Zionism, the Melting Pot, and the Galveston Project (with Rachel Cockerell)
What this covers
Rachel Cockerell and Russ Roberts reconstruct the forgotten entanglement of Zionism, Jewish immigration, and American assimilation through the story of Cockerell's great-grandfather David Jochelman. The conversation centers on the Galveston Project, an ambitious 1907–1914 initiative to redirect Russian Jewish refugees away from overcrowded New York toward Texas, where they would disperse into small towns across the hinterland. Israel Zangwill, the acclaimed writer who partnered with Jochelman, lent his platform to the scheme while simultaneously coining the phrase "melting pot" through his 1908 play of that name. Cockerell frames the project within a larger Zionist schism: Theodor Herzl had never insisted Palestine was the only acceptable Jewish homeland, which opened the door to the Ugandists—Zionists willing to accept alternatives like British East Africa—and made the Galveston effort philosophically coherent to its supporters, even as it ultimately funneled only 10,000 immigrants instead of the millions envisioned.
The conversation ranges across how geographic and social isolation in Texas accelerated assimilation for Galveston arrivals compared to those trapped in New York's dense Yiddish-speaking enclaves, where Jewish observance could survive another generation. Cockerell describes her methodological choice to remove herself entirely from the narrative, letting primary sources—newspapers, diaries, letters—speak across time and create what amounts to a conversation between historical figures. The discussion touches on the 1903 Kishinev pogrom that galvanized American outrage, Theodore Roosevelt's zealous assimilationism, and competing visions of immigrant experience: Zangwill's rosy play against Emjo Basshe II's grittier theater depicting the promised land's failure to deliver. The speakers also entertain the Perfect Is the Enemy of the Good argument—whether a temporary refuge anywhere was more pragmatic than holding out for an impossible Palestinian state—and Cockerell's larger claim that identity and home resist sharp demarcation points, that assimilation happens gradual and invisible.
Cockerell argues that her family's scattered history—and Jewish identity more broadly—is inseparable from the forgotten currents of early Zionism, the Galveston Project, and the American melting pot, and that this story is best told by removing the author and letting primary sources speak directly.
- Removing authorial interjection and juxtaposing primary sources creates a 'time machine' that lets historical voices converse directly
- The Galveston Project diverted 10,000 Jews to Texas to avoid New York overcrowding, accelerating their assimilation
- Zionism's early schism over location (Palestine vs. alternatives like Uganda/Galveston) shaped where her family ultimately scattered
Urgent refuge need justified accepting temporary refuge anywhere over waiting for impossible ideal.
- The Ugandists were vindicated by a 'perfect is the enemy of the good' logic: at the time a modern Jewish state in Palestine was a utopian pipe dream, so a temporary refuge anywhere was urgently needed; both factions proved partly right as history unfolded.
“the Ugandists, to give them their due, they believed that the perfect is the enemy of the good. There was, at the time, seemingly no chance. It was a utopian pipe dream to think that somehow the ancient Israel homeland would become the modern state of Israel.”