Tiffany Jenkins on Plunder, Museums, and Marbles
What this covers
Tiffany Jenkins and Russ Roberts debate the purpose of museums and the case for returning contested artifacts, centered on whether the British Museum should surrender the Elgin Marbles to Greece. Jenkins, author of Keeping Their Marbles, argues that encyclopedic museums serve learning best by housing objects from many civilizations in a single space, enabling cross-cultural comparison that deepens understanding of each culture. Roberts probes the moral and practical dimensions of the argument. Their discussion ranges across the British Museum's unusual origins in Hans Sloane's private collection, the circumstances of acquisition—including Lord Elgin's contested authority and Henry Layard's excavations at Nineveh—and the question of what authentic encounter with objects makes possible.
Jenkins frames the repatriation movement not primarily as a moral correction but as a symptom of lost institutional confidence, one expression of broader presentism in which culture becomes a tool for managing present grievances rather than understanding the past. She contends that museums once held genuine belief in visitors' capacity to be transformed by learning; today they increasingly label and quarantine collections rather than teach. The conversation turns contentious on several points: whether half the Parthenon sculptures scattered between Athens and London is actually preferable to reunion; whether personal moral display about historical injustice crowds out real political redress for current wrongs; and whether the intensity of repatriation demands tracks the merits of objects or merely shifts with political winds—the Benin Bronzes case and Brexit's effect on Marbles rhetoric both surface here. Jenkins also challenges the premise that present-day moral sensibilities should determine what the past was.
Jenkins argues that universal 'encyclopedic' museums like the British Museum best serve human understanding by enabling cross-cultural comparison, and that the modern push to repatriate objects and re-purpose museums for social justice reflects a loss of confidence in learning about the past rather than a genuine moral correction.
- Objects gain meaning through comparison with other civilizations, which is uniquely possible in encyclopedic museums.
- The repatriation movement often originates from within museums that have lost confidence in their educational mission.
- Turning culture into a tool of present-day politics substitutes performative atonement for real political redress.
Physical encounter with authentic objects in curated museum spaces transforms visitors and cannot be replicated by digital or cast reproductions.
- Physically entering a museum provides an irreplaceable encounter with people of the past that digital reproductions cannot replicate, because the curated experience transports the visitor into another world and connects them to a chain of generations.
“it's like you're transported. I find them almost like a time machine.”
- Even excellent casts and digital reproductions cannot substitute for the authentic original, both because the cast is likely not as good as the original and because viewers genuinely value seeing the real thing, even if this amounts to object fetishism.
“I do think we want to see the authentic thing. It might be that we're object fetishists and all the rest of it; but fine, I'm happy with that. I want to see the real thing.”
- When the Marbles arrived in Britain, there was a massive debate over whether they were any good because they did not match expectations (complete limbs, smooth, white) and appeared off-white and relaxed; it was possibly through this very debate that they became established as great works of art.
“So, there's a big debate over whether they're any good or not. Massive, massive debate. It's possibly through that debate that they begin to be established as these great works of art.”
- Placing three civilizations next to each other—Assyrian, Egyptian, and ancient Athenian—allows visitors to understand each on its own terms better through comparison, because comparison reveals the specificity of each culture.
“just having those three civilizations next to each other, you can see both--you can understand each of them on their own terms, better I think, through comparison.”
Repatriation debates are driven by shifting political currents and institutional self-doubt rather than by the intellectual or historical merits of the objects themselves.
- Much of the repatriation impulse comes from within museums that have become unconfident about why they hold objects and unable to do anything with them, leading them to seek to give items away rather than from external demand alone.
“what's the interesting thing about the repatriation argument is that it's come from within museums unconfident about why they have this stuff anymore, unable to do anything with it.”
- The intensity of the repatriation debate moves up and down in relation to broader political and intellectual currents—after Brexit nobody wanted the Marbles returned because it was seen as Greek nationalism, while Black Lives Matter shifted the debate especially over the Benin Bronzes—rather than tracking the merits of the objects themselves.
“The discussion about repatriation moves up and down in relation to other political questions.”
- Despite press reports of near-finished negotiations and the precedent of the Benin Bronzes returning to Nigeria, the Elgin Marbles will not be returned to Greece.
“people think that will impact upon the Marbles, but I will stake my reputation saying, I don't think they'll go back.”
- French looting under Napoleon was conscious, deliberate, and systematic—an instrument of empire—whereas British acquisition was more accidental, haphazard, and informal, coming as a consequence of empire rather than an instrument of it.
“the French were much more conscious and deliberate about their looting. It wasn't to say that the Brits didn't do it, but it's much more accidental and haphazard and informal. And it often came as a consequence of Empire rather than it being a kind of instrument of Empire.”
Modern museums have abandoned their Enlightenment mission to educate and transform all people, instead moralizing collections and suppressing inquiry into past worldviews.
- Contemporary museums have become moralized, labeling collections racist or sexist and removing them from display without being able to explain why, which amounts to quarantining the past rather than exploring it, abandoning the museum's job of helping visitors understand past mindsets.
“I almost think that what we're doing is almost quarantining the past rather than exploring it.”
- Enlightenment and Victorian museums, despite their paternalism and barriers like dress codes, held a genuine belief that ordinary people could learn, be transformed, and move from their circumstances into another world; this confidence has been replaced by a sense that museums must merely reflect visitors' existing culture back to them.
“there was a sense that ordinary people could learn something, could be transformed, could move from their particular circumstances into another.”
- When museums like the National Museum of the American Indian are tied to a political purpose of making people feel part of America, only certain idealized histories are permitted, producing a new kind of 'hidden history' where partial narratives are dressed up in nice language but still suppress alternatives—driven for the benefit of the institution rather than the people it claims to represent.
“you have a new hidden history, because in a way, only certain histories are allowed to be told. They dress it up in nice language, but it's still very partial.”
- Dropping meritocratic entry barriers to admit more students without providing genuine education is a con on those students, because they are told they are 'in' and given a certificate while not being educated to the standard that would let their imagination roam free; the real fix is tackling why people fail to reach the needed educational level.
“if you're not being educated as the standard you need to be get into university... it's a con. I think it's a con for those people.”
Colonial acquisitions were often legally ambiguous, unevenly documented, and contextually complex rather than straightforward theft, while discovery and excavation revealed previously unknown civilizations.
- Lord Elgin came to an agreement with the Ottomans, documented in an Italian translation of a Firman that permitted taking sculptures on the ground, but he probably exceeded those limits by removing pieces off the building; however, the absence of modern detailed contracts and the fact that locals were also taking parts of the building makes this a gray area rather than clear-cut looting.
“which says he can take parts of the sculptures which are on the ground. What we know is he took some off the building.”
- The British Museum is unusual in that it houses very few objects from Britain itself, having been built in 1756 from Hans Sloane's collection of objects from voyages of exploration, in contrast to French and European museums built to house the collections of their nation.
“it doesn't house very many objects from Britain. Lots of other museums, particularly France and Europe, were built to house the collections of the nation.”
- Napoleon followed the Roman model of bringing the greatest works of civilization to the greatest city as imperial trophies, and when Britain defeated him at Waterloo in 1815 and forced the repatriation of looted art, the British were equally using objects as a display of might.
“The idea was that you take the greatest works of civilization to the greatest city of civilization--Paris, then. Napoleon, I think, in his head was following in the footsteps of the Romans who looted.”
- Having roughly half the Parthenon sculptures in the Acropolis Museum and half in the British Museum is probably the best situation, because objects do different things in different places: in Athens they affirm the authentic original site, while in the British Museum they are understood in relation to other world cultures.
“the situation as it stands with half in each place is pretty good. It's probably the best situation. Because I think objects do different things in different places.”
- The museum is an orderer that creates knowledge but also imposes hierarchies; at the time the Assyrian sculptures were acquired, the idea that Assyrians could be as good as the Athenians was anathema, unlike today's view that all cultures are equal.
“the museum is an orderer and it makes things into hierarchies. It creates knowledge but it does also then impose it.”
- When the modern Greek state was formed, it took down many buildings around the Parthenon and almost invented a sense of being ancient Athenian and a continuity with the ancient past, coinciding with the period when people began celebrating the glory of ancient Athens.
“the Greek state, which was formed. And they too started to--that's when they took down a lot of the buildings around it and almost invented the sense of being ancient Athenian and the continuity with the new Greek state.”
- The Assyrian winged-bull sculptures from Nineveh were not plundered from shelves but excavated from underground by Henry Layard, revealing things about those civilizations that were previously unknown.
“they weren't plundered then. They were excavated... they were underground and they were excavated by, in this case, Henry Layard.”
Contemporary culture has become trapped in fighting over past wrongs rather than imagining better futures, losing productive distinction between past and present.
- Because utopianism has fallen into disrepute and religion's promise of a messianic future has retreated, culture has turned away from imagining a better future toward fighting over and repairing the past—a presentism that loses the distinction between past and future and uses history as a battleground for present moral conflict.
“you used to have, and particularly on the Left, this sense of: 'Don't mourn. Organize.'... And now it's flipped over to: We must organize to mourn.”
- If we believe everything today is determined by what happened 200 years ago, we become prisoners of the past with a real fatalism; escaping this requires more ambitious thinking about what humans can do and a rebalanced view of the past that recognizes both its horrors and its achievements like civil rights and medical breakthroughs.
“If we are determined, if everything today is as a result of what happened 200 years ago, then what can we do? We're just prisoners. There's a real fatalism.”