What this covers

This monthly Ask Me Anything episode collects questions from Patreon supporters on topics spanning science, philosophy, education, and social life. Sean Carroll addresses roughly two dozen questions, many grouped by theme, offering technical explanations alongside broader methodological points about how to think clearly across domains.

The physics and cosmology content ranges from concrete questions—why dark matter must exist beyond ordinary matter, how spaghettification actually works near black holes, what white holes are—to foundational puzzles about why the universe exists at all and whether the early universe's low entropy can ever be explained. On quantum mechanics, Carroll distinguishes between the Schrodinger equation itself and interpretations of it, defends Bayesian Updating against a common misunderstanding about certainty, and explains why quantum tunnelling processes make everything eventually fall into black holes. He situates contemporary research tools like the James Webb Space Telescope and theoretical ladders like AdS/CFT not as pathways to revolutionary breakthroughs but as the brightest illuminated corners available for study.

The philosophical and social questions push harder against easy answers. On persuasion and debate, Carroll draws on work analyzing Reddit's Change My View forum to argue that abduction—Inference to the Best Explanation—not deductive logic shifts what people believe, and that anecdotes outweigh formal arguments. He tackles whether consciousness requires special interpretation of John Searle's Chinese Room, explores tensions between Moral Constructivism and objectivism in ethics, and resists clean rules for when protest disruption is justified. Throughout, he emphasizes calibrating confidence to genuine uncertainty rather than tribal commitment to favored theories.

Sharpest takeaway

Carroll argues that physics and philosophy provide powerful but limited tools for understanding reality, and that intellectual honesty requires holding calibrated credences, distinguishing fundamental from emergent phenomena, and resisting the urge to over-simplify complex questions whether in physics, ethics, or social life.

  • Credences should reflect genuine uncertainty rather than tribal allegiance to favored theories
  • Emergent phenomena are just as real as fundamental ones, not illusions
  • Physics-style simplification is valuable but must be applied carefully when extended to messy domains like society

The claims · ranked48 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.60

The objection that Bayesian updating requires 100% confidence in evidence is wrong; you do not need to leave the Bayesian paradigm but must be honest about the likelihood function, which is the probability of obtaining that data given the theory, and that likelihood must account for the possibility that your data-collecting or interpreting procedure is mistaken.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“it requires that the Bayesian needs to be very, very accurate and honest about the probability of thinking they've gotten that evidence if the theory was correct”

0.57

Quantum information differs from classical information because of entanglement: in a bipartite system you can know the exact quantum state of the whole (zero entropy) while subsystems A and B separately have nonzero entropy because they are entangled, which is impossible classically where knowing every molecule's state means knowing every subset's state; this likely makes quantum information theory inapplicable to macroscopic domains like accounting.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“I can have the following situation where I know exactly the quantum state of the whole system, so the system as a whole has zero entropy, but if I divide it up into system A and system B... separately have a non-zero entropy because they're entangled”

0.53

The information economy poses a new kind of market problem because, unlike a working widget that everyone agrees should function, people do not uniformly want true information; they often want information that makes them happy or flatters their preconceptions, so the criterion for successful information differs from truth, making it unclear how to reward providers of accurate information.

causalcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“it is not clear that everyone wants true information. Sometimes people want information that makes them happy or that flatters their preconceptions or that fits into their pre-existing world view”

0.53

It is far easier to fake being human than to actually be human or conscious, so the more immediate AI worry is not superintelligent AGI but programs that fool people into thinking they are human; our imaginations are non-uniform, finding it easier to picture human-like AI than the vast spectrum of in-between behaviors, leaving large design space for quasi-human AIs with no actual intelligence, common sense, or values.

forecastcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“it's way easier to fake being human than to be human. And I think that therefore, the worries about super intelligent AI are perhaps not the most immediate worries we should be worried about.”

0.53

A white hole is nothing more or less than a black hole run backward in time; it is the same object with the singularity and event horizon in the past rather than the future, and neither white nor black hole singularities are naked singularities because both are moments in time (space-like) rather than points in space (time-like), so neither contradicts the cosmic censorship conjecture.

definitionestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“a white hole is nothing more or less than a black hole run backward in time. Okay, it's not a different kind of thing”

0.53

Dark matter cannot be ordinary matter hiding behind stars because Big Bang nucleosynthesis measures the total amount of ordinary (baryonic) matter from nuclear fusion reaction products in the early universe, while the cosmic microwave background measures the total amount of all matter, and these two figures disagree; thus even ignoring all galaxy and cluster dynamics, one must conclude dark matter exists and is not baryonic.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“We have measured how much ordinary matter there is from the reaction products of nuclear fusion in the early universe, then at the same time using the microwave background... we know the total amount of matter... they do not agree with each other.”

0.51

Everyday causation, in which causes precede effects, does not exist at the level of fundamental physics because the same reasoning works in both time directions: you can equally say a particle's present trajectory is caused by a past collision or by a future collision, so whatever you are describing at the fundamental level is not the everyday notion of causality, which requires explaining why causes precede effects at the macroscopic level.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“if you can say it one way, you can say it the other way. And therefore, whatever you're talking about is not the everyday notion of causality”

0.50

In studying Reddit's 'Change My View' forum, deductive arguments (premises to conclusion) almost never change people's minds and may even backfire, because they only work if both parties share premises; personal anecdotes and experiences are what actually change minds, reflecting that humans reason by abduction (inference to best explanation) rather than deduction from foundational beliefs.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“deductive arguments never change people's minds, they're terrible, they maybe anti-change people's minds”

0.50

Books claiming the universe came from nothing actually change the definition of nothing, since a quantum vacuum is something, not nothing; the question of why the universe exists at all is separate from how it began, and it is the kind of question that just might not have an answer, with the most straightforward answer being that there is no reason why the universe exists.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“this is the kind of question that might just... Just might not have an answer. Okay? There is no such thing as the reason why the universe exists.”

0.50

Most things will eventually end up in black holes and then radiate away because such processes increase entropy: a planet can become a black hole of equal mass with higher entropy, which then radiates into even higher-entropy radiation, and even without proton decay objects like white dwarfs can quantum tunnel into black holes, so absent conserved quantities blocking it, any entropy-increasing process will probably eventually happen.

forecastcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“if you have a planet... you can turn that planet into a black hole of equal mass and the entropy will be higher, and then that black hole can radiate into radiation and the entropy will be higher still”

0.50

Moral objectivists and moral constructivists can arrive at the same ethical principles while differing radically at the meta-ethical level on justification; moral objectivists, like constructivists, almost always end up justifying their pre-existing moral intuitions rather than deriving conclusions at variance with what they want, but the justification still matters because it makes a difference in genuine grey areas where answers are unclear.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“Generally, moral objectivist end up justifying their moral intuitions just like constructivists do, they just don't admit it.”

0.49

The James Webb Space Telescope is designed to study early galaxy formation and exoplanets, both well described by the standard model and general relativity, so there is almost no prospect it will teach us new fundamental physics or revise quantum mechanics; most interesting physics is not fundamental physics, and questions about inflation are better probed by all-sky surveys like WMAP and Planck than by narrow-field telescopes.

forecastestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“There's almost no reason to think that we will learn about new fundamental physics from JWST, and that's okay. Most interesting physics is not fundamental physics.”

0.47

There is no clean once-and-for-all rule for which protests are acceptable; people often hide substantive commitments behind procedural arguments, and the legitimacy of disruption depends on circumstances such as whether the protesters are part of the group platforming the speaker, with silent walkouts being mild and acceptable while disruption should be reserved for the most extreme cases and judged case-by-case.

normativecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“there's a general tendency here to hide one's substantive commitments behind procedural arguments”

0.47

The arrow of time is explained by Boltzmann's definition of entropy together with the fact that the early universe had low entropy; what remains unexplained is why the early universe had low entropy, and there is no direct connection between this and the uncertainty principle, since the second law was understood classically by Boltzmann long before quantum mechanics.

causalestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“the arrow of time is explained, it is explained by the definition that we have of entropy from Boltzmann and the fact that the entropy in the early universe was low”

0.47

Grand unification is a technical term referring to unifying the electromagnetic, weak, and strong nuclear forces, not gravity; this is why Hawking joked grand unified theories are 'neither grand nor unified nor theories,' and why string theory's attempt to unify gravity with the other forces was called a theory of everything, a step beyond grand unification.

definitionestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“the phrase grand unification is a technical term within physics that does not refer to gravity. Grand unification was the attempt to unify the electromagnetic force, the weak force and the strong nuclear force.”

0.47

Spaghettification does not happen near the event horizon but when approaching the singularity; for a small black hole the singularity is close right at the horizon, so an object is stretched in one direction and squeezed in the other two, with the person and space suit torn apart together, though whether the suit maintains air-tightness under such stretching is an engineering question.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sean Carroll

“The point of the spaghettification talk is that it doesn't happen near the event horizon, that's not where it happens, it happens when you approach the singularity”

0.46

The classical limit of quantum mechanics does not require Many Worlds; heavy objects act more classically than light ones because the rate at which a wave function spreads out is much smaller for massive degrees of freedom, but a full account also requires decoherence and pointer states to explain why wave packets are concentrated in the first place, and that story is not yet fully settled.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“Heavy objects act more naturally classical than light ones do. And the things that we come across in our everyday classical lives are generally very, very heavy.”

0.46

We may have just gotten lucky that the other forces can be reached by starting with a classical theory and quantizing it, since there is no guarantee a given quantum model can be reached that way; this might be the case for gravity, meaning one should not necessarily start with classical general relativity and quantize it to get the right quantum theory of gravity.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“in the case of the other forces, we just got lucky with this whole idea that you can start with a classical theory and then quantized it, there's no guarantee that a particular quantum mechanical model can be reached by starting with a classical theory and quantizing it”

0.46

Scientists value the AdS/CFT correspondence not because they have good reason to think it generalizes but because it is the world's brightest lamppost for quantum gravity: a known, precisely spelled-out model where you can ask and answer questions, yielding wisdom about how things work even though it does not directly extend to our non-anti-de-Sitter world.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“AdS/CFT is the world's brightest lamppost, when it comes to quantum gravity.”

0.45

Technological progress is still in its early stages not because of simple rate extrapolation but because most progress so far has been based on physics and chemistry (manipulating matter at simple levels), whereas the highest-impact future advances will be in biology, which is vastly more complicated and which we are currently poor at manipulating, leaving enormous room for growth in synthetic biology and gene editing.

forecastcontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“The reason why I think that technological progress is in its beginning states is because it's mostly been based on physics.”

0.45

There is a speculative proposal by Nomura, Susskind and Bousso that the Everettian and cosmological multiverses might be the same thing: applying black hole horizon complementarity inside-out to cosmology means our accelerating universe's horizon contains only a finite number of degrees of freedom, so the entire multiverse could be a quantum superposition of vacuum states within one horizon, though no one knows if this picture is right.

factualfringenovelty 4/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“the whole universe, the whole multiverse, is all contained within one horizon size of a single universe, but the quantum state inside that horizon is a superposition of different kinds of vacuum states”

0.44

Carroll assigns roughly 50% credence to the type-2 (cosmological) multiverse because it concerns regions of spacetime far outside our causal contact for which we have no empirical evidence, and such speculations should not be given high credence regardless of how many physicists endorse them, especially since the experts who understand it best disagree.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“I don't think that these speculations about times and places where we have no empirical evidence should be given too high credence.”

0.44

In the actual world of our experience, things are not deterministic because quantum mechanics tells us so, and quantum probabilistic outcomes can be amplified to macroscopic scales; therefore arguments against free will based on determinism fail on their first premise, even though a God's-eye view (as in Many Worlds or pilot wave theory) may be deterministic but is inaccessible to us.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“the world that you and I actually live in, it is not deterministic. Full stop. That is what quantum mechanics tells us”

0.44

Following Dennett's intentional stance, attributing intentions, goals, and purposes to physical systems is justified when it provides useful insight and predictive power, just as attributing temperature to a fluid is useful even though we could describe individual molecules; there is no deep ontological difference between biological and non-biological perception, but adding intentionality enriches descriptions of complex systems like people while adding nothing to simple ones like a thermostat.

definitioncontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“we take a stance towards something that attributes to it goals, purposes, intentions... because that gives us insight, because it's a useful description”

0.44

Science's success was not the result of people sitting down to invent the scientific method and then following it; rather they started doing empirical hypothesis-testing, being open-minded about alternatives, and it worked, paying dividends in understanding, after which people reflected on why it succeeded, illustrating that shifts in behavior and shifts in justification interplay rather than belief preceding behavior.

causalcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“it wasn't that people sat down and said, 'Okay, let's invent the scientific method,' and then started doing it, they started doing it, and then they sat down and said, What is this thing that is going on that seems to be so successful?”

0.44

Philosophers have contributed to physics not by inventing correct new theories (which they are not good at) but by clarifying conceptual underpinnings and exposing hidden assumptions, cheating, or inconsistencies in theories; historically Mach influenced Einstein's relativity, philosophical ideas influenced Boltzmann and Bohr, and philosophers have done a better job than physicists clarifying the arrow of time and quantum measurement problems.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“Philosophers have done a much better job than physicists at clarifying the issues and the possible solutions to things like the arrow of time problem and the quantum measurement problem.”

0.44

Persuasion cannot be assigned an intrinsic ethical valence because it can be deployed equally for good or bad reasons; persuasion just means trying to get someone to believe something true, teaching mathematics is itself a form of persuasion, and it is essentially impossible to imagine a world without it, so while it can be misused that does not make it ethically bad.

normativecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“when something can be deployed equally well for good or bad reasons, you can't assign it an intrinsic ethical valance as positive or negative”

0.44

Atheist scientists who avoid discussing God because it gets in the way of science are mistaken, because there is no more direct relationship between scientific understanding and the meaning of life than deciding whether God exists; God's existence is an important question that science bears on, so scientists on either side should discuss it.

normativecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“there isn't any other more direct relationship between our scientific understanding and the meaning of life, than to decide whether or not God exists”

0.44

Following Julia Galef's practice, when a news article quotes someone as 'admitting' something, one should mentally translate 'admits' to 'says' because the substantive content is identical but 'admits' adds a normative or evaluative spin, letting readers judge the statement for themselves rather than having a framing imposed.

normativecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“she always in her mind, translates admits to says, because it's the same substantive content... but it's not trying to put some kind of normative or evaluative spin on it”

0.44

The correct response to Searle's Chinese Room is that while the person inside does not understand Chinese, the room as a whole does; the thought experiment merely pumps intuitions by mapping the brain's billions of neurons onto slow punch cards, making a conscious system seem implausible, but if there is nothing more to the brain than its neurons and cells, one must accept the room understands Chinese.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“the person who is doing that... they don't understand Chinese... but the room understands Chinese, and the only thing that the whole thought experiment is doing is trying to make consciousness in a materialistic sense, seem silly by intuition pumping”

0.44

Whether someone has the ability to become a world-class scientist cannot be assessed in advance because it depends on many unpredictable factors beyond intrinsic features; many talented test-takers never become scientists while many who struggle initially have a light bulb moment and succeed, so if you love it you should take the risk rather than worrying about innate ability.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“There's a big difference between doing well on tests as a young person and being a professional scientist.”

0.44

Carroll changed his mind about objecting to Pluto's reclassification after talking with Mike Brown, accepting Brown's argument that if Pluto-like objects count as planets then Brown would be the greatest planet discoverer of all time, since he found many similar dwarf planets at the solar system's edge; the relabeling reflects improved understanding of what objects exist rather than any change in Pluto.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“if things like Pluto count as planets, then he, Mike, would be the greatest planet discoverer of all time... But they don't... those other guys don't really deserve planet status, and therefore Pluto does not.”

0.43

Strong emergence cannot arise from a micro level with entirely local and simple dynamics like particle physics and quantum field theory, so the self is weakly emergent from atoms and particles; however, when the micro level is people (with non-local interactions and complex internal states) and the macro level is society, strong emergence is conceivable because collective behavior may not be capturable in any simple theory of one-on-one interactions.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“If the micro level has entirely local extremely simple dynamics like we do in particle physics and quantum field theory, then there's no room for strong emergence from it”

0.43

It is wrong to call chairs, consciousness, and colors illusions just because they lack fundamental essences; they are emergent, and emergent things are just as real because the criterion for being real is giving us a useful handle on reality and enabling predictions, whereas a true illusion (like a desert mirage) hurts your attempts to understand and navigate the world.

normativecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“I think that things like consciousness, and free-will, and chairs are there, they're not illusions”

0.42

There is roughly no moral obligation either to have or not have children; arguments that there is such an obligation are entirely unpersuasive, and the decision should be made individually by weighing the benefits and downsides, which are substantial on both sides, rather than as a big-picture ethical or social stance.

normativecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“Is there some moral-obligation to either have or not have children? And I think roughly, the answer is, no.”

0.42

While there is no plausible way for turning off a radio 30 miles away to affect a baseball game, non-linear dynamics means a small change can lead to a large effect, so one would have to think very carefully to be nearly certain no macroscopic action could shift the outcome; however, such effects are damped out over distance, making it highly doubtful the influence travels 30 miles.

causalestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“When physicists talk about linear systems, they mean a small change leads to a small effect, whereas a non-linear system, a small change can lead to a large effect”

0.42

Dark energy does deserve to be in the cosmic pie chart and really is an energy, because the Friedmann equation relates the universe's expansion rate to its energy density and you must include matter, radiation, and vacuum energy to fit the data; objections fail because radiation energy also is not conserved as space expands, and dark energy is interchangeable with matter via inflation and false-vacuum decay.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“by all ways that we have of thinking about what should count as energy, dark-energy should count”

0.40

The mere existence of anomalies does not indicate cracks in the standard model because there are always anomalies; doing 100 experiments produces a one-in-a-hundred anomaly by chance, so anomalies must become very strong to be exciting; the muon magnetic moment is the most believable but has an alternative QCD calculation that erases the discrepancy, and the W boson mass result conflicts with other measurements, so the safer bet is that discrepancies will disappear.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“There are always anomalies. We do many, many experiments, if you do 100 experiments, you expect to see a one in a hundred anomaly sometimes.”

0.40

The telescope should never have been named after James Webb because he was an administrator, not a scientist, and naming carries an honoring function distinct from a citation-like label (Schrodinger's equation merely cites who wrote it first); if Webb was complicit in purging gay people from the federal government, the name should be changed even at some cost, because such names send minority groups the message that their feelings do not matter.

normativecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“There is a difference between... using a name as just a label, or almost a citation... and there's a difference between honoring”

0.38

Funding US public schools primarily through local property taxes is wildly unfair because it is the maximally unequal arrangement: the more property you own, the more taxes you pay and the better your schools, perpetuating inequality; even a meritocratic libertarian must concede babies deserve equal opportunity, so roughly the same amount should be spent per public school student.

normativecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“The local revenues are property taxes... which is sort of like the maximally unequal way to do things.”

0.38

Idealism deserves near-zero credence for basic obvious reasons: different minds construct essentially the same physical world (people don't have different views of the laws of physics), which is far better explained by there really being a physical world out there, and once you understand how the physical world works it is natural that minds arise within it.

factualcontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“it certainly seems like different minds construct, more or less, the same physical world... Why is that? ... I have an even better reason why, namely, 'cause there really is a physical world out there.”

0.38

There is a non-trivial chance the US will cease to be a functioning democracy, but this is distinct from riots and mobs; if the Republican party undermines elections so state legislatures can override vote outcomes, democracy would effectively end, yet for many people daily life would go on as usual, the key difference being that those in power would never go out of power.

forecastcontestednovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Sean Carroll

“there's a big difference between not being a functioning democracy and riots on the streets and mobs burning down houses. Okay? Those are not the same thing.”

0.37

Carroll's high credence in Many Worlds rests on the fact that the Schrodinger equation is extremely well-tested and non-speculative; the only speculative move is trying to get rid of the other worlds, which is very hard to do, so Many Worlds is simply the default if you accept the Schrodinger equation and wave functions.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“Many Worlds is based on the Schrodinger equation, which has been very, very tested. That part of the theory is not speculative, and once you get into how to get rid of the other worlds, it's very hard to do.”

0.37

Physicists have a well-deserved reputation for swarming into other fields claiming to clean them up, which stems not from being physicists but from failing to afford other disciplines the same respect they give physics; one should spend as much time learning a field's challenges and techniques before contributing as one spent learning physics, while still attempting interdisciplinary engagement.

normativecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sean Carroll

“physicists have a big bad, well-deserved reputation for swarming in and saying, 'Ah, what you're doing doesn't look that hard, let me clean it up and solve it all.'”

0.34

Although Carroll is not up on the evidence, the story that physical exercise improves intellectual output is very plausible because, on a physicalist view, the mind comes from the body so keeping the body in good shape supports the mind; he recommends regular exercise even in small amounts like a seven-minute routine to keep blood flowing.

causalcontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“'the mind comes from the body, and then you wanna keep your body in good shape.' And again, that's not a scientific hypothesis that has been rigorously tested, but it makes perfect sense”

0.31

Arik Kershenbaum's claim that aliens would not be colonialist was not about human versus alien nature but about practicality: interplanetary and especially interstellar exploitation is impractical because resources are extremely hard to obtain even from remote locations on our own planet, let alone from Mars, Saturn, or planets around other stars, which is exponentially harder.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“He wasn't saying that it was an intrinsically human thing, he said it was intrinsically located on one planet thing... it's impractical to be an interplanetary colonialist because the planets are very far away.”

0.31

It is possible to do something between undergrad and grad school, but taking time away from academia lowers (without zeroing) your probability of admission, because physics admissions committees and tenure committees prefer candidates devoted to doing nothing but physics, regardless of whether they should feel that way.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“my feeling roughly, is that taking time away from academia lowers your probability of success. Does not make it zero”

0.31

The word 'just' in materialist statements like 'humans are just robots made of chemicals' functions as a comparison indicating that an alternative dualist picture would have something extra, asserting nothing extra exists; while the substantive meaning is unchanged if removed, the word performs a rhetorical comparative role.

definitionspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Sean Carroll

“the word just is indicating the fact that in the alternative picture, there's something extra there, and the materialist is saying, 'No, there is nothing extra there.'”