Pigouvian tax
A tax levied on an activity that generates negative externalities, designed to make the actor bear the social cost; Cowen jokingly applies it to Twitter photos and threads.
As defined in Patrick Collison
Where it comes up · 8
- Glenn Loury3 claims
- Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/20073 claims
- Robert Pindyck on Averting and Adapting to Climate Change2 claims
- Mike Munger on Subsidies and Externalities 05/24/20082 claims
- Richard Epstein on Happiness, Inequality, and Envy 11/3/20081 claim
- Patrick Collison1 claim
- Michael Munger on Traffic1 claim
- AMA | July 20251 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “Pigouvian tax” →
- Coase's contribution challenges the Pigouvian tax: in a world with zero transaction costs markets handle externalities by themselves and no Pigouvian taxes are needed, but Coase himself rejected that as unrealistic; the substantive part of the Coase theorem is that because transaction costs are not zero, one must be careful where to place liability, responsibility, and property rights, taking costs into account.Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/2007
- Policies like $4 gasoline to reduce driving sacrifice consumption benefits; the better approach is a consistent tax on pollution set at roughly the measured environmental damage, with the price of oil still varying with market conditions, so people consume more when the opportunity cost is low.Richard Epstein on Happiness, Inequality, and Envy 11/3/2008
- Following Coase, pricing externalities via a carbon tax is not always the right approach because it ignores the potential for adaptation to be a lower-cost way of coping with higher carbon; society may find cheaper alternatives (in true cost to human wellbeing) to reduce damage than reducing driving, so an optimal carbon tax is more complicated than economists often portray.Robert Pindyck on Averting and Adapting to Climate Change
- Economists habitually apply an almost automatic set of steps: if there is an externality, tax it; with the correct tax, the externality reaches an efficient level and the problem is considered solved.Michael Munger on Traffic
- A carbon tax is the most efficient (lowest-cost-to-society) way to reduce emissions because it prices the externality: when you burn carbon you cause damage to society, so charging you the social cost of carbon makes you pay for the damage you cause and reduces emissions by the right amount through decentralized choices rather than mandates.Robert Pindyck on Averting and Adapting to Climate Change
- Before imposing a carbon tax to correct the externality of emissions, policymakers should ask whether a cheaper alternative exists, such as sequestration or other low-cost ways of coping with climate impacts; the Coase lesson is to compare realistic alternatives rather than assume a single Pigouvian instrument is best.Mike Munger on Subsidies and Externalities 05/24/2008
- Economists should advocate first-best Pigouvian taxes even knowing the political process may distort them, because refraining from giving best advice does not remove politics from the tax process—tax policy is already politicized—so the economist's job is to give clear best advice and persuade as many people as possible.Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/2007
- Mankiw's preferred high-impact reforms, ignoring political realism, are: higher Pigouvian taxes; fundamental tax reform along the lines of the president's panel (ideally a broad-based progressive consumption tax); and a very significant but very gradual increase in the retirement age for Social Security and Medicare, on the logic that people are living longer and healthier and shouldn't go on the government dole at the same age as their grandparents.Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/2007
- Replacing income-based taxation with Pigouvian-style taxes that target what should be minimized (energy and finite-resource use) rather than what is beneficial (income) could yield benefits including radical simplification of tax collection, by aligning the tax base with discouraging harmful activity.AMA | July 2025
- Under competitive conditions without internalized environmental externalities, markets exhaust natural resources too rapidly because the initial price level is set too low; the theory holds prices rise at the rate of interest regardless, but the level is too low when external costs are unpriced.Glenn Loury