What this covers

Irving Finkel, a leading scholar of ancient Mesopotamia, argues that the historical record radically misleads us about human capability and the scope of ancient civilization. He contends that modern humans are cognitively indistinguishable from ancients, that writing systems like cuneiform emerged earlier and spread wider than surviving evidence suggests, and that flood myths—including the biblical account—derive from real Mesopotamian catastrophes transmitted through oral tradition rather than supernatural events. The conversation weaves together Finkel's work on decipherment, the reconstruction of ancient games, linguistic archaeology, and textual analysis, grounding each claim in specific artifacts and interpretive method.

The conversation ranges across how cuneiform works syllabically and why the distinction between picture-signs and phonetic representation proved decisive; how the Royal Game of Ur, a 2600 BC board game, spread across three millennia and the Mediterranean without written rules; and how Akkadian, a Semitic language, enabled decipherment through comparison with Hebrew and Arabic, whereas Sumerian's isolation hints at vanished language families. On interpretation, Finkel proposes that the three-bird-release motif proves literary dependence between the Babylonian Ark Tablet and Genesis, and that the flood myth's "noise" conceals a Malthusian argument about population control disguised in theological language. He emphasizes Survivorship Bias throughout—that scholars wrongly treat fragments of cuneiform tablets as if they constitute the whole of written culture, when accounting records and perishable media have vanished almost entirely. He also credits Edward Hincks, an Irish clergyman, over Henry Rawlinson for the real breakthrough in decipherment: recognizing that a single sign carries multiple sound and meaning values.

Sharpest takeaway

Finkel argues that ancient peoples were cognitively and creatively indistinguishable from modern humans, that writing and complex society are far older and more widespread than the surviving evidence implies, and that our understanding is dangerously skewed by treating the small surviving record as if it were the whole.

  • The surviving cuneiform corpus is a 'raindrop' from which scholars wrongly infer the whole 'waterfall' of vanished material
  • Evidence like the Göbekli Tepe seal suggests writing existed thousands of years before Mesopotamian cuneiform
  • Flood myths derive from real localized Mesopotamian catastrophes transmitted through oral and literary tradition, not a single global event

The argument · threads11 threads · 42 claims
0.81

Writing began with phonetic sound-signs, not pictographs, enabling full linguistic expression.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Contrary to the standard Assyriological view that pictographs came first and phonetic signs second, Finkel argues it is more plausible that people who shared a language would have started with sound-signs; the surviving pictographic tablets likely sit at the end of a very long prior period of cross-cultural pictographic communication used between peoples who did not share a language.

    “I find it very bewildering that they started off with the least flexible and the least adaptable system of pictographs and then they moved on to the sound. I don't know why they bothered with it.”

  • The crucial breakthrough in writing was not picture-signs but the realization that a picture could represent the sound of a word rather than just the object; once signs could convey sound, writers were liberated from pictographic limits and could record full language, grammar, proverbs, and literature.

    “once you had the idea that you could write sounds with pictures, that's the crucial thing... Once this happened... you're liberated from pictographic writing into a position where you can record language”

  • Cuneiform works by syllables, not consonants: scribes could not write a bare consonant, so each consonant was clustered with each of the four vowels (e.g., ab/ba, ib/bi, ub/bu, eb/be), and a word like 'museum' is written by splitting it into syllabic signs (mu-z-um) which the reader mentally fuses.

    “the crucial point... is that they wrote in syllables. So if you take the English alphabet... They couldn't write a consonant. They couldn't do that.”

  • A fully trained cuneiform scribe could record not only Sumerian and Babylonian but any language he heard, including foreign tongues, purely by ear—sometimes writing sounds the scribe himself could not understand but which others could read and comprehend.

    “we have examples of funny languages around the world in the Bronze Age, which were written in cuneiform purely by ear. And often, sometimes the scribes who recorded by dictation or by something, wrote stuff they couldn't understand, but somebody else could read and understand it”

  • The early Mesopotamians invented not only writing but lexicography—systematically standardizing, recording, and teaching signs early in the third millennium—and this rigorous standardization is why the system remained stable and legible across three or more millennia, so that scholars in Alexander's time could still read very early tablets.

    “So they invented not only writing, they invented lexicography... They made a systematic attempt to make these signs to standardize them and to make them retrievable, and of course, to teach them.”

  • Cuneiform endured partly because literate scribes who controlled archives commanded great power that the public lacked; they reserved knowledge and philosophical inquiry to a cliquey scribal class, and the idea of universal literacy would have been anathema—anyone advocating teaching all children would have been removed.

    “people who could read and write... commanded a very great deal of power because most of the public couldn't. So they reserved to themselves knowledge, understanding, philosophical inquiry.”

0.76

The surviving cuneiform and archaeological records represent tiny, skewed samples of vanished material.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The earliest evidence of writing dates to around 3500 BC in Mesopotamia, but this almost certainly does not represent the actual beginning of writing; we have no idea when it truly began because the surviving evidence is only the oldest we happen to have, not the earliest that ever existed.

    “the oldest evidence we have is around 3500 BC, but whether that was anywhere near the time or the stage when this started off for the first time seems to me very, very unlikely”

  • Assyriologists wrongly treat the surviving cuneiform record as if it were nearly all that ever existed, when in reality it is a tiny, skewed sample—e.g., thousands of Ur III accounting tablets that likely came from just two storage rooms—and scholars working with skewed material often fail to realize how skewed it is.

    “Assyriologists have the inbuilt idea that what we have is something like all there ever was, which is absurd”

  • A round green stamp-seal carved with hieroglyphic-type signs found at Göbekli Tepe (c. 9000 BC) was used to ratify transactions by leaving impressions, which implies that writing—pictographic or even phonetic—existed there thousands of years before Mesopotamian cuneiform, likely on perishable materials like leaves.

    “it's clear to me, A, that this was a stamp to ratify, where the carvings of the signs on clay or some other sealing material would leave an impression. It must be that. So this is about 9000 BC.”

  • Following a Sherlock Holmes principle, it is theoretically possible to infer the Niagara Falls from a single raindrop—and Finkel uses this as the logic of his whole discipline: the Göbekli Tepe seal is a raindrop from which writing can be inferred, and the surviving tablets are raindrops from which the vanished waterfall of ancient material can be reconstructed.

    “it is theoretically possible to infer the Niagara Falls from a raindrop... that seal from Gobekli Tepe is a raindrop from which I infer writing”

  • The Nineveh library was not destroyed in a fit of pique by the conquering Babylonians and Elamites; because they shared the same language and writing system, they would have carried off the valuable knowledge intact, and what remains there are merely the duplicates, broken, and dropped tablets—not the whole library.

    “they wouldn't destroy the library because it was the giant brain from which the Assyrians ran a world empire... They'd have taken them all safely home, cart after cart after cart.”

0.71

The Mesopotamian flood story derived from a real localized disaster, not a global cataclysm.

7 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Graham Hancock's Younger Dryas hypothesis—that a ~10,000 BC asteroid impact caused a global flood whose memory all civilizations carried—deserves negligible probability, because the flood story is fundamentally a literary matter and the Mesopotamian version owes its origin to a local, non-global disaster, not a worldwide cataclysm.

    “I would say negligible, because I regard it as a literary matter— which is not predicated on the existence of flood in people's minds. But I do believe that the story in Mesopotamia owes its inception to a disastrous flood, but nothing global.”

  • The Babylonian Ark Tablet (c. 1700 BC) gives a 60-line blueprint instructing Atra-Hasis to build a giant round coracle to survive a divinely sent flood; being a thousand years older than the Hebrew flood narrative, and sharing many specific details, it establishes the primacy of the Mesopotamian flood story over Genesis.

    “this one was an early narrative in which the point was taken up where the gods in heaven had decided that the population of Mesopotamia needed to be wiped out... It was like a blueprint to build this boat. And it was just extraordinary because the boat was round.”

  • The Mesopotamian flood story owes its origin to a real localized catastrophe—likely a tsunami sweeping the flat plains down to the Persian Gulf thousands of years before the tablet—of which survivors were those on boats; the memory was transmitted grandfather-to-grandson as a never-forgotten 'bogeyman' tale, but it was nothing global, not touching America or China.

    “I think there must have been some tsunami once, most people were drowned, and those who survived were in boats, obviously. And then afterward, nobody ever forgot it.”

  • The accurate material proportions in the Ark Tablet's boat-building blueprint arose because oral storytellers performing to river communities of coracle-makers could not get away with vague claims; they had to derive realistic proportions from real coracle construction and scale them up, so the tablet sits precisely on the cusp between oral and literary literature.

    “if you do it to a whole load of river people who use coracles and make them, they're not going to take that... So what do they do? They go to a coracle place and they work out the proportions of material and then they bump it up”

  • The three-times bird-release detail appearing in both the Gilgamesh flood account and Genesis proves the two are not independent stories about the same event but are locked together by literary dependence, with the Mesopotamian version being the source recycled by the Judeans.

    “it wasn't two stories about the same thing. It was literary dependence... The one was locked into the other.”

  • The flood myth's stated cause of human 'noise' is a euphemism: before the flood the gods had not created death, so the noise reflects too many people and animals; after the flood the gods institute barren women, infertile men, and non-reproducing figures in society—making the story a sophisticated Malthusian philosophical position on population control.

    “Before the flood, the gods had not created death. So I think the noise was a reflex of the fact there were just too many animals, too many people”

  • The flood story embodies an irresistible narrative structure—one man given a ticking deadline to build something and save life from imminent disaster—that runs unbroken from Utnapishtim to Noah to roughly a third of Hollywood films about aliens destroying the world within 24 hours.

    “about a third of the films that come out of Hollywood are the world's going to be demolished by aliens and you've got 24 hours to think of a cure... So it starts off with Utnapishtim, and then it goes on to Noah, and then it goes on to Hollywood.”

0.57

Ancient humans possessed language, self-awareness, and creative genius equal to moderns; electronic media now reduces human vitality.

7 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Neanderthals and early Homo sapiens certainly had language and self-awareness; with the same vocal apparatus, human brains, and 800,000 years of communal life in Europe under Ice Age pressures, it is impossible they did not speak, and the claim they couldn't distinguish self from other is absurd given that pain and bodily threat are inescapably experienced as one's own.

    “I personally believe that Neanderthals and early Homo sapiens for sure had language, for sure they talked to one another. It's impossible that they didn't.”

  • The astonishing skill of Paleolithic cave paintings—accurate running animals rendered in color—implies a distillation of exceptional creative ability and skill that could not have been universal; rather than every family having a genius painter, it is more likely that singular gifted individuals traveled from place to place producing these works.

    “I imagine that half the cave paintings in Europe were done by one person... Probably there was a person who went from place to place doing these paintings because they could draw straight away accurately like that.”

  • The modern adherence to the electronic universe is disastrously addictive like a drug, reducing human vitality, and its short-clip media is wicked because it leaves children worldwide unable to articulate using rich language—which matters because vocabulary, acquired chiefly through reading rather than conversation, defines the quality of one's thoughts.

    “the modern adherence to the electronic universe is disastrous for humans... People use the electronic world like an addictive drug and they can't get through without it.”

  • Ancient peoples were not lesser, dumber, or more primitive; they were essentially the same as modern humans—you couldn't tell them apart if dressed alike on a bus—and the ancient world arguably allowed humans to behave more naturally, spared the cluttering, vitality-reducing effects of the modern electronic universe.

    “I think if you put them on a bus all wearing the same clothes, you wouldn't know. That's my feeling.”

  • Inertia is nearly as strong a force as evolution in human affairs; the assumption that practices change just because time passes is fallacious, since cultural processes are repeatedly stymied by inertia—for example, people writing on perishable materials like palm leaves both anciently and today.

    “the process of evolution is stymied left, right, and center by inertia. Inertia is nearly as strong as evolution, and this is something that the people who talk about progress and ideas have no idea about.”

  • Since every relationship contains the finite clause that someone will die, grieving endlessly over a loved one's death is infantile because death was always the inevitable outcome; the real tragedy would be if we were not supposed to die, and the painful thing is the knowledge that the whole thing ends rather than the moment of ending itself.

    “all relationships have this finite clause in them. So if you're very fond of somebody or you love somebody and they die, it's kind of infantile to whine about it ever after. Because what did you think was gonna happen?”

  • The British Museum is uniquely a museum of the whole human narrative through objects—not an art museum like the Louvre or the Met—and its task serves two horizons: representing all of humanity without favoring any culture or religion, and stockpiling objects for the unborn, since the significance of objects shifts and sharpens with the passage of time, making distance, storage, and contemplation inestimably valuable.

    “the British Museum is unlike almost all museums in the world because it's to do with the achievements of mankind from the beginning onwards... it's the narrative of the human race, as I see it, as discernible in objects.”

0.54

Complex organization and record-keeping existed at Göbekli Tepe seven thousand years before Mesopotamia.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Writing appears where many people live in an urban environment with rival institutions—kings, governments, temples—creating the organizational pressure to record things, which is why Finkel believes Göbekli Tepe, requiring planned construction, must have had the same conditions.

    “I think that the media in which it appears is when there's a lot of people living in an urban environment. And with rival institutions or the king or the government”

  • Monumental, principled architecture like Göbekli Tepe cannot be built by disorganized nomads; it requires planning, measurement, a managed workforce, and therefore record-keeping, just as the standard account holds for Sumerian cities—so the same logic implies writing and complex organization existed at Göbekli Tepe seven thousand years earlier.

    “the old rule would be you could not have architecture like that, planned and built according to principle with all the different people. You couldn't have that without writing in southern Iraq. So how come suddenly then 7,000 years earlier, they do it there?”

  • The Babylonians knew a great deal about astronomy, measuring celestial phenomena and making calculations to the extent that when the Greeks visited Babylon they were impressed and wrote it all down to take home.

    “They knew quite a lot about astronomy... they measured them and they made calculations. And when the Greeks went to Babylon, they thought, 'Hey man, this is really cool.' And they wrote it all down and went home.”

0.46

Monotheism's claim of exclusive truth bred dogmatism and evil; polytheism respected individuality.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • The creation of monotheistic religions was a great mistake that brought evil into the world, because monotheism is premised on the claim that 'I'm right and you're wrong,' generating dogmatism, inquisitions, and the impulse to stamp out rival faiths—whereas polytheism, with many specialized gods, never affronted individuality and had no religious or racial prejudice.

    “the big mistake for mankind was the creation of monotheistic religions, because they brought evil into the world. Because if you believe in a monotheistic religion, that means I'm right and you're wrong if you don't.”

0.45

Edward Hincks, not Henry Rawlinson, deserves credit for deciphering cuneiform's multivalence.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Henry Rawlinson, called the Father of Assyriology, does not deserve primary credit—his first major book was almost entirely wrong; the real decipherment was achieved by Edward Hincks, an Irish clergyman and possible genius, who worked out that a single sign can carry multiple sound and meaning values (multivalence).

    “He's called the Father of Assyriology, but I think he's the Stepfather of Assyriology because when he first got these inscriptions, he wrote a long book about it, which was almost entirely wrong.”

  • Cuneiform was deciphered using the trilingual Behistun inscription of Darius (in Old Persian, Elamite, and Babylonian); because Old Persian was a known living-related language written in simple cuneiform, scholars read it first, recognized repeated royal formulae in the parallel columns, and—realizing Babylonian was Semitic—matched words like the root for 'river' against Arabic and Hebrew dictionaries.

    “there was an inscription of one of the Persian kings halfway up a mountain in a place called Bisutun, where this King Darius had written an account of his successful career in Elamite and in Babylonian and in Old Persian, a trilingual version.”

  • Babylonian (Akkadian) is a Semitic language related to Hebrew, Aramaic, Arabic and others, which aided its decipherment via Semitic dictionaries; but Sumerian is not Semitic and is unrelated to any known language family, implying that whole language families related to Sumerian once existed but vanished before writing could record them.

    “The other language, which is Sumerian... is not only not Semitic, it's not related to any other known language.”

  • No word in one language ever precisely equates to a word in another; learners wrongly map a single Akkadian word to one English gloss, but a root may carry ten nuances whose extremes barely seem connected, which is why a great resource like the Chicago Assyrian Dictionary treats meaning contextually rather than as fixed A-means-B equivalence.

    “the truth about translation is that you never really have a word in one language which precisely equates another. You never do.”

0.45

The Royal Game of Ur balanced probability and strategy, spreading across millennia without written rules.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The enduring appeal of the Royal Game of Ur lies in its built-in balance of probability and strategy—unlike pure-luck games (Snakes and Ladders) or pure-strategy games (chess)—a balance also found in backgammon, which makes such games widely appealing to different types of person.

    “It's a mix of probability and strategy. So most games are either just probability like Snakes and Ladders... Or you have a game like chess, which is pure strategy. It's a mix”

  • The Royal Game of Ur, a 20-square race game dating to c. 2600 BC, spread across nearly 3,000 years and the entire Middle East—from Mesopotamia to Egypt's Tutankhamun, Greece, and Crete—without written rules and among people who didn't share a language, transmitted by travelers who saw it played, tried it, and reconstructed it from memory.

    “you have a game, which the interesting point about it is that it spread across the known world without written rules and without people necessarily knowing the same language.”

  • Finkel reconstructed playable rules for the Royal Game of Ur from a British Museum tablet written in the 2nd century BC—some 2,300 years after the original objects—which listed the pieces and throws of a derived game, allowing him to work backwards to a workable version now played worldwide and even in Iraqi cafés.

    “I discovered this tablet in the British Museum, which was written at a very late period in the second century BC... working backwards from it, you could reconstruct the game... And it jolly well turned out to be workable”

  • The human desire to play games is part of human nature, serving two functions: it sublimates communal rivalry and hostility into a safe terrain where one can get angry without real harm, and it provides 'time pass'—a graceful, stimulating way to fill the long idle hours imposed by heat or boredom in the ancient world.

    “if you play a board game like that, all the reality of it is sublimated into a safe terrain... where you can nevertheless get angry, but it's not like that.”

0.36

Judean exiles recycled Babylonian creation and flood narratives during the Babylonian exile.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The Hebrew flood narrative and creation material were composed during the Babylonian exile, when Judean refugees—sharing Aramaic, clothing, and appearance with Babylonians—would otherwise have intermarried and disappeared; their authorities drew up a historical charter explaining their plight as punishment for sin, recycling Babylonian creation and flood narratives but reframing the cause from noise/overpopulation to sin against a vengeful God.

    “I believe that the text of the Bible was written then... the only books in the Bible explain to the reader how it is that these people are in such a mess”

  • If you tell a story without a moral, there is usually a moral if you think about it; as narratives grew more sophisticated, lessons were incorporated or emerged unintentionally, reflecting a deep human creative and instructional impulse around the fireside.

    “if you tell a story without a moral, there is usually a moral if you think about it.”

0.22

Religious feeling fluctuates with need and is not constant belief but practical social fabric.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • An individual's response to religious stimuli is not constant but fluctuates and is largely a response to need—people become far more interested in gods when seriously ill or facing disaster—so religious feeling does not arise from nothing, and in Mesopotamia gods were not objects of belief but simply taken for granted as part of the practical fabric of life.

    “the individual's response to religious stimuli fluctuates and is varied and is often a response to need. It doesn't come from nothing.”

  • The conventional translation of Akkadian omens as 'if X, then Y will happen' is impossible; a diviner advising a king could never assert that the queen will die, only that a sign indicates she could die—so omens must encode modal possibility ('could/might/should') even though Akkadian grammar has no way to write modal verbs, and scholars who translate them as flat certainties commit a folly.

    “all you can ever do... is to say, 'There's a sign here that says that the queen could die,' meaning 'could die,' not 'will die.'”

0.18

Epic narratives like Gilgamesh retain formulaic narrator phrases frozen from oral performance.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • The Epic of Gilgamesh, though a sophisticated 12-tablet work, betrays its origins in oral literature: repeated narrator formulae like 'Gilgamesh opened his mouth to speak and addressed his friend Enkidu' are unnecessary in a written story and must be frozen relics of a live performance where a narrator announced each speaker.

    “when somebody speaks, it says, 'Gilgamesh opened his mouth to speak and addressed his friend Enkidu'... when you're reading a story, you don't need that, and that must be because of when there was an enacting of an oral thing”