Thomas Leonard on Race, Eugenics, and Illiberal Reformers
What this covers
Thomas Leonard of Princeton argues that the architects of American professional economics in the Progressive Era—figures like Richard T. Ely and Edwin R. A. Seligman—built the Administrative State on an explicitly racial and eugenic foundation. Speaking with Russ Roberts on EconTalk, Leonard traces how early professional economists weaponized their new discipline to justify state intervention, using minimum wages, immigration restrictions, and labor regulations not incidentally to protect workers but deliberately to exclude what they deemed inferior populations—immigrants, women, and the disabled. The conversation moves through how German graduate training shaped the Progressive vision of the state as an organism rather than a contract, and how Theodore Roosevelt and others embraced "Race Suicide" theory, the fear that superior Anglo-Saxon stock would be outbred by inferior races accepting lower living standards. Leonard distinguishes his historical claim sharply: progressives were not merely holders of period-typical racist views, but actors who deployed the coercive machinery of the state to implement those views, exemplified by Woodrow Wilson's resegregation of the federal workforce.
The conversation covers the economic incoherence of the wage-competition arguments (frugality does not force low wages), the distinction between eugenics and social Darwinism, and why serious eugenic policy required state capacity that did not exist in prior eras. Leonard argues the progressives held a "great contradiction"—genuine compassion for the deserving poor alongside contempt for millions deemed unfit. He contends that modern progressives have abandoned the racism and eugenics while retaining the core faith: that expert rule produces progress and markets are intrinsically unjust. The episode concludes with Leonard's warning that humility is warranted, since these reformers were the intellectual elite of their time, applying the best science available, yet their confidence masked arrogance and self-interest—a pattern worth heeding when today's experts propose solutions to social problems.
Leonard argues that the founders of American professional economics in the Progressive Era built the administrative state on an explicitly racist and eugenic foundation, and that while modern progressives have shed the racism, they retain the core faiths—that expert rule by the best and brightest produces progress and that markets are intrinsically unjust—that should counsel humility.
- Progressive economists explicitly championed minimum wages as a tool to disemploy and exclude 'inferior' races, immigrants, women, and the disabled
- The Progressive vision of the expert-led administrative state was borrowed from German historicism and remains influential today minus its eugenic content
- Eugenics as policy (not just thought) required the coercive regulatory state that progressives built
Progressive reformers built a new administrative state designed to survey, regulate, and engineer economic and social life through expert technocratic authority.
- The progressive economists' best idea for spearheading their reforms was essentially 'install me and my friends'—an expanded role for the state that was simultaneously an expanded role for themselves—combining a quintessentially American naivete (claiming to know what they did not know) with arrogance, a self-serving form of public intellectualism that persists today.
“their best idea for spearheading all those reforms is, 'Well, why don't we install me and my friends?' To put it baldly.”
- After WWI, when German connections became politically untenable, progressive economists conceded they were wrong about Germany but not about the necessity of the administrative state and experts in charge; economics then evolved toward a more technocratic model where experts are given goals by a political process and decide the best route, differing from the heroic Progressive Era conception in which experts also told you what your goals should be, like preachers.
“we evolve towards the view where experts given a goal, a set of goals by some political process, and then decide the best route to get to that goal. Which is a bit different from the more heroic Progressive Era concept, which is experts not only tell you how to get from A to B, they tell you what your goals should be in the first place. Like preachers.”
- Progressive public-finance economists like Seligman laid the intellectual foundations of the US income tax (the 1913 constitutional amendment) on an organicist premise—that taxes are not payment for services but are owed 'simply because the state is a part of us,' implying taxes should vary with ability to pay—because an administrative state needs a reliable funding source beyond tariffs and sin taxes.
“if you are going to have an administrative state, it needs to be funded. And an income tax is a much better, much more reliable way of funding a large institution”
- The Progressives did not merely 'bring in the state' or enlarge it; they changed its nature by creating the Administrative or Regulatory State—a new beast that surveils, investigates (gathering data), and regulates economic life, supposedly in a scientific way, replacing the venal party-dominated Gilded Age government.
“what the Progressives advocated and ultimately succeeded in obtaining... was what they called the Administration or the Regulatory State. Which was a new beast in American economic and political life.”
- Progressives rejected the classical liberal Social Contract tradition (in which individuals pre-exist and create the state) and instead conceived the state as prior to the individual, using biological and anthropomorphic characterizations—the state as a living organism or moral person greater than the sum of its parts.
“They think of the state as prior to the individual. And they do use it... a very biological and sometimes anthropomorphic characterization of the state.”
- The idea of an economist as a vocation, a profession, only emerges in the late 19th and early 20th century; earlier figures who wrote brilliantly about economic matters were something else—Mill a civil servant, Smith a professor of moral philosophy, Marx an agitator and journalist—and a key part of what the progressives did in the US was to professionalize economics, making it academic and expert.
“the idea of an economist as a vocation--as a job, as a profession, is something that really only emerges in the late 19th, early 20th century.”
Minimum wage and eugenic policies were purposely designed to disemploy inferior racial and ethnic groups deemed unfit for the labor force or citizenship.
- Original progressives advocated a binding minimum wage precisely to disemploy 'idle, inferior' workers—Jews, Catholics, and Orthodox Christians from Southern and Eastern Europe, Asians vilified as coolies, and 'parasites' already in the labor force—treating job loss as a desirable feature performing a eugenic social service, the exact inverse of today's view that disemployment is a cost or bug of a minimum wage set too high.
“if you fixed what we today call a binding minimum wage, you would disemploy idle, inferior workers.”
- Eugenics in the Progressive Era meant the social control of human heredity and was seen by many progressive economists as among the most fundamental reforms the state could carry out; it came in two flavors—negative eugenics (preventing children from the unfit) and positive eugenics (promoting more children from the fit).
“Eugenics, at the time, was the social control of human heredity.”
- The 'Race Suicide' theory, named by Edward A. Ross and called by Theodore Roosevelt the greatest problem of civilization, held that the American working man would refuse to lower his standard to the 'coolie level' and would instead have fewer children, so hereditary inferiors would outbreed their biological betters—adding eugenic urgency to what was otherwise framed as unfair economic competition.
“The idea is that the American working man will not lower his standard to the coolie level, and will instead have fewer children. And because of that, the inferior, the hereditary inferiors, will outbreed their biological betters. That's what Race Suicide means.”
- At the time, labor economics (not yet called that) had not fully adopted marginal productivity as a theory of wage determination; it was a mishmash in which wages were thought partly determined by living standards, so if living standards could be made a function of race or gender, the racialized wage-competition argument could proceed.
“This is the moment where Labor Economics... still hadn't fully adopted marginal productivity as a theory of how wages are determined... there's still an idea that wages are partly determined by living standards and if you can say that living standard is a function of race or indeed of gender, then you are off to the races.”
- While eugenic ideas and isolated practice (e.g., the Oneida Community) predate it, serious wholesale eugenic policy—revising human heredity in the name of improving it—could not be carried out without a powerful regulatory state, so actual eugenic policy (as opposed to eugenic thought) had to await the arrival of the administrative state with the power to implement it; the key difference from today's genetic screening is who decides who is fittest—parents with doctors, or the state directed by experts.
“One thing about eugenics, about using the state to improve human heredity, is: You can't do it without a regulatory state, really. In any meaningful way.”
- The Great Contradiction at the heart of the Progressive reform movement was that progressives felt genuine compassion for 'the people' they judged worthy of citizenship—the deserving poor offered the helping hand of state uplift—while simultaneously scorning millions deemed disabled, of an 'inferior race,' or female, who were offered the closed hand of exclusion.
“I think they felt genuine compassion for "the people"... But simultaneously, they scorned millions of ordinary people who happened to be disabled or belonging to a "inferior race," or female. And they were offered the closed hand of exclusion.”
Progressives' genuine compassion for deserving citizens contradicted their violent exclusion of those deemed racially or biologically inferior through state coercion.
- The racist passages largely require no further indictment beyond letting the men who said them hang themselves—the arguments they made are damning on their face.
“these quotes are, if you like, letting the men who said them hang themselves. It doesn't require any further sorts of indictment than to see what sorts of arguments that they made.”
- The economics of the anti-Chinese argument was incoherent: just because a worker lives frugally or can subsist on little does not mean they will accept low wages—if there is any market competition they won't; frugality means saving money to bring family over or start a business, so the supposed link between subsistence living and substandard wages does not follow.
“Just because you live frugally doesn't mean that you are willing to accept low wages. If there's any competition in the market, you won't.”
- Woodrow Wilson won the 1912 election largely by accident—Teddy Roosevelt's run as a Progressive split the Republican vote—and Wilson secured popular majorities only in the states of the Confederacy, after which his administration resegregated the federal workforce.
“he won the election because Teddy Roosevelt ran as a Progressive, capital "P"-Progressive, splitting the Republican vote--Wilson got majorities, popular majorities, only in the states of the Confederacy.”
- Today's right-wing populism, exemplified by the Trump campaign, makes arguments eerily similar to those of the progressives a century ago—an implicit form of eugenic thinking, the 'Race Suicide' fear that America must remain white or pure and that certain races are not capable of becoming part of a democracy or workforce—differing in source (Right rather than Left) but not in intellectual roots.
“The kind of right-wing populism you are hearing from, the Trump campaign, is just eerily similar to the arguments that were sketched in my book of a period a hundred years ago.”
- History helps draw a crucial distinction between people who merely held unpleasant racist views (widespread at the time), those who acted on those views to harm others, and—most sinister of all—those who acted on them using the coercive power of the state; Woodrow Wilson's resegregation of the federal workforce, devastating the black bourgeoisie of Washington, D.C., exemplifies the third category.
“between people who had arguably unpleasant views... and those who acted upon those views in a way that harmed others. And third, those who acted upon those views using the coercive power of the state to harm others.”
German graduate training, Darwinian materialism, Evangelical Social Gospel, and American Pragmatism converged to shape progressives' organicist view of the state.
- Though both are species of evolutionary thought applied to social problems, eugenics starts from the opposite premise of social Darwinism: where the Darwinian says those who survive are fittest, the eugenicist worries that the fittest are NOT surviving—that hereditary inferiors are outbreeding their betters—and therefore the state must intervene to stop it.
“The eugenicist is worried that those who are surviving who are outbreeding their hereditary betters need to be controlled.”
- The progressive organicist view of the state had four converging sources: (1) German graduate training in the historical school, where progressive economists earned PhDs because US programs barely existed; (2) Darwinism, whose material explanation of evolution made inalienable Creator-endowed rights seem a fiction; (3) Evangelical upbringing producing a Social Gospel that shifted Protestantism from saving the individual to redeeming the whole nation; and (4) American Pragmatism, which licensed departures from absolutes if they proved useful.
“all of the leading progressive economists and many of their activist confreres did their graduate work in Germany. In the late 1870s and early 1880s you really couldn't get a Ph.D. in the United States.”
- The Progressive Era was a motley set of political and social reform movements responding to profoundly changed economic and social conditions at the end of the 19th century—a severe depression triggered by financial crisis combined paradoxically with rapid growth (the US economy quintupling from 1870 to 1900), mass immigration, urbanization, and the rise of the US as a single nation and global power.
“a set, a rather motley set of political and social reform movements that are responding to profoundly changed conditions--economic conditions and social conditions--at the end of the 19th century”
- The Progressives were 'illiberal' in two senses: first, they sought to dismantle 19th-century classical liberalism—treating individual rights enshrined in the Constitution as archaic impediments to their reform project of improving health, welfare, and morals—and second, they were illiberal in the original sense of being closed-minded, intolerant, and bigoted rather than open-minded and free from prejudice.
“what they were trying to do was to dismantle 19th century classical liberalism in the name of health, welfare, and mores. They basically saw individual liberties... as basically archaic impediments to their reform project”
Two persistent beliefs carry forward from original progressives to modern ones: that expert technocrats will deliver progress, and that markets are inherently unjust.
- Two notions carry over from the original progressives to their 21st-century namesakes despite the abandonment of racism and eugenics: the core faith that if smart, well-intended best-and-brightest people are put in charge, economic and social progress will inevitably follow; and the belief that free markets are intrinsically—by design, not merely in practice—unjust and wasteful, and therefore require the visible hand of a vigorous, activist regulatory state.
“they still hold to progressivism's core faith, is that: If smart, well-intended people are put in charge, the best and the brightest, then progress--economic progress, social progress--will inevitably follow.”
- We should avoid the tempting retrospective mistake of dismissing eugenics and race science as pseudoscience; at the time it was the best science of the day, and the progressives were not cranks or proto-fascists but the leading intellectual and political lights of their era who believed they were applying the best available science to social problems—which should counsel humility for today's policy economists.
“we want to make sure we don't make the tempting mistake of condemning all that's eugenics and race science as pseudoscience... at the time, it was nothing of the sort. It was the best science of the day.”