Administrative State
Government's deliberate effort to subject industrial and commercial activity to oversight by expert professionals presumed able to manage the economy, constrained by political (electoral) accountability rather than markets.
As defined in et_368
Other definitions
The system of regulatory agencies that both write and enforce rules, exercising powers traditionally divided among legislatures and courts.
John Cochrane on Economic Growth and Changing the Policy Debate
Where it comes up · 16
- Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers4 claims
- Arnold Kling on Reforming Government and Expertise4 claims
- George Will on America, Politics, and Baseball 2/28/20113 claims
- Niall Ferguson: Why Great Civilizations Rise and Fall2 claims
- George Will on the Conservative Sensibility2 claims
- How the Constitution Can Bring Us Together (with Yuval Levin)2 claims
- 403 - Sanity Check On Trump 2.02 claims
- Ezra Klein on What’s Wrong with Trump1 claim
and 8 more
Most important claims · 10 of 28Search all claims for “Administrative State” →
- While eugenic ideas and isolated practice (e.g., the Oneida Community) predate it, serious wholesale eugenic policy—revising human heredity in the name of improving it—could not be carried out without a powerful regulatory state, so actual eugenic policy (as opposed to eugenic thought) had to await the arrival of the administrative state with the power to implement it; the key difference from today's genetic screening is who decides who is fittest—parents with doctors, or the state directed by experts.Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers
- The Progressives did not merely 'bring in the state' or enlarge it; they changed its nature by creating the Administrative or Regulatory State—a new beast that surveils, investigates (gathering data), and regulates economic life, supposedly in a scientific way, replacing the venal party-dominated Gilded Age government.Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers
- Two notions carry over from the original progressives to their 21st-century namesakes despite the abandonment of racism and eugenics: the core faith that if smart, well-intended best-and-brightest people are put in charge, economic and social progress will inevitably follow; and the belief that free markets are intrinsically—by design, not merely in practice—unjust and wasteful, and therefore require the visible hand of a vigorous, activist regulatory state.Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers
- The growth of the administrative state inherently produces rent-seeking because when government decisions allocate great wealth and opportunity, great wealth will be spent influencing those decisions—making lobbying a natural market consequence, not a moral failure.George Will on America, Politics, and Baseball 2/28/2011
- The administrative state is inherently an engine of inequality because those most able to manipulate the administrative process—the wealthy, well-connected, and compact interest groups with legal talent—dominate it, while the unorganized mass of Americans are simply not involved; this follows the law of concentrated benefits and dispersed costs (e.g., sugar quotas benefiting roughly a dozen families at the expense of 308 million sugar-eaters).George Will on America, Politics, and Baseball 2/28/2011
- Political norms—checks and balances, the role of Congress and the courts, the limits on the executive—decay over time in the face of temptation, so that much constitutional change comes not from changing the letter of the law but from changing how the law is enforced and how people feel about it, exemplified by the steady growth of presidential executive power.Will DOGE and Musk Make a Difference? (with Michael Munger)
- Progressivism was a doctrine of, by, and for the elites who objected that markets function well without intellectual supervision, so it naturally benefits the cognitive elites and has produced an increasingly cognitively stratified country where those who acquire cognitive skills flourish and those who don't are left behind.George Will on the Conservative Sensibility
- Progressive public-finance economists like Seligman laid the intellectual foundations of the US income tax (the 1913 constitutional amendment) on an organicist premise—that taxes are not payment for services but are owed 'simply because the state is a part of us,' implying taxes should vary with ability to pay—because an administrative state needs a reliable funding source beyond tariffs and sin taxes.Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers
- Whether the American system gets 'enough' done depends on what its purpose is; the Constitution's purpose is to facilitate cross-partisan bargaining and a cohesive political culture rather than rapid major legislation, so Congress's true failure is the collapse of cross-partisan negotiation—which is why constraints like the filibuster, far from being defects, are the best remaining inducement to deal-making.How the Constitution Can Bring Us Together (with Yuval Levin)
- DOGE is not governing but operating in the mode that government is the enemy, ransacking institutions like the NIH with cleavers and blindfolds; even if they reverted today, the disruption to basic research funding has created backlogs of tens of thousands of grants and long-term consequences, because they are extractive raiders rather than reformers with a theory of how government should operate.403 - Sanity Check On Trump 2.0