? Really? And across what dimensions? What are the dimensions of equality that you want to establish? It's just socioeconomic? Is it just salary? What about all the other ways that people are unequal? Are you just going to stop with economic inequality? Are you?”

0.47

Intersectionality represents the radical Left's discovery of the fundamental flaw in their identity politics ideology: that groups can be multiplied without limit, which is not merely a problem but a fatal flaw that the Left has discovered but failed to fully understand.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“And intersectionality, the discovery of intersectionality on the Left, is actually the radical Left's discovery of the fundamental flaw in their identity politics ideology. Groups can be multiplied without limit. That's not a problem; that's a fatal flaw. And they've already discovered it, they just haven't figured it out.”

0.47

If equality of outcome is to be measured by a bureaucracy, which bureaucracy will do it becomes a major problem, and such a bureaucracy would necessarily be very large with its fingers everywhere, and it would be staffed by exactly the sort of people you don't want staffing it.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“"A bureaucracy." Okay, which bureaucracy? "Well, a large one that has its fingers everywhere." Okay, that's problem number one. And it's staffed by exactly the sort of people that you don't want to staff it, by the way.”

0.39

The consequence of transforming Marxism into post-modern identity politics has been a devolution into tribalism that will tear the Left and Right apart.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politic… [8UVUnUnWfHI]

“And we've seen the consequence of that. It's not good. It's a devolution into a kind of tribalism that will tear us apart on the Left and on the Right.”