What this covers

This is a single-speaker Talks at Google session in which Nassim Taleb walks through the book Skin in the Game. He frames it as an attempt to bring two neglected ideas into social thought: dynamics, meaning how systems change over time, and scaling), meaning that rules and behavior change qualitatively as groups grow. The argument builds from a simple ethical rule, that the cook should eat his own cooking, to claims about expertise, fairness and how institutions survive.

The examples cover a wide range. Taleb takes the peacock's costly tail as a biological case of risk as signaling, and he notes that fewer than a third of roughly 300 Roman emperors died naturally. He sets these against Thomas Friedman advocating wars from a safe office. The Bob Rubin trade serves as his model of asymmetric payoff, and he says it breaks Hammurabi's Code. On expertise, he contrasts pilots and surgeons, who are selected by consequences, with macroeconomists, who get no feedback. The green lumber problem illustrates what practitioners know that outsiders cannot guess. He also claims that restaurants judged by their peers are more likely to close.

The more contested turns come later. Taleb says bankruptcy rates matter more than inequality, and that companies should be allowed to die. He points to the shrinking tenure of firms in the S&P 500 as a healthy sign. He prefers the Silver Rule to the Golden Rule because it is negative and does not impose preferences on others, and he extends it to relations between countries. He argues that ethical behavior in a group of 250 does not carry over to a group of 200,000, so politics should be layered, with different governance at different scales. He ends on virtue signaling, such as the hotel towel card, which he contrasts with the costly virtue of Socrates. He also offers a rule of thumb for choosing a doctor: pick the one who looks like a butcher.

Sharpest takeaway

Nassim Taleb argues that 'skin in the game'—having personal risk exposure to the consequences of one's decisions—is the fundamental principle that separates genuine expertise from pseudo-expertise, enables ethical behavior, and creates functional systems that learn and survive.

  • Fields where practitioners face consequences for their mistakes (surgery, piloting, trading) produce genuine expertise; fields where decision-makers avoid consequences (academia, policy, finance) produce BS and collapse
  • The absence of symmetry between decision-makers and those harmed by their decisions violates Hammurabi's Code and prevents systems from learning
  • Scaling matters: ethical rules that work in small groups fail at large scales; political systems must be layered with different governance models at different scales

The claims · ranked56 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.78

Skin in the game engages with two aspects of social thought usually neglected: dynamics (how systems change over time) and scaling (how rules and behaviors must change qualitatively as group size increases); these are mathematical transformations, not linear adjustments.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Nassim Taleb

“one thing about skin in the game skin in the game is interested in two aspects of social thought that are not discussed the first one is dynamics and other things happen over time how systems what rule should be applied over time takes a snapshot and we'll see how why and at the mistake and the second one is scaling that thing changed in scale a small hamlet will not become cannot you cannot turn the dynamics of a hamlet into a small village and a small village cannot become it's not you know cannot turn it to a very very small town okay you have scale some kind of scale transformation that happened when when groups become larger and that's mathematical”

0.75

Risk as virtue (signaling fitness through risk-taking) exists in nature: the peacock's tail is metabolically expensive and useless for survival, which is precisely why it signals fitness—only a genuinely healthy organism can afford such a costly signal, and people instinctively respect those who demonstrate costly commitment.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“now comes the notion of risk as virtual we're not stupid we have some organic understanding of these things and the peacock you know the havean peacock story is that the peacock white because there's a big tail absolutely useless it's precisely because it's useless and the peacock can maintain such a tail it shows some kind of some kind of biological fitness okay to be able to carry such a tail now the peacock is a hive in peacock it's a nice you know framework the world calls as having a trait superfluous trait but that gives you definitely some kind of fitness people who have scars people who have scars command respect people who have to take risks command respects people who don't realize it but that's what's happening okay”

0.74

The Bob Rubin trade exemplifies asymmetric payoff: a bank executive makes large upside when right but shareholders and employees pay for losses; this violates Hammurabi's Code, which required those who create risks for others to also be at risk themselves, and prevented civilized society from functioning without such symmetry.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Nassim Taleb

“there's something I call the Bob Rubin trade the absence of symmetry and again the skin in the game is about certain classes asymmetry and we're gonna see the what the name comes from and the link to sue the expert the fellow was chair men of the now to be called chairperson of Citibank or Citicorp spent ten years there and he received 120 million dollars in compensation okay and when the crisis happened ten years ago I don't know if you were many of you were born at least were you know conscious it was going on so 10 years ago there was a crisis so and then he said some that very unfortunate highly unexpected event often called Black Swan for which we apologize profusely but we are excused as nobody could predict these things happened okay no very nice he will acknowledge that there was it was a Black Swan named after a very very stubborn author okay okay but but sometime pleasant if you have coffee with them you know not never stabbed or definitely intellectually all right so what's the problem there let's think about it he made you make the upside when you're right and when you're wrong who pays for the losses sorry there's a Spanish grammar instructors a recurring person in the book who pays for losses made by others yoga instructors Google sushi chefs okay okay and and and and so on okay they paid the price directly or indirectly so what we have here is a violation of a law that effectively is the first law extent Hammurabi's rule”

0.74

Roman emperors—approximately 300 in total—rarely died of natural causes; fewer than one-third died naturally, with the rest killed by rivals or successors, creating extreme risk exposure that modern warmongers who make decisions about wars face none of.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Nassim Taleb

“risk as virtual of the I don't know how many Roman emperors we've had close to 300 how many died and of natural death assuming those real desired national deaths I really don't have what our modern autopsies how many half three quarters hundred percent no more than a third all right and we're not sure about that third and of course had they lived longer had they not died of pneumonia or something all right they would have been killed by someone right”

0.74

'The Betrayal of the Clerks' by Julian Benda (1930s France) identified the same problem in earlier intellectual class: insincere intellectuals without skin in the game pursuing prestige through theoretical innovation rather than actual knowledge.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Nassim Taleb

“there is a book that came to that effect called by in France and in 1930 nineteen hundreds and it's called the betrayal of the clerk's bar Julian benda who really said the same thing and I realized that for a long time people kept citing benda about what they call full-on sincere intellectual for intellectual and sincere intellectual”

0.74

A simple and obvious principle that applies everywhere: the cook should eat his or her own cooking; this has been a foundational ethical principle for a long time but has stopped being applied in recent generations.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Nassim Taleb

“something quite obvious as obvious as the cook should eat his or her cooking okay needs to apply everywhere and these rules were did prevail until recently and we're gonna see well where they stopped prevailing but they prevailed for a long time until say maybe in generation half ago two generations ago”

0.73

Focusing on bankruptcy rates is more important than focusing on inequality; a system with high bankruptcy rates (where businesses fail and leaders fall) is fairer than one with high inequality, because repeated bankruptcy prevents entrenchment of power.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“don't you for equality shoot for high bankruptcy rates so people have these they also the illusion that you want opportunity means people to be able to go up no you want people to come down okay from the top this is what you got to focus on in society this is an approach a dynamic approach to social problems”

0.72

Modern warmongers like Thomas Friedman can advocate for wars (Iraq, Libya) that kill hundreds of thousands from safe air-conditioned offices with zero personal consequences; this violates skin in the game and prevents systems from learning, because learning requires the people making mistakes to face consequences.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Nassim Taleb

“warmongers today warmongers who are sitting in an air-conditioned office in Washington can we name names on Google saying you can sue me directly okay in an a in a book I name names like Thomas Friedman are all these they can cause wars in Iraq devastations hundreds of thousand people kill maybe more financial you know trauma what price did they pay zero so let's merge the ethics and epistemology if they had to pay for their mistakes like the driver who disappears the system don't learn because people learn systems don't learn system learn if you have the survival mechanism by eliminating those who don't have that trait”

0.69

Fields are self-correcting through Darwinian selection: pseudo-expert pilots died along with their passengers, creating strong selection for genuine expertise; this natural selection process eliminates those without real knowledge, so fields with high consequences for failure produce genuine experts.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“I mean you cannot believe in God when it comes to academia but just believe in God outside you have to be consistent okay so and this of course you remember this cartoon which violates my idea of other pseudo experts because they say these smartphones have lost touch regularly the regular passages like us who think I should fly the plane so the point is what we're observing is not a riot against experts it's a riot against a certain class of experts I call those the iyi intellectually at idiot because of lack of contact with reality anything like academia doesn't have contact with reality collapses academics are you judged by other by peers pasquale who judges you even actually boston same them you know we're down the same department who judges you your peers other academics well there's an expert problem okay so if you're not judged by PNL we say or reality or something like that...the pilot definitely has to be an expert and they're very simple reason what happened to pilots who were pseudo experts there we go there we go they died and and their passengers died so basically we have Darwinian it's called Darwinian you know the school athletes survival of the fittest or survival of the of the non non experts”

0.69

Restaurants that win prestigious prizes judged by peers (journalists and other restaurant owners) rather than by customer feedback are more likely to close; any business judged primarily by peers rather than by contact with reality will rot eventually, because peer judgment decouples from actual performance and creates an expert problem.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“the restaurant business has a lot of prizes the best sushi in lower Manhattan the best sushi you know with music sushi whatever so you have all these categories okay and then there is a best restaurant in that category right the best rare steak the best t-bone or whatever west of the Hudson was you have all these categories and at their prices actually now who decide on these prices journalists and other restaurant owners there is a gala dinner where they give these prices and guess what most restaurants who got prizes we're closed we're shut down all right shut it down no you know out of business okay so it tells you the following any business were you judged by your peers and not by some contact with reality it's gonna rot eventually all right”

0.69

A trader lost a million dollars trading green lumber because while he knew economics, mathematics, statistics about lumber, he didn't know the crucial distinction: green lumber means freshly cut, not lumber painted green; practitioners know distinctions that cannot be guessed from outside without experience.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“there's a story in Atmos anti fragile and skin in the game of a fellow who lost a million dollars trading green lumber he knew everything about a lumber green lumber and everything the economics the mathematics the statistics collected data everything and lost a million dollars and wrote an account what I learned losing a million dollars and he reports there's a fellow a bit trader you know I don't know if you met the traders but they look like the traders of the act like the traders right and these the the fellows making tons of money with green lumber and had been doing so consistently now the narrator discovers that the fellow made a lot of money green lumber didn't know he thought it was lumber painted green he didn't know it was freshly cut lumber okay so is it that that person this is very high can argument know knew nothing about it know that he knew a lot of stuff but not necessarily what you think from the outside is valuable”

0.68

Traders and practitioners develop an empirically-grounded, bottom-up understanding of probability and risk that is fundamentally different from the theoretical, top-down, formula-based understanding of mathematicians and academics, who are 'full of Bologna' because they rely on models divorced from reality.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“I was a trader so I didn't become someone mathematically oriented early on in life first I had to become a trader now you learn when you're trader first of all you learn that that mathematicians and people who model are full of s star I don't never spell it out in my books so this let's use Bologna as a good proxy whenever I say Bologna you know what I mean all right so that theoretician and academics are full of Bologna because we have a view of the formulas we used that is organic bottom-up and this led to anti fragile where I was explaining that architects always do a better job when they don't use Euclidian geometry when they use the rules acquired by architect not mathematical top-down rules bottom-up”

0.68

Macro is easier to BS than micro because in macroeconomics you don't see feedback from decisions (mistakes are attributed to unpredictable events), while in microeconomics or micro-level fields like pediatrics you get direct feedback; this applies broadly: fields with no contact with reality breed pseudo-experts.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“that's skin in the game that's Tamala G of scaring again and you can apply to a lot of things people in policymaking they're not experts and I think macro is much easier to micro bs and micro bs and that's the motto of the book okay so when Macrobius you don't see the feedback you know Adventists will be an expert but then PDA ologist will not be an expert okay there is no feedback”

0.68

The Golden Rule ('do unto others as you would have done to you') is intrusive and problematic because it imposes your preferences on others; the Silver Rule ('do not do to others what you would not want done to you') is more robust because it is negative and respects diversity of preferences.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“You've heard of the Golden Rule do unto others what you wanted to do to you which I in fact I find a little intrusive because say I like raw Lebanese meat Lebanese could be I'm not going to force you to eat it alright so there's actually and say I'm a bureaucrat and like this kind of stuff I don't force you there is a much more robust silver rule don't do to others what you don't want to do for you”

0.68

The Silver Rule extends to international relations: treat other countries the way you would like to be treated if you were weaker; it has a fractal property where the same principle applies at multiple scales (individual, family, tribe, community, nation).

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“and also and unfortunately people don't understand it extends to international affairs the civil rule how treat other countries the way you would like other countries to treat you if you were weaker and there's a fractal aspect of the silver rule counties we treat other countries the same you know and so on”

0.68

Universalism is impractical because universalism kills the particular and is not fractal; effective ethical systems must be layered, respecting that rules differ appropriately at different scales and contexts.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“I talk a lot about content universalism it's not practical because the universal kills the particular it's not fractal okay it becomes anonymous you have to layer it and and and if you have time you know we can say why but there so this is the golden rule came across ethical systems religion and the less last iteration is is is with the year was count but but basically the most the most robust is a silver rule”

0.68

Political ideology is scale-dependent: you can legitimately be communist at village scale, libertarian at federal scale, and Democrat at county scale and Republican at state scale simultaneously; this is perfectly compatible because different scales require different governance models.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“and that's a political implication you can both say it's very very compatible to be a communist in your village and libertarian at the federal level and Democrats for the county what being a Republican for the state okay it's perfectly compatible you cannot have a political opinion without attaching the scale to it so communism can work and Singapore okay because it's small much better than China look at the success okay that form of socialism or you can have you cannot you should separate the political label from the scale”

0.68

When choosing between two doctors with identical track records, choose the one who looks like a butcher not a Hollywood surgeon, because the attractive doctor had to overcome perception bias to succeed, meaning all other things equal he is more competent; appearance is inversely correlated with merit in fields with skin in the game.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“your choice between two doctors one doctor who looks like the Hollywood version of a doctor a surgeon well mannered well educated ever and then the other person looks like a butcher and these two had the same track record had the same rank at the hospital okay which doctor would you pick yes sorry the one because this person had to overcome because now is not just a tall by anything external lessening and also peer review entirely by the track record did you see by the performance you have to overcome all this perception bias to get there so this is it when a field that has skin in the game the cosmetic beware of the cosmetic”

0.68

Corporations should be allowed to die and be replaced rather than propped up; short company lifespan (10-12 years at S&P 500 level) is healthy; family businesses and non-public companies show greater survival advantage than public corporations because they face different incentives.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“no it's best for corporations to die and be replayed on a die for corporation dies okay or mutates into a different group or spin-offs and stuff like that but if I you know visibly if I want to come if you want to come back to this world come back as a decentralized system with cockroaches because an elephants your survival as a species is gonna be longer you see so the corporation's basically the minute car company Jones the S& p500 it looks like the you know it started committed a suicide process okay and and of course companies that that don't run the S& p500 have a huge survival advantage what shows from the data family businesses stuff like that”

0.68

Large public corporations face pressure from 28-year-old Wall Street Journal journalists and MBA analysts at investment banks who bully company leadership into pursuing stock-focused policies; this pressure accelerates the suicide of large corporations.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“but if I you know visibly if I want to come if you want to come back to this world come back as a decentralized system with cockroaches because an elephants your survival as a species is gonna be longer you see so the corporation's basically the minute car company Jones the S& p500 it looks like the you know it started committed a suicide process okay and and of course companies that that don't run the S& p500 have a huge survival advantage what shows from the data family businesses stuff like that so it looks like when you join the market become large enough to have investors your policy is going to be driven by the the 28 year old journalist major who joined the near the at the at the Wall Street Journal was going to comment on you and and collapsed eve jobs and bullying has happened okay so so this is the the press so the stock market accelerates the process and then we have no evidence we've seen no evidence of economies of scale for being large as a matter of fact that they are diseconomies of scale that I'll discuss an anti fragile”

0.68

Mandatory military service for those who vote for war is an effective policy to reduce wars; it forces decision-makers to be exposed to consequences, making them less reckless; conscription is not pacifist but a practical constraint on war-making.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“do you want countries to force mandatory participation in armies like conscription so will be less Wars okay exactly the other thing is people thought that is a pacifist approach to not have you know mandatory service it's the worst possible thing you could do if you want to avoid war because you want people who vote in Congress for wars to have children or grandchildren or themselves as part of the you know endanger themselves definitely make people a lot more peaceful a lot more be seeking”

0.68

Science often comes from technology rather than the reverse; most sciences came from people doing something without knowing exactly why it worked, and then someone later claimed credit by 'lecturing birds how to fly'—retroactively explaining what was already discovered through practice.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“we had so much evidence from history that people had the illusion that technology comes from science ok when in fact science comes from technology more often except for well-advertised things most sciences came from technology in other words they started doing something didn't know exactly why it worked and then someone claimed credit later on what I call lecturing birds how to fly”

0.68

Virtue signaling without skin in the game (e.g., hotel towel reuse to 'save the planet') is cheap and self-serving; true virtue requires personal cost or risk; Socrates, journalists under oppressive regimes, and those who take intellectual risks by naming opponents are demonstrating actual virtue through skin in the game.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“every time I get them to a hotel room I get into it I don't know if you've seen me angry on Twitter I'm like that in person what I'm angry you know okay what sets me off is going in save our planet the others are saying really what is is this virtuous I think it makes it would make much more sense if they told us listen you know it's good for us if you save if you if you saved on towel it's good for us bar on wine okay so don't invoke the planet because as a you see so this is cheap cheap virtual signaling is actually the self-serving way is what we're getting into true virtue is respeaking socrates this is what we try to impart to the christ he really suffers and can't be God you know had to be human to suffer Socrates standing up for your ideas journalism when you know when you have an oppressive regime like in in Argentina or in in Latin America you know during these dark periods that is a risk taking and effectively the only way I can claim that imagine sailin entropy that a public intellectual is not a BS vendor as he or she takes risk with every statement”

0.68

Inequality is mismeasured by looking only at static snapshots; using dynamics (mobility, turnover), Google's time at the top has shrunk from 50-60 years for S&P 500 companies in the past to now 10-12 years, meaning the path from obscurity to dominance is short, and equally, the path from dominance to obscurity is short, which is healthy.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“finally when it comes to inequality there's something about inequality that's mismeasured and I said we have to use dynamics not statics people tolerate inequality if the person at the top got their VR is taking not rent-seeking and more significantly if he or she has a chance to collapse you see the company the the bad news for Google I mean Google is definitely a lot but good news for humanity and bad news for Google when I was an MBA student I'm very very old as you can see there then the company spent about 50 60 years and yes & p500 so was stable at the top how stable is it today less than keep going less than 30 keep going sorry 10 years 10 to 12 years I think maybe even its dropping all right you can't matter because a standard error in measurement okay we have a big statistical expert here my co-author will tell you that but we know there's definitely much lower and you can't take fluctuation but that basically tells you that the way from dorms to Google can only be short these guys want dorms no to Google can only be short it's the road from Google to dorms as equally so okay you have you need short route from the top okay and in fact if you have a short route from the top it doesn't take long Sears okay”

0.68

In-group and out-group distinctions exist at multiple layers (family, tribe, community), and these layers must maintain their own symmetry; when you remove layering and try to flatten to a single group level, systems fail because you lose the intermediate governance mechanisms.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“likewise in commerce okay if you don't have in groups and out groups and different layers things don't work because you don't have individual and then the rest of the world you have layers we have visual the family or whatever is the finances fat or her family the tribe whatever he or she defines his tribe and then you go up the layers and and that works a lot better because the tribes deal with one another the dynamics of tribes dealing with one another need to mirror the same symmetry”

0.68

You can predict the behavior of individuals but not the behavior of a group because a group is a different animal; ethical individuals placed in a group of 250 will avoid overfishing to protect future generations, but at group size 200,000 the same ethical individuals will overharvest resources because group dynamics change with scale.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“many levels for example I can predict how each and every one of you behave assuming I could do that but as a group I can't predict the behavior as a group because group is different animal likewise we know that if people are have all these ethical traits individually when we put them together in groups of 250 they will be very ethical and preserving the comments like fishermen not overfishing because you know harming future generation but when the group becomes 200 thousand it doesn't work see so that's one aspect of scalability that has a political implication”

0.68

There is no evidence of economies of scale for corporations; instead, there are diseconomies of scale, meaning larger corporations are less efficient than smaller ones in their operations.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“we have no evidence we've seen no evidence of economies of scale for being large as a matter of fact that they are diseconomies of scale”

0.66

Historically at all levels—economic, military, political—people with rank made decisions but were themselves exposed to harm from those decisions (e.g., feudal lords traded risk-taking for social status), but this pattern has recently broken down in modern institutions.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Nassim Taleb

“they're gonna use any excuse to to to warm our to become more mothers okay and then even will get leftist ideas okay because the the armed merchants know how to play the system and can take over humanitarian war maintained in war like in Libya change the regime right oh yeah but look we have democracy you kill everyone and say well look their cholesterol level improved so the that was used those metrics so the point is the that has this is very recent Hannibal first and battle Napoleon had to be more exposed than other soldiers and the English feudal system the Lord you're a lord because you are Lord because you're you take risk for others you trade a risk for social status very few societies had people of rank make decisions without being themselves exposed to to the harm from these decisions at all levels economic financial everything physical”

0.66

Truth has greater basin of attraction in history than BS; while BS takes lots of energy to displace, truth will eventually prevail unless it is actively harmful to survival.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Nassim Taleb

“it takes a lot more energy to displace BS the truth it's the opposite truth is as the basin of Attraction has been over history so it eventually thing revert to the truth from what there's also a mechanism I call the minority rule that makes things we've heard to the truth but but in history unless the truth is not helpful for survival you see the the it will it will you know unless it's really not helpful it's guaranteed to prevail eventually”

0.62

For individual investors, use a barbell strategy: ensure survival first and everything else later (via safe assets like T-bills and TIPS), then take all the risk you want with the remainder; this is different from taking moderate risk across the entire portfolio.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“so the whole thing is there's a slide here talk about fast dependence to make sure that that survival comes first and everything else later take all the risk you want but make sure you're there tomorrow it's a different class of risk-taking than the one that takes risk for small return but can blow you up completely”

0.62

It is a bad idea for political parties to propose lifetime bureaucrats as candidates because people instinctively detect lack of skin in the game; a genuine expert or risk-taker commands respect, while a careerist bureaucrat does not.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“which is a very bad idea for political parties to propose candidates who are lifetime bureaucrats you see and people detected like in Switzerland they try to pass a law to limit the income for chief executives but nobody thought of limiting the income of entrepreneurs why an entrepreneur takes risks chief executives someone who worked through the system and making seventy five times when an employee makes true the law didn't pass but that's a the idea behind it”

0.62

People should start businesses rather than work for NGOs because NGOs create problems to justify hiring more staff and flying executives in business class to Geneva; a business creates actual jobs and value, while NGOs are rent-seeking institutions that manufacture their own purpose.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“people ask me what should I be doing okay 20 and you know go somewhere start a business take risks now because everybody wants to work for a GMO to improve the world as you end up like the UN offices manufacturing problems to serve hire more staff will fly business class and have an apartment in Geneva or that kind of stuff start a business because we're tired of people who want to work for NGOs okay start a business create jobs for others okay and do not rent seek do not be in rent seeking I have some skin in the game just like you know your grandparents probably you rent one of your grandfather's I was 18 disembarking in Normandy it took a lot of risk these kids 18 year old okay take some risk starting business”

0.62

If someone makes money in an area and you don't understand how they do it, hire them; this is the green lumber problem—they may lack explanatory knowledge but have practical knowledge that works.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“likewise you want to funk people if they know how to write business plans know okay if they make money at something and you don't understand how hire them right it's a green lumber problem”

0.62

If you want to read a lot, adopt the rule: if something bores you, close the book and move to something else; most books are boring and don't survive, and you can develop a technique to read widely by following your interest.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“nice out there there's a simple rule if something bores you close the book that's it go to something else it's not that if you have to also say if you want to read a lot of stuff it's not that you need to stop reading because you're bored you're bored that specific author and then little by little you figure out how people get bored with but most books are boring and most books don't survive and you can tell that books that are boring don't survive I mean people may buy them for a while just to show off with them but so if something bores you skip it”

0.62

A system without skin in the game has a limited lifespan before it collapses; there is a rule of thumb for how long pseudo-expert systems can last before failure, which relates to their ability to create artificial classifications that don't correspond to reality.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“if you have a group of experts or pseudo experts that has no skin in the game you have a rule of thumb on how long they can last before it collapses definitely this is very excellent question because no system as I was saying about those people for example flying and universities now to create all these recreate classifications that didn't exist before okay can it survive no because you cannot use sometimes you read something that's completely BS that it takes a lot more energy to displace BS the truth it's the opposite truth is as the basin of Attraction has been over history so it eventually thing revert to the truth”

0.62

Historically most people didn't attend university but learned through apprenticeship; Germany today still maintains this apprenticeship model with 50% of youth participating; universities are maintained as 'prestige goods' but don't serve clear economic function.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“in the past most people didn't go to university people went and study the craft or a trade typically via that's Linde via a the apprenticeship mechanism and this is the apprenticeship mechanism okay and still in Germany today half the people go through some kind of apprenticeship so the the we have enough money to maintain prestige goods like Harvard okay and we tone backs but but it's not you know the society doesn't doesn't need these universities and they themselves are pricings himself out of the market”

0.62

Universities are turning into theology-selling institutions rather than theory-selling; example: French professors of French literature who speak broken French but write on postcolonial identity issues, gaining prestige through opaque jargon rather than actual knowledge of their domain.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“because of they turning into selling audiology rather than selling and our theory for example to give you an idea I've run into French professors of French literature who spoke broken French because they speak and then they have prestigious position because they write on some post-colonial aspect of the identity of this of this and in that French in Maupassant and that's how that is how they trust one another you see”

0.62

Harvard today is not Harvard of the past; the purpose has changed from a place for free people to seek knowledge to a credentialing system; Google no longer hires from universities, suggesting universities have become disconnected from economic reality.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“horrid today as Lindy has survived so long that several things number one Harvard today is not the way Harvard was in the past and the purpose of going to Harvard and a path was not the same purpose of going to Harvard today people had the illusion that universities started as a place for people to go read interesting books and then go home alright that was the university free people's liberal arts free people's art so it was like organized not as a professional thing you know like medical school like accounting school like vocational school but organized as a place for people to seek knowledge...and then but look at universities today these versus today I mean Google now no longer hires from universities”

0.62

Machine learning succeeds because it learns from inside (from data patterns) rather than from outside (from pre-specified features); similarly, people with skin in the game learn what matters by discovering it through practice, not by being told what matters by theory.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“with skin in the game you tend to know a lot of stuff about business about things right that you wouldn't guess you need to know from the outside and this is very hard to explain and this is why machine learning is successful become machine learning has no ideas doesn't learn is learn from the inside not from the outside”

0.60

Pseudo-left intellectuals lack real leftist traits and actually function like white supremacists through what they call identity politics (which Taleb frames as a form of racial segregation); real left and pseudo-left are completely different.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“well I mean this may be a transitory phenomenon it's very strange because people don't understand skin in the game now as an outcry against BS intellectuals who actually are sued or left typically when they're on the Left they're pseudo left because I really have all the traits of non left they want identity politics it's actually form of racial racial segregation in a way you know the way they define themselves is it's a white supremacist type saying whatever that everything they do is backwards okay but then there is a real left”

0.59

Academic economists lack contact with reality and don't have to be consistent; the Nobel Prize in economics has been awarded to two people making opposite claims, which would be impossible in physics or any field where claims have real-world consequences.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“this is the mind of an economist well that's a clarity of mind on a good day of an economist why because there's no contact with reality you don't have to be consistent so you can have the Nobel Prize given in the pseudo Nobel in economics given to two people saying opposite things you can't say I mean you can't do that and physically see those you throw the ball it goes up let's be hedged let's give them a well to both because the problem is you end up with a mind like this if you judge by by your peers not by experts”

0.57

Under conditions of high uncertainty, there is often moral certainty about what to do: if you receive a suspicious package from a war zone, you have absolute certainty that opening it is bad, even though you don't know precisely what will happen if you do; this principle of knowing what not to do under uncertainty pervades the book but took 25 years to articulate clearly.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“there is a lot of uncertainty in the world there's a lot more uncertainty than anything there is but the way to deal with such a certainty is unique so in other words there is a lot of certainty about how to act under conditions of uncertainty you see I'm a very simple example if you receive from Erica which is in Syria and Isis and Isis think a package all right written on it you know originates in Raqqa this is a package what do you do with it do you open it no so you have a lot of certainty what to do that package all right so under the moral certainty there is the more certainty there is what to do if you really don't know if the plane is robust you don't get on it okay so the moral certainty about the plane the more certainty but not getting on it”

0.56

Christology (the theological debate about the Trinity and Christ's nature) persists as a problem because it ultimately requires Christ to have suffered and been human rather than divine; a divine being would be like an acrobat with a parachute—eliminating risk and making the act meaningless—while genuine sacrifice requires genuine suffering.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Nassim Taleb

“and this explains christologies think about it why is it that we have the Trinity which absolute makes no sense to anyone outside the Christian religion why is it that we had to keep going back to the Trinity fights arguments debate debates in Greek that nobody could understand because it's translated into land be the same word kept going back that the Christ cannot be God let's think about it if this person had a parachute if an acrobat had walked in with a parachute would you pay for for that it'd be like a video game all right so the whole thing is you signal by risk-taking and the idea of Christology is is it really put skin in the game in in a daily so he's not God because he had to suffer if he didn't suffer it will be like a tomato you know and for an actor in the movie it's not tomato sauce it's not that doesn't work that way you see”

0.55

The Lindy Effect—derived from observations at a defunct New York restaurant—states that for non-perishable things, the longer something has existed, the longer it is expected to exist; thus, old ideas and technologies have survival advantages over new ones because what will be displaced is newer technology, not older.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Nassim Taleb

“the Lindy effect it was discovered in that restaurant by actors that plays because the the restaurant specialized and given a cheap coffee or undrinkable coffee to unemployed actors unemployed actors actors by the way are usually unemployed particular on Broadway so they've sit down and talk about plays all right so the they discovered that a play that had been around for 200 days had an extra 200 days of life pregnancy and thousand days thousand more days”

0.55

Universities will mutate back to apprenticeship models because peer-based credentialing without real-world feedback is not sustainable; this change is quiet sure to happen (inevitable).

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“so this is why it will go to mutate to the apprenticeship model back it's quiet sure I'm”

0.52

A book that can be summarized in two sentences will not survive, and a book that can be summarized is not worth reading, because a book must be a self-standing, irreducible item that cannot be reduced to an idea the way a painting is more than what it depicts.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“a book is not an idea and the first thing before we start I'm gonna discuss how I write okay how the whole body of work is organized and what is the insert though and why it's in a fractal organizing fractal way my idea that if a book can be summarized two things one it will not survive and the second thing is not worth reading”

0.52

To write something that will survive 20 years or more, ensure it could have been read and found interesting by someone 20 years ago; protect yourself backwards in time rather than forwards, because predicting what is new is impossible but you can predict that what is old and durable will continue to be durable.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“how do you make your book survive what's the trick if you want people to read your book ten years or 20 years from now if you won't have any chance of that happening that works but there's got to be something else what else sorry mmm that may work show that you is like the insert to is not body parts but it's one hole yes very good use old ideas the battle in the effect and old technology has a huge survival advantage of a new technology okay like I'm not saying that the future will not be technological but I'm saying that what will be displaced is a newer technology not the old technology so the way if you want to write something there can be read 20 years from now or hope the great friendship make sure it could be read by someone 20 years ago so protect yourself backwards in time it's much easier than go forward”

0.52

The ludic fallacy is the false assumption that probability, risk, and uncertainty encountered in real life have much in common with games, casinos, and formal games where rules are known and fixed; real-world risk differs fundamentally from ludic (game-based) risk.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“the ludecke fallacy is that the probability we or the risk and uncertainty that we encounter in real life has very little to do with thank you you incontinent casinos and games and ludic is game from game coming from games in Latin that's what I call the logic fallacy”

0.52

You cannot predict what new things will happen in the future (nobody predicted Google), but you can predict that what is recent will be replaced by something even more recent; therefore it is easier to predict that what is fragile can break than to predict specific future innovations.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“if you want to predict the future you can't predict what new will happen nobody predicted Google okay your grandparents didn't think that you guys would be wearing a gym clothes and you know with was the dog friendly Thanks delivering sushi for free okay and so and and cappuccino actually a very good cappuccino I mean I remember when I first came to New York how it tasted so your grandparents didn't predict that you cannot predict but you can predict something which is that what is a recent would be replaced by something more recent so it's easier to predict that what is fragile can break and what is by the Lindy effect”

0.52

Susan Sontag (intellectual) exhibited a lack of skin in the game: she publicly opposed markets while living in a $17 million Chelsea mansion; she refused to engage with Taleb during his first interview, dismissing him mid-sentence to humiliate him; this is hypocrisy between stated values and lived behavior.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Nassim Taleb

“I realized that for a long time people kept citing benda about what they call full-on sincere intellectual for intellectual and sincere intellectual for me like I have a say I named Susan Sontag Susan Sontag as an instance here intellectual had one day I was the first time I ever you know was ever interviewed in my life you know fubar randoms was out I was in a radio station at the BBC in the office in New York and she got developed interest this book writes a book on randomness oh very interesting ah you're in the markets I hate them the markets is explosive whatever went on and on on and on okay so trying to explain to her it's not rent-seeking but that she treated me like I was I was crap and and she left as I would mid-sentence as I was mid centers just to humiliate me okay so I said okay sure she probably does upstate New York Woodstock and the farms are more vegetables and she wants to live outside the market system and then orbit where he came she lived in seventeen million dollar mansion they're not here around here in Chelsea so you realize you know that's the absence can the game if you is fine to be against the market system but please live in a commune somewhere on the kibbutz in upstate New York eating radishes and stuff and that's fun I have respect for that okay but I don't have respect for the caviar that you know and then you extend the caviar intellectual tool of many many many things”

0.48

Skin in the game is multi-layered and cannot be fully explained because it has too many dimensions; different framings reveal different aspects—one approach is to contrast how Fat Tony (a practitioner) learns and views the world versus how a bureaucrat learns and views it.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“I have absolutely no idea what skin the game is about because every time I try to explain it I come up with a different story okay so it means it has a lot of layers multi layer okay the only problem is it doesn't have fat Tony my character of previous books because I killed them at the end of anti fragile and I and I couldn't really I didn't know how to get him back alright I had to I looked at how Gerald Holmes came back and it was anachronistic so III didn't know how to do it okay so so I'm sorry so for this episode of the insert Oh Fat Tony will be absent however is miss them will permeate the book so someone asked me what is Skinner game about that say about how Fat Tony learns things how he would view the world as compared to some bureaucrat simple okay so that's one one approach”

0.48

Nassim Taleb's approach is to tell people what he is doing (e.g., deadlifting and bearing the injuries from it) rather than telling them what they should do; this way he demonstrates skin in the game rather than preaching.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“and thanks because let me tell you something about that love thing I was no I was I had this motto screaming again that you should never tell people what they should be doing you should tell them what you're doing okay and I had the back injury when I was writing Angie fragile about seven years ago and I cured it basically by the dead lifting so and then I start discovering the value of intense heavy weight on on humans like the bone stuff like that and and reason I talk about my own dead lifting is only to say that asking the game I'm telling you I have the injuries of a dead laughter I'm telling you so I bear the risk of my advice”

0.48

The best way to kill a lot of people on a highway is to drive drunk against traffic at 50 mph; yet we don't hear about these incidents because the reckless driver is already dead—immediate feedback from reality selects against this behavior through natural consequences.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“when you get on a highway you know on Hudson you know you can you know get drunk to whatever some things that people do when they want to have fun or want to become reckless drivers and become a reckless driver go and the best way if you want to kill a lot of people is we go against traffic okay how 50 miles an hour against traffic why is it that we don't see we don't hear about these people it's a mystical punishment they're already dead visibly you know if you have these traits you're gonna you're more exposed you're exposed or even more exposed than than regular people”

0.48

A plumber is trusted and judged by their clients (reality), not by other plumbers, so plumbing has genuine expertise; contrast this with fields where practitioners are judged primarily by peers with no contact to reality.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“the this person I think is a plumber right our plumber is in trust by other plumbers or the judge by okay they're just by other promise no I know they're just by you your client okay very good so if you you know they may love you other plumbers but that's it so any business that where you have contact with reality inform your client judging you okay will has more you know has fewer expert what I call expert problem”

0.43

The reason Taleb insults people directly in his books and curses on Twitter is not cruelty but risk-taking; he is taking the risk of personal retaliation and social backlash by openly naming those he criticizes, thereby signaling he believes his claims.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“people ask me why am i insulting people directly in my books we're staking assuming that's simple it's not like I have nothing that I've never met Thomas Friedman actually I did once crossed I've had already insulted them in Davos and it was an eye contact that was okay that's but I never met many of the people I robbed Reuben had never met him okay but I want to take risks this is this is the idea I'm signaling why do I curse on Twitter not in my books because I don't like the aesthetics of a curse because it's risk-taking you see so that's simple”

0.20

The Incerto series is a sequence of fables, investigations, autobiographical essays, parables, philosophical and historical discussions organized fractally; it deals with opacity, luck, uncertainty, and probability in a form that resists reduction.

definitionspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Nassim Taleb

“the main idea of the insert oh if they settles for Astra so to describe it I say it's a series of fables whether what do I call it an investigation of opacity luck a certainty probability lalala okay in a form of personal essays was autobiographical sections stories parable philosophical historical and scientific discussion so basically it's a mishmash of thing that are thrown out to be readable for some okay well for at least they pay the price”