substratum
An underlying substance or ultimate reality of which all other qualities are properties; Huayan Buddhism denies any such ultimate substratum exists.
As defined in 319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World
Where it comes up · 2
- A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism7 claims
- 319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “substratum” →
- Berkeley extends his argument against abstract ideas to argue that we have no abstract idea of matter itself, since Locke conceded that matter is 'something I know not what'—an unknown substratum. Similarly, we have no abstract ideas of space or time as such, only of particular spatial relationships and durations.A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism
- Berkeley employs three arguments against Locke's representative realism: (1) unperceived things (Locke's unknown substratum of matter) have no reference and no empirical meaning; (2) ideas are mental things, and by the principle that the cause must be like the effect, ideas must have mental causes; (3) primary and secondary qualities are inseparable in experience and both relative to the perceiver, so neither can be objectively real.A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism
- Berkeley is not claiming that ordinary objects like hands, castles, or alarm clocks are illusions; rather, he is claiming that the independently existing material substratum traditionally postulated by materialists has no empirical evidence and therefore should be rejected, while the experiences of these objects remain fully real.A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism
- Leibniz opposed mechanistic science by denying that matter in the Newtonian sense is the ultimate real or basic substratum, instead proposing that the basic stuff of reality consists of monads as units of force or energy, a position that is realist but about energetics rather than mechanistic physics.A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism
- Samuel Johnson's refutation of Berkeley by kicking a rock and claiming the pain was real misses Berkeley's point: Berkeley agrees the pain is real and involuntary (not imagined), but the question is what causes the pain—whether it requires a material substratum or can be caused by God.A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism
- If both primary and secondary qualities are relative and subjective, then there is no empirical evidence for the existence of matter as an objectively real substratum independent of perception. This conclusion follows from rigorous empiricism applied to Locke's own framework.A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism
- In Huayan Buddhism, things are defined entirely by their relational qualities with no ultimate substratum—'turtles all the way down'—a view illustrated by the Rafter Dialogue where a rafter is the building and the building is the rafter because identity depends on relational roles and parts, paralleling how even one's physical existence is relational through quantum entanglement, gravity, and causal history back to the Big Bang.319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World
- Plotinus and the Platonic tradition are phenomenalist in character because matter has no independent existence in that framework—rather, as one descends the hierarchy of being through emanations, one approaches nonbeing, with no substratum of reality called matter at the lower levels.A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism