319 | Bryan Van Norden on Philosophy From the Rest of the World
What this covers
Sean Carroll interviews Bryan Van Norden, a philosopher trained at Stanford who now teaches at Vassar and Wuhan University, about the geographic narrowness of philosophy as it is taught and studied in English-speaking institutions. Van Norden argues that the common belief philosophy originated uniquely in ancient Greece is a relatively recent invention tied to 19th-century pseudoscientific racism, and that non-Western philosophical traditions—Chinese, Indian, Africana, indigenous—contain rigorous arguments deserving serious engagement. The conversation traces how this narrowing happened, what alternative traditions offer, and why broadening philosophy's scope would strengthen the discipline itself rather than dilute it.
The discussion ranges from historical recovery to substantive philosophical comparison. Van Norden notes that pre-19th-century European sources typically credited philosophy's origins to India or Africa; the Greece-only narrative emerged during the era of Western imperialism, when racial ideology demanded justification for dominance. He then moves into the actual philosophy: the School of Names anticipated Wittgenstein and Quine on the Indeterminacy of Reference; Nagasena's chariot argument on No-Self (Anatta)) in the Questions of King Milinda stands alongside Descartes as a rigorous account of personal identity; and wu wei—spontaneous correct action—parallels Aristotle's mature virtue. Van Norden also frames a deeper tension: Western philosophy assumes the individual as ultimately real (creating the problem of why one should care about others), while Chinese thought takes things as interconnected parts of a whole (creating the opposite problem). He argues that logical positivism, once a political weapon against fascism, was repackaged in America as apolitical technicality, and that contemporary philosophy's retreat into narrow formal debates has left it vulnerable to the charge that it serves no public purpose.
Van Norden argues that the idea philosophy began uniquely in ancient Greece is a relatively recent invention rooted in pseudoscientific racism, and that the 'less commonly taught philosophies' (Chinese, Indian, Africana, indigenous) contain rigorous arguments that should be brought into dialogue with the Western tradition to improve philosophy itself.
- Pre-19th-century European sources commonly held that philosophy originated in India or Africa, not uniquely in Greece
- Non-Western texts like the School of Names and the Questions of King Milinda contain sophisticated arguments comparable to Wittgenstein, Quine, and Descartes
- Philosophy's own commitment to interrogating presuppositions implies it should welcome alternative traditions
Chinese and Indian philosophical traditions contain sophisticated arguments that rival or prefigure Western philosophy.
- In Huayan Buddhism, things are defined entirely by their relational qualities with no ultimate substratum—'turtles all the way down'—a view illustrated by the Rafter Dialogue where a rafter is the building and the building is the rafter because identity depends on relational roles and parts, paralleling how even one's physical existence is relational through quantum entanglement, gravity, and causal history back to the Big Bang.
“you get in Huayan Buddhism this notion that things are defined by their relational qualities. And in a sense, it's turtles all the way down, in the sense there are just things in relation to other things, but those things are defined by their own relational qualities. And there's no ultimate substratum”
- The Chinese School of Names made a serious philosophical point—anticipating Wittgenstein and Quine—that the reference of terms cannot be ultimately fixed, because one must already deploy the mechanism of reference to identify reference itself, and this debate underlies the Daoist claim in the Tao Te Ching that 'a way that can be spoken of is not a constant way.'
“anything you can refer to is a referent, but reference is not a referent... I think they're making a deep point that was also made by both Wittgenstein and Quine in different ways, which is that there's no way to fix the reference of terms”
- Nagasena's chariot argument in the Questions of King Milinda shows there is no self as a thing: just as 'chariot' is merely a linguistic convention for a collection of parts (not the wheels, not the parts taken together, not something beyond them), 'Nagasena' is just a label for a collection of parts, demonstrating there is no substantial self—an argument that, read alongside Descartes's Meditations, makes Descartes's case for the self look less compelling.
“we use the word chariot when a certain collection of parts are present. And he said, So likewise, we use the name Nagasena when a certain collection of parts is present but there is no thing that is Nagasena”
- Chinese and Western philosophy are more formally similar than stereotypes suggest: the Analects resemble Wittgenstein's aphoristic style, Chinese philosophy uses dialogues (like Plato, Berkeley, Hume), essays, and commentary on classics (like Aquinas's Summa), revealing 'similarities in differences and differences in similarities.'
“The writing structure in many ways is like Wittgenstein, either of the Tractatus or the Philosophical Investigations. And a lot of Chinese philosophy is in the form of dialogue, like Plato wrote dialogue”
- Contrary to the traditional account presenting Confucius and Lao Tzu as near-contemporary founders of Confucianism and Daoism, Daoism was not an organized movement until long after Lao Tzu (if he existed), and the Tao Te Ching is best read as responding to the later crisis in philosophy of language raised by the School of Names.
“if you read the Tao Te Ching, it's really a work that is responding to this later crisis in the philosophy of language raised by the School of Names. And you can't understand what they're doing unless you read it in that context.”
- Wu wei (non-action / spontaneous correct action) in Confucianism, Daoism, and Buddhism—doing the right thing spontaneously without deliberation—parallels Aristotle's view that the highest virtue is so habituated that one performs it spontaneously, such as honestly giving correct change without weighing whether to cheat.
“in both traditions, you find it very clearly in thinkers like Aristotle, that the highest virtue is ultimately something that you become so habituated to that you do it spontaneously... Well, that's wu-wei. That's non-action.”
The Greco-centric philosophical canon was constructed by racist ideology, not historical fact or philosophical superiority.
- As late as the early 18th century, the most common views in European philosophy textbooks were that philosophy originated in South Asia (India) or Africa and was given as a gift to the ancient Greeks, or originated independently in both and given to Greece—not that it originated uniquely in Greece.
“the most common views in Europe were that philosophy began in either South Asia... from, say, India, philosophy was given as a gift to the ancient Greeks. Or philosophy began in Africa.”
- The view that philosophy began uniquely and only in ancient Greece was not common in European sources; it only became dominant with the rise of pseudoscientific racism and Western imperialism, because people needed to rationalize their dominance of other civilizations by denying that those civilizations had philosophy.
“It only began to be a common view that philosophy began in ancient Greece and only in ancient Greece with the rise of pseudoscientific racism and Western imperialism. Because people needed a way to rationalize their dominance of other civilizations.”
- Immanuel Kant, despite his stature as epistemologist and ethicist, endorsed white racial superiority—claiming Indians could not abstract, Africans could only be servants, and indigenous Americans were incapable of serious thought—and his students rewrote the history of philosophy so that everything led back to Greece and toward Kant's transcendental idealism, excluding non-Western thought.
“Kant's students rewrote the history of philosophy textbooks in Europe, and they rewrote all of the history of philosophy so that it all goes back to ancient Greece, and it's groping more or less successfully towards Kant's transcendental idealism.”
- The philosophical canon has always changed—Aquinas faced student riots for reintroducing Aristotle (preserved in the Islamic world) into the University of Paris because it was seen as not part of the tradition—so adding non-Western traditions to the canon is not unprecedented.
“the professor I have in mind is St. Thomas Aquinas. He was teaching at the University of Paris, now the Sorbonne, and he wanted to reintroduce Aristotle back into the curriculum when Aristotle's works had mostly been lost in the West but fortunately it had been preserved in the Islamic world.”
- Philosophers routinely dismiss the existence of Chinese philosophy without having read any of it, asserting there is none while admitting their ignorance, which Van Norden characterizes as a form of structural racism.
“I'll say, well, of the famous Chinese philosophers, which ones do you not regard as genuinely philosophical? And they'll admit, oh, I've never read any of it, but I know there isn't any.”
Understanding non-Western philosophy is essential for educated citizens and policymakers to navigate an interconnected world.
- Because China, India, and Africa are increasingly important globally, the next generation of policymakers and educated voters cannot understand how to interact with the rest of the world unless they know the thought that informs the lives of people in other parts of the world and how it differs from their own.
“how are they going to understand how to interact with the rest of the world unless they know something about the thought that informs the lives of people in other parts of the world and how it's different from our own?”
- Every mainstream English-speaking philosophy department staffs experts on narrow Western debates (like the Strawson-Russell debate on definite descriptions) while having no one able to teach the philosophy that deeply influenced over a billion people in East Asia and over a billion in South Asia.
“you're always gonna have somebody on staff who's willing to passionately debate whether the statement, the present king of France is bald... but they have nobody on staff who can teach the philosophy that has had a deep influence on the more than a billion people in East Asia”
- Philosophy should be taken back to its traditional cross-cultural concern with how one should live and how society should be organized, rather than the modern analytic preoccupation with narrow technical questions (such as arguing that the term 'mental state' is non-referring) that leave people rightly wondering why such work deserves funding or study.
“I want to take philosophy back to what it's always been traditionally across cultures, it's concerned with how you should live, how you should organize society.”
- Following Alasdair MacIntyre, one has no rational reason to believe in one's own tradition unless it has engaged in dialogue with rival traditions and can articulately explain why they are not superior; sometimes the encounter improves a tradition by producing a synthesis, as Augustine and Aquinas synthesized Christianity with Platonism and Aristotelianism.
“MacIntyre made clear you have no reason for believing in your tradition unless it has engaged in dialogue with other traditions and can articulately explain why these other traditions are not superior to your tradition.”
Philosophy emerges from real-world crises and addresses how one should live, not narrow technical debates.
- Philosophy develops in times of crisis—Plato was driven to philosophize by the corruption he saw in Athens, Confucius and the Daoists by the Warring States chaos, and the Buddha by the problem of human suffering—so the next great philosophers will emerge from confronting real-life problems, contrary to the stereotype that philosophy is idle chatter.
“philosophy develops in times of crisis, when people say, what is going on in the world? How do I fix it?”
- Everyone is a philosopher before entering a philosophy classroom because they already hold opinions about truth, knowledge, and what exists—opinions inherited from earlier philosophers via popular culture—and the only question is whether one is self-conscious about defending ideas developed by earlier thinkers.
“you are a philosopher. You might not know it, but you're a philosopher before you step into a philosophical class, because you have opinions about what is truth, how do we arrive at the truth, what kinds of things exist in the universe.”
- Early modern Western philosophy's drive to find unshakable foundations for knowledge (Descartes's 'I think therefore I am,' Hume's sense impressions) was motivated by living in an era where everything—Aristotelian science, the divine right of kings—was being overthrown, so thinkers sought firm foundations so they could never be deceived again.
“people like Descartes and even a few centuries later, Hume, are living in eras where so much has been called into question... people are looking for some firm foundations for knowledge so they can never be deceived again.”
- Both natural science and ethics rest on basic facts that must simply be accepted (that 1+1=2, that bacteria die in penicillin, that punching your parents in anger is wrong); just as flat-earthers and vaccine skeptics become unresponsive to evidence, in ethics someone who denies basic moral claims is a 'barbarian' with whom further argument is pointless.
“in both science and ethics, at a certain level you have to accept basic facts like one plus one equals two or here's a Petri dish, here is the bacteria dying in the presence of penicillin... It's the same thing in ethics, there are certain basic things you have to accept.”
Logical positivism's dominance in analytic philosophy obscures its political origins and refuted foundations.
- Logical positivism has the distinction of being one of the few philosophical positions to have been definitively refuted, so people who claim natural science covers everything philosophy does are unwittingly repeating refuted positivist arguments.
“most people think that logical positivism has the distinction of being one of the few philosophical positions to have been definitively refuted.”
- Logical positivism is now taught as a purely semantic and philosophy-of-science theory, but the original Vienna Circle positivists were deeply political, defending positivism as a weapon against the obscurantism of fascism; this political role was forgotten when the movement migrated to the US, where McCarthy-era fears pushed philosophy toward presenting itself as apolitical, formal, and science-like.
“It turns out the original logical positivists were extremely political and they were defending logical positivism as a way of combating what they saw as the obscurantism of fascism.”
Fundamental differences between Western and Chinese metaphysics reveal distinct but equally rational approaches to existence.
- A fundamental difference between Western and Chinese thought is that the West assumes what is ultimately real is the individual (forcing the problem of explaining why we should care about anyone else), while the most common Chinese view is that things are interconnected parts of a whole (forcing the opposite problem of justifying any individual deviation from the community's good).
“by and large what you find in the West is an assumption that what's real is in some way individual... the most common view is to say, well, things are interconnected. Things are part of an interconnected whole.”
- In the Republic, Plato gave a prescient account of how a democracy transforms into a tyranny when a rich person presents himself as the hero who will represent the interests of the masses; and the Chinese philosopher Huang Zongxi argued that what matters is not mass voting but that intellectuals have a way to freely tell the government what is going wrong.
“in the Republic, Plato gives a frighteningly prescient account of how a democracy will transform into a tyranny because a rich person will come along and present himself as the person who's gonna be the hero who will represent the interests of the masses.”
- Some Chinese support for Trump functions as a way of identifying oneself as opposed to communism without openly opposing the Chinese government, since Trump presents himself as attacking the radical left.
“Trump presents himself as attacking the radical left. And so in China, if you say you like Trump, it's a way of identifying yourself as opposed to communism without coming out against the Chinese government.”
- About ten years ago a shift occurred in academic philosophy in which undergraduates, graduate students, beginning assistant professors, and some senior professors became much more receptive to the idea that philosophy exists outside the Plato-Aristotle tradition, leading some departments to teach non-Western alongside Western philosophy.
“About 10 years or so ago, I noticed a change in the field where all of a sudden, not just undergraduates, but graduate students in philosophy and beginning assistant professors and a handful of senior professors all of a sudden were much more receptive”