Resource Curse
The paradox whereby countries rich in natural resources often experience worse economic and political outcomes than resource-poor countries.
As defined in Edward Glaeser and David Cutler
Other definitions
The phenomenon whereby countries rich in natural resources (especially oil) tend to experience worse economic, political, and social outcomes than resource-poor countries, often becoming less free, less peaceful, and more corrupt.
Leif Wenar on Blood OilThe observation that countries rich in natural resources, such as minerals, often have weaker institutions and development than resource-poor countries, because rents encourage extraction over productive enterprise.
William Bernstein on the History of Trade 04/28/2008
Where it comes up · 10
- Leif Wenar on Blood Oil6 claims
- Edward Glaeser and David Cutler2 claims
- Jeffrey Sachs2 claims
- John Nye2 claims
- Kareem Abdul-Jabbar2 claims
- Robot Plumbers, Robot Armies, and Our Imminent A.I. Future | Interesting Times with Ross Douthat2 claims
- Lars Doucet — Progress, poverty, Georgism, & why rent is too damn high1 claim
- 469 - Escaping An Anti-human Future1 claim
and 2 more
Most important claims · 10 of 20Search all claims for “Resource Curse” →
- By analogy to the resource curse (where governments earning most GDP from extracted resources stop investing in or being accountable to their people), the 'intelligence curse' arises when much of a nation's GDP comes from AI: companies no longer need humans for labor, governments no longer need them for tax revenue, so people lose both economic value and political power—guaranteeing an anti-human future of new cancer drugs alongside mass disempowerment and a handful of trillionaires, unless we deliberately build an 'intelligence dividend' like Norway's sovereign wealth fund or Alaska's dividend.469 - Escaping An Anti-human Future
- Abundant natural resources can be harmful: a valuable resource that can be funneled to political allies tends to produce bad government and violence, as in Nigeria, so bad government rather than resource endowment is the major determinant of national wealth.Thomas Sowell on Economic Facts and Fallacies 02/25/2008
- The decisive factor in whether resource wealth helps or harms a country is whether the government is accountable to the people: accountable governments (like Norway's) are forced to use the money for public goods and savings, whereas unaccountable rulers use it to rule without accountability and oppress, and rebel groups use it to buy weapons and cause chaos.Leif Wenar on Blood Oil
- A severance tax is a tax on the extraction of non-renewable natural resources; Norway's heavy severance tax on oil is a key reason it avoided the resource curse, and similar logic implies companies like Nestle should pay a severance tax on water they enclose since they only add value by bottling a pre-existing common resource.Lars Doucet — Progress, poverty, Georgism, & why rent is too damn high
- Natural resources are special and genuinely cursed because they are highly concentrated sources of economic value that, when controlled by authoritarians or armed groups, do not make people richer or freer but tend to stimulate civil war and sometimes wars between countries—unlike ordinary trade in goods.Leif Wenar on Blood Oil
- Russia's economic prospects are correctly rated as poor because of two problems: the well-known resource curse from abundant oil and gas, and the under-discussed imperative of holding together a gigantic multi-ethnic land empire and guarding its borders, which overwhelms incentives to promote internal growth and development—evidenced by Russia's deliberate failure to develop Vladivostok and the Far East as it has Moscow and St. Petersburg.John Nye
- While we should fight against distributing rents to particular localities (it was good that Rio stopped being Brazil's capital), there is nothing normative about Zipf's law: social scientists have no way to know whether New York is 'too big' or Chicago should be '30 percent larger,' so we should resist any urge to micromanage the locations of firms and individuals through national spatial policy.Edward Glaeser and David Cutler
- The trouble Muslim-majority states have separating religion from the state is not a tension in Islamic doctrine but a function of wealth distribution—rulers in oil- and mineral-rich countries care about keeping control of the wealth rather than morality or law, with ruling cliques monopolizing goods, services, and resources.Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
- Tunisia is the only Arab Spring country that made a real transition to democracy, and notably it does not have a lot of oil—suggesting that the absence of resource wealth removes the incentive for elites to plot against each other and hold power, unlike oil-rich Libya next door.Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
- Many of the major international threats and crises of recent decades—ISIS, Assad's barrel bombs, Putin's interventions, Gaddafi, Saddam, Al Qaeda, Saudi-spread extremism, Iranian terrorism, the Soviet threat—all originate from states that export oil, which is a central feature of the Resource Curse.Leif Wenar on Blood Oil