
Generosity, Cynicism, and the Future of Doing Good: A Conversation with Chris Anderson(Episode #349)
What this covers
This is a conversation between Sam Harris and Chris Anderson, the curator of TED, built around Anderson's book on generosity. It starts from a diagnosis: the early-2000s hope that the internet would spread freedom and bring people together has given way to disappointment, and a new cynicism now treats ESG, DEI and effective altruism as sanctimonious scams or virtue signaling. Anderson's answer is that anger and resentment have gone viral, but kindness can too. He also says that many people hold back from generosity because they fear being attacked for mixed motives.
The middle of the conversation covers the science and the philosophy. Anderson describes a "mystery experiment" in which 200 people in seven countries were given $10,000 and spent roughly two-thirds of it generously. Both men argue that the selfish gene is a misleading phrase, since selfish genes can build unselfish organisms. Harris presses the false opposition between selfishness and selflessness: wise self-interest already includes caring for others. Anderson calls bridging) across tribal lines a form of generosity and cites Daryl Davis, who befriended members of the Ku Klux Klan, as his example.
The conversation turns more contentious on culture and institutions. Anderson criticizes the language of DEI as tribal and self-referential. He also describes the controversy at TED over Coleman Hughes's talk advocating color-blindness), and the left's objection that such policies have not eliminated racial injustice. Later they discuss giving at scale: orders-of-magnitude differences in charitable cost-effectiveness, Paul Bloom's case against empathy as a guide, the strengths and failures of effective altruism after Sam Bankman-Fried, and the ethics of billionaire philanthropy. Harris also uses his own podcast, with its voluntary-subscription model, as a case study in the confusions that can discourage opt-in support.
Anderson argues that generosity is both biologically hardwired and culturally amplifiable through digital platforms, and that viewing giving through a lens of mixed motives and measurable results—rather than demanding purity—unlocks greater social good and personal fulfillment.
- Humans evolved as a cooperative species with genuine capacity for altruism, not merely selfish survival machines
- Generosity produces measurable ripple effects online and offline, multiplied by internet leverage
- Mixed motives in giving are inevitable and desirable; purity is a false ideal that paralyzes action
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
There is a gap between people's intuitive generosity instincts and their reasoned behavior around giving, with loss aversion often preventing people from acting on generous impulses, but the payoff from generosity in terms of fulfillment is reliable even if not felt in the moment.
“there are indelible profound links between generosity and happiness. But I think they're often hidden and we in the moment when we're thinking about being generous, what we're actually also aware of is the fear of loss...you can be pretty sure that afterwards you'll get payback. It will there will be a feeling of fulfillment.”
Anderson cites Daryl Davis, an African American who built a friendship with KKK leadership, attended KKK rallies, and helped a leader leave the organization, as a modern hero of bridging and the kind of generosity of listening and understanding across tribal lines that society needs more of.
“the story in the book of of this African American Daryl Davis who was puzzled why people hated him because of his skin color you know and invited the local leader of the Ku Klux Klan to to a meeting ended up forming a relationship with him...his his story you know became widely reported and inspired many others. I mean people like him I think are rare modern heroes that we need so so many more of”
Without the ability to listen to each other and work together across tribal divides, humanity will be unable to solve major future challenges including climate change, global wars, and artificial intelligence risks.
“if we can't figure out how to start listening to each other, talking to each other, working together, collaborating, we're not going to be able to solve any of the giant problems that that the future is is sort of throwing up”
In the 'mystery experiment,' 200 people across seven countries and different income levels were given $10,000 with no strings attached, and they spent approximately two-thirds of that money generously, which contradicts rational agent economic theory predictions of purely selfish spending.
“200 people on the internet were given $10,000 out of the blue, told no strings attached, you just have to tell us what you spend it on. And they ended up spending 2/3 of that money generously...This held across seven countries and different income levels”
There is a biological mechanism whereby humans experience uplift and increased generosity when witnessing other people being generous, creating a ripple effect of generosity.
“There's a third biological piece that is the the feeling we get when we see other people being generous. There's a sort of feeling of uplift that also increases levels of generosity.”
The techno-optimism of the early 2000s, which framed the internet as bringing people together and spreading freedom and democracy, has been replaced by a narrative of disappointment as social media and political division have produced the opposite effect.
“the techno-optimism of say the early 2000s, when it really seemed like you could frame the internet, for example, as bringing the world together...the narrative of the last 10 years has been the opposite of that...the internet was not doing what we thought it would do. It was actually helping engender the opposite.”
Around the rise of social media and the election of Donald Trump, the world became highly divided, and the most fervent conversations became tribal fights where picking a side and being angry at the other side became the dominant pattern.
“somewhere around somewhere around the rise of social media, the election of Donald Trump, the world became very very very divided and it was it was almost the only thing you could be was to pick a tribe and then fight and and be really annoyed at at the other side. And those were the most sort of fervent conversations.”
Humans have evolved mechanisms for trust and belief in each other that enabled cooperation and sharing, which is at the heart of civilization and everything humans have built.
“Humans along with several other species have developed this as a kind of superpower and and it's that that has enabled basically everything that we've done by being the cooperating species that that that learned to for example, you know, share bounty of hunting or whatever back in the day and learned mechanisms for for trust and belief in each other. It's it's that that I think is at the heart of everything that we have built. It's at the heart of civilization.”
The phrase 'selfish gene' is a misnomer that has misled many people into thinking human nature is fundamentally selfish and that altruism is an illusion, when actually selfish genes can and do build unselfish organisms.
“this opposition between selfishness and and selflessness is fairly spurious...the selfish gene which you know, it almost was almost an afterthought for you when when Dawkins could have named it the immortal gene or the eternal gene...doesn't mean that we're capable of altruism obviously”
DEI language has become tribalistic and self-referential, alienating people outside the movement with its perceived sing-song nature, making it impossible to have substantive discussion about the real underlying injustices it was originally designed to address.
“the language of DEI has become its own sort of sing-song thing that is is almost invisible to the people who are in it and it just sounds so exhausting and and mind-numbing and and annoying to people who aren't...you couldn't even have a discussion about the actual merits of the case”
Paul Bloom's book 'Against Empathy' argues that empathy alone is insufficient for good decision-making in philanthropy because there are so many resources in the world that spending them wisely requires reason, not just emotional responsiveness to immediate tragedy.
“Paul Bloom wrote this book against empathy which was kind of trying to argue that too much of that is not it you know, it doesn't get us where we need to go because there are so many resources in the world. It actually really is important that we spend them wisely”
Effective altruism's core contribution is the principle that altruism should be effective, and asking whether giving is wise is the right question, even though some specific EA recommendations have changed over time as evidence evolves.
“if you just ask the question, do we want our altruism to be effective? Well, yes, I think we do...what they're anchored in is the desire to figure out what is a wise way to give. And when you put it that way, that is absolutely the right question to ask.”
Humans evolved the capacity for unselfishness and altruism because selfish genes can build unselfish organisms, and unselfishness became a successful strategy for survival if it could spread across a species through mechanisms like group selection or reciprocal altruism.
“it was possible for selfish genes to evolve unselfish people, to build unselfish people and that you could that unselfishness was actually a brilliant way of surviving if it could spread, you know, across a species”
There are orders of magnitude differences in cost-effectiveness between different ways of spending money on charity, such that spending money 'smartly versus stupidly' can produce vastly different results for the same dollar amount.
“there are orders of magnitude difference between spending money smartly and spending it stupidly”
Coleman Hughes's TED Talk advocated for color-blindness as a policy approach, which the left views as ineffective based on decades of evidence that color-blind policies have not eliminated racial injustice, whereas color-bold policies (actively seeking diverse candidates) have proven more effective.
“One one narrative is that we, you know, you know, invited a controversial man to Ted to give a talk about he made the case for color blindness. On the left, this is seen as a super controversial... the left the view is that color-blind policies over decades have been proven not to work.”
There is a new spirit of cynicism surrounding efforts to do good in the world, particularly in tech and finance, where activities like ESG, effective altruism, and DEI are viewed by influential people as sanctimonious scams and mere virtue signaling rather than genuine efforts to help.
“almost any conspicuous efforts to do good in the world now seem suspect...this relates to various degrees to things like ESG...effective altruism, DEI...all of this stuff amounts to little more than a sanctimonious scam. It's all all just virtue signaling.”
Sam Harris's podcast business model revealed a flaw in opt-in donation models: people who might support the podcast hesitated due to confusion about its costs, expected earnings, and impact—confusions that wouldn't occur with standard business transactions.
“someone said, well, I would support the podcast if I knew what he was going to do with the money. And another person said, well, I I I would support the podcast if I knew how much it cost to run a podcast. And another person said, well, you know, I would support the podcast if I knew how much I thought a person should earn from a podcast. Right? And I looked at those three statements and I mean my head practically fell off my shoulders because I realized I mean at a glance there was something deeply wrong here because these are the kinds of considerations that would never have occurred to a person when they were thinking about buying my next book”
Finding leverage points in giving—ways to amplify impact through technology, policy, education, or ideas—is more difficult but more satisfying than direct giving that provides immediate emotional reward, yet both have value.
“when you spend money you're you're looking for what is it that makes this a good value for money? You know, can you leverage technology? Can you leverage government policy? Can you leverage the internet? Can you leverage education and and knowledge? And I think when you find something that really where you get wow, that organization is being really smart about how they're spending their money. It's it's very exciting”
Nasty things (fear, resentment, disgust, anger) have gone viral online in the last decade, but good things (generosity, compassion, kindness) have equal potential to go viral with proper framing and effort by people of goodwill.
“just as nasty things have gone viral online in the last decade especially, fear, resentment, disgust, anger, there it is also possible for really good things to go viral. There is no reason why they shouldn't.”
Generosity and care for others produce happiness and self-actualization, so the opposition between selfishness and selflessness is false—wise selfishness contains all prosocial and self-sacrificing attitudes because such attitudes are actually in one's long-term self-interest.
“caring about others is a very good strategy for caring about yourself...your actualization entails this capacity to genuinely care about other people and to genuinely love them and feel rewarded by your moral concern for them...wise selfishness, which contains all of the prosocial and even self-sacrificing attitudes”
Many people are fearful of being generous or vocal about generosity precisely because they are afraid of being attacked for having mixed motives, so the cynicism about mixed motives actually inhibits generosity.
“a lot of people are fearful of doing or certainly fearful of saying anything for precisely the reason that they're going to get shot at. It's crazy. It's really crazy.”
Anderson argues that being generous is an 'amazing strategy' for any person or organization because the effects (reputation boost, good outcomes) can far exceed the costs, and rather than criticizing people for benefiting from generosity, we should celebrate it to encourage more of it.
“Generosity is actually an amazing strategy for any person, any organization, any company. You give away stuff and you know, incredible things can happen as a result. It can boost your reputation...rather than criticizing people for that, we should celebrate it because we want more of that. We don't want less of that”
Sam Harris increased his impact on the world by at least an order of magnitude when he moved from selling books to giving his podcast away for free while still maintaining financial sustainability through voluntary subscriptions.
“you took a risk at some point and put all your time and effort into, you know, giving away...you discovered was that your impact on the world increased by at least an order of magnitude”
Harris's core principle is that money should never be the reason someone cannot access his podcast or meditation app, motivated by the belief that access to useful content and ideas is important for its own sake.
“I'm very committed to money never being the reason why someone can't get access to what I'm doing because it's it's important that that not be the reason”
Ideas are supposed to be able to leap from one tribe to another, and this cross-tribal transmission of ideas is one of humanity's most important superpowers, which is lost if tribes become hermetically sealed.
“Ideas are supposed to be able to leap from one tribe to another. That's the whole reason they're powerful and if we if we give up that connectivity we're giving up one of humanity's most important superpowers.”
Harris argues that intentions matter ethically because they predict future behavior: if someone gives only to burnish reputation, you can predict they'll be 'blown around by whatever incentives aim at burnishing their reputation' and therefore won't be reliable partners in the broader project of reducing suffering.
“if someone's giving, you know, to a cause simply to burnish the reputation, that's all they care about and they don't really care about alleviating human suffering or doing any other good in the world, well then if that's what they care about, you can predict in the future that they are going to go, you know, they're going to be blown around by whatever incentives aim at burnishing their reputation, right? And they're not they're not going to be reliable partners in the in the project of reducing human suffering because that's not what they care about”
Harris notes that when you look at the public figure Trump and his half-country following, the appeal of naked selfishness is that it makes hypocrisy impossible—you can't be a hypocrite if you make no claims to virtue—whereas virtue claims create vulnerability to accusations of moral inconsistency.
“if you can be just you just nakedly selfish and merely selfish, one of the superpowers you acquire is that it's impossible to be a hypocrite. And it's it's the moments of hypocrisy that many people have found so despicable in our efforts to do good”
Harris argues that making Coleman Hughes the focus of racial identity politics is a tragic 'opportunity cost' because Hughes is a brilliant thinker with much to contribute on topics beyond race, and restricting him to race commentary because of his race perpetuates exactly the kind of racial essentialism he criticizes.
“it will soon become a travesty if a man of Coleman's intelligence has to spend all of his time, most of his time, even much of his time talking about race simply because he's black. He's He has so much more to contribute on so many other topics. It's a massive opportunity cost”
Anderson notes that when people speak passionately about social justice but use language that triggers tribal responses, they lose the people they most need to persuade, so effective social change requires attention to language that can bridge rather than divide.
“it is pointless having a talk about social justice if the people you want to persuade aren't aren't going to hear it because of the because of the language. And so we have to get the language side right”
The Kantian ideal of pure generosity—giving without any mixture of self-interest, reputation benefit, or hedonic reward—is impossible to achieve and is a false ideal that inhibits actual giving.
“we have to let go of this idea of perfect generosity. It never was perfect and in in the modern era there actually more reasons than ever to look at the effects of generosity”
The distinction between selfish versus selfless motivation is less important than attention to actual results and effects, and it's possible for someone with purely selfish motives (a sociopath) to produce good by building a hospital, such that the good outcome is valuable even if the motive is not.
“if some sociopath is going to give you a $100 million to build a hospital, it's still you still get a hospital. but I wouldn't I don't think you have to describe that as as generosity.”
TED has intentionally shifted toward platforming more centrist and right-of-center voices in recent years to counter what Anderson characterizes as an overrepresentation of progressive voices in the height of political division.
“it's true that in the political in the height of the sort of political division, when we did stuff that was political, most of it came from the progressive side of the equation...We are fighting to address that...we are we are absolutely committed to a broader open tent”
Harris believes color-blindness as a long-term aspiration—where race becomes morally irrelevant like hair color—is correct, but notes that people who opposed Coleman's talk may actually share this long-term vision while disagreeing on tactics for reaching it.
“I hope that someday skin color is like hair color or eye color, right? Where we get to a place where no one would even think to ask...I would bet anything that there are times when you look at your podcast lineup and say, I can't just have a a lineup of of white guys”
TED's position is that it is non-partisan and committed to platforming ideas worth debating from across the political spectrum, not just ideas worth spreading, and that controversy itself doesn't disqualify an idea from being shared.
“TED is non-partisan...we're ideas worth debating. You often don't know whether an idea is worth spreading in the current environment. You have to really hammer it out.”
Harris maintains a dedicated customer service team of 30-35 people to manage free scholarship accounts, with 95% of their work devoted to processing free account requests, including periods during COVID when 1,000 people per day requested free accounts.
“I staff literally full-time something like 30 or 35 people in the customer service and 95% of what they do is just minister to free accounts. And there were days during COVID where 1,000 people would send that email a day”
Harris made a 10% giving pledge to donate pre-tax income to the most effective charities, and then gives beyond that to causes he finds emotionally compelling (like individual GoFundMe stories), which he views as both satisfying his commitment to effectiveness and his desire for emotional reward.
“I took the their 10% pledge to give, you know, 10% of all pre-tax dollars to the most effective charities. And so, I do that, but then I give more than that and I consider that the those gifts, you know, to the one person with a GoFundMe who has some truly tragic story...that wouldn't survive an EA analysis, but it's something that I really want to do”
TED struggled internally with whether to include Coleman Hughes's color-blindness talk in its popular podcast, with team members uncomfortable about it; the decision to exclude it from the podcast for a time resulted in artificially low view counts that later led Hughes to publicly question whether TED was suppressing his ideas.
“Some people in the community were really upset by it, it's true to say. That meant that we had some people internally were were troubled at the notion of pushing it out online and wondered whether we should whether it really was an idea worth spreading.”
Anderson had a religious background where he believed altruism and conscience were only possible through belief in God, but discovered through science that unselfishness could emerge from evolutionary mechanisms and that humans developed generosity as a cooperative superpower.
“my background was religious and um as I one thing that kept me in the church for a long time was the belief that there was no basis for generosity or kindness or goodness or altruism outside a belief in God...it was the most thrilling discovery to realize that actually it was possible for selfish genes to evolve unselfish people”
Harris argues that most of the recent failures of altruism-aligned initiatives (Sam Bankman-Fried, DEI bureaucrats who couldn't condemn antisemitism, billionaires flying private jets to climate conferences) were failures of hypocrisy and inconsistency rather than failures of the underlying altruistic goal.
“you have someone like Sam Bankman-Fried or you have the DEI bureaucrats who are apparently unable to condemn calls for genocide against the Jews. It's just very easy to see what is wrong here. I mean, I'm thinking of one with with with respect to ESG now. You have I guess you you know, you had the spectacle of you know, lots of right-thinking people flying their on their private jets to a climate conference, right?”
Anderson, as a philosophy student, spent hours trying to solve the logical problem that even obeying conscience 'feels good,' which technically means it contains selfish motivation, making pure unselfishness impossible to define or achieve.
“As a as a philosophy student, I literally would lie on the floor of my room for hours at a time trying to figure this one out because the notion of like I I wanted to be a good person, but to be good without external motivation, to be purely good, I couldn't see how that happened. Like even if you were just trying to obey the call of conscience, wasn't it true that obeying the call of conscience in a sense felt good?”
Harris believes cultural relativism is a disastrous philosophy and that morality can and should be built from the ground up based on science and what we know about human nature, which opens the door to moral progress.
“the notion of building a morality from from the ground up based on science, based on what we know about human nature...I actually believe that because it's that's what opens the door to moral progress...I don't I think cultural relativism is a disastrous philosophy.”
Harris dislikes aspects of many religions, particularly what he views as the disempowering effect of fatalism ('inshallah'—God's will) that can undermine people's agency and motivation to improve their circumstances.
“I do dislike huge aspects of of actually lots of religions and I I think living for you know, paradise rather than the the current world is incredibly incredibly dangerous. I think the whole inshallah, you know, if it is is can be a very disempowering way to live where people give up trying because they just oh well, you know, God will do whatever he will do.”
Harris argues that most people actually share an unspoken desire to be in the center between tribes and to solve problems collaboratively, but the social cost of being visible in that center position (attack from both sides) is so high that few people occupy it.
“I think most people in America, in Europe, in the world, are not at the extreme ends of the of of of the spectrum here. I think most people actually would, if they could find a way, like to embrace a more centrist position. The trouble is that if you put your head above the parapet, you get it blown off by both sides”
Harris notes that the controversy around Coleman Hughes's color-blindness talk is revealing because the talk itself was so mild and traditional (essentially restating MLK's dream) that if Harris gave the same talk, he would receive more criticism, suggesting the response was not about the substance of the argument but about racial identity signaling.
“had a white guy given that same talk, had I had the temerity to come back and give a talk on color blindness, you would have received much more controversy and I would have received much less defense than Coleman did. Yeah. Purely but based on the color of our our skins. And that makes no sense because the argument stands or falls on its merits”
In practice, we never know anyone's true intentions, so the appropriate response is to look for the good in others' motives rather than the bad, since people's intentions are almost always mixed and we have no reliable way to discern the ratio.
“We actually never know that. But it's still good it achieves good... the truth is that in almost every circumstance, we don't know. I think people's intentions are almost always mixed. I think most people their main focus is the giving away of the money in the hope that it will do something”
Anderson's foundation for years could not identify what causes excited him about giving until he came to TED and discovered that leveraging the power of ideas gave him a different kind of deep satisfaction than direct charity, even without the immediate emotional reward of helping a family in need.
“I had a foundation and for years I was I couldn't figure out what to spend the money on that that got me excited. Coming to TED, I I suddenly found wow, okay, I get this. I'm leveraging the power of ideas...It didn't give me the kind of here's a family crying and I'm I can do something about it kind of feels, but it gave me a a different kind of satisfaction”
Some critics of color-blindness not only believe it doesn't work as policy, but appear to want to enshrine racial differences as permanent and important, which Harris equates with white supremacist logic that similarly treats race as indelible and fundamental.
“The people who reacted so badly to Coleman's talk are people who not only don't think we can get there fast enough by pretending to be color blind, they don't even want to get there, apparently. They want to enshrine these differences among people as indelible, as true for all time... The only other people who want to do that in our society are white supremacists”
Anderson lived for years as a kid growing up in Afghanistan and Pakistan with many Muslims, and developed respect for some genuinely spiritual Muslims and Muslim women who preferred aspects of conservative Muslim culture to what they perceived as excessive Western public sexuality.
“I was a kind of ex- missionary kid if you like...I had lived for years as a kid growing up in Afghanistan and Yeah. Pakistan with a lot of Muslims...there I just got to know many super spiritual Muslims and and many Muslim women who actually liked aspects of the conservatism of Muslim culture and and preferred it to the sort of uh you know, the the excesses of the West if you like, the excessive public sexuality of of the West.”
Anderson discovered in his early engagement with science that there was an abundance of amazing things happening—evolutionary biology, and many other fields—that he hadn't previously discovered, which provided intellectual respite from the emotional pain of the dot-com crash.
“I got survived it, I think by reading and getting just entering remembering how amazing the world of ideas is and how much cool science was happening. I hadn't really discovered evolutionary biology. I had there were so many things that I got into for the first time.”
Harris initially responded to his first TED Talk with intervention from Anderson, but their subsequent private and podcast conversations about Islam and religion have allowed them to hash out disagreements, and they have developed respect despite initial tensions around how to discuss Islam and religious criticism.
“you came up on stage afterwards and tried to perform a bit of an intervention...we've since talked a fair amount about Islam and and my approach to criticizing it...we've hashed that out on your podcast and and in private”
Coleman Hughes received a standing ovation from some people at the conference for his color-blindness talk, indicating that his message resonated with a significant portion of the TED audience despite the controversy.
“at the conference there was a there was a standing ovation for the talk from some people. Some people were really delighted.”
Harris does not consciously aim for demographic diversity in his podcast guest selection, instead selecting guests based on topics and individuals who have caught his attention, though he acknowledges he has received criticism for lacking diversity.
“I simply reach out for the next topic of interest or the next person who's caught my attention...I've been pointed out to me that, you know, I don't have enough people of color, I don't have enough women, or etc. etc. And so I've heard that criticism.”
Chris Anderson lost approximately $1 million per day on average over 18 months during the dot-com crash, experiencing a severe decline in his net worth despite initially hitting a $1 billion valuation on paper.
“for 18 months I basically lost an average a million dollars a day”