What this covers

John Gray and Russ Roberts examine the philosophical foundations of modern atheism and its unacknowledged debts to Christian thought. Gray's central claim is that contemporary atheism, especially the militant variety, has mistaken the rejection of specific theological doctrines for the rejection of monotheism's deeper framework. He argues that most New Atheism is actually an inversion of Christian monotheism—it retains the structure of the original belief while simply reversing the sign. In this view, the atheist faith in Progress as Secular Religion becomes just another form of the redemptive mythology that monotheism offered, except now humanity itself is cast as the agent of salvation through reason and science.

The conversation covers substantial ground beyond this central inversion. Gray distinguishes sharply between the Science-Morality Distinction: while scientific and technological knowledge genuinely accumulate, he argues that human nature does not evolve, and therefore ethics and politics run in Cyclical Theory of History rather than moving toward permanent improvement. He documents the Recurrence of Evil through historical examples—the return of torture, anti-Semitism, and even nostalgia for communism—to undermine claims about moral victories. Gray also challenges atheists on the assumption that liberal morality is somehow universal truth rather than Morality as Time-Bound Convention, pointing out that atheists a century ago accepted racism without question. The exchange touches on Technology's Moral Ambiguity, the nature of religion as practice rather than proposition, and the inescapability of Indispensability of Myth in human life, even for those who believe they have transcended it.

Sharpest takeaway

Gray argues that most modern atheism is an unwitting continuation of Christian monotheism—especially its belief in progress—and that while science and technology genuinely advance, moral and political life is cyclical, so there is no warrant for optimism about the human future.

  • Religions are primarily practices, not propositions, so the New Atheist 'religion vs. science' framing is a parochial inversion of Christian monotheism
  • Scientific and technological knowledge accumulate, but the human animal and its credulity do not change, so ethics and politics run in cycles
  • Atheists assume liberal morality is 'morality itself' when it is just the conventional morality of their time, as shown by atheists who were racists a century ago

The argument · threads10 threads · 44 claims
0.75

Progress conflates technological advancement with ethical improvement, but humans remain unchanged and use new tools to serve whatever ends they already had.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The belief in progress confuses genuine progress within science and the accumulation of technological power with ethical and political progress; the two are completely different things, because the human animal does not change and uses the advancing fruits of science to serve whatever ends it already has, good or destructive.

    “the view that so many people take confuses progress within science and progress in the increase of technological power that occurs as a result of progress within science with ethical and political progress, or I would call it the quality of civilization. They are two quite completely different things.”

  • Modern progressive thought has replaced the worship of God with the worship of humanity, substituting the myth that God will redeem humanity with the myth that human beings will transform and redeem themselves through the application of reason and science.

    “you argue that we've replaced the worship of God with the worship of humanity: that we've put the God who will transform human beings and redeem human beings into a different myth. Which is the myth that human beings will, through the application of reason and science, transform humanity.”

  • The huge increase in material wealth and the comforts of daily existence over the last few hundred years are nearly all spin-offs from new technologies, which are in turn spin-offs from the growth of scientific knowledge, and so represent genuine progress.

    “First of all, I think the last 2- or 300 years is a very short time span. If you look out through the longer perspective of human history, you find many examples of civilizations that grew up and achieved higher levels of material progress than they had in the past. I mean, Rome at its peak... And then, of course, Rome collapsed.”

  • The central confusion in Western liberal and Communist thinking is the belief that as knowledge grows humans become more reasonable and civilized; in fact knowledge grows but humans stay exactly the same, retaining their need for consoling stories and never becoming more reasonable.

    “knowledge grows; humans stay the same. Knowledge grows, but humans do not become more reasonable. That's the confusion in Western, not only Communist but Liberal thinking. They think that as knowledge grows, humans become more reasonable and more civilized. They don't.”

0.75

New Atheism is an inversion of Christian thought that leaves monotheism's underlying framework intact and misunderstands religion as belief rather than practice.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • An atheist is simply anyone who does not need the idea of a creator-god; atheism need not be organized or associated with any particular view of the world, and on this definition many religions—such as Buddhism (no creator-god, no immortal soul) and polytheism (no single supreme creator)—are themselves atheist religions.

    “for me an atheist is just anyone who doesn't need the idea of a creator-god of that kind... if you think of atheism in that way, that rather simple negative way, then many of the religions of the world have been atheist religions. For example, there's no creator-god in Buddhism.”

  • New Atheism is an inversion of Christian monotheism: by merely rejecting or turning upside down its key beliefs, atheists believe they have rejected the whole framework, but inverting the beliefs leaves most of the underlying framework of monotheistic thought intact.

    “New Atheism is a kind of inversion of monotheism, particularly Christian monotheism. It just turns upside down that body of thought, by rejecting the key beliefs in it... just turning the beliefs upside down, inverting them or rejecting them, leaves most of the rest of the framework of thought intact.”

  • Throughout most of human history and most of the world, religions have been composed of practices rather than beliefs, and most have had no creeds or written propositions; the New Atheist view of religion as a set of obsolete explanatory theories is therefore a primitive misunderstanding that scholars of religion would reject.

    “Religions are in most parts of the world, throughout most parts of human history, of being composed of practices more than of beliefs. Most of them haven't had creeds, written down as propositions.”

  • There is nothing new in the so-called New Atheism; nearly all its criticisms of religion were made in similar but better forms in the 19th century, and the New Atheists are ignorant of the history of ideas and even of atheism beyond the last 20 years.

    “The first thing that's wrong with the so-called New Atheism is that there's nothing in it which is new. Most of the criticisms of religion that they advance, nearly all of them, in fact, were made in similar but better forms in the 19th century.”

0.61

History moves in cycles of civilizational rise and fall, not linear progress; modern barbarism mirrors the past and earlier peoples understood this better.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Civilizations run in cycles—born, growing, peaking, then dying and being replaced by periods of barbarism, including modern barbarism—a cyclical view of history that almost everyone in the world held until roughly 1720-1750 and which corresponds better to human experience than the modern progressive view.

    “I take the old-fashioned view that civilizations require different tools... that, civilizations run in cycles. They are born, they grow up, they reach a peak, and then they start dying. And as they--and they are replaced then by periods of barbarism.”

  • There has been a huge increase in material wealth over the last few hundred years as a spin-off from science and technology, but the last two or three hundred years is a very short span; in the longer perspective civilizations such as Rome reached high material levels and then collapsed to lower levels of comfort, technology, and population.

    “First of all, I think the last 2- or 300 years is a very short time span. If you look out through the longer perspective of human history, you find many examples of civilizations that grew up and achieved higher levels of material progress than they had in the past. I mean, Rome at its peak... And then, of course, Rome collapsed.”

  • Nazism and Soviet Communism show barbarism with a modern face: very few anticipated how monstrous they would be, yet modern technologies enabled these regimes to commit crimes greater and more terrible than any in the past.

    “we see the barbarism with a modern face, barbarism with modern technologies, enabling the regimes... to commit or support crimes much bigger, much greater, in some cases more terrible than in any of the past.”

  • A disastrously bad regime, not natural catastrophe, can drive a country from prosperity to ruin—Venezuela went from one of Latin America's richest, oil-rich countries to one of the most devastated, just as revolutionary Russia, a fast-growing economy from the 1880s to 1910, stalled for two generations and did not regain late-Czarist output until the 1960s.

    “Venezuela went from being one of the richer countries in Latin America, huge oil riches, to being one of the most devastated... Not because of any natural disaster or catastrophe... but because they have a disastrously bad regime... in the case of Russia, they didn't get back to late Czarist levels of production and consumption till about the 1960s or later.”

0.61

Technology is morally ambiguous; it enables both good outcomes and atrocities, and predictions of liberation through innovation have repeatedly failed.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Like all human knowledge, genetic science can be used for good or ill; Gray regards it as a certainty that it will be used for frivolous purposes such as designing children and, more darkly, could be used for racist ends, genetic weapons, or genocide.

    “the potential of genetic science to improve the human lot is great; but I'm afraid I regard it as a certainty that, if it's not already happening that genetic sciences will be used to, from frivolous purposes... But then you get into darker areas, where genetic science can be used to... edit out certain groups, human groups, for the purpose of genetic weapons. Or even for purposes of genocide.”

  • Technology is not inherently liberating: predictions that the photocopier or video camera would bring down Communism failed, as Tiananmen Square was filmed and seen worldwide yet caused no collapse, while the same technologies of telegraphs, telephones and filing systems made the Holocaust's continent-wide genocide possible.

    “People said that the video camera and video recording would do it... Well, we had Tian An Men Square. Everybody's seen that actual footage. And it did not cause any such collapse. So, technology isn't liberating... that colossal genocide would have been much harder to commit if there hadn't been telegraphs and telephones and filing systems”

  • Following Popper's maxim, one should always try to falsify any strong conjecture or view one holds; Gray applies this by trying to think of technologies that are purely good, and finds only anesthetic dentistry and contraception as plausible candidates while nearly all others are deeply ambiguous.

    “Karl Popper, the famous philosopher of science, said you should always try and falsify any conjecture or view you put forward... So, I've always tried to think of technologies or advances in science as if [?] being purely good. And I've come up with a couple. It's very hard to think of a downside to anesthetic dentistry.”

  • Future wars will not closely resemble the 20th century's world wars but will involve new dimensions of conflict—cyber-conflict, possibly genetic weapons—and may be fought through surrogates because nuclear weapons can deter full-scale collisions between major powers, yet they could still be enormously costly in material and human wellbeing.

    “the wars that happen won't be the exactly same as those or even closely similar to the big world wars of the 20th century because we'll have new dimensions of conflict--cyber-conflict, possibly genetic weapons... nuclear weapons may prevent some of the full-scale collisions between major powers... So, there might be surrogates in Syria”

0.61

Intellectuals uncritically absorb the conventional morality of their era and mistake it for timeless truth, bearing special responsibility for lending prestige to prejudice.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Following Nietzsche's observation about Christians, atheists always believe what is the conventional view of their time in ethics and politics with a slight inflection, so Gray can easily imagine the brightest atheists of 30 or 40 years hence being racists, just as they were a hundred years ago—it is chance, not insight, that gives them their morality.

    “Atheists are exactly the same. They always believe what is the conventional view of their time... I can easily imagine, 30 or 40 years hence, I can imagine the worst kinds of racism coming back. And I can imagine the brightest atheists of the time being racist. Just as they were a hundred years ago. So, it's chance.”

  • It is very hard to be free of one's time even while believing one is; intellectuals like Voltaire and Hegel bear larger responsibility than ordinary people because they gave intellectual prestige, rationality and authority to the prejudices and errors of their age while claiming to be the moral and intellectual leaders of humanity.

    “when... atheist and agnostic and other enlightened thinkers defended atheism, they gave it an intellectual prestige that it didn't have among ordinary people... they are giving dignity--they are giving rationality. They are giving authority to prejudices and errors that were strong at the time. And they are claiming to be... the leaders: Intellectual and moral leaders of humanity. So I think they bear a larger responsibility”

  • Historically most atheists in modern Western atheism have not been liberals but anti-liberals—racists, Bolsheviks, Nietzscheans—so present-day atheists deserve no credit for picking a good liberal morality; they simply absorbed the one they grew up with, as illustrated by Ayn Rand's exaltation of egoism, Comte's invention of altruism, and Julian Huxley's racist writings that reversed only when the consequences became evident.

    “Historically speaking, most atheists in the history of modern Western atheism have not been liberals. They've been anti-liberals. Most. So... I don't give them any credit for picking a good morality. Because it's simply the one they grew up with and they never thought about it.”

  • Atheists who ask whether morality is possible without God assume the morality of liberalism—itself inherited from Jewish and Christian monotheism—and mistake their particular, time-bound morality for morality itself, just as atheists in 1900 took racist morality for granted.

    “atheists who say that: Are we going to have morality without religion? They assume the morality of liberalism broadly, liberalism which in many ways is inherited from aspects of Jewish and Christian monotheism. That's what a atheists today assume... If you went back to 1900... you'd find most atheists at that time held to a version of morality in which white people were superior to black people.”

0.61

Myths and meaning-making practices are indispensable to human life; religions and myths cannot be abolished and can serve good ends as antidotes to credulity.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The Biblical Genesis story of Adam and Eve was never meant as an early theory of how life arose; this is documented by Jewish thinkers before Christianity and by Augustine within it, so the tradition of reading these stories allegorically rather than literally goes back well over 2000 years.

    “the Biblical Genesis myth, the myth that Adam and Eve and the Garden of Eden and so on--which never meant as an early theory of how life came about on this planet... you can go back an awful long way in the history of Christianity; and before Christianity are Jewish thinkers, who completely explicitly say that that Genesis myth is not to be read literally. Augustine, within the Christian tradition, quite explicitly”

  • Myths (what Roberts called allegories) are indispensable in human life, and the idea that we can do without them is itself a myth; only people unaware of the myths they live by claim myths can be abolished, but there can be good and bad, shallow and poisonous myths—the latter being those that demonize a section of humanity.

    “Myths are indispensable in human life... The idea that we can do without them is itself a myth. Only people who aren't aware of the myths they are living by tell you that myths can be abolished. But there can be good myths and bad myths.”

  • Although Gray is himself an atheist, he thinks the idea of a God who can be perfect in ways we can never understand is a very useful and valuable myth, because it captures the truth—found in the best forms of Christianity, Judaism and other religions—that humans do not and cannot have a clear conception of perfection.

    “although I am myself an atheist, I think the idea of a God that can be perfect in ways that we cannot ever understand, is actually a very useful and valuable myth.”

  • The belief that religion will wither because science has shown it to be wrong is itself a form of credulity; religions are useful now precisely as antidotes to credulity.

    “I think that's a form of credulity. I think religions are useful now. Antidotes to credulity.”

0.57

No gains in ethics or politics are permanent; technological disruption brings unforeseen harms, and liberal economies require intelligent constraint, not pure central planning.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Before British colonialism, India's level of production and consumption was incomparably higher than a hundred years later; India was one of the world's two great economic centers and that economy shrank under colonial rule, even though Gray rejects the view that Western prosperity depended on colonialism.

    “it's a fact that before British colonialism in India, the level of production and level of production and consumption in India was incomparably higher than it was 100 years later. So, India was kind of one of the two great centers of the world economy... And that shrank.”

  • Central planning does not and never will work, for the reasons Hayek explained, not even when done by computers, and it also has many costs in human freedom; the goal should instead be some intelligent form of capitalism.

    “central planning for reasons that Hayek explained doesn't and never will work, not even when it is by computers, and it also has many costs in human freedom. But if capitalism, Western capitalism in its present form, goes into deeper difficulty”

  • There are no permanent victories in ethics and politics—literally none; Gray attacked Fukuyama's view from October 1989 that the defeat of Communism was a permanent victory, and the present revival of illusions about Communism among 'golden youth' confirms that such gains are always reversible.

    “I attacked the Fukuyama view that this is a victory and it's permanent victory. There are no permanent victories in ethics and politics. None. Literally, none.”

  • Contrary to a purely Hayekian view, wartime rationing in Britain worked: despite black markets and blurred edges, it raised nutrition for poorer parts of society so that deficiency diseases like rickets, previously widespread, largely disappeared—though this does not mean an economy can be organized on a wartime basis forever.

    “Rationing during that war--we can't organize the whole economy forever on the basis of a war, wartime basis. That's true. But that time rationing worked... diseases of deficiency, nutrition diseases like rickets which had been absolutely widespread throughout Britain beforehand pretty well disappeared as a consequence of the war.”

  • The growth of modern capitalism is not dependent on Adam Smith's ideas; Roberts and Gray disagree here, with Roberts holding that price-mediated exchange and property rights had a positive impact on human wellbeing and Gray skeptical that the rise of capitalism turned on those ideas.

    “Well, I don't think that the growth of modern capitalism is dependent on those ideas.”

  • When the internet entered everyday life Gray predicted it would abolish privacy or make it much harder to achieve, turning privacy into a luxury good of the rich, and encourage living in a virtual world with less care for the human world—though he did not anticipate the virulence and rancor of Twitter.

    “one of the things that this might do, up to 10 or 15 years ago, is abolish privacy or make it much more difficult to achieve: Privacy will become a luxury good of the rich... It will encourage living in a virtual world and less caring about the human world. I did not anticipate the virulence and rancor of Twitter debate”

0.56

Evils vanish only in name; repression, torture, slavery, and anti-Semitism resurface under new labels, and ideas like protectionism return despite refutation.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Bad ideas and practices do not slowly disappear through gradual evolution; evils thought safely consigned to the past return, usually relabeled—torture as 'enhanced interrogation,' slavery as 'human trafficking' or 'forced labor' or 'Socialist construction'—as shown by the reappearance of torture in the Iraq War and of high-level anti-Semitism in Europe.

    “these evils come back, but they're called--slightly different form--but they're normally called something else. So, torture was called enhanced interrogation. Slavery is called human trafficking. A system of slavery is called Socialist construction... bad ideas and bad practices don't slowly disappear in a process of gradual evolution”

  • Because human nature does not change, economic policies based on sheer fallacies will be re-adopted; protectionism—the idea whose theoretical foundations have been most comprehensively destroyed by economists—has returned as policy and is already having damaging effects, with the world's largest economy now risking a trade war.

    “Protectionism is one of the ideas that we most comprehensively--that the theoretical foundations of which have been most comprehensively destroyed, and by economists and by others. But it's back at least as a set of proposals... certainly already have some damaging effects.”

  • Contrary to the confident claim of nearly all Western progressive thinkers that large-scale serious repression in the Soviet Union began only under Stalin, it began the moment the Bolsheviks took power under Lenin—a fact extensively documented from émigré reports at the time and from archives after the Soviet collapse, which the Western progressive Left has never wanted to know.

    “Nearly all Western Progressive thinkers... would tell you, confidently, that large-scale serious repression began in the Soviet Union only under Stalin... It didn't. It began the moment the Bolsheviks took power under Lenin. And that can be extensively documented; and has been.”

0.47

Deep human flourishing requires long-term commitment to practices, relationships, and callings, not treating life as experimental projects to be abandoned.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Treating life as a series of experiments in living to be scrapped when they don't work—as Mill and Rawls's rational life plan suggest—turns life into a series of uninteresting short stories rather than a deep human life, which can only come from committing oneself deeply and continuously to certain practices such as a religion, art, craft, or relationships.

    “what John Stuart Mill... wanted to create our lives: he said we should have experiments of living... I think that's a very bad idea, actually, because if we treat our lives as an experiment... I think that's a kind of way of life which will--you turn your life into a series of not-very-interesting short stories rather than being a deep human life. Which can only come from committing yourself rather deeply in daily practice to certain things”

  • Joseph Conrad exemplifies the admirable type of atheism: a strong atheist who sought no surrogate for religious meaning and had few expectations of human progress, yet lived a creative, adventurous, productive life and believed humans show their true mettle—grace, courage, integrity—precisely when confronting situations that have no solution, such as a sinking ship, rather than relying on future technological salvation.

    “Conrad's lack of belief in progress is central to his atheism... he thought that human beings were at their most admirable when they confronted situations that had no solution. I mean, if you are in a ship that could go under, everything depends on your skill and courage... That's what matters, not how people may or may not be 200 years time when technology has produced ships that don't sink”

  • All the means human beings have invented—religions, therapies, arts, fiction, music, and social practices—can enable people to improve themselves and become more of what they want to be, and to some extent it can work.

    “all of the means that human beings have invented in the course of their history, which might include not only religions and therapies... but also arts-- fiction, novels, music. All kinds of social and other practices can enable people to improve themselves and become more of what they want to be. I think that's just a fact... and to some extent, it can work.”

  • Conrad said that when he went to the Belgian Congo he was a mere animal and when he left he was a human being, because witnessing its horrors—and that the Belgian King called his private rule there a civilizing mission—destroyed the last vestiges of his faith in European progress and made him a real human being shorn of civilized illusions.

    “he visited the Belgian Congo, as a sailor, during its worst period; and witnessed it. And he said it changed him forever... He said that when he went to the Belgian Congo, he was a mere animal, and when he left he was a human being... he arrived with all the illusions of civilized human beings; they were destroyed and he became a real human being, when he left without those illusions.”

0.47

Self-knowledge and self-realization are largely illusory; humans misunderstand themselves and their motives, and most cannot improve themselves without basic stability.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The very idea of personal self-improvement presupposes living in one of the comparatively rare periods of history with enough stability and basic decency for one's actions to shape one's life; for most people self-improvement is impossible if their lives are liable to be cut short by arbitrary arrest, murder, famine, or war.

    “the idea of personal self-improvement presupposes that you are living in one of those, to my mind, comparatively rare periods of human history when self-improvement is possible. Because, if self-improvement is going to be suddenly interrupted by your being arbitrarily arrested, murdered, starving in some gigantic famine, or consumed in some terrible war, you aren't going to be able to improve yourself very long, are you?”

  • The credulity of the human animal does not change, especially when the truth is difficult or painful, because there is usually little incentive to care about what is true.

    “the credulity of the human animal-- doesn't change... Well, there's not much incentive to care about what's true... Usually, especially when the truth is difficult or painful or none at all”

  • It is fortunate that humans cannot turn themselves into the people they think they want to be, because our conception of the best kind of person—and of a perfect world—is internally flawed; perfection cannot be approached because there is no such thing, and the visions of a perfect world we construct turn out to be ones we would dread to live in.

    “I'm glad that human beings cannot turn themselves into the type of human beings that they think they want to be, because if they did, they would very often if not always impoverish themselves... There's no simple form of a human life which can be imagined or which can possibly exist which is perfection; and that means you can't approach perfection because there's no such thing.”

  • The modern idea of self-realization implies there is within each of us a true self to be extracted, but this is a delusive image, because humans do not understand themselves or what leads them to act, and even people who succeed in extracting a 'true self' or who become rich often fail to flourish.

    “I'm very critical of the modern... idea of self-realization, because the modern idea of self-realization implies that there is within each of us a sort of [?]... idea of ourselves... but that's just a kind of delusive image... one of the big illusions about time is that human beings really understand themselves. I don't think any of us understands what leads us to do and not do certain things.”