What this covers

Russ Roberts interviews Dan Klein on the fundamental distinction between two kinds of coordination that economists have conflated and confused. Klein opens by describing the marvel of spontaneous order—how millions of unconnected people, separated by vast distances and with no awareness of one another, nonetheless produce the goods that fill supermarket shelves on any given Sunday. No coordinator orchestrates this chain; no single mind could comprehend it. Yet it works. Klein then pivots to argue that economics has abandoned the language to describe this phenomenon, crowded out by two competing forces: the rise of game-theoretic "mutual coordination" (where parties deliberately align on terms, prices, and schedules) and the displacement of spontaneous order by the efficiency-and-optimality paradigm that dominates modern economic thought.

The conversation ranges widely across the costs of this linguistic and conceptual loss. Klein traces how economists' historical vocabulary shifted after Thomas Schelling and game theory, leaving no credible language to express how thousands of people can truthfully say "we made the pizza" without having cooperated in any meaningful sense. He then introduces the "people's romance"—the political mythology that society should function as a single unified organization, with shared sentiment and common purpose—and argues that this romance actively crowds out genuine local cooperation in churches, schools, and voluntary associations. Roberts and Klein explore how this myth, while maladaptive in the modern world, persists as an evolutionary atavism and carries real dangers: when bad actors exploit it at scale, the result is not merely inefficiency but tyranny. The discussion touches on education, Social Security, and the hostility toward private actors like fund managers, showing how the romance shapes policy and public sentiment alike.

Sharpest takeaway

Klein argues that economists conflate two distinct ideas of coordination—'concatenate' (the vast spontaneous chain of activities producing goods) and 'mutual' (game-theoretic, awareness-based coordination)—and that the former has been crowded out by both mutual coordination and the efficiency/optimality paradigm, leaving us without language to appreciate spontaneous order or to resist the dangerous mythology of the 'people's romance' that seeks to make society into a single cooperating organization.

  • Concatenate coordination (spontaneous order producing all goods) is incredible precisely because no mind can fully comprehend or explain it, so it cannot be officially manipulated.
  • Mutual coordination (Schelling, common knowledge, shared awareness) and the efficiency/welfare-function paradigm displaced concatenate coordination in economics.
  • The 'people's romance'—the urge to treat the whole polity as one cooperating organization—crowds out genuine local cooperation and risks tyranny.

The claims · ranked34 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.86

JSTOR research by Klein and Aaron Orsborn shows that economists historically used 'coordination' to mean concatenate coordination, but after Thomas Schelling and game theory the usage shifted to mutual coordination, with the efficiency/optimality paradigm simultaneously crowding out concatenate coordination because it could not engage it while remaining value-free.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Dan Klein

“Aaron Orsborn and I have done JSTOR systemic JSTOR research to show that it used to be concatenate coordination that economists meant but then after Thomas Schelling in game theory its mutual coordination”

0.81

Because Super Bowl viewers know that millions of others are watching simultaneously, advertisers concentrate on 'social goods' (drinks, fashions, software) whose value depends on common knowledge; the shared viewing acts as a focal point making a brand acceptable or stylish to display at any party.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“people who advertise manufacturers who advertise during the Super Bowl sort of know that people know that people are seeing this... that's a kind of mutual coordination... more social goods are advertised during the Super Bowl”

0.81

There is a second, distinct sense of coordination—'mutual coordination' associated with Thomas Schelling and game theory—where parties like a supplier and baker coordinate terms, schedules and prices; this usage now dominates economics, having largely displaced the older concatenate sense.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“this brings us to the other kind of coordination what I call mutual coordination associated with Thomas Schelling and game theory this notion of coordination is actually the usage that now dominates in economics”

0.78

We lack a language, verb and pronouns to describe non-cooperative spontaneous coordination—thousands of people can truthfully say 'we made the Super Bowl pizza' yet this is fundamentally different from a team literally cooperating in one room—a gap Hayek agonized over throughout his career.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Dan Klein

“we don't have a language or a metaphor for this this experience of non cooperative coordination”

0.77

Adam Smith distinguished two kinds of rules: definite and exact rules (like grammar, where criticism is only negative and merely meeting them earns no praise) versus loose, vague and indeterminate aspirational rules (like those for sublime writing, art and beauty), and much of economic conversation belongs to the latter aesthetic realm despite economists' science-pretensions.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 4/4durability 4/4· Dan Klein

“Adam Smith and the Moral Sentiments makes an distinction between two types of rules... One type is he calls definite and exact and it gives the example of grammar... and he contrasts that with the rules for sublime and elegant writing... Smith calls loose vague and indeterminate”

0.75

The spontaneous coordination that makes pizza, beer, hot dogs and croissants all reliably available—on time, on the shelf—for an unusual demand spike like Super Bowl Sunday is marvelous because it requires no central coordinator yet never produces shortages of the unusual goods nor surpluses of the displaced ones.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“if you want to cross off on Super Bowl Sunday you can still get one... that doesn't happen there's always plenty of beer and we understand that that the coordination that it necessary for all the stuff people want on Super Bowl Sunday to be there is is somewhat marvelous”

0.75

Concatenate coordinations can be more or less planned: within a firm there is an actual coordinator (the boss) who delegates details but coordinates the basic scale of activities, whereas vaster concatenations proceed without any central planning through spontaneous mechanisms.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“you can have concatenate coordination z' that are more or less planned actually there's a coordinator and you can have a vaster concatenate concatenations that proceed without any kind of central planning through various spontaneous mechanisms”

0.73

The vast chain of activities producing everyday goods like a woolen coat or pencil constitutes a 'concatenate coordination'—a series of linked, mutually complementary activities that produces society's output without being enclosed in any single plan or comprehensible to any real human being's view.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“I'd like to think of the whole chain of activities that make the woolen coat or the pencil as a kind of concatenation... a series of linked and mutually complementary activities so this vast concatenation we are in the habit of saying exhibits a kind of coordination”

0.73

Marx clearly understood that capitalism's vast concatenation is not actually a cooperation; he hated capitalism precisely because it was not one unified cooperation, and he wanted the whole economic chain to become a single organization.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“Marx saw this clearly Marx was actually great on this and he kind of hated capitalism because it wasn't a vast cooperation and he wanted the economy to be... a cooperation to be an organization essentially”

0.73

There is not enough love to go around for society to rely on mutual caring; the power and humanity of the spontaneous, uncoordinated order is precisely that it does not require love to function well, whereas a society that genuinely relied on universal love would be in a bad situation.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“the reality is is there is not enough love to go around... The power and the humanity of the uncoordinated spontaneous order... is that you don't have to rely on love”

0.73

Coordination differs fundamentally from efficiency/optimality/social-welfare-function economics because coordination requires no well-defined maximum and makes no pretense of one, whereas the modern paradigm presumes a well-defined maxim—a presumption driven by the urge toward scientific status and positivism.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“the coordination doesn't require a maxim and there's no pretense there is an man clearly there's no pretense of a well-defined Maxim and whereas the others do have the pretense of a well-defined Maxim... part of a kind of urge towards scientific status and positivism”

0.73

Adam Smith's two books form a sequence: the Moral Sentiments posits a strong natural penchant for coordinated sentiment (sympathy), consistent with our solidaristic hunter-gatherer origins, while the Wealth of Nations authorizes self-interest to be 'cut loose' because, when we think hard about how concatenations work, focusing on the local works out better for making things like the woolen coat.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“I see Smith is like authorizing this now our self-interest to be cut loose so in a sense he's really starting with the solid derek impulse and then saying folks we should now authorize the self-interest because it works better to make the woolen coat”

0.73

Human intuitions about coordination are evolved for the concrete small group—the hunter-gatherer band our genes come from—which makes it cognitively difficult to fathom the vast, extensive concatenation of links and the mechanisms holding modern society together.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“our intuitions I think are more about the concrete the small group you know maybe the hunter-gatherer band which our genes come from they say and so we don't we have a hard time fathoming the this vast concatenation”

0.73

Efficiency in the abstract consumer-surplus-plus-producer-surplus framework is not nearly as well-defined, exact or measurable as mainstream economists claim, because it depends on contextual factors—available options, knowledge of willingness to pay, time span, reflection—and behavioral economics shows inconsistent, regretted choices, weakness of will, and information limits; so the right response to 'it's not efficient' can be 'so what,' even while supply-and-demand and surplus remain useful for revealing the costs of interventions.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“if you want to do you know willingness to pay consumer surplus plus producer surplus there's all sorts of you know contextual things about what that means... I just think it's not nearly as really well-defined or exact or definite as they make out”

0.68

A fragmented school system avoids divisive political fights (over prayer, evolution, creationism) because families self-sort into schools matching their values, yielding both competition and an escape from the political dissension that inevitably arises when a single solution is forced on everyone.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“if you have a fragmented school system you don't fight over prayer in school people choose if they want prayer in school they go there... you avoid the political dissension that inevitably occurs when you force a single solution”

0.66

The vast concatenation is 'incredible' in a literal sense: any claim to know it in detailed fashion is not credible, and because society cannot really be known or explained, it is unlikely to be officially manipulable—which is a key reason to dwell on its incredibleness when thinking about policy.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“one way I interpret incredible is that anybody's attempt to say they know this vast concatenation or to really know in any detailed way how it works would not be credible”

0.64

The people's romance actively crowds out, subverts and is jealous of more meaningful local 'club romances'—voluntary club coordination of sentiment (Buchanan-style club goods) such as homeschooling, private schooling, churches and private concentrations of wealth—sometimes working against them almost deliberately, as seen in antagonism toward Walmart.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“the people's romance version does crowd out what would be all sorts of more meaningful local actually genuine forms of cooperation what I call club romance... it like actually sometimes works against it I would say almost deliberately”

0.63

Social Security is a leading instance of the people's romance—'us taking care of us'—where the language of a social safety net that encompasses everyone gives the whole polity the flavor of an encompassing shared experience and sentiment.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dan Klein

“the Social Security is another leading example of this people's romance enterprise it's we take it's us taking care of us... it's the social safety net... it like encompasses all the polity”

0.63

Systems built to satisfy the people's romance perform comparatively well on the people's-romance metric but perform terribly on almost everything else—materially failing to produce woolen coats and the goods people actually care about, and frustrating fundamental liberal pursuits.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Dan Klein

“it's not an effective way of actually producing woolen coats and so many things we do in fact really care about... they do basically almost terrible I think basically on just about everything else”

0.61

Cooperation, properly defined, requires both a referent concatenation (a chain of activities people contribute to) and mutual coordination of awareness and sentiment about contributing to it; people merely linked in a production chain without mutual awareness (like distant links in the woolen-coat chain) are not actually cooperating.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“I want to use the two coordinations concatenate and mutual to define cooperation... they are mutually coordinate coordinating their awareness their understanding in their sentiments about it being about contributing to that”

0.61

The people's romance is an evolutionary atavism analogous to our penchant for sweets—adaptive in the ancestral environment of solidaristic hunter-gatherer bands but maladaptive now; unlike sweets, where we bear personal costs and have strong incentives to subdue the impulse, the people's romance lacks such individual feedback and is harder to restrain.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“the people's romance is also a kind of atavism and it's a kind of penchant that people have to learn to over subdue... just like we have a penchant for sweets which evolution selected for”

0.61

The great danger of the people's romance is not merely inefficiency one can live with, but that bad people will use the romance to do something other than help the elderly; scaling shared-purpose communal arrangements up to the body politic risks not just a different mix of goods but tyranny and real evil.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“there are bad people in the world who will use that romance to do something other than take care of the elderly... when you go to the larger body politic you don't just get a little more of everything... you get tyranny you get the risk of a real evil”

0.57

The reviewer who reacted in horror to a stranger thanking fund manager Peter Lynch for the returns that let him build a home addition—insisting such gratitude belonged to labor unions and political parties—reveals the people's-romance hostility to private actors as rival focal points of shared experience.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“the book reviewer told the story in horror because he said we should be feeling that about labor unions and about political parties not about a mutual fund manager”

0.56

The 'people's romance' is the political urge to mythologize the whole polity or society as a single organization that literally cooperates—seeking encompassing coordination of sentiment, common purpose and shared narrative—which leaders and pundits constantly exploit, often more than they actually believe it.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“the people's romance is is this kind of Mythology about the polity as or society as organization so that these sentiments yearnings for kind of encompassing coordination of sentiment about common purpose about a common narrative”

0.56

When we judge the whole concatenation as 'well coordinated,' we are implicitly imagining a mind able to behold the whole that we ourselves cannot, and we are negotiating an incomplete, aesthetic conversation about what that mind would find more satisfying or beautiful—not computing a well-defined maximum.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“what we do if only implicitly is imagine a mind able to behold it even though we cannot and we're having a kind of conversation about what that mind is like what that mind would find more satisfying”

0.52

People who insist on an encompassing, people-wide shared experience exhibit a kind of 'cultural greediness'—wanting culture their way—and are very prepared to use force against those who do not want it, whereas subduing that penchant opens abundant spiritual opportunity in more limited, voluntary forms of shared sentiment, cooperation and beauty.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“there's a kind of greediness actually to them I think this is a cultural greediness where you know they want it their way and they're they're prepared very prepared to use force against people who don't particularly want that”

0.52

Sustaining the people's romance is a cultural disaster because the power structure, focal points, public schools, utility grids, and the superstitions and notions promulgated to maintain the system fail badly in terms of intellectual quality and integrity, so the deepest case for a liberal society is that the culture would be better, not merely that coats would be cheaper.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“the superstitions and notions that that get promulgated to sustain this whole system are just dreadful... why I want a more liberal society not so much so that I can buy Quillen coats more cheaply but so that the culture would be better”

0.44

The left-right political distinction breaks down when analyzing the people's romance, since the impulse toward encompassing collective identity appears across the spectrum (left-wing solidarity, right-wing 'supporting our troops' and 'spreading democracy').

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Dan Klein

“it's not as though it's not sitting right wedding planning... this left right thing just breaks down I think that's maybe the main lesson on this whole”

0.31

Listeners to this podcast share a real, if fragmented, experience: alone with earplugs yet listening alongside thousands of unknown others, illustrating that fragmented enterprises can be a route to meaningful shared experience rather than a loss of it.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“you're by yourself listening to these words today but you're listening with thousands of other people you don't know who they are... I think these enterprises that are fragmented are the way to a meaningful real shared experience”

0.31

Much of what is taught in economics classes is a dumbed-down version of graduate economics rather than what a civilized, thoughtful person should understand about the world, and the concatenate order is precisely what economics has to contribute to that broader understanding.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“a lot of what we do in our classes unfortunately I think is dumb down Graduate economics rather than what a civilized person should understand about the world”

0.31

The traditional argument that having only three TV channels was better because it gave shared workplace conversation ignores the impact of competition on quality.

causalcontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“some people claim that you know what's better when we only had three channels and everybody was watching a handful of things on television... that argument ignores the impact of competition on quality”

0.27

Econ Journal Watch directly criticizes academic economics—pointing out omissions, irrelevance and steps in reasoning that don't follow, addressing replicability, and investigating whether economists in specific areas reach undisclosed policy conclusions—filling a function the major journals abandoned when they cut comment sections.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Dan Klein

“it launches criticisms of academic economics... pointing out omission irrelevance steps in lines of reasoning that don't follow... the major journals no longer do they've more or less cut the comment sections out of their journals”

0.18

Major economics journals like the Journal of Economic Literature and the Journal of Economic Perspectives fail terribly to disclose how often economists working in specific areas reach policy conclusions—more often than people realize.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Dan Klein

“whether economists working in specific areas reach policy conclusions and very often they do more than the people realize and more than journals like the journal of economic literature and the journal of economic perspectives tell us I think those journals fail terribly in that respect”

0.12

The example comes from Adam Smith at the beginning of The Wealth of Nations describing the woolen coat as the produce of the joint labor of a great multitude of workmen.

factual· Russ Roberts

“the example comes from Adam Smith it's right in the beginning of The Wealth of Nations and he talks about the woolen coat”