
Ron Brownstein on the 2024 Presidential Election: What Just Happened?
What this covers
This is a post-election conversation between Bill Kristol (listed in the metadata as Bill Crystal) and Ron Brownstein, split into two halves. The first reads the 2024 result as it came in. The second looks ahead to 2026 and 2028. Brownstein leans on exit polls and votecast data and on county-level results. He notes that Donald Trump improved his share in 49 of 50 states and that about 90 percent of counties moved his way, and he puts the popular-vote margin at roughly 2.5 points. The two also argue over how much to trust the demographic breakdowns. White voters barely moved in the surveys, and the predicted 15-point gender gap on each side never appeared. Hispanic voters shifted most, and Black men more modestly.
The middle of the discussion takes up why voters accepted a candidate they distrusted. Majorities called Trump too extreme and a threat to democracy, yet voted for him. Brownstein describes this as wishful thinking, with voters pushing doubts aside to hold on to the hope of lower costs. He compares it with 1992, when voters took a "leap of faith" on Bill Clinton, and with the long record of "look forward" campaigns by unpopular incumbents failing. Kristol raises the possibility that incumbents lost ground across the world, a point flagged as contested. They also discuss why the Joe Biden administration's industrial investments, which reached far fewer people than inflation did, failed to register.
The forward-looking half is more conditional. Brownstein says early moves on tariffs and mass deportation, both possible without Congress, will show whether Trump follows through on his promises. He cites the scale of potential family separations and the backlash to the first-term policy. He also argues that Trump's biggest risk is an agenda that worsens the cost of living, and that majorities side with Democrats on abortion, immigration and health care. Kristol brings in Ronald Reagan as a model of a president who compromised and had to prioritize, and asks how much independence Congress will show.
The 2024 election reflected a nationwide verdict on Biden's economic performance, particularly inflation, rather than candidate-specific or tactical factors; voters prioritized economic security over concerns about Trump's risks, following a historical pattern where dissatisfaction with the status quo outweighs uncertainty about change.
- Uniform 3-4 point swing toward Trump across all geographic and demographic segments indicates a shared national experience, not targeted messaging
- 70% of voters viewed economy as poor/fair and 46% reported being worse off; these voters overwhelmingly favored Trump regardless of other concerns
- Precedent shows unpopular incumbent presidents' parties lose power (Truman, LBJ, Bush Sr.), suggesting structural incumbent penalty rather than candidate-dependent outcome
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
When unpopular presidents try the strategy of telling voters to 'look forward' at the next four years rather than looking back at their record, it has historically never worked, because voters find it difficult to conclude a president will be better for them in the future if they don't think they were better off under that president in the past.
“you know the issue of whether Trump's agenda is going to improve any of that is a very different question but historically you know when you have a president that is unpopular and he is running for real ction like Carter HW Bush or Trump in 2020 they lose I mean that you know they and they and they always try the same strategy to say let's not look back let's look forward at the next four years whose agenda is going to be better for you and it it's never worked”
Trump improved his vote share in 49 of 50 states, with 90% of US counties moving toward him according to New York Times calculations, representing uniform gains across the electoral map.
“I believe Trump improved his vote share in 49 of the states the New York Times calculated that 90% of the counties in the US move toward him”
In exit polls and votecast data, a majority of voters (roughly 55%) said Trump was too extreme; 55% said he was a threat to democracy; a majority had an unfavorable view of him; yet they voted for him anyway, indicating voters entered the booth with eyes open about Trump's risks.
“a majority of Voters roughly 55% said that he was too extreme 55% again roughly said that they view him as a threat to democracy a majority of Voters in the vote cast I believe said they had an unfavorable view of him this is while they are electing him”
Biden's disapproval rating, established by summer/late summer of 2021 after inflation began rising, remained essentially stable through the entire presidency and into Harris's campaign, suggesting that once voters form a negative performance judgment they are extremely resistant to changing it despite subsequent positive developments.
“they certainly made that judgment over 3 four years with Biden it never changed really right from the summer late summer of 2021 that is pretty striking that number was flat”
In 1992, George H.W. Bush stayed close in a race where voters were discontent about the economy by raising doubts about Bill Clinton (age, inexperience, not sharing American values, cultural criticisms), but ultimately voters who were discontented took a 'leap of faith' on the unknown candidate rather than continuing with the status quo they knew.
“I remember in 1992 in a campaign that you were uh involved in and George HW Bush was laboring under widespread discontent with you know all the outcomes in the country particularly on the economy which also was wasn't that bad at the time in in reality and he stayed close in that race by raising doubts about Bill Clinton too young inexperience you know didn't share American values...but in the end voters who were discontented took the leap of faith on you know the guy they didn't know rather than continuing what they did know”
For most Americans, inflation and secondarily the border were the primary issues driving the election, overshadowing Biden's legislative successes and allowing Trump to gain everywhere despite Democratic advantages in swing states.
“for most Americans inflation and secondarily the Border uh I think maybe crime primarily inflation overshadowed all of that and allowed Trump to basically gain everywhere uh overcoming all of the kind of Castle keeps the the the last lines of Defense the Democrats thought they had built in the swing States”
In 2020-2024 exit polls, white voters showed virtually no change, improving slightly from 58-41 Trump to 57-41 Trump; in votecast, white voters remained essentially flat at 55-45 Trump in both elections, contradicting the geographic uniform swing data and raising questions about demographic exit poll accuracy.
“in 2020 I'm I'm I'm gonna do apples to apples okay in in the exit polls uh Trump won white voters in 2020 5841 he won them 5741 in the exit polls this time...in the vote cast last time he won white voters 5543 and he won them 5543 this time”
Trump can do tariffs and mass deportation unilaterally on day one without Congressional approval; tariffs and deportations are early indicators of whether Trump will follow through on his campaign promises or moderate once in office.
“presidents have enormous unilateral authority over tariffs and immigration doesn't really need Congress to to give him the authority to do these things so he can do them on day one you know and they have said they're going to start deportations on day one”
The Financial Times documented that every incumbent party in the last year has lost or significantly lost vote share, suggesting that pandemic inflation and global disorder hurt incumbent parties regardless of specific circumstances.
“the Ft had a piece that get got to people people notice that every incumbent party is basically either lost or certainly lost vote share in the last year”
Intel plants, manufacturing facilities in Ohio, Georgia, and Michigan, and clean energy investment all increased under Biden through IRA, but these benefits reached hundreds of thousands of people while inflation affected tens of millions, making the aggregate impact appear limited.
“look at that Intel plant going up in Ohio or you know everything that's going up in Georgia or in Michigan and uh in the clean energy space...the number of people who benefit from that even at the most expansive version of it is still pretty limited it's hundreds of thousands of people...whereas tens of millions are affected by inflation”
Hispanic voters showed the most movement toward Trump, with significant declines in Democratic support; black voters, especially black men, showed more modest but real declines; black women showed much less movement, while white voters showed minimal movement in all four subcategories (non-college men/women, college men/women).
“Hispanics the most I mean you know uh uh a a significant decline in both uh a more modest but real decline among black voters especially black men uh in both and you know um the the Hispanic men you know in particular you know dropped substantially uh but there was also there was was also a drop among Latinos um uh uh for them not not not so much among black women um among whites you know even uh in all four groups not again in both the exit polls and the vcas not a big change”
Reagan, who didn't have the House, still was able to accomplish major policy goals; Reagan also gave way on many promises and raised taxes despite conservative critique, made deals with Tip O'Neill, and didn't accomplish conservative goals on abortion and Social Security reform, showing presidents must prioritize which issues to pursue.
“Reagan didn't have the house obviously in 1981 and still was able...Reagan did not do a lot that he promised to do in taxes he raised taxes big social sec I mean all this conservative critique of Social Security Happ make a deal with tip o' the abortion stuff talk more of a game Sandra Dale Conor”
Historically, when a president is unpopular and running for reelection (Carter, Bush Sr., Trump in 2020), they lose; this time, even though Harris stepped aside, the structural disadvantage of the incumbent party persisted as they always do when there is widespread presidential disapproval.
“historically you know when you have a president that is unpopular and he is running for real ction like Carter HW Bush or Trump in 2020 they lose”
People recognize Trump's risks (authoritarianism, military deployment, political opposition prosecution) but are engaging in wishful thinking ('la la la') to suppress doubts in order to maintain belief that he'll deliver economic improvement.
“I mean he talks he's talked on multiple occasions on multiple different reasons about sending the military into US cities you know I think people discounted that because they again like that that analysis they want to believe he is going to give them a more stable economic situation and therefore they kind of push out of their mind anything that would cause them to hesitate about voting for that more stable economic situation because that's what they really want to do so I don't la la la la la I don't want to hear that he's going to send the military into Chicago”
The biggest risk to Trump is that his agenda does not solve the problem he was elected to solve (cost of living) and in fact makes it worse, which is what most economists believe will happen with his proposed policies.
“I think the biggest risk to him is that his agenda does not solve the problem he was elected to solve and in fact makes it worse which is what most economists believe”
Family separation in Trump's first term affected 5,000 children and provoked massive backlash; there are approximately 4 million US citizen children with at least one undocumented parent, plus another million children of other nationalities with at least one undocumented parent, so potential family separation at scale would be massive and could spark major political reaction.
“family separation was 5,000 kids yeah right so tragedy it was 5,000 huge backlash as I said there are 4 million US citizen children of uh with at least one undocumented parent among Latinos and I think there's about another million bill of other nationalities of kids who are citizens and have at least one undocumented parents”
Trump will win the popular vote by approximately 2.5 percentage points, representing a roughly 7-point swing from Biden's 4.5-point popular vote victory in 2020.
“I figure that drifts down to saying it's 2 and A2 and Biden won the popular vote by 4 and A2 seven point swing which is a pretty big swing”
The swing in swing states was smaller than in non-competitive states, but not nearly as good as 2022, showing partial but incomplete Democratic success in swing state messaging and organization.
“the swing was less it did in the swing States...the swing was less in the swing States but it was not as big a gap as 2022 when Democrats won them in many cases is Comfortably right”
The magnitude of Trump's electoral victory was startling even to those who expected Republican gains due to anti-incumbent sentiment; the uniformity of the swing suggests a uniform national verdict rather than sophisticated targeting or messaging.
“the magnitude of it you know was was startling I mean and again I think the core I think everyone expected that in states that weren't being fought Trump would improve whether they were blue States or red States because you can't have 75% wrong track 60% disapproval of the president and not have an erosion of his party's position but the idea that you could Hive off or put the swing States under a dome and in those States you could counteract the underlying Trend”
A majority of voters (roughly 55%) said abortion should be legal in all or most circumstances, a majority opposed mass deportation and believed undocumented immigrants should have a chance to apply for citizenship, more than half said they want government more involved in healthcare, and more than half want government more involved in ensuring childhood vaccinations.
“still somewhere around two-thirds of Voters said abortion should be legal in all or most circumstances um a majority said they oppose Mass deportation and and believe undocumented uh should have a chance to apply for citizenship half of Voters said they want the government more more than half said they want the government more involved in in providing Access to Health Care coverage health insurance and and half said they want the government more involved in um uh ensuring that kids are vaccinated”
Pre-election polling suggested Trump would win men by 15 points and Harris would win women by 15 points, but the actual results came nowhere near that predicted gender gap.
“we were looking you know there were polling pre-election polling that was like he was going to win Men by 15 and she was going to win women by 15 and we did not get anywhere near to that kind of Gender Gap”
Biden's approval rating was only around 40% with approximately 60% disapproving; between two-thirds and 70% of voters said the economy was in bad shape; and 46% said they were worse off than four years ago, with only about half that saying they were better off.
“approval ready for Biden was only around 40% around 60% disapproved you know somewhere between 2third and 70% of Voters said the economy uh was in bad shape and in the exit pole 46% said they were worse off than they were four years ago only about half that said they were better off”
Congress still has power independent of the president: there are independently elected senators and members of Congress who may exercise independence on specific issues like deportations, taxes, or SALT deductions, though party discipline has generally weakened independence.
“we still do have independently elected senators and members of Congress for all that they don't exercise their independence much...there's political pressure on them whether it's on deportations or on tax policy or on you know fights about salt”
When people are unhappy with the status quo, they are willing to risk an unpredictable future rather than voting for continuity with an unacceptable present, following historical precedent.
“when people are unhappy with the status quo they are willing to risk an unpredictable future rather than voting for continuity with an unacceptable present”
Performance determines political outcomes more than ideology or demographic shifts; when voters are unhappy with an incumbent and its performance record, they vote for change, and the opposition party's success depends primarily on whether it delivers on voters' expectations, with performance in 2025-2026 determining 2026 and 2028 electoral outcomes.
“I mean we've seen enough of these to know that there is no last word ever uh in American politics and and I guess my main thing that I'm coming away from this is that like performance really matters I mean it's not just ideology it's not just the shifting allegiances of different groups or places you know everybody wants you to deliver and if you don't you pay a price everywhere and that's what exactly what we saw fair enough um of course they have to judge what to in means and so forth but yes they certainly made that judgment over 3 four years with Biden it never changed really right from the summer late summer of 2021”
In a presidential year, achieving separation from voter unhappiness over the economy is harder than in non-presidential years because voters attribute economic responsibility to the president specifically, whereas they view governors and senators as one step removed from economic policy decisions.
“when it was not about electing Governors or Senators who were one step removed from that those decisions and it was about electing a President Who voters I think you know um attribute econ give Agency on economic policy um that separation didn't hold”
Trump showed clear signs of cognitive decline during the campaign: he couldn't complete thoughts, relied on rambling to explain incomplete sentences, and appeared to have more cognitive challenges than Biden had when entering office at age 78.
“Trump showed clear signs on the campaign of cognitive decline right without a question I mean just the debate I mean he couldn't complete a thought many of his rallies he just the you know came up with the weave to explain why he could not complete a thought”
Trump was helped significantly by being an ex-president rather than a newcomer: he had the advantage of change (being outside the current administration) while also having reassurance (he had been president for four years, the economy was good, and the country survived).
“he he was defeated as president but I think for people who raised the risk argument...the obvious answers well he was present for four years and it was it was a mixed bag but it wasn't terrible in fact the economy was good and we you said the retrospective job refal for Trump so he sort of had the best of both worlds you want change Trump Chang Biden Harris incumbent you want reassurance he was President for 4 years”
Two consecutive elections where there were substantial shares of non-college-educated white women reluctant to vote for women as president suggest they may believe they are safer with a male president; this pattern could limit female Democratic nominees' viability unless Trump respects constitutional term limits.
“the fact that you've had two elections in a row where there were a a substantial core of white women who appeared non-oled white women who appeared reluctant to vote for a woman as president tend tended to kind of fall back into the belief that they are more likely to be kept safe by a man um that you know that's that's something that's out there”
More women describe the economy in negative terms than men (70% versus lower percentage), yet a quarter of pro-choice women still voted for Trump, suggesting the economy was so dominant an issue it neutralized abortion's salience for some women voters.
“70% more Bill more women describe the economy in negative terms than men okay so like all right you know I'm yes women were pro-choice but as I said one quarter of women who said they support legal abortion voted for Trump what can explain that I mean you'd have to start with the economy as the overwhelming factor”
Tax cuts passed under Trump in 2017 are set to expire at the end of 2025 and Republicans will likely extend them as the major legislative lift of the Trump term, similar to how Reagan (1981) and Bush (2001) used tax cuts as their primary legislative victories.
“traditionally presidents that's the one issue I would say a new president who takes over from the other party almost always gets his way one or two very big pieces of legislation and they're almost always taxes because that's kind of an obvious one to do...that would be Reagan 81 and it would be Bush and 2001”
Trump administration may use administrative action to intervene in civil rights cases, challenge private sector diversity efforts through the Securities Exchange Commission, and pressure RFK Jr. to restrict vaccines and fluoridation, representing major threats to civil rights and public health.
“Civil Service intervening yeah Civil Service re they're going to be intervening in cases you know against uh racial Equity or diversity you know against private sector companies that are doing Dei they'll probably use the uh the Securities Exchange Commission to go after that you know he said he wants RFK Jr to go wild on on the Health Care system”
Trump said day-before he doesn't want to revoke vaccine legal status but wants parents more educated about risks; CDC data shows 5% non-compliance with public school vaccination mandates triggers outbreak risk, and current non-compliance is at 3%; if RFK Jr. influences parents against vaccines, compliance could drop and outbreak risk could increase.
“he said yes he said the day before we're talking that he doesn't want to like uh revoke uh the legal status of any vacc but he wants parents to be more educated about the risks CDC reported last year that I'm not a you know epidemia public health specialist but CDC says that once you get to 5% non-compliance with public school vaccination mandates you start running the risk of outbreaks we're at three now for many of the major childhood diseases 3% non-compliance if Donald Trump gives RFK Jr a platform to make the case against vaccines what are the odds that some more parents really on both ends of the other Spectrum but especially the conservative you know say well hey the President says we we shouldn't be doing this”
Blue-collar white women in focus groups rejected extreme claims about Trump even when they came from Trump's own mouth because they experienced too much cognitive dissonance, as they wanted to believe Trump would deliver economic security and stability.
“I talked to a woman who runs a group that studies uh uh basically white women that's they do tremendous research data polling and focus groups and she said that you know talking to blueco collar white women in the fall they would reject any of the extreme possibilities about Trump even when they came from his own mouth because they it was too much cognitive dissonance they believed he was going to give them an economy that was more secure and stable for them”
JD Vance, Tucker Carlson, and Stephen Miller represent committed America First ideologues focused on implementing Trump's more extreme agenda, while Susie Wiles (incoming chief of staff) represents more establishment/pragmatic approach; Trump's actual governance will depend on which faction has more influence.
“you got JD Vance and Tucker Carlson and people like that you're you're dealing with pretty committed ideologues who were all this stuff America First and all this um on the other hand that's not what Trump is exactly and it's not what Susie Wilds his incoming chief of staff is going to be like I don't think”
The immediate evidence suggests that the movement toward Trump among Latino voters was primarily a performance grade on Biden rather than a lasting realignment, though this interpretation is uncertain.
“we may maybe we will look back on this as a lasting realignment of of Latino voters but the immediate evidence suggests to me that this was a performance grade of fail”
Democrats' future electoral message must focus on economic concerns affecting working-class voters across racial lines, as Biden's manufacturing investment boom didn't overcome inflation's salience; Democrats need material economic alternatives that resonate with workers, not just cultural messaging.
“I think they look I think you know a part of the uh I the obvious message the Democrats will take away from this is we have to do better among workingclass voters across racial lines um now you know some will say well that will require cultural moving to the middle maybe maybe not I'm not sure how important that was in the end um it does it is going to require convincing them that Democrats have a plan that can make their life better uh in material ways”
Harris was a pretty good candidate: she hit her marks on big moments, generated excitement and enthusiasm, but couldn't reassure enough working-class voters that she had an economic alternative that would make their lives better, which is historically required for incumbent party candidates to succeed.
“Harris I thought was a pretty good candidate uh you know the situation she inher obviously that one very bad moment on The View couldn't think of anything she differ from Biden but overall she hit her marks on all of the big moments I mean and certainly generated a lot of excitement and enthusiasm what she really couldn't do was reassure enough workingclass voters in particular that um she had an economic alternative”
American politics is generally moving toward a more parliamentary system where Congress does not break from the president of their party; the House under Democratic control passed everything on the Democratic list (assault weapon ban, voting rights, LGBTQ rights, police reform, Build Back Better), suggesting Republicans will similarly pass Trump's agenda.
“I I think we are generally moving toward a more parliamentary system where the Congress does not you know uh break from the from the president of their party very much...if you look at the house I mean they had a tiny majority and they passed when the Democrats control the house they passed everything on the Democratic list I mean assault weapon ban uh voting rights uh you know lgbtq rights police reform build back better I think you're going to see something like that in the house”
Voters cannot separate Trump's agenda into desirable and undesirable components; voting for Trump means accepting a package deal including RFK Jr. on vaccines and fluoride, weaponized Justice Department, potential mass deportations, and other extreme policies alongside economic promises.
“this is a package deal you don't get to order uh you know this is a package deal you don't get to order off different columns in the menu here if you are voting for Trump because you think that somehow he is going to bring prices down...you can't you you know it it it requires a kind of um a will was it a suspension of disbelief to to basically say that you're not going to get the other parts of it”
Democratic voters in swing states like Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania had Democratic governors and some Democratic state legislators, so they may have believed they were protected from extreme Trump policies on abortion without needing a Democratic president.
“if you live in Wisconson or Michigan you don't think you're really which let's say Michigan Pennsylvania certainly you don't think you're really at risk on that because you got Democratic Governors and some democratic state legislators legislatures”
Enhanced ACA subsidies expire at the end of 2025; Republicans will likely let them expire, removing insurance coverage from approximately 10 million people, as Democrats increased ACA enrollment from 11-11.5 million when Trump left office to 21 million through enhanced subsidies.
“on the ACA subsidies they expire at the end of 2025 I think Republicans just going to let them go away I mean I can't see them extending those enhanced subsidies which have dramatically increased the number of people I think there were 11 million 11 and a half million people on the exchanges when Trump left office it's 21 million now that's 10 million more people covered um uh and that's because of the enhanced subsidies”
Republicans may attempt to go after Medicaid block granting and cuts, which has been a goal since the 1990s and was central to government shutdowns under Clinton; with a Republican House and Senate, significant Medicaid cuts become possible if 4 Republican senators (Collins, Murkowski, possibly Tillis or McCormick) don't block it.
“do they block rent Medicaid and cut it I mean that's been a goal of Republican since the 90s it was at the center of the government shutdowns under Clinton um uh and you know uh house Republican you know would a 220 seat 221 seat house Republican majority block rant Medicaid um probably you know and we will 50 are there four Republican Senators who would vote against it if McCormick ends up winning which it seems like he will uh we know marowski and Collins wouldn't block rant Medicaid maybe Tillis maybe McCormick”
If Trump's cognitive abilities deteriorate during his presidency, this could create political vulnerability similar to Biden's, potentially shifting GOP positioning heading into 2026 and 2028 if voters develop similar fitness concerns.
“if that deterioration which I think was evident at clearly evident at points during the campaign continues um uh you know that was a problem I mean Biden's age became a symbol of weakness and out of touch and feeble people don't see Trump as feeble but there are already concerns in the electorate about whether he's too old to do the job and he's just starting”
Democrats should consider how to make Trump's transition less successful, through obstruction and other means, though this is politically risky if Trump's early approval is high.
“democrats should think about how to make it less successful honestly”
The uniform swing and the fact that it's performance-based rather than message-based suggests that the shared national verdict on the next four years will be the most important factor in 2028, not cultural changes or realignments.
“I think rather than the leading indicator I take it as performance basically will influence both...the shared National verdict on the next four years is going to be the most important factor in 2028”
The 2026 midterms and 2028 presidential election will likely feature younger Democratic governors (Shapiro, Whitmer, Newsom, Beshear) as nominees, representing a generational shift; a Democratic senator is hard to imagine as the 2028 nominee given structural trends toward younger leadership.
“there will be a generational and Geographic shift I think Allah Bill Clinton in '92 there will be a lot of interest in a younger Governor...hard to imagine a senator being the nominee in 2028 uh hard to imagine it won't be someone who's younger you know Shapiro Whitmer Nome people like that uh uh Basher”
There will likely not be a Women's March in January 2025 like there was in 2017, because Trump's victory is stronger (winning popular vote, possibly majority support) and his opposition is smaller, reducing the intensity of organized resistance.
“is there going to be a women's March in January of 2025 I probably not um uh you know again he did better among women than he did in 2016”
There are multiple imponderables about the 2024 result: it could be a slight bizarre one-off, the beginning of a new era, or a new era that is different from what observers expect, requiring patience and observation rather than premature interpretation.
“it is kind of amazing how many impound for all that this was a big election which I think has real consequences and implications as you say a big National swing we both said on the other hand there's so many imponderables and you sort of don't know I mean it's entirely possible it's a Slightly bizarre oneoff and it's entirely possible we're at the beginning of a new era in American politics or May we're the beginning of a new era but it's not the era we think it is”
Markets mark inflation to new 'baseline' levels after price shocks (similar to marking assets to market); voters similarly reset their expectations and will accept current price levels as the new normal rather than demanding deflation, so Trump doesn't need to reduce prices to absolute 2019 levels but rather deliver price stability and wage growth going forward.
“I mean he gets a sort of like with stocks you know you get a what's that called when you mark them up to the a new level you know when Mark to Market yeah yeah Mark to Mar you know like when people die and stuff theate you know marks it to um I I think he gets fresh people will accept that prices are where they are and I think yeah I do think the moment he sees though if he sees the Tariff stuff leading to inflationary pressures”