Veil of Ignorance
A thought experiment in which one chooses social arrangements without knowing what position one will occupy in the resulting society, used to test the fairness of institutions
As defined in Michael Munger on Slavery and Racism
Other definitions
John Rawls's thought experiment in which principles of justice are chosen without knowing one's own position (race, sex, wealth) in society; Goldberg uses it to argue one would choose to be born in the present day in America.
Jonah Goldberg on The Suicide of the West
Where it comes up · 15
- Michael Munger on Slavery and Racism3 claims
- A Theory of Justice: Bibliotheca Webinar3 claims
- David Schmidtz on Rawls, Nozick, and Justice2 claims
- Tyler Cowen on Big Business2 claims
- Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler1 claim
- Richard Epstein on Cruises, First-Class Travel, and Inequality1 claim
- Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee1 claim
- Jonah Goldberg on The Suicide of the West1 claim
and 7 more
Most important claims · 10 of 21Search all claims for “Veil of Ignorance” →
- The veil of ignorance—asking whether you would endorse an arrangement if you didn't know your position in society—functions as a challenge to persuasion, and Montesquieu anticipated it in 1748 regarding slavery by asking whether advocates would still endorse slavery if, upon leaving a room, some of them would become slaves; it problematizes conventions we accept merely as tradition.Michael Munger on Slavery and Racism
- John Rawls's veil of ignorance—the principle that a just world should be organized from the perspective of not knowing where one will end up in the genetic or geographic lottery—provides a compelling framework for thinking about why the privileged should give back.Bill Ackman: Dealing with Haters, My Largest Trade Ever, and Sounding the Alarm for the Government
- Rawls's Veil of Ignorance asks people to decide distributive questions as if they don't know who they are—not knowing their talents, risk tolerance, or social position—so that decisions about what someone like Russ Roberts should get are made impartially rather than self-servingly.David Schmidtz on Rawls, Nozick, and Justice
- Smith's impartial spectator is a heuristic for judging whether a contemplated action is right. You ask whether a person who knows everything about you and your situation that you know, but has no stake in the outcome, would approve. Unlike Rawls's veil of ignorance, the spectator is fully informed rather than ignorant. Smith also calls it 'the man within the breast' and 'the vicegerent of God upon earth'.James Otteson on Adam Smith 06/27/2011
- John Rawls held that to judge whether a moral act is acceptable you must not know who the actor and recipient are, because the moment you or someone reminding you of you is involved, consciously or otherwise, bias contaminates the judgment.134 | Robert Sapolsky on Why We Behave the Way We Do
- While we are rightly partial to our own children, that bias cannot be mapped onto society at large; the ethical person in extremis retains awareness that others' children matter as much to them as his does to him, and when designing laws and institutions we hold onto a 'view from nowhere' and 'veil of ignorance' that yields fair systems — such as hospital triage that may work to one's own disadvantage — which is the only system that is genuinely ethical.99 - What Happened To Liberalism
- The Veil of Ignorance is a thought-experiment about our actual world, not a different one; it asks us to imagine viewing our world impartially while still knowing general facts of economics, sociology, and psychology, but not the particular facts that determine our own payoff.David Schmidtz on Rawls, Nozick, and Justice
- We can usually rely on Smith's impartial spectator, but because Southern elites managed to persuade their impartial spectator that slavery was acceptable by avoiding the logic of the veil of ignorance, the veil—asking what if I occupied the position of people I have little contact with—serves as an occasional abstract check on our self-serving moral conclusions that we are all capable of evading.Michael Munger on Slavery and Racism
- Using Rawls's Veil of Ignorance, one cannot know one's place in the future income distribution under AI displacement; framing it concretely, if your brother (a cab or truck driver) will likely be unemployable in 5-10 years, the BIG question is whether you would simply give him $18,000-24,000 a year so he need not worry—Roberts uses this to probe whether cash is really the right form of help.Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee
- The principle of office and position should be open to all talented individuals regardless of background, ensuring there is no exclusive political caste and allowing all those with capability to develop their talents and influence political life.A Theory of Justice: Bibliotheca Webinar