unit banking
A banking structure in which each bank operates as a single standalone office prohibited from opening branches, leaving it tied to one local economy and unable to diversify risk.
As defined in Charles Calomiris and Stephen Haber on Fragile by Design
Where it comes up · 4
- Charles Calomiris and Stephen Haber on Fragile by Design6 claims
- Thomas Rustici on Smoot-Hawley and the Great Depression 01/04/20104 claims
- Charles Calomiris on the Financial Crisis 10/26/20093 claims
- Larry White on Hayek and Money 02/01/20101 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “unit banking” →
- Banking panics and waves of large bank failures are distinct phenomena that only sometimes overlap; the Fed's 1913 founding genuinely reduced US panics by stabilizing seasonal reserve fluctuations (tied to the cotton market) made acute by America's peculiar unit-banking structure, but the US did not historically suffer the large-loss bank-failure crises seen elsewhere, so the Fed's panic-prevention role is separate from the over-speculation/large-loss problem.Charles Calomiris on the Financial Crisis 10/26/2009
- Canada, with a branch-banking system from the 1860s and no central bank until 1935, experienced none of the panics the US suffered (1873, 1884, 1890, 1893, 1896, 1907), demonstrating that US panics stemmed from the fragility of its unit-banking structure rather than from an inherent need for central banking.Charles Calomiris on the Financial Crisis 10/26/2009
- The agrarian-unit-banker coalition fell apart because technology (networked ATMs and computer credit assessment let banks evaluate borrowers at distance and skirt branching laws, upheld when the Supreme Court ruled in 1985 an ATM is not a branch) plus 1970s inflation that made Regulation Q-capped deposit rates strongly negative, driving deposits into money market funds and triggering the S&L Crisis.Charles Calomiris and Stephen Haber on Fragile by Design
- Unit banking means banks were constrained by regulation to operate in only one location, producing over 20,000 highly undiversified banks unable to coordinate responses to shocks, which made agricultural shocks systemically destabilizing.Charles Calomiris on the Financial Crisis 10/26/2009
- The 19th-century US had tens of thousands of banks unable to open branches, meaning each bank was tied to its local economy, could not move funds during runs, could not spread risk across regions, and could not capture scale economies—making the system inefficient and crisis-prone.Charles Calomiris and Stephen Haber on Fragile by Design
- By the 1980s the globalization of finance led US banks to lose market share both internationally and domestically as Japanese, German, and British banks entered the US; figures like Greenspan articulated that the US needed an efficient banking system to remain a global player, which combined with demographics, ATMs, and the S&L crisis to finally enable nationwide branch banking via 1994 federal law.Charles Calomiris and Stephen Haber on Fragile by Design
- US Federalism let unit banking persist about 150 years because states had authority over banking rules and could restrict out-of-state banks, so agrarian interests only had to win battles at the state level—far easier than a centralized fight—making a nationwide branch banking system very hard to establish.Charles Calomiris and Stephen Haber on Fragile by Design
- Pre-Fed US banking instability, such as the 1907 Knickerbocker Trust panic and state bank failures in the 1920s, reflected government policy failures, and the unit-banking and branching restrictions amplified losses rather than market forces causing them.Thomas Rustici on Smoot-Hawley and the Great Depression 01/04/2010
- Unit banking laws barring out-of-state branching and branch banking had no efficiency or stability rationale; they were a political arrangement benefiting local unit bankers with captive monopoly markets and prosperous local farmers who had a captive lender, at the cost of everyone else and system stability.Charles Calomiris and Stephen Haber on Fragile by Design
- Texas unit-banking laws caused two-thirds of its banks to fail when oil prices fell, because the banks were undiversified—almost all their loans were to oil-related industry or real estate—demonstrating how prohibitions on branching create fragility.Larry White on Hayek and Money 02/01/2010