vouchers
Government-funded certificates that let families spend public education money at a school of their choice.
As defined in Bryan Caplan
Where it comes up · 11
- Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good2 claims
- Richard Epstein on Happiness, Inequality, and Envy 11/3/20081 claim
- Bryan Caplan1 claim
- Edward Glaeser and David Cutler1 claim
- Eric Hanushek on Test-based Accountability, Federal Funding, and School Finance 08/10/20091 claim
- EconTalk #1000 (with Russ Roberts)1 claim
- Luigi Zingales on Capitalism and Crony Capitalism1 claim
- Martha Nussbaum on Creating Capabilities and GDP1 claim
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “vouchers” →
- Republicans are advocating ways to abandon public schools through vouchers, while Democrats have abandoned standards and accountability; both failures cause kids to fall through the cracks, leaving reading at a 30-year low with 50% of kids unable to read at grade level.470 - Democrats At A Crossroads
- Urban schools persist in dysfunction because change is uniquely hard: unlike police chiefs who can change officer behavior 'on a dime,' principals cannot quickly change teacher behavior, and powerful entrenched interests—especially teachers' unions whose members vote and are anxious against change—block reforms like vouchers; a workaround is competitively sourced, pay-for-performance wraparound/vocational training that bypasses unions.Edward Glaeser and David Cutler
- K-12 vouchers underperformed expectations on raising standardized test scores, which is puzzling given how easy it would be to teach to the test; the real lesson is that most parents don't actually care about test scores — when given a choice they select on convenience, location, and especially whether their kids are happy, making the option to escape a miserable school an undervalued benefit of school choice.Bryan Caplan
- Roberts argues that while he remains a believer in the power of incentives (vouchers, competition) to improve education, Elizabeth Green's work showed him there are cultural reasons schools underperform and students struggle to learn, so incentives alone are insufficient and the picture is more complicated than economists assume.EconTalk #1000 (with Russ Roberts)
- The two-tier income structure reflects a two-tier education system: suburban schools and private schools serve the affluent well, while large urban public school monopolies trap most students, and resistance to vouchers and charter schools blocks escape.Richard Epstein on Happiness, Inequality, and Envy 11/3/2008
- Wealthy people already have educational choice through where they live and private options, so school choice is needed specifically for the poorest, and any education policy that fails to deliver choice to the poorest should be rejected on destinationist grounds as not good enough.Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good
- Roberts's preferred solution would be to get government out of schooling entirely or at least out of provision—keeping perhaps a subsidy role with dollars following students not schools—but with 90% of the population in public schools, a free and open voucher system is too far off, so the realistic path is more choice via expanded charters and market-like incentives supported by government.Eric Hanushek on Test-based Accountability, Federal Funding, and School Finance 08/10/2009
- The objection that school vouchers disadvantage children whose parents cannot select schools can be solved by making vouchers worth more for particularly disadvantaged kids, so schools actively seek them out—a private-sector solution to the problem of poor neighborhoods.Luigi Zingales on Capitalism and Crony Capitalism
- Despite decades of reform efforts since A Nation at Risk in 1983, US education reform has achieved very little because of huge resistance from teachers' unions and school boards: only about 6% of kids are in charter schools, less than 1% use vouchers or tax credits, and accountability has been gutted by being handed to state and local governments.Terry Moe on Educational Reform, Katrina, and Hidden Power
- Lovers of liberty divide into directionalists, who take political realities as given and accept any policy that moves outcomes toward a better destination, and destinationists, who refuse compromise within a bad system and advocate only for the ideal system itself, viewing incremental movement as complicity.Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good