Omer Moav on the Emergence of the State
What this covers
Omer Moav of the University of Warwick speaks with Russ Roberts about what actually enabled states to emerge from stateless societies. The conventional account, tracing back to Adam Smith, holds that farming created agricultural surplus, which then made taxation and hierarchy possible. Moav argues this theory is wrong in a precise, testable way: it was not surplus itself but the presence of storable crops—cereals—that allowed states to form. Where productive but perishable crops like cassava, tubers, and bananas dominate, states failed to emerge despite abundance.
The conversation moves through several layers of the argument. Moav explains why surplus cannot ground the standard theory: if Malthusian Trap dynamics hold, population expands to consume any surplus, leaving none to tax. Tax collectors, by contrast, can seize grain after harvest regardless of whether true surplus exists. He then presents empirical tests across multiple datasets and methods—including historical crop domestication centers, the Ethnographic Atlas, and panel data tracking the rise of states over time—all showing that cereal suitability, not land productivity, predicts hierarchy. A separate strand addresses the institutional puzzle: regions with untaxable crops face a Curse of Plenty, where farmers rationally choose less productive but untaxable options, preventing state formation and leaving weak property-rights protection that stifles long-run development. The discussion also touches on the Stationary Bandit Model of state formation and Moav's critique of modern economics' emphasis on causal identification over theoretical understanding.
Moav argues that the emergence of the state was driven not by agricultural surplus but by the cultivation of storable, easily-taxable crops (cereals); where productive but non-storable crops like roots and tubers dominate, states fail to emerge—a 'curse of plenty.'
- Malthusian dynamics eliminate surplus, so surplus cannot be the prerequisite for taxation that conventional theory claims
- Tax collectors can seize stored grain regardless of surplus, but cannot tax cassava that rots within days of harvest
- Empirical tests across multiple datasets show suitability for cereals, not land productivity, predicts the emergence of hierarchy
Storable cereals enable taxation and state formation; untaxable roots and tubers prevent hierarchy.
- Using a newly built dataset mapping the detailed geographic distribution of wild relatives of domesticated crops, the authors find hierarchies emerge where cereals were available for domestication but roots and tubers were not; where only roots and tubers were available, hierarchies did not emerge; and places where both were available resemble the roots-and-tubers-only places—because farmers given the choice prefer the untaxable tubers.
“hierarchies emerge where cereals are available, but roots and tubers are not. Places that only roots and tubers are available, you don't see the emergence of hierarchies. Places that both available are very similar to places that only roots and tubers are available.”
- To avoid relying on modern crop data, the authors use proximity to one of ~20 archaeological centers of crop domestication: proximity to a center of cereal domestication predicts the emergence of hierarchy (measured by archaeological findings like cities, temples, pyramids, quarries), whereas proximity to a center of root/tuber domestication has no positive effect.
“what really matters for the emergence of hierarchies, proximity to a center of domestication of a cereal. Roots and tubers do not matter--simply have no positive effect”
- Surplus is also not a sufficient condition for taxation: a village with abundant cassava (a tuber that stays preserved in the ground but rots within days of being dug up) produces real surplus, yet that surplus cannot be efficiently appropriated, moved, or used to build pyramids or fund a military—so what truly enables a state is an easily-taxed food, not surplus.
“What you really need is not surplus, but a food that is easily taxed. And, that's the main claim we make.”
- Surplus is not a prerequisite for taxation: with a seasonal cereal that must be stored for year-round survival, a tax collector backed by force can simply seize a share of the stored grain after harvest regardless of whether any true surplus exists, indifferent to whether some people consequently starve.
“What you really need is not surplus, but a food that is easily taxed. And, that's the main claim we make.”
- Using the Ethnographic Atlas of ~200 societies and FAO crop-output data converted to calories, a regression horse race between land productivity and an exogenous geographic instrument for cereal suitability shows that controlling for cereals kills the apparent positive effect of land productivity on hierarchy, while cereal suitability has a positive effect—indicating it is the crop, not raw productivity, that drives hierarchy.
“you see that a lot of areas, land productivity improved, but that doesn't explain the emergence of hierarchies. Whereas, the increase in the advantage of cereals over roots and tubers, this does explain.”
The surplus theory of state formation is logically and empirically false on multiple grounds.
- Because one cannot randomly assign countries to grow roots and tubers, the authors compensate for the impossibility of a single perfect experiment by examining many different datasets, proxies for roots and tubers, time periods, and statistical methods, and demonstrating that once crop type is controlled for, the surplus/land-productivity theory has zero statistical significance across all specifications.
“we look at various data sets... different ways to--a proxy for roots and tubers, different periods of time and different statistical methods, and to show consistency. And, the end result is that in all our specifications, once we control for the type of crop, the surplus theory has zero statistical significance.”
- The surplus theory contradicts Malthus: if Malthusian dynamics hold, any income above subsistence raises fertility and population until income per capita falls back to subsistence, meaning no persistent surplus exists—so surplus cannot be the prerequisite for taxation.
“If Malthus is right, then there is no surplus, because population will adjust to eliminate any surplus.”
- The conventional theory, traceable to Adam Smith and earlier thinkers, holds that the transition to farming let farmers produce more food than they needed, creating surplus, and that this surplus is the prerequisite for taxation and the emergence of states and hierarchies.
“The transition to farming allowed increased output... they could actually produce surplus... And, this surplus is a prerequisite for taxation and the emergence of states.”
- The novel theoretical contribution of the paper is the claim that the surplus argument is wrong and surplus is not needed at all; the prior idea that grains are easier to tax than tubers was already made by James Scott and researchers in the 1970s-80s, but those scholars retained the surplus framing, only adding that surplus must be of something storable.
“our theoretical contribution--is to say: Surplus argument is wrong; you don't need surplus.”
Multiple datasets, methods, and time periods consistently confirm crop type over productivity drives hierarchy.
- Historically the state is best understood not as a benevolent contract-based organization but, following Mancur Olson's 1993 argument, as roving bandits becoming stationary—a transition from random crime to organized crime that can be a win-win because organized predation leaves enough for the subject to survive and protects them from other bandits.
“the better view of a state is, as Mancur Olson published in his 1993 article, is just roving bandits turning stationary. So, a state is a transition from random crime to organized crime.”
- Using a panel dataset that codes each modern country's territory every 50 years as state, chiefdom, or tribe, the authors test whether the Columbian exchange's increase in land productivity explains the rise of states; it does not—rather, the increase in the advantage of cereals over roots and tubers explains the emergence of hierarchies, replicating the cross-sectional result with a different method, dataset, and time period.
“you see that a lot of areas, land productivity improved, but that doesn't explain the emergence of hierarchies. Whereas, the increase in the advantage of cereals over roots and tubers, this does explain.”
- In highly productive regions where the productive crops are hard-to-tax roots, tubers, taro, bananas, or fruits, hierarchies fail to emerge—the 'curse of plenty': although farmers are individually better off growing untaxable crops in the short run, the absence of a state means weak institutions and weak property-rights protection, leaving these regions worse off for long-run economic development and welfare.
“What you really need is not surplus, but a food that is easily taxed. And, that's the main claim we make.”
- There is extensive research showing the persistence of institutions, and this paper matters because it helps explain why some states today are failing while others succeed—going to the root cause of institutional quality, which much economic research highlights but is largely unsuccessful at explaining.
“there is a lot of research that shows the persistence of institutions. And, in this sense, I think the paper is not just about the emergence of states. It also helps understand why some states today are failing states, why others are successful.”
Economic research now prizes causal identification above understanding reality and logical theory development.
- Economics over the last 20-30 years has been dominated by an 'identification revolution' prizing the identification of causal effects (e.g., randomized controlled trials), but identifying a causal effect is a means, not the goal; the goal is to understand reality, and the profession has to a large extent lost interest in logical claims and theory.
“this is the identification revolution. So, to identify causal effects. Now, don't get me wrong: Identifying a causal effect is extremely useful and important. But, we should remember this is the mean, not the goal. The goal is to learn something about reality.”
- Following Thomas Kuhn's argument, science advances from funeral to funeral as defenders of challenged paradigms die off—but progress remains difficult because deceased scholars leave behind intellectual offspring who continue to defend the old theory.
“when they die, they already have all their intellectual offspring that still protect the old theorem.”
- Good research is not defined by identifying a causal effect but by significantly changing one's priors about an important topic; a combination of data and logical argument can shift prior beliefs even without rigorous causal identification, and conversely careful identification of a previously unknown effect can do so too.
“Good research is research that significantly changed your priors about an important topic.”
- Although adding a confirming dataset statistically strengthens an argument, for many narrow-minded referees additional datasets merely lengthen their list of concerns, leading to rejection—an inversion of how cumulative evidence ought to be evaluated.
“for many referees, that just makes their list of concerns longer. Well, with a longer list of concerns: of course we reject the paper.”
Hostile referees from other disciplines undermined the paper's acceptance despite methodological rigor.
- The dramatic rise in Western government spending from about 10-15% of income in the 19th century to 45-50% today is driven not by crop type but by increased taxability—income tax, accounting, and large firms made the economy easier to tax—because governments tax because they can, with benevolent rationalizations supplied ex post.
“it is income tax, accounting, large firms. And, it's a similar argument, because it's taxability. So, once the economy is organized in a way that it's easier to tax, governments will tax more.”
- A state is an organization with a strong elite that controls outcomes and taxes the masses, with income flowing from the masses (historically farmers) to a central authority that uses it to provide law and order, military, attacks on others, or monuments like pyramids.
“a state is an organization in which there is a strong elite which controls what happens, more or less, and taxes the masses. That's a state.”
- The most hostile anonymous referees were often not economists but political scientists, sociologists, or anthropologists whose theories the paper challenged; this is a bad combination because they are both hostile and frequently do not understand the economic methods, producing negative reports that are also silly and flawed yet sometimes lead editors to reject.
“I think most of the really hostile referees were actually not economists... they're hostile. B), in many cases, they don't really understand what we are doing.”