Samuel Johnson's refutation of Berkeley by kicking a rock and claiming the pain was real misses Berkeley's point: Berkeley agrees the pain is real and involuntary (not imagined), but the question is what causes the pain—whether it requires a material substratum or can be caused by God.

normativepending

Speaker

Unknown Lecturer

Evidence Quote

“yes it's what we call quote real because it was an involuntary kind of pain”

Source

A History of Philosophy | 44 George Berkeley's Idealism— wheatoncollege
Created: 8/10/2026, 11:17:52 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...