An Extraordinary Introduction to the Birth of Israel and the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Haviv Rettig Gur)
What this covers
Haviv Rettig Gur, an Israeli journalist, joins Russ Roberts for a wide-ranging historical argument about how the founding of Israel and the shape of the Arab-Israeli conflict emerge from six decades of systematic European exclusion of Jews—not as an ideology or nationalist aspiration, but as a lived response to conditions that made the continent progressively uninhabitable. The conversation moves from the 1881 pogroms through the Holocaust, then forward to Palestinian resistance and the anti-colonial paradigm that structures Palestinian strategy. Gur contends that Jewish immigration patterns, the strategic core of Zionism, and Israeli behavior under attack all flow from a singular fact: unlike other refugees, Jews had nowhere else to go.
The conversation traces how bottom-up pogrom violence in Eastern Europe followed industrialization and rail networks, how American immigration quotas engineered after 1921 funneled Jews away from the West, and how Theodor Herzl's founding strategic prediction was not about national identity but about the emergence of new mass imagined communities that would police their boundaries and expel the Jews. Gur explores why the anti-colonial cost paradigm—which succeeded in Algeria—fails against Israelis whose foundational identity was forged precisely by the fact of having nowhere to retreat: terrorism meant to raise costs until a colonizer leaves instead triggers the behavior that constitutes Israeli self-preservation. The conversation also engages the demographic reality that roughly half of Israeli Jews originate from the Arab world, complicating narratives of European colonialism, and examines how Jewish history as lived by Israelis differs fundamentally from the diaspora experience of American Jews.
Gur argues that the founding of Israel and the persistence of the Arab-Israeli conflict can only be understood through the lived Jewish experience of a 60-year European campaign (1881-1948) to make the continent uninhabitable for Jews, which produced an Israeli identity immune to the anti-colonial terrorism strategy because Jews believe they have nowhere else to go.
- The Holocaust was the culmination of six decades of bottom-up and top-down European exclusion of Jews beginning with the 1881 pogroms, not an aberration starting in 1939
- Zionism's core is Herzl's strategic prediction that new mass national identities would expel Jews, not an idealistic nationalism
- Palestinian strategy copies the Algerian anti-colonial model of raising costs until the colonizer leaves, which fails against Israelis who have no mother country to return to
Police states need ordinary citizens as enforcers through profit incentives to extend surveillance and control.
- A police state cannot oppress a nation through police alone because they can't be everywhere; oppression depends crucially on incentivizing everyday citizens to participate, as in the Soviet Union where neighbors profited from reporting negative remarks about Stalin, extending the eyes of the police through bottom-up incentives—and the systematic murder of six million Jews similarly required the cooperation of local citizens.
“A police state can't really thrive by having the police everywhere. They just can't be everywhere... They rely, crucially, tragically, on incentivizing everyday citizens to be part of the authoritarian state, the police state.”
Jews remained in America despite hardship because they were fleeing persecution with no viable alternative.
- Between 1908 and 1925, large fractions of immigrants returned to their home countries (57% of Italians, 40% of Poles, 64% of Hungarians, 67% of Romanians, 55% of Russians), but only 5% of Jews returned—because other immigrants were seeking a better life while the Jews were running away and had nowhere better to return to, even when America was harsh.
“57% of Italians, 40% of Poles, 64% of Hungarians, 67% of Romanians, and 55% of Russians. Among the Jews, the figure was just 5%.”
Palestine was a geographic territory under British Mandate, not a prior nation-state.
- There has never been a country called Palestine in world history—only a geographic area; in the 1940s 'Palestine' meant the territory the British controlled under Mandate after taking it from the Ottoman Empire following World War I, which the Zionist movement eventually focused on as its destination.
“There is no country called Palestine in world history. There is a landscape, an area called Palestine... Palestine meant the land that the British controlled in the aftermath of World War I.”
Decolonization often involves violence, though nonviolent alternatives like India's independence exist.
- There is an alternative to anti-colonial terrorism—the nonviolent strategy India followed to gain independence from British rule—though decolonization usually involves some violence, as America's own 1776 war for independence illustrates.
“There is an alternative, by the way, which is the nonviolent strategy that India followed in liberating itself from colonial rule and other places. But it usually takes some kind of violence.”