Zionism
The movement, founded as a modern political project by Theodor Herzl in the 1890s, advocating the establishment of a Jewish homeland.
As defined in Zionism, the Melting Pot, and the Galveston Project (with Rachel Cockerell)
Other definitions
The movement and belief supporting a Jewish homeland and self-determination in the land of Israel.
431 - What Is Happening On College Campuses
Where it comes up · 23
- Ilan Pappé on Israel and Epstein and Why Zionism has No Moral Limits7 claims
- David Deutsch on the Pattern5 claims
- Daniel Gordis on Israel and Impossible Takes Longer5 claims
- The Match That Lit the Flame: Hannah Senesh and the Creation of Modern Israel (with Matti Friedman)4 claims
- Israel Palestine Debate4 claims
- 373 - Anti-zionism Is Antisemitism3 claims
- Trump, Israel, and the Future of Liberal Democracy — with Ezra Klein | Prof G Conversations3 claims
- Mohammed El3 claims
and 15 more
Most important claims · 10 of 56Search all claims for “Zionism” →
- Despite many idealistic strands (cultural, religious-messianic, communist, aristocratic), the unifying heart of Zionism is not nationalist identity or historical belonging but Herzl's strategic argument: that Europe's industrialization and urbanization were producing new mass imagined-community identities that would police their boundaries and expel the Jews, so a catastrophe was coming and Jews must get out regardless of their ideology.An Extraordinary Introduction to the Birth of Israel and the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Haviv Rettig Gur)
- Even in founding modern Zionism with his pamphlet The Jewish State, Herzl treated a Jewish refuge as not strictly Palestine-or-nothing, suggesting alternatives like Argentina; this openness later produced the movement's first schism between 'Ugandists' who accepted the British East Africa offer and 'pure Zionists' who insisted on Palestine.Zionism, the Melting Pot, and the Galveston Project (with Rachel Cockerell)
- The historical prominence of Jewish bankers in Europe was not due to innate Jewish financial ability but to forced occupational restriction: Jews were legally barred from other professions and land ownership, so banking became their default role, accidentally creating wealth that later funded early Zionism.Ilan Pappé on Israel and Epstein and Why Zionism has No Moral Limits
- Zionism was a minority view among Jews and was more attractive the closer one was to the pogroms—quite attractive in the Russian-speaking East but mocked among Vienna's Jews—until refugee pressure made it mainstream, exemplified by 65,000 German-speaking Jews arriving in Israel in 1935 alone versus only 50,000 total in the 40 years after 1881.An Extraordinary Introduction to the Birth of Israel and the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Haviv Rettig Gur)
- Zionism is a relatively new ideology (created in early 20th century) that is often treated as a religion nobody can question, despite many religious Jews considering it heretical.Glenn Greenwald Reveals Why the Israel Lobby Is in Full PANIC Mode
- The early Zionist revolution was, semi-figuratively, a revolt against God: traditional Talmudic Judaism held that God made a deal that the nations would not oppress Jews too much in exchange for Jews not 'hurrying the hands of time' to return to Zion; Zionism rejected this, declaring the nations had broken the deal—which is why many religious Jews considered Zionism a fundamental sin and some ultra-Orthodox remain anti-Zionist today.Daniel Gordis on Israel and Impossible Takes Longer
- Stalin had more to do with Israel's independence than Truman or the US, because the Soviets saw the British Empire as the weak point of Western containment and used the question of a Jewish state to drive a wedge between the US and Britain, destroy British power in the Middle East, and radicalize Arab opinion against the pro-British order—all of which Stalin gained from.Walter Russell Mead
- In Islamist thinking, Zionism is seen as the worst of all the indignities Islam suffered because the Jews were weak refugees—'the weakest thing that ever pushed islam back'—so overcoming the Jews and reclaiming what was lost becomes the necessary first step in Islam's return to its rightful redemptive place in history, making Hamas's war about overcoming the Jews rather than liberating Palestine or creating an independent Palestinian state.422 - Zionism Jihadism
- Judaism resists Western categories (religion, nationality, ethnicity, tribe, family) because it is pre-Western, conceived in the ancient Near East; it is best understood as a religious family that one is born into but can also join, and can only truly leave by choosing another family—so calling Israel a Jewish state does not make it a religious state the way a Christian state would be.348 - The Politics Of Antisemitism
- The Jew of October 7th was no different from the European Jew during the pogroms of the 1880s-1890s or Kishinev in 1903—butchered with no one coming to their aid—which is the existential wake-up call, because it reveals that Zionism's central promise to create a new, safe reality for the Jew was not fulfilled.From the Second Intifada to October 7th (with Daniel Gordis)