central planning
An economic system in which a central authority decides what is produced and consumed rather than leaving it to market price signals.
As defined in 205 | John Quiggin on Interest Rates and the Information Economy
Other definitions
Economic system where a central authority determines what goods are produced, how much, by whom, and at what prices, rather than allowing markets to coordinate these decisions through price signals.
Top 9 Economic Lessons of the Past 35 Years | InFi #54
Where it comes up · 13
- Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history3 claims
- Sarah Paine – Why Russia Lost the Cold War2 claims
- 205 | John Quiggin on Interest Rates and the Information Economy2 claims
- 🚨 Stay on mission. Gut the bureaucracy. Don't get distracted.2 claims
- Top 9 Economic Lessons of the Past 35 Years | InFi #542 claims
- Walter Williams on Life, Liberty and Economics1 claim
- Capitalism, Government, and the Good Society1 claim
- John Gray on the Seven Kinds of Atheism1 claim
and 5 more
Most important claims · 10 of 19Search all claims for “central planning” →
- Communism failed as an economic system because without market prices, everyone in the planning chain lies—understating inventories and overstating needs—so that aggregated data becomes progressively worthless up the hierarchy, leaving the government with no idea of the true value of capital or labor, actual productivity, or consumer preferences, causing misallocation that goes unnoticed until it metastasizes into catastrophe.Sarah Paine – Why Russia Lost the Cold War
- Top-down quotas incentivized perverse production: steel factories made thicker bars to count as greater output, then other factories had to thin the steel down for actual use, with both the inefficient production and the corrective re-processing being double-counted toward GDP—illustrating systemic waste in central planning.Sarah Paine – Why Russia Lost the Cold War
- When communist regimes refuse political liberalization and find economic reform either insufficient or threatening, they turn to technological fantasies—believing computers and tech can perfect planning, overcome the pathologies of the planned economy, and make their dictatorship immune to challenges through all-encompassing surveillance—thereby avoiding the hard structural choices that would end the party monopoly; the Soviets tried this and it failed, and China is now seduced by the same temptation.Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history
- Although free markets historically outperformed Soviet central planning because prices aggregate dispersed information more efficiently, advances in technology and algorithmic information-gathering (as used by companies like Uber) raise the question of whether centralized planning could eventually match or surpass markets in practical efficiency—and if so, whether free markets would then become morally questionable.AMA | August 2025
- The fall of the Soviet Union vindicated Mises and Hayek's decades-long critique of central planning, with mainstream economists increasingly accepting that top-down planning cannot work and that market economies with private property are necessary for efficient resource allocation.Top 9 Economic Lessons of the Past 35 Years | InFi #54
- Sending $5,000 checks to all 78 million households is not restitution or returning taxpayers' money because most recipients do not pay taxes, and it constitutes redistribution via central planning rather than genuine fiscal relief.🚨 Stay on mission. Gut the bureaucracy. Don't get distracted.
- Chinese economic liberalization began not as proactive policy but as the party's grudging acceptance, decree by tiny decree, that society would rebuild through its own hard work—and what reform actually did was surface existing illegal market behavior (already pervasive even at the level of the military-industrial complex obtaining ball bearings on the black market) into a legal or quasi-legal realm, rather than inventing markets from scratch.Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history
- China's economic liberalization began in part because the Cultural Revolution had unwittingly destroyed the planning system—sending economic planners to manual labor and smashing intellectuals—so unlike Stalin's purges which left the Soviet political and planning system intact, Mao's frenzy annihilated state capacity, forcing the party to grudgingly allow market behavior to rebuild and avoid famine.Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history
- Carlson argues that the US is not really a capitalist free market because it has more central planning than Russia, citing the climate/energy agenda imposed without popular demand and an economy dominated by monopolies like Google, and that the largest of all monopolies is the federal government itself.Tucker Carlson
- Hayek's Road to Serfdom argues that any movement toward planning launches a society down the slippery slope to serfdom, yet Hayek concedes the line between state and market must be drawn somewhere while giving no guidance on where—a fatal weakness, because as soon as he admits the extreme is not possible, his own slippery-slope argument is undone.Capitalism, Government, and the Good Society