subsistence
Living at the bare minimum level needed to survive, with no surplus for investment or accumulation, characteristic of the feudal peasantry under constant predation.
As defined in Barry Weingast on the Violence Trap
Where it comes up · 5
- Josiah Ober on the Ancient Greek Economy4 claims
- Lars Doucet — Progress, poverty, Georgism, & why rent is too damn high1 claim
- Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Altruism, History, & Technology1 claim
- Barry Weingast on the Violence Trap1 claim
- Omer Moav on the Emergence of the State1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “subsistence” →
- Landlords can extract escalating rents not by collusion but because land is fixed in supply: unlike watermelon growers who respond to demand by producing more, there are only so many locations, so tenants are forced into one-sided competition bidding against each other; landlords can charge up to the 'margin of production' (the best free alternative) and ultimately up to subsistence, which is how frontier privatization progressively raises rents.Lars Doucet — Progress, poverty, Georgism, & why rent is too damn high
- The Solon-Croesus story teaches that happiness is not judged by great masses of wealth but by an adequacy of wealth well above subsistence; moderate wealth in a moderately wealthy community is the foundation for the special goods of a complete, honored life.Josiah Ober on the Ancient Greek Economy
- The surplus theory contradicts Malthus: if Malthusian dynamics hold, any income above subsistence raises fertility and population until income per capita falls back to subsistence, meaning no persistent surplus exists—so surplus cannot be the prerequisite for taxation.Omer Moav on the Emergence of the State
- Robin Hanson's argument that competition drives emulated minds to subsistence does not imply bad lives, because subsistence is a demographic balance of income and population growth and is consistent with ems being in bliss—at subsistence they could have lives thousands of times better than ours.Will MacAskill - Longtermism, Altruism, History, & Technology
- By about 300 B.C. there were roughly 7-10 million people in the Greek world and 3.5 million in core Greece, exceeding the late-19th-century Greek population that lived right at agricultural carrying capacity, implying the ancient Greeks imported substantial food and therefore produced exportable goods and services rather than being a subsistence agricultural economy.Josiah Ober on the Ancient Greek Economy
- Walter Scheidel's 'wheat wage' method, measuring how many liters of wheat one day's wage buys (a standardized cross-cultural proxy for food and housing), shows that while most pre-modern people lived just a little above subsistence, Athenians lived at about two and a half times subsistence, addressing the worry that high nominal wages merely reflected inflation.Josiah Ober on the Ancient Greek Economy
- Wage information from Athens shows wages exceptionally high by ancient or any pre-modern standards, well over subsistence and comparable to wages in golden-age Holland of the 16th-17th centuries.Josiah Ober on the Ancient Greek Economy
- Smith's Book III explains feudalism as a stable equilibrium that is essentially a violence-trap argument: local lords fought constantly, the king was only slightly stronger and could not impose security, so there was no law and constant predation, leaving roughly 99% of the population at subsistence (since acquiring more would only tempt the injustice of oppressors) under a small extractive military elite—and recurring shocks like a lord dying without an heir constantly reshuffled relative power.Barry Weingast on the Violence Trap