What this covers

Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler Cowen on the case for treating sustainable economic growth as a primary moral imperative. Cowen argues that if future well-being is not discounted over time, the compounding returns of economic growth dominate nearly all other policy concerns—redistribution, inequality, and most specific causes fade in importance relative to the exponential value that growth generates across centuries. The conversation pivots through philosophy, economics, and history to build this case, moving from the math of Zero Discount Rate on Welfare to concrete examples like how a one-percentage-point growth slowdown in the medieval period would have consigned all of us to poverty and early death.

The discussion spans several contentious claims. Cowen contends that standard discount rate conventions used in finance—commonly 5–7 percent—are irrational when applied to all of society and the far future, since they treat the survival of civilization centuries hence as worthless relative to immediate cash flows. He argues that growth and stability usually reinforce each other rather than conflict, and uses the Soviet experience under Stalin as a case where rapid industrialization, despite its moral horrors, generated net historical good by enabling resistance to Nazi Germany and improving lives through urbanization and education. He also tackles Derek Parfit's Nonidentity Problem—the puzzle that harms to future people may not count as wrongs if those people wouldn't have existed otherwise—by pivoting to aggregate welfare across generations rather than person-specific harms. On the downside, Cowen notes that catastrophic tail risks like civilization-ending war persist over long timescales, and that societies often panic and overreact in emergencies, which compounds the difficulty of sustaining growth itself.

Sharpest takeaway

Cowen argues that maximizing the rate of sustainable economic growth is the closest thing to an objective moral imperative, because a zero discount rate on future well-being makes the compounding value of growth dominate other concerns like redistribution—subject only to a caveat respecting human rights.

  • If we don't discount future well-being, compounding economic growth (a 'Crusonia plant') generates overwhelmingly large value over time
  • Growth and civilizational stability usually come together rather than conflict (e.g., national defense, environmental cleanup)
  • Aggregating welfare across people and generations is unavoidable and the consequentialist case for growth is hard to escape, though deontological rights set outer bounds

The argument · threads1 threads · 81 claims
0.85

Stable totalitarianism enabled by surveillance technology could permanently lock in bad moral values and destroy future potential.

1 pointcentrality 5/5
  • A negative global totalitarianism enabled by surveillance technology is a major worry not because it is destabilizing but because it could be very stable yet bad—locking in negative or neutral moral values such that most of the potential value of the future is permanently lost.

    “The problem is it would be very stable, but bad. We would still lose most of the value because, perhaps, we’ve locked in a bunch of negative or neutral moral values.”