virtue signaling
Performative gestures intended to display one's moral correctness rather than to produce real change.
As defined in Tiffany Jenkins on Plunder, Museums, and Marbles
Other definitions
The public expression of values or commitment to social causes primarily for the purpose of enhancing one's reputation or image, rather than for genuine commitment to the cause.
Generosity, Cynicism, and the Future of Doing Good: A Conversation with Chris Anderson(Episode #349)Performative morality without actual risk or cost; claiming credit for virtuous positions (e.g., saving the planet) without bearing consequences; distinguished from true virtue which requires skin in the game and actual sacrifice.
Skin in the Game | Nassim Nicholas Taleb | Talks at Google
Where it comes up · 21
- 128 - Transformations Of Mind4 claims
- Tiffany Jenkins on Plunder, Museums, and Marbles2 claims
- 458 - The Bulwark Against Maga2 claims
- Why Are We Glorifying Insanity? - Konstantin Kisin (4K)2 claims
- Joe Rogan Experience #1309 - Naval Ravikant1 claim
- Generosity, Cynicism, and the Future of Doing Good: A Conversation with Chris Anderson(Episode #349)1 claim
- Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Work, Slavery, the Minority Rule, and Skin in the Game1 claim
- Megan McArdle on Catastrophes and the Pandemic1 claim
and 13 more
Most important claims · 10 of 27Search all claims for “virtue signaling” →
- A cultural shift on the right involves 'vice signaling'—performing bad conduct that starts as ironic detachment and, per the maxim that our faces grow to fit the masks we wear, hardens into genuine belief; it functions as both an antidote to left 'virtue signaling' and an in-group code, as seen in staffers casually invoking gas chambers.458 - The Bulwark Against Maga
- Performative apology and museum-based contrition for past injustices salves consciences and creates a sense that one's part is done, thereby crowding out the real political redress of present injustices—such as deeply troubling current government policy toward Native Americans—rather than supplementing it.Tiffany Jenkins on Plunder, Museums, and Marbles
- What the internet has been especially good for is tribalism—a way to feel one belongs through virtue signaling or ganging up on someone, often anonymously—and as religion wanes worldwide, finding other non-outrage-driven ways to satisfy the human need to belong could be a source of hope for repairing online discourse.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- The charge of virtue signaling is essentially unfalsifiable because any public modeling of virtue can be reinterpreted as a selfish desire to seem virtuous rather than actual virtue, so no one escapes the accusation; though toxic virtue signaling is real, most who hurl the phrase online are just people fed up with the climate of fear around being seen as bigoted.White Privilege
- The United Nations exhibits a documented double standard against Israel—roughly 760 of 800 condemnatory resolutions target Israel—driven both by antisemitism and by 'sin signaling,' where members who are not themselves antisemitic attack Israel knowing all the antisemites will approve, exemplified by the UN women's conference taking two months to name the October 7th sexual violence against Israeli women.348 - The Politics Of Antisemitism
- Because utopianism has fallen into disrepute and religion's promise of a messianic future has retreated, culture has turned away from imagining a better future toward fighting over and repairing the past—a presentism that loses the distinction between past and future and uses history as a battleground for present moral conflict.Tiffany Jenkins on Plunder, Museums, and Marbles
- Virality-enhancing social media has shifted the cost-benefit of virtue signaling: it lowers the cost of expressing moral outrage to one's own side (no need to physically counter-protest and risk confrontation) while raising the benefits (likes from a safe bedroom), producing a kind of tribal performance that no one learns from and that does not build enriching group solidarity.Reclaiming Tribalism (with Michael Morris)
- Policies like the minimum wage should be decided by those who bear the consequences—the unemployed and those earning near the minimum—rather than by intellectuals with secure jobs who advocate it for virtue signaling, because the advocates will not pay for adverse consequences (job losses, automation, offshoring) while those affected have genuine skin in the game.Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Work, Slavery, the Minority Rule, and Skin in the Game
- Shifting from aiding victims to aiding everyone who claims victimhood has led to charlatanism and virtue signaling, with their interaction now defining Western online cultureWhy Are We Glorifying Insanity? - Konstantin Kisin (4K)
- Most social media outrage and 'woke' discourse is white-on-white violence (college-educated progressives attacking blue-collar whites), not actual minority activism; it's elite virtue signaling warfare disguised as social justice.Joe Rogan Experience #1309 - Naval Ravikant