Malthusian
Describing an economy where technological gains are absorbed by population growth, keeping per-capita living standards near subsistence with high mortality and low life expectancy.
As defined in Brad DeLong
Where it comes up · 13
- Gregory Clark5 claims
- Brad DeLong4 claims
- WE049 – Decoding Energy: Power, Politics, and Personal Growth with Doomberg3 claims
- Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler2 claims
- Carl Shulman (Pt 2) — AI Takeover, bio & cyber attacks, detecting deception, & humanity's far future2 claims
- Jeffrey Brenzel: The Essential Value of a Classic Education | Big Think1 claim
- Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Altruism, History, & Technology1 claim
- Peter Thiel on 'Anti-Anti-Anti-Anti Classical Liberalism' | Oxford Union1 claim
and 5 more
Most important claims · 10 of 24Search all claims for “Malthusian” →
- Malthus was correct as a historian: charting English population versus prosperity from roughly 1200 to 1800 shows a pendulum where people were only prosperous when few in number, because a hard ceiling on extractable resources (chiefly food) capped wellbeing—until the industrial revolution broke that ceiling by harnessing fossil-fuel energy, allowing population and prosperity to rise together for the first time.170 - The Great Uncoupling
- The flood myth's stated cause of human 'noise' is a euphemism: before the flood the gods had not created death, so the noise reflects too many people and animals; after the flood the gods institute barren women, infertile men, and non-reproducing figures in society—making the story a sophisticated Malthusian philosophical position on population control.Irving Finkel
- Superlinear scaling from wealth creation and innovation produces, from the same theory, a rising exponential growth curve for cities and economies that fits the data well — but this system is destined to collapse for Malthusian reasons because it runs out of resources.Geoffrey West: The surprising math of cities and corporations
- Nature is generally Malthusian—things that replicate expand until some limiting factor (food, mutual killing over density, frequency-dependent disease) stops them—but this need not apply to human civilization, which could use collective norm-setting to block evolution toward maximum reproduction.Carl Shulman (Pt 2) — AI Takeover, bio & cyber attacks, detecting deception, & humanity's far future
- Robin Hanson's argument that competition drives emulated minds to subsistence does not imply bad lives, because subsistence is a demographic balance of income and population growth and is consistent with ems being in bliss—at subsistence they could have lives thousands of times better than ours.Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Altruism, History, & Technology
- It is wrong to raise animals in factory farms designed for large-scale efficient torture, but animals live in a Malthusian world where much of life is suffering anyway and they lack cones of sustainable growth, so making them suffer in our preferred way at the margin is not necessarily wrong; abstaining from meat is nonetheless a more moral diet, all else equal, and helps with climate change.Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler
- Humans are programmed to kill and eat animals and to see that as not very wrong, so even with fabulous future wealth we are unlikely to take significant steps to improve wild animal welfare because that biology is stronger than changes in philosophy or inclination; we'll only change for selfish reasons, such as inventing something better than meat.Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler
- During the 1970s oil shocks and today with Google showing over 3 million results for 'Malthus,' Malthusian ideas have returned to prominence in debates about peak oil, environmental damage, global population, and prospects for global catastrophe, with books like 'The Future in Plain Sight,' 'Collapse,' and 'Peak Everything' invoking Malthus as people wonder if the world is about to prove him right.Jeffrey Brenzel: The Essential Value of a Classic Education | Big Think
- The cost and timeline of the nuclear renaissance are artificially inflated by regulatory barriers created by malthusian anti-human extremists; if standards for safety were relaxed from nine nines to eight nines, costs and timelines would collapse.WE049 – Decoding Energy: Power, Politics, and Personal Growth with Doomberg
- Because AI can replicate at extremely rapid rates and pay back its creation costs quickly, if even one individual or institution chooses to replicate AIs they can expand to use any available natural resources; this forces Malthusian outcomes—e.g. a universal basic income funded by resource taxation would be driven down to the subsistence level of one more mind almost immediately—unless blocked by child/AI welfare laws requiring minimum resource endowments or by accepting jurisdictional diversity.Carl Shulman (Pt 2) — AI Takeover, bio & cyber attacks, detecting deception, & humanity's far future