causal
Strong emergence implies the lower theory was wrong
If strong emergence is real—higher-level properties not predictable even in principle—then the lower-level theory must actually be wrong in that domain, not merely incomplete with gaps; strong emergentists rarely admit this, so strong emergence risks being not a deep feature of the world but a sign you made a mistake in choosing the lower-level theory.
causalpending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“the problem in this sense with strong emergence is just that it raises the possibility that it's not a deep feature of the world. It's just that you made a mistake when you invented that lower level theory”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:11 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...