causal

Consciousness research is not strong emergence

Research into consciousness is not an example of strong emergence: by definition zombies behave identically to conscious beings, so every book, discussion, and field of inquiry produced by conscious people could be produced by zombies, meaning the existence of consciousness research does not require top-down causal power; the self-reference problem of modeling yourself within the world (per Jenann Ismael) is a problem of describing the world perfectly given you're in it, not a problem of incompleteness in the laws of physics.

causalpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“There is no school of consciousness research that is populated by researchers who are not themselves conscious. That's true. But this is not something that is in any way in conflict with the idea that conscious creatures are just collections of physical particles obeying the laws of physics.”

Source

AMA | December 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...