
Thomas Sowell on Economic Facts and Fallacies 02/25/2008
What this covers
Russ Roberts talks with Thomas Sowell about Economic Facts and Fallacies, taking popular beliefs one at a time and testing each against data. The opening stretch is about measurement. Household income suggests stagnation, but households have shrunk, so Sowell points to per capita income, which rose 51 percent over roughly thirty years while average household income rose about 6 percent. Roberts adds the question he treats as the core of economics, "and then what," and the two apply it to minimum wages and to pressure on multinationals.
The middle of the conversation covers why nations are rich or poor. Sowell argues that natural resources explain little. He contrasts Venezuela and Uruguay with Japan and Switzerland, and Saudi Arabia with Singapore. He also holds that a "resource" is a product of human knowledge, and that valuable resources can produce bad government, as in Nigeria. He takes apart Lenin's theory of imperialism by breaking its aggregates into parts: investment flowed more to the United States than to the whole British Empire. He also rejects Malthus-style overpopulation arguments.
The most contested material concerns group disparities. Sowell argues that the male-female earnings gap largely reflects career interruptions, and he cites the mirror-image relationship between marriage age and women's professional share. He says black-white comparisons that omit Asian Americans prove too much, and that family structure drives aggregate poverty rates. The discussion also covers CEO pay, wages at Nike factories, immigration and assimilation in the United States versus Europe, and why economists' lessons about trade-offs lose elections to promises of free lunches.
Sowell argues that most popular economic fallacies (stagnant living standards, group disparities, colonial exploitation, sweatshops, CEO pay) come from comparing unlike things, ignoring alternatives, and assuming third-party planners with less knowledge can make better decisions than those who have experience and a stake.
- Per-capita and consumption measures reveal rising living standards that household-income statistics hide because household composition has changed
- Critics fail to ask 'and then what' and compare outcomes against the realistic alternatives people actually face
- Dispersed local knowledge and personal stakes make decentralized decisions superior to centralized ones made by intellectuals or policymakers
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Intellectuals wrongly assume they know more than other people, but the knowledge that matters includes local, practical knowledge such as the location of a store: McDonald's and Walmart invest heavily in site selection because such knowledge has large economic consequences.
“just knowing what a particular location is like can be worth millions of dollars big companies like all McDonald's is one a and P during its heyday and I suspect Walmart today”
Abundant natural resources can be harmful: a valuable resource that can be funneled to political allies tends to produce bad government and violence, as in Nigeria, so bad government rather than resource endowment is the major determinant of national wealth.
“if you have a big prize like a natural resource that you can funnel to your friends you tend to get bad government”
Economics is hard to absorb not only because it is technically difficult but because people do not want to learn its lessons: politicians win elections promising free lunches, while economists' messages about trade-offs are emotionally unsatisfying.
“economist a constantly saying there's no free lunch but politicians keep getting elected by promising free lunch”
Natural resources do not explain national wealth: Venezuela and Uruguay have more natural resources per capita than Japan or Switzerland yet far lower per-capita income, and Saudi Arabia, the leading oil producer, has roughly half Singapore's per-capita income even though Singapore imports its drinking water from Malaysia.
“the natural resources per capita there is higher than in Japan or Switzerland and yet the per capita income in Japan is Switzerland is some multiple of what it is at work why”
A natural resource is not an objectively given thing but a function of human knowledge: uranium and waterfalls were not resources until people found uses for them, and crude oil was 'a stinky gross substance' until refining was developed.
“what we call a natural resource is not some objectively given thing it's what it's what people know how to use”
Lenin's imperialism argument, that Western industrial prosperity came from exploiting poor countries through investment, is unsupported: the British Empire invested more in the United States than in the entire empire, and the United States remains the country where most foreigners invest, while Western investment in Africa is minimal compared with Canada or Western Europe.
“at the height of the British Empire they invested more in the United States and they invested in the whole British Empire”
Lenin's theory of imperialism relied on aggregating heterogeneous categories like the entire Western Hemisphere; when broken down, investment flowed more to the United States than to the rest of the Western Hemisphere, and at the height of the British Empire more to the US than to the whole British Empire.
“at the height of the British Empire they invested more in the United States and they invested in the whole British Empire”
Cultural differences between groups predate modern group comparisons: white Southerners and white Northerners differed in literacy and violence rates before the Civil War, and features now attributed to Black Americans, including Black English, were already present among Southern whites and their British ancestors.
“white Southerners and white northerners had very large differences in things like literacy violence rates of illegitimately at century”
Economic knowledge is dispersed among hundreds of millions of people; if you transfer decisions from ordinary people to elites, you move decisions from where the knowledge is to where it is less, producing more presumption and worse outcomes, as in the Soviet economy.
“if you transfer a decision-making from the people from the ordinary person to these elites you're transferring the knowledge you transferring the decision from where there's more knowledge to where there's less knowledge but more presumption”
The zero-sum fallacy, the belief that one person's gain must come at another's expense, drives hostility to corporate profits and CEO pay, as in the mistaken view that a pilot's salary exploits passengers.
“the zero-sum fallacy that anybody getting ahead must be coming at someone's expense”
Anti-discrimination laws do not explain the progress of women or Black Americans: women's economic gains tracked the age of first marriage and childbearing, with women's professional share rising mid-century as marriage age rose, and gains in the early 20th century occurred before such laws.
“it has very little correlation with affirmative action or with anti-discrimination laws”
Household income statistics wrongly suggest stagnation because households have shrunk over time and differ in size across income brackets, while per-capita income rose 51 percent over about 30 years even though average household income rose only about 6 percent.
“the average household income in the United States only rose by about six percent but over that very same through the time the per capita income rose by fifty one percent”
Black-white comparisons that leave out Asian Americans collapse under scrutiny: whites get conventional mortgages more often than Asians, use subprime loans less, and are laid off less in downturns, so accepting racial disparity as proof of discrimination would imply white employers and lenders discriminate against whites.
“if you included the data on asian-americans would really make the case collapsed like a house of cards in a lot of cases”
Low wages paid by multinational firms like Nike in poor countries do not impoverish workers: multinational operations pay about twice the local wage rate, and workers take these jobs because they are better than their alternatives.
“the multinational operations tend to pay about twice what the local wage rate happens to be”
Family structure drives the aggregate poverty rate: poverty falls within every family type, but the share of single-mother families rises sharply, so the overall poverty rate stays flat; the poverty rate for Black married couples has been in single digits since 1994, while Black single-mother households have high poverty.
“the problem is is that the proportion of all families that are single women with kids explodes over that period and as a result the overall poverty rate basically stays flat”
Occupational segregation by sex may reflect free choices rather than discrimination: women who expect career interruptions rationally avoid fields like law or technology where skills depreciate quickly, while the predictability and hours of work also shape which occupations they pick.
“what we observe as some something that looks like occupational segregation which has a pejorative sound to it need not be majority of it could merely be the choices that people make freely”
Shareholders and boards have strong incentives to pay CEOs no more than necessary when the money is theirs, but where boards spend other people's money, pay is less disciplined; CEO pay is highest where a few large financial institutions own the company and spend their own money.
“the pay of CEOs is the highest in those places where small numbers of financial institutions are deciding what to pay and are spending their own money”
Most of the male-female earnings gap is explained by differences in experience patterns, because women take years out of the labor force for childbearing; when women have comparable education, field, and consecutive employment, there is very little income difference.
“there's really very little income difference today between men and women who are comparable and across the law the whole range of things that matter”
The United States assimilated immigrants for 250 years because its constitution limited the ability of groups to use political power destructively, while Europe's political system is not robust enough to absorb guest workers with hostile attitudes.
“we had a constitution that limited the ability of groups to use political power in destructive ways voting blocs to be destructive in various ways”
Group comparisons of income (by race, sex, or other categories) are misleading because there was never reason to expect groups to have equal outcomes; age alone differs by about a decade between groups, and experience accounts for much of the income gap.
“one of the simplest differences among groups age group groups and the United States and in other countries around the world often differ from each other by up by a whole decade in age and income varies enormously by age”
Dependency theory and similar exploitation theories faded by the end of the 20th century because very poor places such as Hong Kong, Singapore, and South Korea became prosperous by opening to Western investment, and sub-Saharan Africa received little US investment compared with Canada or Western Europe.
“once very poor places like Hong Kong and Singapore South Korea suddenly have become very prosperous and they did it by opening up to investment from the West”
The essence of economics is asking 'and then what': a policy like a minimum wage or pressure on multinationals may help some workers but must be evaluated for its downstream consequences and the alternatives forced on others.
“the essence of economics is asking and then what”
Overpopulation is not a source of world poverty, because no country has been more prosperous when its population was half what it is today; the Malthusian prediction was not even true in Malthus's time and was defended by redefinitions.
“name me a country whose prosperity was greater when their population was half of what it is today”
Common accounts of women's progress begin in the 1960s, which hides that women's share of professional occupations was higher in the early twentieth century, fell as marriage and childbearing ages dropped, and then rose again in the mid-1950s as marriage ages rose, producing almost mirror-image graphs of marriage age and women's professional share.
“the people who are the other way avoid all that by the simple practice of starting their discussion in the 1960s as if the world were created in 1960s”
Income quintiles are misleading because they are equal shares of households, not equal shares of people: the bottom 20 percent of households contains far more people than the top 20 percent would suggest, so comparing the standard of living of quintile groups treats statistical categories as if they were equal-sized populations.
“they live the tendency to look at statistical categories as if you're talking about flesh-and-blood human beings”
Consumption is a better measure of living standards than income, and consumption has risen by a very substantial amount over the past several decades, so claims that the average American's standard of living is no higher than 35 years ago are false.
“if you look just at the consumption figures that's the easiest way that the consumption is going up by a very substantial amount over the whole period”
Intellectuals favor centralized decision-making partly for self-interested reasons: as Hayek argued, people with high IQs who favor socialism expect to gain power in those systems, an early public-choice argument.
“his explanation for why intellectuals were more likely to be socialists than capitalists was a purely self-interested one”
Price indexes understate real income growth because new commodities such as video cassette recorders are extremely expensive when introduced, so they are omitted from price baskets until after their prices have fallen, and their decline is never counted; VCRs debuted near $30,000 and later sold for a couple hundred dollars.
“the classic example I think would be video cassette recorders which I think debuted at about 30,000 dollars a piece and now you can get them for a couple hundred”
Black poverty declined sharply before the civil rights laws: the poverty rate of Black Americans fell from 87 percent in 1942 to 47 percent in 1960, and the downward trend continued through the 1960s without acceleration after civil rights legislation.
“the percentage of blacks who were in poverty declined from 87 percent back in 1942 thirty to a forty seven percent in 1960 and that was before they were civil rights laws of any consequence”
Colonialism-based theories of world poverty are an ideological triumph over facts: the poorest places are typically those the West paid little or no attention to, and the evidence contradicts exploitation theories.
“it's really uh it's a triumph I think of ideology over facts that it almost any factual assessment of situation would make this argument collapse like a house of cards”
The standard of living of the average American has risen substantially over the past 35 years, as shown by consumption figures, which keep climbing over the whole period.
“if you look just at the consumption figures that's the easiest way that the consumption is going up by a very substantial amount over the whole period”
Higher material standards are not evidence of debt-driven prosperity in most cases; people always want more than they can afford because desires exceed means, and as a result people could work about two-thirds as hard as they do now and still live as well as they did fifty years ago, but they choose to live better instead.
“we could work about 2/3 as hard as we work now and live as well as we did fifty years ago but people evidently don't want to live that well they want to live a lot better”
Perhaps the most fallacious assumption is that third parties with neither experience nor expertise can make better decisions from emotional reactions than those with both experience, expertise, and a stake in the results.
“perhaps the most fallacious assumption of all is that third parties with neither experience or expertise can make better decisions on the basis of their emotional reactions”
Pay for CEOs is not set by a central authority: it depends on how many people buy a firm's products, and anyone who wants a different distribution would need to openly argue for replacing market determination with politicians deciding how much everyone is worth.
“how much I'm paid is determined by how many people buy my books how many people read my columns”
Belief that the economic system is deliberately designed to produce particular outcomes is a fallacy: policymakers tinker with pieces of the system, but no one intends the aggregate outcome, and this error drives calls to re-tinker the system for fairness.
“the system is designed which isn't true but it has pieces that are tinkered with by policymakers and therefore because there's tinkering the outcomes must be intended by someone”
The word 'distribution' in 'distribution of income' is misleading because income is not distributed by any central agent; it is earned through voluntary exchange, with each person's pay determined by those they serve, who are best placed to judge its worth to them.
“in most income isn't distributed in the first place but what it does it allows people to act as if society quote-unquote is in the act of distributing income”
Anti-sweatshop campaigns ignore alternatives: workers in poor countries pay bribes to get multinational jobs because they are desirable relative to what is available, so the relevant comparison is to the workers' actual alternatives, not Western wages.
“people in these countries in point of fact often pay a month salary to somebody on the inside who can get them a job because the jobs are that desirable given their alternatives”
Central planning is the government suppression of other people's plans by imposing a collective plan created by third parties armed with government power and exempted from paying the costs their plans impose on others, and this is what political rhetoric calls 'planning'.
“what is called planning in political rhetoric is the government suppression of other people's plans by superimposing on them a collective plan created by third parties armed with the power of government and exempted from paying the cost”
The claim that prosperity came from debt is wrong, though debts must eventually be repaid or lenders stop extending credit, and people overextend themselves; the real driver is that human desires always exceed what can be afforded.
“our desires are always greater than what we can afford and so by our human nature we tend to struggle to get by”
Complaints that people cannot make ends meet are mostly a matter of personal choice about what standard counts as 'meeting needs'; people two generations ago could not have lived at today's level without both parents and children working.
“it's trying to treat as a an objective fact well what is nothing more than a personal choice”
The appeal of measured equality stems from intellectuals who have long been preoccupied with it and who spread the concern through media and education, while the general public is less concerned than intellectuals wish.
“the sweet amount of that is artificial in the sense that intellectuals have been terribly preoccupied with this for a very long time”
Some occupations demand unpredictable hours, such as a lawyer who must travel at short notice on a multibillion-dollar case or represent a client facing imminent execution, and these demands make them harder to combine with parenting, which contributes to differences in occupational choice.
“those are those are very tough things to do for a for for a mother who has children”
Cost increases at universities are actually decisions to spend more on dorms or faculty salaries, so calling them 'costs' disguises chosen spending as an uncontrollable external factor.
“you see that in colleges and universities where they say you know we have to raise the tuition because costs arisen well by cost they mean they have chosen to spend more money”
Israel has a higher standard of living than Kuwait even though Kuwait has oil and Israel does not, and the world's leading oil producers are not reliably the richest countries, which shows natural resources are neither necessary nor sufficient for prosperity.
“Israel standard of living higher than Kuwait's Israel has no oil Kuwait has oil”
CEO pay is wholly arbitrary as a moral issue: the average CEO of an S&P 500 company earned a little over $8 million a year, about one-third of what Alex Rodriguez earns, while public outrage over CEO pay is not matched by outrage over athletes' or entertainers' pay.
“the average CEO of a company is big enough to be in Standard and Poor's 500 was a little over eight million dollars a year that's about one-third less than one one-third rather of what Alex Rodriguez gets”
Years of education are a crude measure in economic analysis because two years of college in different fields are not equivalent, yet economists treat them as identical.
“we measure education so crudely usually in our statistical analyses as economists it's just years of education”
Discrimination can explain some disparities, but it must be established case by case, not assumed as a blanket explanation for group outcome differences.
“there is discrimination is one of a number of factors which which can explain differences in a particular case but of course the case that has to be the analysis has to be for that particular case”
Immigration debates are flawed because there is no such thing as 'an immigrant in general': immigrants are not homogeneous, and some, like the scientists who fled the Nazis and helped build the atomic bomb, have been worth their weight in gold.
“there's no such thing as an immigrant in general there are some immigrants who come to this country who have been worth their weight in gold”
Immigrants who work are invited guests of the employers who hire them, so the useful distinction is between people who come without working and people who work, not the 'gatecrasher' framing; the economic focus of economists can overlook immigrants hostile to a country's culture.
“for immigrants who work which is a substantial number they are invited guests by the people who employ them”
Child labor laws and minimum wage laws push children into illegal activities such as street drug sales, because legitimate jobs are removed from the market for them, while teenagers are kept out of air-conditioned office jobs.
“one of the said effects of our own child labor laws is that we have a lot of kids out there selling dope in the street because who would be able to have legitimate jobs in a free market”
Public hostility to CEOs compared with movie stars and athletes reflects that CEOs stand in the way of those who want elites to direct the economy, while entertainers do not represent a competing elite, so resentment targets corporations as obstacles to planned economies.
“corporate CEOs are among those who stand in the way of people who think that they are to be deciding what society as a whole is doing”
Illegal immigration means the host country does not choose who comes, so self-selected migrants may be the least suited to the country, and economists who focus only on economic contribution may admit people hostile to the society's culture.
“insofar as the ilegally Galla t means that we don't choose who's going to come here people people themselves decide whether they want to come here”
Political rhetoric about economic outcomes persists because people avoid asking about consequences; the economic explanations are unpleasant, so people do not want to think about them, and half of politicians' rhetoric in an election year would vanish if people asked the consequence question.
“at least half the rhetoric of politicians especially in late an election year would have to disappear into thin air people started asking what will be the actual consequence of this”
Intellectuals' verbal skill is a fatal talent because it lets them argue away realities, and moral motive (such as Che Guevara's revolutionary image) washes away the sins of communist regimes in popular opinion.
“they have an enormous virtuosity and the use of words and I think it's a fatal talent because it can keep you from facing realities”
Economists have done a poor job defending liberty because they argue in dry economic terms and fail to appeal to the deeper emotional urges people have, while politicians win by blaming evil groups for problems, as FDR blamed economic royalists for the Great Depression.
“we've done a very bad job as both economists and defenders of Liberty and couching our arguments and appealing to the deeper urges that people inevitably have”
Intellectuals' moral 'motive washes away sins': Che Guevara's reputation survives despite his record, and it is considered hip to wear communist memorabilia while Nazi regalia is taboo, showing that the stated motive of an ideology shapes how its atrocities are judged.
“it's just interesting how motive washes away a lot of sins for people”
Socialist regimes such as Cuba and the Soviet Union are judged by their intentions rather than outcomes, so failures are excused as growing pains, while the same excuse is not granted to Pinochet's Chile, showing a double standard.
“they never judge these things by their factual outcomes even as they is the Soviet Union and after that”
No one should want politicians in Washington deciding how much everyone is worth; if people want that radically different system they should openly argue why it would be better than the current market determination of income.
“if people want that radically different system I think they ought to come out openly and explain why that way of determining income would be better than what we do now”
Concern about foreign legal norms is misplaced in two directions: Americans should not make allowances for crimes that are legal in immigrants' home countries, and the idea that international law is superior to domestic law is a stereotyped notion.
“we have people who think that when someone commits a crime according to American law which would not be a crime where they come from that we should somehow make allowances for that”
Intellectuals and Americans promote the belief that all cultures are equal, which undermines any reason to protect the existing American culture against influxes of people with different attitudes.
“there's no thought that you have to protect the culture that exists here because as we multi calculus tell us all cultures are equal”
American culture is best understood as a melding of many immigrant influences, not as separate cultures; the Internet's success owes much to immigrants such as Andy Grove and Sergey Brin.
“our culture is American culture is truly multicultural not the way the multicultural is think of it which is this culture and that culture but rather a melding and mix and stew”
Sowell's books are underappreciated and underread, and something ought to be done about that.
“your books are not well well-read enough I don't think are appreciated sufficiently”
Expressing a general opinion that the episode was a good discussion of economics.
“thanks for joining us”