strong emergence
A purported form of emergence where collective behavior is genuinely new and could not have been predicted by simulating the lower-level laws on a computer.
As defined in AMA | April 2022
Other definitions
The thesis that higher-level phenomena exhibit genuinely novel causal powers not derivable even in principle from lower-level laws, in contrast to weak emergence.
AMA | May 2026
Where it comes up · 16
- 168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness3 claims
- AMA | June 20223 claims
- 295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality2 claims
- 79 | Sara Imari Walker on Information and the Origin of Life2 claims
- 249 | Peter Godfrey-Smith on Sentience and Octopus Minds1 claim
- 25 | David Chalmers on Consciousness, the Hard Problem, and Living in a Simulation1 claim
- AMA | April 20221 claim
- AMA | August 20221 claim
and 8 more
Most important claims · 10 of 22Search all claims for “strong emergence” →
- Genuine strong emergence would mean the local laws governing an electron stop holding once you assemble enough particles—e.g., new laws appearing at 10^23 electrons that depend on the organization the electron is embedded in—which is conceivable but would be completely incompatible with everything we know about physics.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
- In the physicist's sense (weak emergence), higher-level descriptions speak different vocabularies but remain compatible with lower levels because they exploit patterns implicit in the microscopic dynamics; the center-of-mass example shows that throwing away almost all microscopic information still yields good predictions only because the retained information is extraordinarily special—keeping random information would predict nothing—making emergence a wonderful, non-trivial feature of nature rather than the strong emergence where macro behavior cannot be derived from micro at all.AMA | September 2021
- Whether strong emergence (collective behavior not predictable from simulating lower-level laws) occurs at all depends on what your two levels are: it does not happen when the lower level is simple, local fundamental physics like quantum field theory, but there may be a useful sense in which strong emergence occurs when connecting one complex level of analysis to another complex level, such as a nation emerging from its citizens.AMA | April 2022
- Even if one modified the Standard Model to allow strong emergence, any such strongly emergent behavior could itself be mathematically encapsulated in the laws, so no matter how surprising it would still pose no threat to materialism about the mind.AMA | August 2025
- Weak emergence (per Bedau) means higher-level properties arise from lower-level dynamics in principle—operationalized as being predictable by putting the microscopic state and laws on a computer—whereas strong emergence (per Chalmers) means higher-level properties are fundamentally new and not deducible even in principle from the lower level.295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality
- If strong emergence is real—higher-level properties not predictable even in principle—then the lower-level theory must actually be wrong in that domain, not merely incomplete with gaps; strong emergentists rarely admit this, so strong emergence risks being not a deep feature of the world but a sign you made a mistake in choosing the lower-level theory.295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality
- Although we want to reduce biology to physics, physics is itself an emergent property of biology because the standard model is an equation that emerged from human minds, creating a recursive loop in which a biological system constructs the model used to probe the smallest scales of reality, and the physics describing that loop is not encoded in physics as we currently know it.79 | Sara Imari Walker on Information and the Origin of Life
- The question is whether there is any example where strong emergence has been resolved to lower-level properties as a result of new observations and understanding—i.e., where supposedly non-reducible emergent properties turned out to be reducible.AMA | May 2025
- Strong emergence—the idea that a macroscopic property is in principle not reducible to its microscopic components and exerts downward causal power on them—is uncomfortably close to magic, does not fit a physicalist picture, and is suspicious because the only example that reliably comes up to motivate it is consciousness itself, creating a reciprocal mystery.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
- Research into consciousness is not an example of strong emergence: by definition zombies behave identically to conscious beings, so every book, discussion, and field of inquiry produced by conscious people could be produced by zombies, meaning the existence of consciousness research does not require top-down causal power; the self-reference problem of modeling yourself within the world (per Jenann Ismael) is a problem of describing the world perfectly given you're in it, not a problem of incompleteness in the laws of physics.AMA | December 2021